Privacy, hypocrisy and the Hobby

genintoronto

Retired
Feb 25, 2008
3,223
4
0
Downtown TO
renteddesign.com
From The Stranger: Private Lives: This Male Escort Doesn't Think Mike Jones Is a Hero.

I agree with this male escort re: what a client pay for is not only sex, but also privacy. I would personally never think of outing a client, no matter what the circumstances are.

But some people have argued that by actively attacking gay people and campaining against gay rights while enjoying gay-for-pay sex, Pastor Ted Haggard relinquished his right to privacy. In other words, by publicly and actively denying other adults their right to do whatever they want in private, he doesn't keep his right to do whatever he wants in private without being outed.

What do you think?
 
red said:
he didn't relinquish that right in my opinion
I agree with you, but why do you think so?

My logic is that by taking the money, the escort implicitly agrees to a privacy contract. Period.

Sure Haggard is a big ass hypocrite, but Mike Jones could have refused to see him as a client. But he agreed to see him, took his money, and therefore took part in the hypocrisy. As such, he has no right to turn around when the deed is done and out the guy.
 
Interesting question ... karma must ultimately have its day ... live by the sword, die by the sword.
 
genintoronto said:
I agree with you, but why do you think so?

My logic is that by taking the money, the escort implicitly agrees to a privacy contract. Period.

Sure Haggard is a big ass hypocrite, but Mike Jones could have refused to see him as a client. But he agreed to see him, took his money, and therefore took part in the hypocrisy. As such, he has no right to turn around when the deed is done and out the guy.

Fuck him...that Pastor is the biggest slime ball, IMHO. Those kind of people make me sick. They vehemently preach against certain "evils" that they indulge in themselves.
 
is a good question

“It was a bad week for the good pastor. The ultraconservative, anti-gay Christian evangelist was not only fingered for hiring a gay male prostitute, but for buying meth off the sex worker as well. (The sex worker claims he didn't sell Haggard the meth, just hooked him up with someone who would.)”

Anti gay yet seeing male escort. That is playing with fire. Taking meth on top of it all. I would never out a client. I have had good reason to do so in the past, but I am old school and live by a code.

I think there might be more to this. Like the escort is of the street variety with drug issues. One can not be to careful when doing the dirty deed. Especially in this case. Dirty deeds where done dirt cheap and he got burned.
 
I say that the Pastor deserved everything he had coming to him:) . No pun intended.

The pastor was IMHO such a hypocrite that I can't fault the male escort for outing him in this particular situation.

According to the article the pastor kept verbally abusing and attacking gay people for having gay sex. What a joke as he was doing exactly the same thing.

In 99% of cases I would think that the male escort would be totally wrong for outing a paid client. This is the 1% of the time that I don't!
 
The Houdini said:
Fuck him...that Pastor is the biggest slime ball, IMHO. Those kind of people make me sick. They vehemently preach against certain "evils" that they indulge in themselves.
Make me sick too. But I think I would rather just refuse to see such a client than indulge him in his hypocrisy and then out him.

But someone on another board brought an interesting argument:

If a client was dangerous to the community (say, abusive toward sex workers), then a sex worker would be justified to out him. Since it could be argue that Ted Haggard was actively harming the community by spreading vile hate toward gay people and sex workers, then outing him was justified.
 
Whereas I agree with Genie, this guy is the ultimate slime ball hypocrite as far as my opinion goes.

Here's a supposed "born again" christian type preaching to everyone else on how they are supposed to live their lives & then he goes and does the complete opposite himself?! The old "do as I say and not as I do" routine?

Come on! May he take his place in history along with Jimmy Swaggart, Jimmy Bakker and all the other hypocrites of his ilk! :rolleyes:
 
While this guy deserved it, I wuld agree with Genie that however much of an Ahole the guy was, he still was paying for privacy as well as sex.

At the end of the day the privacy thing is an honour code. SP's should never share/out the real identity of clients if they know that info (other than by a Terb handle, say) and clients should not share/out the real identities of SP's if they know them (other than Terb handles, stage names, etc). It is a mutual respect thing.

With any honour system, one has to assume that not everyone in the world is honourable...so you may find an SP who spills the beans on you, and SP's may find cleints who out them in public/online for some reason or other. It happens, unfortunately.
 
True

genintoronto said:
Make me sick too. But I think I would rather just refuse to see such a client than indulge him in his hypocrisy and then out him.

But someone on another board brought an interesting argument:

If a client was dangerous to the community (say, abusive toward sex workers), then a sex worker would be justified to out him. Since it could be argue that Ted Haggard was actively harming the community by spreading vile hate toward gay people and sex workers, then outing him was justified.

Very good point.
 
I think this is a new spin on an old question: Is it ok to do a bad thing if you do it for a good reason?

I completely agree with Gen's point that your paying for privacy, and this man did violate that and it was ethically wrong. He knew full well what would happen to Haggard. Home life devastated, family horrified, professionally killed and his flock disturbed. He knew this would be the result, and that in taking his money had committed to protecting his secret but he violated it anyway. that was WRONG.

But Haggard's hypocrisy needed to be exposed. He was contributing to a continued violation of human rights. He has damaged many lives by dividing families, teaching people to feel shame, and generally being a horrible human being, all the while indulging in a lifestyle he spoke out against. His downfall exposes the wrongness of his stances, and a lot of people will learn from seeing it and have better lives for it. The result of Jones' actions are GOOD.

So in my case, I thank him for the action I condem him for taking. There's a major cognitive dissonance there but I'm fine with it.
 
genintoronto said:
I agree with you, but why do you think so?

My logic is that by taking the money, the escort implicitly agrees to a privacy contract. Period.

Sure Haggard is a big ass hypocrite, but Mike Jones could have refused to see him as a client. But he agreed to see him, took his money, and therefore took part in the hypocrisy. As such, he has no right to turn around when the deed is done and out the guy.

I agree. An escort's private life and the private life of his or her client(s)NEVER should surface. Haggard was always nothing more than a fake asshole to me straight from the get go. I love your posts.
 
While I agree that a customer and sp do deserve to have some implied privacy but by the same token, they both deserve the same amount of respect and responsibility to society and to protect that society.

I guess I'm becoming less selfish and more society aware in my old age but I am finding more and more often now I'm thinking of the greater good than my individualistic needs.

If the customer in question had an STD for example, would it be ok to out him to protect others in the biz or in society in general? If he is a known purveyor of sexual services everyone should be aware of the risks involved.

IMO this type of person is what is wrong with our western ideals: the hypocrasy of not being true to oneself. I personally feel that people should be aware of who they are dealing with. It's not like this was Mr Average joe who was going around minding his own business and flying under the radar. He was actively publically denouncing this lifestyle. I think once you enter the public life your life then becomes public. You can't have it both ways: pay attention to ME but only see what i want you to see. Just like politicians: If you're supposedly serving the greater good and want to serve the public, the public has a right to know exactly who they have representing them.

I know people hate my analogies but this would be like our Transportation Minister (I forget his name) who brought in the anti racing law racing around the highway in his Lambo Gallardo doing 200+ mph.

I think people who are hypocrites should be publically condemned for the two facedness of their actions. But that's just me....
 
I am constantly amazed that anyone who enters the sex trade indusrty in the States as consumers or suppliers thinks they will encounter discretion, ethics or responsible behaviour.
 
genintoronto said:
Make me sick too. But I think I would rather just refuse to see such a client than indulge him in his hypocrisy and then out him.

But someone on another board brought an interesting argument:

If a client was dangerous to the community (say, abusive toward sex workers), then a sex worker would be justified to out him. Since it could be argue that Ted Haggard was actively harming the community by spreading vile hate toward gay people and sex workers, then outing him was justified.

That's for sure.

You would be 100% justified in outing such a person. Especially when there is any form of violence.
 
genintoronto said:
Make me sick too. But I think I would rather just refuse to see such a client than indulge him in his hypocrisy and then out him.

But someone on another board brought an interesting argument:

If a client was dangerous to the community (say, abusive toward sex workers), then a sex worker would be justified to out him. Since it could be argue that Ted Haggard was actively harming the community by spreading vile hate toward gay people and sex workers, then outing him was justified.


It is well known in the gay community that many of the most rabid homophobes are closeted gay or bisexual males who hide behind their hate as a way to deny the homosexuality in themselves.

I point this out because Haggard is a classic example of such a person. I think however that his desire for Meth makes him a danger to himself and others. By resorting to drugs he is seeking to escape through chemicals the very ugly truth that he is a gay man and he has been living a lie.

The most difficult thing to do is the harder thing to do. Ted Haggard has to go to the SF gay pride parade, hold a coming out party and confess his own sins. Ted Haggard needs a man, period full stop.

EU
 
gramage said:
I think this is a new spin on an old question: Is it ok to do a bad thing if you do it for a good reason?

I completely agree with Gen's point that your paying for privacy, and this man did violate that and it was ethically wrong. He knew full well what would happen to Haggard.
I agree. Further, does hypocrisy alone on the part of the client give an escort (straight or gay) the right to out them? If so that seems a rather dangerous and slippery slope. To keep the analogy relatively straight forward if you patronize an incall service and campaign to keep incall illegal does that give the escort the right to out you? Is that not a different situation than seeing an outcall escort while campaigning to make outcall illegal? Are not both quite different from seeing an escort while campaigning to make all prostitution a criminal offense with a five year jail term? It is my belief that the "bad thing for a good reason" argument only truly applies to the last of these. Further is not campaigning a different thing than actually having the power to make law?
 
Aardvark154 said:
Further is not campaigning a different thing than actually having the power to make law?

It is, but someone who spoke regularly with the last President and claimed to have influence over him is also a different type of campaigner. Also your incall example is a legal issue only, while many people (myself included) consider gay marriage and discrimination a human rights issueas well, and you need only learn a little about the "curing" gay movement or the childrens camps like the one in the film Jesus Camp to see this as an abuse issue as well.