Prince Charles attacks GMO foods

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
London - Prince Charles said the widespread use of genetically modified crops would the "biggest disaster environmentally of all time" in a newspaper interview published on Wednesday.

The 59-year-old heir to the throne is well known for his support of organic farming but his comments during an interview with the Daily Telegraph are his most outspoken attack yet on GMO foods.

His views will strike a chord in Britain where biotech crops have faced significant opposition, with concerns centred on both food safety and possible environmental impacts.

Charles said multinational food companies were conducting a "gigantic experiment with nature and the whole of humanity which has gone seriously wrong."

Small farmers would be the victims if "gigantic corporations" took over the mass production of food.

"We (will) end up with millions of small farmers all over the world being driven off their land into unsustainable, unmanageable, degraded and dysfunctional conurbations of unmentionable awfulness," he declared.

He said "excessive approaches to modern forms of agriculture" had already damaged water supplies in India's Punjab and in Western Australia.

"What we should be talking about is food security, not food production - that is what matters and that is what people will not understand.

"And if they think it's somehow going to work because they are going to have one form of clever genetic engineering after another, then again count me out, because that will be guaranteed to cause the biggest disaster environmentally of all time."

His intervention comes as a wave of food inflation has reopened the debate on the ways science can boost agricultural production.

Earlier in 2008 Britain's chief scientist John Beddington said GMO crops should not be shunned as agriculture seeks to respond to rising food demand, particularly from China and India, at a time when climate change is expected to hit yields.
 
Did Frankenfood cause his big ears?

I have a feeling that the debate on GMO foods will take a turn like the biofuels issue did.

If genetics can improve the yield and nutritional value of foods it can provide a great benefit in places where there are shortages. Truly organic farming is more labour intensive and requires more land to produce the same amount of produce. It is easy for those in wealthy countries (especially a guy who has never really had to earn a living) to criticize modern high yield farming methods but I doubt that those opinions will be taken kindly by those who are struggling to survive.
 
Eh ...

danmand said:
unsustainable, unmanageable, degraded and dysfunctional conurbations of unmentionable awfulness

how's that again???:confused:
 
He's got a point. Ever notice how food sensitivities are way up recently? Gluten allegies, lactose sensitivities, etc. Frankenfood is to a large degree responsible I think, as well as pesticides, additives, growth hormones, antibiotics and various treatments.

Buying locally produced organic produce is healthier. However big food corporations obviously care about total crop yields, lowest price for the consumer and appearance more than intrinsic quality.

I buy most of my food now at farmer's markets. Big difference in quality from major chain supermarket produce departments most of the time.
 
Who gives a f*#k what that wimp has to say, tell him to go home to his ugly douchebag Camilla.
 
Statements from people like Prince Charles hold more weight with me than those made by stock holding CEOs. When you're rich beyond compare, you can speak what you feel is the truth without fear of economic woe.

For me, the term "organic" is vague. Are we talking about food grown without pesticides etc., or food that is genetically re-engineered in the lab (as opposed to the old fashioned method of breeding?) Charles seems to be referring to the latter.

By the time we know he is right (or know that Al Gore is right, for that matter), it might be too late to heed his advice. History has many examples of human arrogance marching to the cliff. And yet, progress happens only when a calculated risk is taken. Where the balance lies, is anyone's guess.
 
mildandlazy said:
Statements from people like Prince Charles hold more weight with me than those made by stock holding CEOs. When you're rich beyond compare, you can speak what you feel is the truth without fear of economic woe.

Yeh once he's been to a third world country and personally had a crop devasated by drought or disease I'll give this guy the benefit of two seconds of my time.
 
Based on how the British royals are looking they could use some new blood or some GM themselves.

OTB
 
Strongbeau said:
I have news for him: ALL foods have been genetically modified

Genetic modification, as referenced in the article re Charles opinion on GMOs, basically refers to the deliberate physical implantation of genetic material that is alien to a given organism: this is definitely not common to all foods.

On the basis of the results of the only long term ( 3 years if I remember correctly - sorry but I can't be bothered to look up the specifics right now) public study of GMOs ( undertaken by the British government ), attempts to persuade the British public to be more receptive to the widespread cultivation of same in the U.K. were abandoned by Blair's government. Although the study was not as comprehensive as many would have liked and some accused the government of trying to provide a study that would generate positive press for the pro GMO groups, the study clearly indicated GMO correlation with decreased viability of nitrogen fixing bacteriae in soil as well as ( GMO correlation with ) significant decrease in local biodiversity. I would think that even though they weren't the only results that could be used by the anti GMO groups, those alone should have been significant enough to cool Blair's enthusiasm. I'm not alone in seeing that the politics surrounding genetic modification far outstrip the reality of its supposed agricultural benefit: For example, there have been a number of excellent documentaries/ exposes in this regard ( from the BBC ) and even the Canadian Farmers Union sent a delegation to the U.K. saying as much. Has none of this been reported in the Canadian press?! I guess not. The U.K. study was not even mentioned by Dr. Ann Clarke, a professor of plant agriculture at Guelph university, on CBC radio's 'The Current' broadcast on Mon. 28th. April 2008, though she did make a number of strong points and cited other studies that strongly indicated the lack of feasabilty of GMOs as a means of providing increased food supplies for the world's growing population.

Finally, it is clear to me that we assume a level of arrogance of the highest proportions if we think that we can safely and merrily cut, paste, splice together and implant genetic material that even theoretically could never be found together under 'natural circumstances' ( because nature has developed the 'constituent parts' along such divergent lines, in many cases for millions of years! ) without any risk. There are no worldwide standards and it is surprising to know how hit and miss the methodology actually is.
It is perhaps more surprising that we really know so little. When we found out that CFCs had unintended deleterious consequences, we were able to do something effective about it. Now that there are numerous studies indicating unintended radiation problems with long term use of mobile telephones, we can choose to do something effective about it. Now that we know how our use of fossil fuels is unintentionally destroying our habitats, how our 'efficient fishing methods' have led to unforseen massive fishery collapse and how our fish farms are unforseen breeding grounds for disease , etc. etc. ... we can choose to do something effective about it: However, once any unforseen problems arise with genetically modified crops - let's say in relation to the spread of their genetic information into non GM populations ( such spread can and has already occured though so far we don't seem to have identified any associated any problems ), then we will not be able to recall the product or eradicate the problem! When we compound this risk factor with the fact that much research in this field is being done and/or funded by non-public organizations primarily expecting to gain large profits from their efforts, and who usually are not required to publicise the results of their studies, good or bad, and who have been shown to restrict their researchers from publishing said results without express approval of said organizations then I think you can begin to see the reasons behind Prince Charles' concern.
 
What's he on about ...

Frankenfood anyway? Thought he was the Prince of Whales? Last time I heard, they were still in quite a bit of trouble!:mad: