Power generation??

fmahovalich

Active member
Aug 21, 2009
7,256
25
38
So I look at St Lawrence, or Niagara rivers...and see locks...and dams where generating of power occurs.

A question for engineers.....

Why do we not have some sort of DRUM system, floating on the surface of these rivers, attached to a centre shaft. These drums have 'paddles'...sorta like the old paddle boats, that spin the shaft.

We could have rows and rows of these on the remote parts of our mighty rivers....where flow is consistent....and flotation keeps these thins in the water.

We could reuse and reuse the water over and over again.

Imagine a couple acres of these covering the Ottawa river...not countin on wind...to spin endlessly.

Cheap to build...no?

I realize that boating would need to be accommodated...But we have mighty remote areas that would Work.

Picture the rows of tires on an asphalt roller (compaction)

Redesign these into floating larger units that sit on a river and Spin and spin and spin.

Engineers?? Would it work?
 
It would work but not enough power would be generated to be practical

The turbines would not be spinning fast enough is my guess

They are not doing it for a reason
 
The Niagara River has:

1. A huge flow of water
2. A huge drop in elevation

The more electrical Power you want, the more energy you need.

In short, Potential Energy = mgh (m=mass, g=9.81 m/s2 (constant) and h = the height of the drop)

Your example does not have enough m or h.

Your example relies on the mechanical power or kinetic energy = 0.5 mv2, where m is mass, and v is volocity. You just can't get enough v (and be able to control it) to be useful.
 
Yes...water wheels used to drive grain grinding mills and such...and usually were behind a small dam.

My thought is more of large drum like cylinders..spanning fast flowing rivers...and paddles reaching into the water.

Lets say two foot 'paddles'.

The river wold flow towards it..build up pressure and turn it.

I realize slow...but in optimum configuration, would be a 24/7 cheap option.

I realize mass and velocity come into play...affecting cost recovery potential.

Seems to me they would produce as much as those long tube snakes they lay out into the ocean and rely on the rocking of the waves to create energy.
 
In the ocean you're dealing with salt water and corrosion.

My idea is to have every woman crouched over a piston and riding it hard for 8 hour shifts.
 
Those paddles are extremely inefficient. The propeller was a major leap in technology over those.
Propeller style generators do exists and they harness the power of the tides.
 
Just a not on the Niagara River.They have recently finished digging a new tunnel to supply more water to the Sir Adam Beck generation station.The tunnel isn't complete as of yet.They still are doing some work before they let the water in.How much more juice this will provide I don't know.
At night they close the dams upstream to divert more water into the exsisting tunnels on both sides of the border.During the day they keep them open so the Falls looks nicer for the tourists.At night it looks like their is lots of water going over.
 
They are testing wind mill type setups under water in rivers where the water is always flowing. Maybe keeping them water tight is a problem that has stopped wider use.
 
anything that happens to make clean energy more viable is being slowed to a crawl cuz it would make it so the companies that manufacture electricity would not have a stranglehold on the industry and would make less so they don't want it to happen as quickly as it could happen.
 
Yes...water wheels used to drive grain grinding mills and such...and usually were behind a small dam.

My thought is more of large drum like cylinders..spanning fast flowing rivers...and paddles reaching into the water.

Lets say two foot 'paddles'.

The river wold flow towards it..build up pressure and turn it.

I realize slow...but in optimum configuration, would be a 24/7 cheap option.

I realize mass and velocity come into play...affecting cost recovery potential.

Seems to me they would produce as much as those long tube snakes they lay out into the ocean and rely on the rocking of the waves to create energy.

You're forgetting maintenence and winter
 
I had forgot about ice...perhaps move south.

maintenance though would be limited.

Yes they would be a hindrance to navigation, but the would be on faster flowing areas, in non navigable waters...perhaps near locks, etc.

The reason I ask..is I don't see the efficiency and cost recovery of the large wind turbines at 3 million per.

My idea would maybe be slower, But WAY WAY cheaper, and running 24/7
 
Ice aside, I don't see how yours is way cheaper. You still haven't told us how you're gonna transfer either the rotational energy from your spinning, floating drums or the electrical energy from the generators (that float and rotate along with them? Tie a lamp to a bicycle wheel, then plug it in and spin it.) to shore. And there's still jtk's equations. KBear's underwater version of the wind gennies seems like it might harness more actual water power, and need less new engineering, but you couldn't just float them out there. Thing is, I'm not sure you could just float yours out there either.

Thanks for raising this, I knew I'd seen something somewhere on small scale hydro, and Bingo! The Last Whole Earth Catalog, Random House, 1971, pp71 The James Leffel Co. of Springfield Ohio has been selling single-family turbines for years. Ask for Pamphlet A and Bulletin H-49.
 
I could see something along those lines being tried for a remote cottage kind of situation but the efficiency would have to be pretty high for it to be worthwhile. The largest problem (beyond the engineering problems already mentioned) with a large scale implementation is that each paddle would slow down the water so it would move slower with each successive generator.
 
We could have rows and rows of these on the remote parts of our mighty rivers....where flow is consistent....and flotation keeps these thins in the water.

Power = pressure head x mass flow rate. Velocity of water counts for nothing.


Thanks for raising this, I knew I'd seen something somewhere on small scale hydro, and Bingo! The Last Whole Earth Catalog, Random House, 1971, pp71 The James Leffel Co. of Springfield Ohio has been selling single-family turbines for years. Ask for Pamphlet A and Bulletin H-49.

There's also Rapid-Eau in Cambridge. One of theirs is the 170kW unit at Elora Mill


I could see something along those lines being tried for a remote cottage kind of situation but the efficiency would have to be pretty high for it to be worthwhile. The largest problem (beyond the engineering problems already mentioned) with a large scale implementation is that each paddle would slow down the water so it would move slower with each successive generator.

There are dozens of 20kW streams in S.Ontario. Economics depends on difference between what Hydro charges you and what Hydro pays you. But never invest in a technology that needs tax breaks to make it look good.
 
Your method of the paddle wheel on moving water will generate electricity, it is just not the most efficient known method available to generate electricity. Then there is the matter of preventing boats from navigating the rivers, Electricity is better off generated a far distance away from cities.

Quebec is a place that has far away hydro electric generating resources. Quebec sells their surplus power to New York State during the day at a high price and actually shuts off the water flow to the hydro generators and buys power back from New York during the night at about a tenth of the price per kilowatt because at night New York has to maintain their coal and nuclear power generators and has a surplus. This way for the dams fill up with water and for every cheap kilowatt of electricity bought from NY they can sell them one kilowatt during the day at ten times the price.

There are draw backs and advantages to every method, but some methods are much more efficient and environmentally friendly
 
Electricity is better off generated a far distance away from cities.
Quebec is a place that has far away hydro electric generating resources. Quebec sells their surplus power to New York State during the day at a high price and actually shuts off the water flow to the hydro generators and buys power back from New York during the night at about a tenth of the price per kilowatt because at night New York has to maintain their coal and nuclear power generators and has a surplus. This way for the dams fill up with water and for every cheap kilowatt of electricity bought from NY they can sell them one kilowatt during the day at ten times the price.

Transmission losses waste a significant fraction of generate power. Power stations should be close to cities. Some are wary of having a nuclear station in their backyard, and nobody wants a windmill station, but otherwise you're the wrong way round, baby.

Quebec does what you say because northern Quebec is where the copious falling water is. It would be far better if the falling water were located near population centres.