Potash decision

red

you must be fk'n kid'g me
Nov 13, 2001
17,551
10
38
gov't rejects potash takeover offer from bhp. politics meets idealogy
 
What's the rationalization for this?

OTB
 
What's the rationalization for this?

OTB

none given.- just did not in "Canada's best interest". What I think happened was BHP had planned to send the long form census to each of their customers and employees- so that turned the feds against them
 
The way the world is going and the depletion of all the arable farm land diminishing. Potash is now and in the future a very valuable resource. Why sell the milk cow ? Keep the profits here and put the revenue generated back into Canada. I'm sick and tired listening to all the laissez faire, Chicago School of Economics, Uncle Milton nuts. It's been a disaster wherever it's been implemented. You can see it in what's happening in the USA today. It's a freakin disaster ! Don't sell !

BS
 
It could have swung enough seats in the next election to push the conservatives into opposition.

At the Fed level or Province?

Is this a protectionist decision or is there something else going on?

Don't know anything about it just curious.

OTB
 
The way the world is going and the depletion of all the arable farm land diminishing. Potash is now and in the future a very valuable resource. Why sell the milk cow ? Keep the profits here and put the revenue generated back into Canada. I'm sick and tired listening to all the laissez faire, Chicago School of Economics, Uncle Milton nuts. It's been a disaster wherever it's been implemented. You can see it in what's happening in the USA today. It's a freakin disaster ! Don't sell !

BS

Interesting perspective for a net exporting nation.

OTB
 
At the Fed level or Province?

Is this a protectionist decision or is there something else going on?

Don't know anything about it just curious.

OTB
Currently the federal Conservatives hold all but one seat in Saskatchewan (the other is NDP). Selling Potash Corp to Australian BHP Biliton would have been very unpopular among the people in Sask. so approving the sale had the potential to cost the Conservatives some valuable seats, as terbul said. From what I've heard & read, the company was nationalized by the provincial government in the mid-70s, then sold off in '89 when the province had a serious debt problem.

The downside to selling off a resource company to foreign ownership is that the processing jobs are more likely to be taken out of the country. I don't know if that would happen with potash, but when you see raw logs exported, metal ore exported, etc. I'm not really disappointed about this decision.
 
Currently the federal Conservatives hold all but one seat in Saskatchewan (the other is NDP). Selling Potash Corp to Australian BHP Biliton would have been very unpopular among the people in Sask. so approving the sale had the potential to cost the Conservatives some valuable seats, as terbul said. From what I've heard & read, the company was nationalized by the provincial government in the mid-70s, then sold off in '89 when the province had a serious debt problem.

The downside to selling off a resource company to foreign ownership is that the processing jobs are more likely to be taken out of the country. I don't know if that would happen with potash, but when you see raw logs exported, metal ore exported, etc. I'm not really disappointed about this decision.

I guess there isn't much risk is pissing off Australia, I would assume China would be a different story.

OTB
 
Potash demand and prices are in a bull market anyway; both are likely to rise in the not too distant future. Ergo, we're not giving much up. Why should canucks hand this upside to the Aussies? When BHP was in danger of selling a strategic stake to the chinese, the government in Canberra intervened to stop them from doing so, and rightly so. It was a good decision.
 
To correct my earlier post, the non-Conservative MP Saskatchewan is Liberal, held by Ralph Goodale.

Also, I heard on the news last night that the share price on the market for Potash Corp. is above what BHP Biliton is offering. Does this mean:
a) current shareholders wouldn't sell to BHP, regardless of what the Canadian government decided?
b) the market is expecting another, more lucrative, offer from BHP?
c) both?
 
There are quiet whispers in the Rockslinger clan that some distant members of our family were exiled to Australia. Maybe, you met some of them when you were in Sydney.

everyone in Australia is an exilie (dont know if its a right word)
 
I guess there isn't much risk is pissing off Australia, I would assume China would be a different story.

OTB
Actually, I think arguments against sales to foreign state owned firms have some logic in them (as is often the case with Chinese takeovers). It is arguments against sales to private firms that are clearly questionable. If you assume private firms maximize profit, their behavior should be similar whether most of the shares are owned domestically or by foreigners (not to mention the royalties they have to pay for the potash are up to the government of Sask anyway). However, I am not confident that government owned firms will necessarily only have profit maximization as their goal.