Portuguese Dropouts

JohnFK said:
NOW your remarks are totally unfair.

If it wasn't for Portuguese, nobody would go into construction it seems, particularly the harder trades like bricklaying, or cement finishing, or general labourers, etc. People born in this country generally don't want to get into such trades.

We have assisted in the immigration of workers of Portuguese origin so that we can meet the shortage of skilled workers.

I even know of a couple of Portuguese guys, father and son, that work at the Tremco plant. They have a large contingent of Portuguese workers that bring their work ethic and make that plant successsful per the executive I know there.

Third world labour will make any company's plant successful ;)
 
JohnLarue said:
I think you missed the point
Some of these kids will do OK in the trades and even a smaller number will eventually acquire the skills you describe and make $100,000 or more.

But a lot of them will not
As you say "you generally don't find allot of dummies in the trades, especially the guys doing the thinking."
If you can not read or write, the probability of getting the thinking job is very limited


Sure some trades setting, sewers, watermains, carpentry, brick laying, roofing, etc. will not go away, but are subject to economic fluctuation (Construction may still be a relatively strong sector only due to govt spending & that may slow down soon).
It is also tough physical labor and not all of these drop outs are built for that shit.
Tough physical labor can only be done so long.
I know several buddies who dropped out to work construction at age 17.
All of them have a fucked up back or some other physical problem at age 45
Try roofing when your 55 years old

They are limiting their prospects by dropping out and long term economic trends definitely are working against them.

Bye The Way
MBA-yes
Labor negociatior- No
Over-bearing know-it-all- perhaps


Bad Grammar - without a doubt.

You consistently write your, when you mean you're. (See above.) You serve to reinforce the stereotype of MBAs. (This is what - Grade 8 grammar. You're (you are), your, they're (they are), their, there. For someone who has a Master's Degree, you should at least know how to spell.) By the way, it's By the way, not bye the way. Fark.

A good Tradesman is quite capable of earning 100 grand or more per year. It is not a "smaller number". Hell, even Locomotive Drivers make 140 grand a year.

Forbes did a study on the the highest growth industries for the next 25 years and if I recall correctly, Infrastructure Renewal was No. 3. Sewers, Roads, watermains, bridges are all coming of age.

You might think that there are all kinds of current Government Infrastructure programs, however, I can assure you that it is a farce. Typically, infrastructure renewal programs are planned in 5 year windows, with another 5 on the horizon after that. In the City of Toronto there is not currently one construction project out for tender that hasn't been planned for the last 5 years. Trust me on that. All that ever happens is that the Feds say they're going to spend money on infrastructure, but it's generally just a song and dance. You might get one special project that was being back burnered due to lack of funding that gets a green light, but that's about it. To my knowledge, that hasn't happened in the City of Toronto. Even "Transit City" has been in the planning stages for at least 5 years now.

Sometimes what happens is the feds come up with some money that they give to the municipalities to fund infrastructure but what happens is that money that is ALREADY budgeted for infrastructure simply gets shifted to other city departments. The net result is no NEW infrastructure projects, just money gets shifted around.

Then you have the TTC trying to buy new street cars and subway cars and the Feds doing everything they can to avoid contributing to the purchase yet saying how they are funding infrastructure. It's a joke.

So you might think that infrastructure spending is at a high right now due to Federal Stimulus packages, but really it isn't.
 
james t kirk said:
Bad Grammar - without a doubt.

You consistently write your, when you mean you're. (See above.) You serve to reinforce the stereotype of MBAs. (This is what - Grade 8 grammar. You're (you are), your, they're (they are), their, there. For someone who has a Master's Degree, you should at least know how to spell.) By the way, it's By the way, not bye the way. Fark.

A good Tradesman is quite capable of earning 100 grand or more per year. It is not a "smaller number". Hell, even Locomotive Drivers make 140 grand a year.

Forbes did a study on the the highest growth industries for the next 25 years and if I recall correctly, Infrastructure Renewal was No. 3. Sewers, Roads, watermains, bridges are all coming of age.

You might think that there are all kinds of current Government Infrastructure programs, however, I can assure you that it is a farce. Typically, infrastructure renewal programs are planned in 5 year windows, with another 5 on the horizon after that. In the City of Toronto there is not currently one construction project out for tender that hasn't been planned for the last 5 years. Trust me on that. All that ever happens is that the Feds say they're going to spend money on infrastructure, but it's generally just a song and dance. You might get one special project that was being back burnered due to lack of funding that gets a green light, but that's about it. To my knowledge, that hasn't happened in the City of Toronto. Even "Transit City" has been in the planning stages for at least 5 years now.

Sometimes what happens is the feds come up with some money that they give to the municipalities to fund infrastructure but what happens is that money that is ALREADY budgeted for infrastructure simply gets shifted to other city departments. The net result is no NEW infrastructure projects, just money gets shifted around.

Then you have the TTC trying to buy new street cars and subway cars and the Feds doing everything they can to avoid contributing to the purchase yet saying how they are funding infrastructure. It's a joke.

So you might think that infrastructure spending is at a high right now due to Federal Stimulus packages, but really it isn't.


Grammar WTF ??
Its not important on a board like this
The Masters degree did not teach me spelling (I never could, and probably never will spell words well). If its is real important, then I get someone to check it for me, spell checker catches most errors.
The Masters taught me to apply logic, analytical thinking, reasoning and focus on big issues.

Criticizing spelling is a trivial, wasteful exercise, however if it makes you feel better, knock yourself out

So here it is
Dispute all the great trades related jobs currently in the market place (as you describe)
1. A drop out is not assured of getting one of them
2. Economic conditions may greatly reduce the volume of these great jobs.
3. Firms in search of more efficient methods will always seek new construction methods. Many which will either
a) require less labor overall
b) require more specialized (educated) labor

These kids are greatly increasing the risk of a limited economic future for themselves by not finishing high school.
Argue against this age old truism all you wish, however its is more relevant than when the last generation was telling their kids to remain in school
 
Here is a shocker>>>

JohnLarue said:
Grammar WTF ??
Its not important on a board like this
The Masters degree did not teach me spelling (I never could, and probably never will spell words well). If its is real important, then I get someone to check it for me, spell checker catches most errors.
The Masters taught me to apply logic, analytical thinking, reasoning and focus on big issues.

Criticizing spelling is a trivial, wasteful exercise, however if it makes you feel better, knock yourself out

So here it is
Dispute all the great trades related jobs currently in the market place (as you describe)
1. A drop out is not assured of getting one of them
2. Economic conditions may greatly reduce the volume of these great jobs.
3. Firms in search of more efficient methods will always seek new construction methods. Many which will either
a) require less labor overall
b) require more specialized (educated) labor

These kids are greatly increasing the risk of a limited economic future for themselves by not finishing high school.
Argue against this age old truism all you wish, however its is more relevant than when the last generation was telling their kids to remain in school


Could not agree more!!
 
Mrbig1949 said:
Could not agree more!!

Oh boy, whats going on here?
Whats next?

Will I join a union?? (not likely)
Will you make a financial contribution to the Tories?? (equally unlikely)
 
Wow. I'm going to start off by apologizing for the fact that this post could end up taking up an entire page. I've been away from the Lounge for a while and haven't seen it progressing, so I have some catching up to do....

I understand that a review board for sex trade workers is not exactly the place to find the most enlightened minds, but this whole thread is filled with useless opinions from people that can barely share a coherent thought. I'm amazed that some of you can even tie your shoes!

Starting with this...WTF? The good doctor must be over medicating himself because I have no idea what point he is even trying to make here or what relevance it has to this thread!? New country/old country? Are you speaking of first generation Portuguese-Canadians? Second...third? Do you think that Canadian culture is what exposes these people to sex and drugs? Take a trip to Portugal, where it is perfectly normal to see kids drinking by the age of 10 or 11 and so many that are sexually active by their mid teens. It's not like they're living in a bubble, where they have never been exposed to western culture! I also assure you that there is no complex from Portuguese people that others are looking down on them, since most Portuguese people feel that they are better than everyone to begin with...INCLUDING other Portuguese people! Call them arrogant, but don't tell me you think they have an inferiority complex.
Doctor Zoidburg said:
What I am about to say can be applied to many ethnics, but it applies well to Portugese.

The a real whore is a Portugese whore because if they choose to sell pussy for cash they realy try to bargain and haggle to get the most for themselves. A real slut is a Portugese slut because if they choose to give away pussy they want as much cock for thelselves and the man is a dildo, and he better be a pleasing dildo or else she will get another one. Years ago I knew a 18 yer old Portugese slut that would have sex and was still a virgin. Her ass was all stretched out to accomdate cock, but her virgin pussy was for her future husband. ( I would like to know if she still takes cockc on the side these days? ) When I was younger I went to a bar while I was under aged with a group of guys, one was Portugese. There were 2 older women ( 26 - 27 years old ) at the bar trying to pick up cock. These two ladies spoke english, but they talked to each other in Portugese and said that this guy was too young for them. My friend was Portugese but told the ladies that he was Italian. These ladies were young married Portugese ladies that were out for cock. Because of tradition they were married young into their own community into a loveless marriage.
As far as Portugese thugs, when you get one you get a bad one that will stick you with a knife.

Some of these people that are from Portugese hertage are stuck between the new world and the old world. They have family and church on one side and the new world things like drugs and sex on the otherside. Then there is the mentality, they have an inferiority complex. They think people look down on them and over compensate by trying to outsmart others and end up outsmartng themselves.

The fact of the matter is that most people will aspire to be what they know. If you want to generalize, lets take the "white trash" living on the system. In many cases, that's what you know growing up, so you are going to be content marrying another piece of trash and having 7 trashy kids with 2 or 3 baby-daddies and living on the system and passing that gift on to your future generations. Some people will grow up with at least one of their parents in prison and, therefore, will likely end up there themselves. On the inverse, a doctor might expect their child to become someone "successful" like a doctor or lawyer or at least achieve an MBA :rolleyes: (I'll get to you in a minute). The fact of the matter is that ALL of these people rely on these Portuguese drop-outs to build their homes, or pave their roads, or lay the sewer lines that wash your shit away!

As for the higher education that they are missing out on...find a University grad (any one will do) and ask them if they would like to make $80,000 per year as a base salary from the day that they graduate. How many do you think would be content with that? Now ask if they would like that same salary with no debt. Think they're still game? That's basically what you have in these kids who are dropping out to take jobs. If you look at the stat that is being reference, they point out that most of these kids are leaving school for a trade and not to go work at Starbucks or Timmies or The Gap. Jobs which some Marine Biologists are working.

I am Canadian, from a Portuguese decent (parents are from the motherland), but did not drop out of high school to go lay bricks. I finished high school, attended college (some days) and ended up in a career in telecommunications. A quite successful one, at that. Don't get me wrong, I would much prefer that my kids go to university and "make something" of themselves, rather than taking a job out of high school, but only because someone who completes post secondary education is more likely to find a career and work a job that they enjoy. I considered joining one of the many family businesses, but truthfully, don't know if I can handle the physical labour.

However, all of these generalizations about Portuguese people that go outside of what the OP states are ridiculous and almost offensive. Good thing that I don't really care about what all you cake eaters think anyway. : D
 
...and to you Mr Larue...I said I'd get to you....

JohnLarue said:
Grammar WTF ??
Its not important on a board like this
The Masters degree did not teach me spelling (I never could, and probably never will spell words well). If its is real important, then I get someone to check it for me, spell checker catches most errors.
The Masters taught me to apply logic, analytical thinking, reasoning and focus on big issues.

Criticizing spelling is a trivial, wasteful exercise, however if it makes you feel better, knock yourself out

So here it is
Dispute all the great trades related jobs currently in the market place (as you describe)
1. A drop out is not assured of getting one of them
2. Economic conditions may greatly reduce the volume of these great jobs.
3. Firms in search of more efficient methods will always seek new construction methods. Many which will either
a) require less labor overall
b) require more specialized (educated) labor

These kids are greatly increasing the risk of a limited economic future for themselves by not finishing high school.
Argue against this age old truism all you wish, however its is more relevant than when the last generation was telling their kids to remain in school
Grammar is always important, even on a board like this, because it's a direct representation of who you are. Your masters degree should have, almost certainly, taught you grammar since I'm sure that most of your professors would have nailed you to the wall for the use of poor spelling or grammar. ESPECIALLY in a MBA program, since a large part of your work would likely be writing correspondance such as reports and forecasts to colleagues and onlookers.

Although I do not have my MBA, I am still responsible for hiring people to work as part of my sales force and many of the applicants that I encounter have their MBA or at least a business degree. I can assure you that one of the main things that I look at is whether or not they use proper spelling, grammar and punctuation. These people will be the representation for my company and, therefore, I expect them to be able to write properly.

Just my two cents....
 
futurelegend said:
...and to you Mr Larue...I said I'd get to you....


Grammar is always important, even on a board like this, because it's a direct representation of who you are. Your masters degree should have, almost certainly, taught you grammar since I'm sure that most of your professors would have nailed you to the wall for the use of poor spelling or grammar. ESPECIALLY in a MBA program, since a large part of your work would likely be writing correspondance such as reports and forecasts to colleagues and onlookers.

Although I do not have my MBA, I am still responsible for hiring people to work as part of my sales force and many of the applicants that I encounter have their MBA or at least a business degree. I can assure you that one of the main things that I look at is whether or not they use proper spelling, grammar and punctuation. These people will be the representation for my company and, therefore, I expect them to be able to write properly.

Just my two cents....

Correspondence is spelled with e not an a as you have written. (As per spell checker)
If your going to criticize me for grammar & spelling, please ensure yours is perfect or keep your two cents to yourself
You can apologize if you wish.


Like I said its never been a strong point and is not critical to making my point.
I do not really have the time to proof read posts for this board. I hit the spell checker. If thats not good enough for you, then do not read my posts

Grammar was never an issue for any report submitted in the MBA program.
I was more vigilant there and in my professional career, than here on the board.

Proper spelling, grammar and punctuation are nice to haves for a salesman, however if they cant sell, they are not much good to you on your sale force are they?

Conversely, are you sure you have not prematurely dismissed an applicant for your sales force due to poor grammar without knowing if he / she was a dynamite sales rep?
 
I think there are many ways to achieve success in career and life. Many Portuguese have adopted one model and they seem to be doing fine in their career/job and life. My own personal view is that one should obtain at least a high school diploma before going into a trade, college or university, but that is my view and may not necessarily be appropriate for everyone.
 
I am Canadian, from a Portuguese decent

I expect them to be able to write properly.

I hope you'll be lenient if they make the occasional mistake. ;)

but for the boneheaded exchange of the thread award....

Originally Posted by james t kirk
Well, here's another "generalization" about Portuguese vs. Italian Construction workers.


The Portuguese take pride in quantity of work accomplished in one day. The Italians take pride the quality of their work.

Seriously, I've worked with both Italians and Portuguese in the trades and the Portuguese crew will form twice as many square feet in a day as the Italian crew, but it will look like shit because they lack finess which the Italians have in spades. At the end of the day, the Portuguese will be all proud that they formed X square feet, but the Italians will be proud that they formed a wall that would make Michael Angelo proud.

The Italian crews - their work will be mint. Straight, tie ins are 100%, they think ahead. In the end, they will save you money because their work is so good.

Sadly, the Italian crews are fading away because young Italians have no intention of working like the old man did - busting his hump from 6 in the morning till 8 at night 6 days a week.

I don't know about that, but the old Italian craftsmen are gone -either passed away or retired. Some of the old Portuguese workers learned from the Italians. There are Portuguese in all lines of work and I would imagine some are quite good at what they do.

Quality in construction seems to have changed over the years too.
 
My old neighbour is Portuguese and old school. It is a MALE machismo culture MUCH more than the Italian way of life.He thinks nothing of going to the Vasco Da Gama Club a "social club" for men only spending all day coming home after 1100 pm.Hamilton has a large Porto population.Drive down James St. N. and you can see it

Many Porto men have ladies on the side a well known fact.(Catholic Church?)
Those cute little "Josie" girls (popular name for Porto girls) become butterballs after a few years and kids.

I give them credit though they work hard WHEN they work and dont seem to be wrapped up in a materialistic world like us Canadians.Family is first it seems soccer second!!!!!!!!