Porn Ultimatum

I can't believe the OP is coming HERE asking for relationship advice...I mean HOW dumb is he?

no offence dude but this is the WRONG place to be asking....

(and for the record, I say give it up (the porn). If the relationship doesn't work, porn will still be there, but will SHE be if you don't???)

I concur with everything except the sentence! Rain man (why did you choose that handle?) are you like Dustin Hoffman?
3 month relationship and she's giving ultimatums? What do you think that she'll be like in a year, five years, etc. You'll be one unhappy sportsfan. She's manipulating you now; it only gets worse.
Do you really believe that you're the only guy she's swallowed? She's got you pegged for a sucker! Dump her on March 15th because March 14 is steak and blow job day and get yours!
 
IMHO, if your significant other is giving you that kind of ultimatum, she probably shouldn't be your significant other. All you have to do to figure out this dilemma is to think about how reasonable her request is.
 
Her problem is more personal than philosophical. She has issues with her own body image...I wonder what will be next too, it’s like I’m dealing with a terrorist and if I give in to one demand what will be next?
I think you blew it by telling her you like petite women, but its a little late for that now. So you need to help her deal with her own body image issues. Give her all the positive reinforcement you can without being a complete phony. I agree with comments about it being early for ultimatums. I also like the suggestion to turn it around and ask her to give up romance novels. Because the romance novels make you feel that you do not give her enough romance and that hurts you. I would at least incorporate that into a discussion around why she wants you to give up porn. That should help her see it as her issue rather than your issue.
Just once, I’d like to have a relationship where I can be honest.
I know what you mean. I'm still working on that too.
She is an Oprah devotee, so hopefully I can find some support there. I like your advice. I’ll see how that goes.
LOL Good luck with that. It'll be a cold day in hell before Oprah comes out in favour of porn.

I guess she doesn't know about your other "hobby." LOL.
Yeah, but does she realize that she's hurting you by denying you access to something that brings you pleasure?
Did you have a frank discussion about her objections with respect to porn? Maybe she just has some misconceptions about it. If that's the case, maybe you two can sit down together and watch a movie together. If it's a feminist argument (i.e. porn is bad for women), then there's probably nothing that you can say to persuade her. Then it's up to you to choose. But I would be leery of entering into a relationship with a woman who uses the ultimatum technique so early in the relationship. What's going to be next? Dress this way or I'm out?
Or you could do what a lot of married guys do around here and lie to her that you stopped but look at porn somewhere else.
GL whatever you do.
This is well stated. Lying is an option but there are consequences to living a lie. There is a sex shop on Queen just east of Bathurst with a good selection of porn. The sales people are really helpful. Ask for a dvd that will appeal to women. And don't get something that has lots of petite women in it. Maybe even bring your gf to help pick it out, if she will agree to try it. It might normalize it in her mind to talk with the sales help who are completely open minded about sex and porn.
Is this more because she is morally and philosophically revolted by porn (and by extension, anyone who cnsumes it) or is it more of a power issue rooted in controling the other person's sexuality and the general predisposition to extracting concessions?

I only ask because the first reason is a legitimate personal preference while the second is just a reflection of a person who is incapable of love without ownership. But either way, are you really compatable with such a person?

I'd say you are wrong for each other. For either of you to stay in the relationship (at least on a serious level) you would be doingit for the wrong reasons and would require both of you to be dishonest with each other.

If you are struggling with the thought of giving up porn now, when the infatuation is fresh and hot, can you imagine how tough it will be in a few years? You will come to resent her for it. If you go behind her back, it will make you a fake and a cheat and she will eventually find out and resent you for it.

But I could be wrong. If it's important enough for you to trully embrace the change she is insisting on, then go ahead and do it. But once you do, you no longer have the right to go back and claim it was unfair or unreasonable once you agreed to it...
Good points made. RM already stated the objection to porn is due to personal issues, but there may be more behind it. I would keep these points in your mind for discussion.
I can't believe the OP is coming HERE asking for relationship advice...I mean HOW dumb is he?

no offence dude but this is the WRONG place to be asking....

(and for the record, I say give it up (the porn). If the relationship doesn't work, porn will still be there, but will SHE be if you don't???)
I don't think this statement is fair at all. You get all kinds of opinions here on terb. A lot of it is not very well thought out. A lot of it is not appropriate or relevant to the person asking. But that doesn't mean the op is going to follow the bad suggestions. Its like brainstorming an idea. All he needs to do is recognize the suggestions that will work for him.
 
" I think it’s because I told her that I like really petite girls and she’s not that petite, but she’s still very attractive and I enjoy the chemistry that her and I share."

Ok, that was your mistake - don't tell your non-petite new gf that you really like a body type she isn't. What she hears is you wanting to watch porn because you prefer (physically) the petite porn stars to her, which makes her feel dejected. So to 'eliminate the competition' she wants to ban porn from your life. It would have been better to say you liked porn without saying why. Since that cat is out of the bag, I guess you should either give it up and pursue the relationship, or secretly watch porn on the side and not tell her.

I think you nailed it right there (was that a pun?). I am a BBW & have HUGE issues with porn! (another pun?) Yeah.. I know - no need to point out the obvious & the hypocrisy / irony - I already get it. I think many posters are over analyzing it - or perhaps I haven't analyzed my feelings on the subject more. BUT, I don't want to. I don't need porn in my life & I don't need a porn-addicted guy in my life (sense the bitterness of knowing I'll be alone forever! Hehehe... ) It comes down to one basic thing - him watching porn makes her feel like crap. It doesn't matter why. It is such an inflammatory topic that hits a woman right in the female gonads that we're not going to examine it so we can feel good about it. We are aware - however consciously / subconsciously or to what degree - that our looks are a HUGE factor in our value as a person. No matter how many Oprah shows we watch or female empowerment tapes we listen to, we can not escape it. A man's constant pursuit of "different" is one of those things that makes us different & drives us crazy. Just another one of the Universe's jokes.

In this fight, there is no winner, sadly. If porn is that important to you you need to give her up. Your entertainment is going to make her feel more terrible than you can imagine & you won't be able to understand it. The more you fight for it - which you will because she made the mistake of offering an ultimatum - the more crappy she will feel about you wanting the porn more than you care how it makes her feel. This is already over - you just don't know it yet.
 
I can't believe the OP is coming HERE asking for relationship advice...I mean HOW dumb is he?

no offence dude but this is the WRONG place to be asking....

(and for the record, I say give it up (the porn). If the relationship doesn't work, porn will still be there, but will SHE be if you don't???)

......+1
 
Does anyone else find giving up porn for lent really funny?

I could use that in my stand up routine LOL.

I thought it had to be a joke...at first. Sorry Rain Man.

But once I got by that...I know where you are coming from. Same situation with me. And I really appreciate the post from AJ Raven in a post above explaining why it bothers her so much too. That is the best explanation I have ever heard.
 
Why are you dating a fat chick??

Anyhow, you have to determine whether her ultimatum is a power grab or because she feels you are creepy and cheating on her by looking at porn. If you are in a respectful and equal relationship, then out of respect for your woman you shouldn't really be looking at porn. But....assuming you live apart, try to cut back on your surfing and simply lie to her that you are no longer looking at porn. Yes, that takes a chunk of the respect out of the relationship, but I suspect she is trying to impose her morals on you. That's fine, as you and your ideal mate should be somewhat similar in your beliefs, but its rarely fair that one person be required to fully adopt the wants/needs/ideals/morals/demands of their partner. But......such things really can't be explained to a woman. So, surf porn, keep your mouth shut about it, and be honest and faithful in every other aspect of your relationship.
 
No!!!

Do not negotiate, do not discuss. If she's giving you an ultimatum, show her the door NOW.
I would cheerfully bet $100 that she will shortly come back begging for forgiveness, and you just might be able to have a relationship where you are accepted for what you are and maybe even treated with a little respect now and then.

Why the hell would you ever even tell a woman about porn? She will never understand a man's perspective on this. It's like a cat trying to explain to us its feelings about chasing birds.

Dude, you have to rethink your concept of honesty. Telling a woman you're involved with that you prefer a different body type from hers, and then telling her about downloading porn is not being "honest". It's being a fucking moron.


It's time for you to man up. Or you can be like so many men and spend the rest of your life lying, cheating and feeling guilty. Your choice.
 
how important is she to you? is porn more important than a real woman? if it is, then you may have some addiction issues.
 
i disagree....just because we don't practice what we preach doesn't mean that we don't have the knowledge or that it is invalid.

But I would never accept advice from a hyppocrite.....

how important is she to you? is porn more important than a real woman? if it is, then you may have some addiction issues.

No shit.....the way the guys are talking here you'd think she asked him to give up seeing his friends or something......

The one who suggested watching it together isn't a bad idea. I had a gf once who never watched it so we'd get naked under the comforter on the couch, put on something and then fool around while it was on. She eventually said that she liked to watch it with me because SHE could play out fantasies at the same time. Her big turn on was thinking of me with another chick so she'd like the three way scenes.
 
If you find this choice a dilemma, just my opinion but I think you've got a bigger smelly fish to fry. As others say, it's a lame issue to draw a line in the sand over. If she wants you to dump your friends, join a cult, ask her permission before ordering from the menu or drinking a social beer, etc., then it's time to make a stand or look else where.
Do yourself a favor. Even if you split with her, give up porn for a while, prove to yourself you can do it. You don't want a woman controlling you, logically you don't want porn or some other addiction controlling you either.
 
I’d just really like to be honest in a relationship for a change, and she should except me as I am.

Except or Accept? Now, are you saying that she should accept you as a porn addict? Or are you saying she should accept what you do as opposed to who you are?

We can change what we do, but it is more difficult to change who we are.

Here's a good question for you:
Can you go 24, 48 72 hrs without watching porn? If you can't, what you've got there is an addiction. And IF you have an addiction, substitute the word alcohol or meth or crack for the word porn.

So, should she accept you as a crack addict? Alcoholic? Meth Addict?

Now there are good addictions: wanting to help others, working out, hosting dinner parties, giving to charities, but for the most part, addictions are a negative in someone's life......if you DO have an addiction, why WOULDN'T you want to quit?
 
Porn is an addiction? What a bunch of happy horseshit, and what a profound abuse of the word "addiction", which used to have some meaning.

If it wasn't for the male sex drive the human race would have gone extinct eons ago. Why the hell should men go around being ashamed of being horny and needing a release now and then? Of course most women don't understand it - how could they? This is why sometimes the most honest thing a man can do is to not tell women everything.

Regardless of this, any man who puts up with this sort of ultimatum deserves all the endless misery he will surely receive.
 
Porn is definitely addictive. Watch out young Jedi! Keep it in moderation or soon your stiffy will turn to spaghetti unless you're glued to the screen.

My take is that if you are fucking the crap out of your voluptuous lady then she wouldn't care. Are you giving her orgasms? It seems natural to me to fantasize about other women but not to the point where it is interfering with your relationship. Only you know the answer to that question. Find the right balance!
 
I forced my wife to quit smoking. She did. I figure she's better off for it.

In the case of smoking I had notions that I wanted a partner that would still be around when I'm older, it's one of my goals not to be old and lonely and a partner who smokes simply isn't likely to be there later on. I made that clear to her early on while we were still dating, that I could not be serious with a smoker and that she's have to quit if she wanted to be more than friends. In the case of porn the issue is just ideological so it seems silly but some people are pretty seriously attached to their ideology.

Ultimatums are fine so long as you really mean it. If blueflame's GF is now ex- because she stuck by her words and left him good on her, she knows what she wants, and it wasn't him. If she backed down from the ultimatum then that's indecisive and lame.
 
I wonder fuji: does your wife know you see sp's?

As for Roger Melonhead: yeah, porn can be an addiction. In fact, just about anything can become an addiction. Hell there's hundreds of thousands who are addicted to world of warcraft. One guy's wife left him, he lost his job, got kicked out of his apartment, all because the ONLY thing he wanted to do was play that fricken game 24/7. Now he's homeless and any money he panhandles he spends at the internet cafe playing the game. THAT'S an addition.

Anytime you can't go more than a day or two without is an addiction (and don't turn this around to and say "water")......
 
One significant factor is that women are in general, not particularly turned on by porn. However, a number of psychological studies have shown that they get the same sort of stimulation of the brain from reading "Bodice rippers" that men do from watching porn.

Yet porn has a negative image while “Bodice rippers” do not.

Oh by the way welcome to TERB Rainman.

I remember reading a study on women's responses to porn. First they asked women what kind of porn excited them. They got the usual boring shit about Romance, desire, bodice rippers, blah blah blah.

Then they wired them up to measure their physical responses - heart rate, blood pressure, pussy wetness, etc.

A funny thing happened. When shown so called "Femme Porn" the results were that the women were not turned on. When shown the really nasty shit - woman gets taken behind the barn and gang raped by Uncle Pete and the stable gang - those pussies started throbbing.

What women say turns them on and what really turns them on can be 2 very different things.
 
Hey James, I saw that study or one similar. They did it to men too. I think the one I saw was being done at a university and they had all sorts: college chicks, moms, cougars and you're right. For the most part, it was the raunchy hot and heavy stuff that did the trick.
 
Oprah-devoted, anti-porn, with ultimatums. I'm guessing she has some good qualities too or you wouldn't be conflicted....