Polls and Privacy

Hangman

The Ideal Terbite
Aug 6, 2003
5,593
3
0
www.fark.com
So I see some newer members are all curious about Terbites. All these polls are a very bad idea, as I'm sure most of you realize. If you participate, and especially if you respond with specifics in the thread, you are associating identifying information with your username. It may be innocuous, but it may not. Anyone with sufficient patience and motivation can go through your entire posting history to glean details about you. If you use the same username on other boards, the potential vulnerability increases.

It's always newbies, too.

"How much do you make?"
"How much do you hobby?"
"How tall are you?"
"What's your education?"
"Why do you hobby?"
"Are you married?"

A sense of community is all well and good, but let's give the personal questions a rest. Mind your own business and don't be so damn curious.

If you have such a desperate need to share and connect, I suggest Facebook. Not Terb.
 
Since we can't control what's posted, that's why we should just ignore such polls.

But yeah, it's annoying, even if 'some' of the queries are innocent. There seem to be a lot of folks on TERB who don't care about discretion - and if that works for them, more power to 'em I guess. Good warning to those that do reply and provide details.
 
I always assume most of the polls from new members are the result of said members being sociology students at UofT wanting to do reserach into who uses review boards lol.
 
If you participate, and especially if you respond with specifics in the thread, you are associating identifying information with your username. It may be innocuous, but it may not. Anyone with sufficient patience and motivation can go through your entire posting history to glean details about you.
Actually I found the recent polls interesting. Further there is posting and there is posting. Hopefully all of us on boards like TERB have a sense of "situational awareness" and don't post details so specific as to identify us as particular individuals. "I'm a physician" is quite different from "I'm an Attending Neurologist in Kingston" Likewise "I live outside the city" or "I don't live in Ontario" is quite different from "I live along the river in Peterborough."
 
It is my impression that anonymous polls on TERB are precisely that.

Perhaps Fred or the Mods would care to clarify this?
 
I always assume most of the polls from new members are the result of said members being sociology students at UofT wanting to do reserach into who uses review boards lol.
I highly doubt it. There are methodologicl and ethical standards to follow when doing research in social sciences, especially when involving human beings. Data gathered through anonymous polls on an anonymous internet review board without disclosing the purpose of the data gathering wouldn't meet the minimum standards.
 
Since we can't control what's posted, that's why we should just ignore such polls.

But yeah, it's annoying, even if 'some' of the queries are innocent.

LOL!
Either ignore the polls or give false answers to fark up the polls.
 
Anyone with sufficient patience and motivation can go through your entire posting history to glean details about you.

Yup, and more likely than you may think. You have no idea who I am, or other terb posters are. It's possible we know each other in real life. If you are a sociable person, it's PROBABLE that someone you know is also on TERB.

It will happen like this:

You post some comment on some thread about something you did, and this person says, huh that's funny, my friend just said/did the same thing yesterday. I wonder...

Then they go looking through your posting history in detail for confirmation that it's you, and bingo, yup, same age, yup, same job, yup, same city, same number of kids, oh look same vacation, drives the same car, check, yup it's him.

Now they know who you are, and everything about you that you post here, but you don't know that about them. Depending who they are, their relationship to you, this might not go down well for you.
 
I tend to agree with"Hangman" so I have made a concious decision not to post any more polls and ignore polls from now on, as well as Genintoronto said they do not meet the minimum standards either so henceforth NO POLLS
 
Yup, and more likely than you may think. You have no idea who I am, or other terb posters are. It's possible we know each other in real life. If you are a sociable person, it's PROBABLE that someone you know is also on TERB.

It will happen like this:

You post some comment on some thread about something you did, and this person says, huh that's funny, my friend just said/did the same thing yesterday. I wonder...

Then they go looking through your posting history in detail for confirmation that it's you, and bingo, yup, same age, yup, same job, yup, same city, same number of kids, oh look same vacation, drives the same car, check, yup it's him.

Now they know who you are, and everything about you that you post here, but you don't know that about them. Depending who they are, their relationship to you, this might not go down well for you.

Thanks Fuji for elaborating - that's the kind of thing I'm talking about. I'm not talking about becoming paranoid counterintelligence freaks, just about curbing the natural social instinct to blab and share.
I'm not talking about the poll mechanism except insofar as they encourage people to elaborate.
And as for all the belief that polls are anonymous, I don't personally believe that ANYTHING you post online is truly private unless you've taken your own scurity precautions. But no need to get your faces in a knot; its just a friendly piece of advice and food for thought.
 
So I see some newer members are all curious about Terbites. All these polls are a very bad idea, as I'm sure most of you realize. If you participate, and especially if you respond with specifics in the thread, you are associating identifying information with your username. It may be innocuous, but it may not. Anyone with sufficient patience and motivation can go through your entire posting history to glean details about you. If you use the same username on other boards, the potential vulnerability increases.

It's always newbies, too.

"How much do you make?"
"How much do you hobby?"
"How tall are you?"
"What's your education?"
"Why do you hobby?"
"Are you married?"

A sense of community is all well and good, but let's give the personal questions a rest. Mind your own business and don't be so damn curious.

If you have such a desperate need to share and connect, I suggest Facebook. Not Terb.



It was never my intention to violate any privacy or the sanctity of terb. If I did I apologize.
I never expected this sort of reaction from the polls I posted. They have been done before. Perhaps these same polls have been done so much that they have become annoying. If so, then perhaps future polls should be removed and their should be a restriction. However, if annoyance is factor that dictates the viability of a thread then a lot of threads and face extinction and restriction.

Whether or not one decides to participate in a poll is a matter or free will. If one suspects an ulterior motive to any poll...or thread for that matter... one can choose not to participate. The polls I posted were simply based on typing a unique and interesting populous here on Terb. There is no commercial, socioeconomic, no detective or any other gain nor motive for the polls.

To be clear the polls are anonymous...no handles are revealed... and the information, as all threads/posts/pictures, is strictly for terbdum.

The behaviour and success of one going through these polls and associating ones answers to a certain individual leading to a revelation of a true identity is beyond me and seems unlikely.

Hangman, rest assured I am not a newbie and have been a part of terb for a long time, in a few forms, but my profession disconnected me therefore I had to renew. To put to rest any questions of any altruistic motive behind my polls...and I can't believe i have to justify this.....but I am in health care, and if you have any medical questions please feel free to ask,and yes, I will have to strictest privacy and confidentiality.

I know that within any population there it is highly likely that any opinion, thought or action will be criticized and deemed unfit by someone.
I just posted an anonymous poll that seemed benign with the purest intentions.

As with any thread. Post/Vote if you want.
If one finds a problem with that, and by the logic displayed here, prehaps the mods should remove the poll option entirely and restrict thread topics...because everytime one posts a thought, an opinion, a vote, a review etc..they are revealing something about themselves.
 
Chaos, if you've been a member of Terb for a long time in one form or another, then you should know polls are BS as many Terbites don't take them seriously and just lie, they don't care and no harm done. You're correct we don't have to participate and I for one don't, they are useless, frivilous data that does not reflect reality, but then again, Terb is fantasy, so if fantasy polls are your thing, knock yourself out. Why a profedssional in the healthcare field would start a poll on STD's is beyond me, especially when you should know that no one will tell you the truth on this board, but you must have your reasons.

What bugs me is the number of polls you've initiated in such a short period of time, you've basically spammed the General Forum and is irritating, perhaps there should be a forum dedicated just to polls and then you can really go to town.
 
polls are BS as many Terbites don't take them seriously and just lie, they don't care and no harm done.

What bugs me is the number of polls you've initiated in such a short period of time, you've basically spammed the General Forum and is a waste of our time, perhaps there should be a forum dedicated just to polls and then you can really go to town.
\

I see your point MiaColpa, and you are correct. I knew that there was a chance of sensationalism thereby rendering a poll like this largely unreliable. However, the size of the misnomers is uncertain. Likewise the same uncertainty can be applied to any thread requesting opinions/help (there will always be disturbers out there giving false opinions/data...in any thread)
I do apologize for spamming. It was not my intent. I just wanted to be complete.

However, in terms of wasting time, there are a lot of threads on here that can be considered a waste of time. Furthermore a lot of members post many threads over a short period of time.
In all cases one just reads the title.. perhaps the introductory thread and moves not without any further form of engagement.

I thought the problem with demographic polls was an issue of a possible dereliction of privacy and hence the problem with me posting those polls.The solution to that has been outlined, and a violating this privacy was not my intent. I thought anonymity would be the solution to what I thought were innocent polls.

If it is an issue of spamming again I apologize. And if i offended/irritated/bugged anyone I apologize.

Now let's get out there and make some SPs/MPAs happy.
 
ChaosTheory, I for one found your polls interesting. As Sheik said anonymous polls are just that ANONYMOUS, there is absolutely no reason to lie on them - if you don't want to answer a particular anonymous poll then don't.

Of course due to their voluntary nature and the spoiled child factor always present on TERB, they doubtless give a warped view who we actually are at TERB but I think some interesting broad outlines are certainly there.
 
ChaosTheory, I for one found your polls interesting. As Sheik said anonymous polls are just that ANONYMOUS, there is absolutely no reason to lie on them - if you don't want to answer a particular anonymous poll then don't.

Of course due to their voluntary nature and the spoiled child factor always present on TERB, they doubtless give a warped view who we actually are at TERB but I think some interesting broad outlines are certainly there.

LOL, love it, well said.