Politicians eyeing circumcision ban

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
Danish Politicians eyeing circumcision ban
Published 18.11.08 14:42

Several parliamentary parties are considering creating legislation that would spare all children from circumcision - not just girls A proposal to ban circumcision for boys may be on its way to parliament after intense discussions by MPs over the past...

Although circumcision of girls was outlawed in response to the practice being common among immigrants from some Muslim countries, boys may still be circumcised if a certified physician is present.

Jewish traditions calls for the circumcision of newborn boys, and many Muslims and Christians support the practice as well. But both the Ethics Council and the National Council for Children have recently criticised the practice, stating that a boy should be able to decide for himself if he wants the procedure performed when he reaches the age of 15 - the legal age in Denmark for a child to have sole jurisdiction over his own body.

While the Social Democrats, Red-Green Alliance and Liberal Alliance have come out in support of a ban, the Danish People's Party called it 'tyranny'.

'It's completely ridiculous to compare the circumcision of girls - which is a barbaric mutilation - with that of boys, where it's just the removal of a skin flap,' said the party's Jesper Langballe.

But the party's own health spokeswoman, Liselott Brixt, said she supports a ban.

'A lot of parents want it done to their children because they themselves had it done. But we're living in the present and it isn't fair to expose healthy children to religious circumcision.'

Medical wisdom is mixed on the supposed benefits of male circumcision, some studies claiming it prevents disease while others indicate normal hygiene procedures sufficiently negate the need for the practice.

The American Academy of Pediatrics does not support male circumcision, indicating any health advantages from it are minimal.
 
So no Jewish infants in Denmark then?

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
So no Jewish infants in Denmark then?

If it becomes law, I am sure the jewish people as well as the muslim people in
denmark will (have to) obey the laws of the landt
 
danmand said:
Danish Politicians eyeing circumcision ban
Published 18.11.08 14:42



But the party's own health spokeswoman, Liselott Brixt, said she supports a ban.

...... 'it isn't fair to expose healthy children to religious circumcision.'

This is the anti religious types advancing their adgenda.

EU
 
danmand said:
If it becomes law, I am sure the jewish people as well as the muslim people in
denmark will (have to) obey the laws of the landt

I'm not sure what the state of religious freedom is in Denmark but I think that in Canada a law prohibiting circumcision of males without allowing exceptions for religious practice would violate the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and would be struck down by the courts. The court would balance the harm to the child and the societal interest in protecting children with freedom of religion, and I think given the relative importance and seriousness of both, the court would weigh in favour of religious freedom.

This will be an interesting test of the progressiveness of the Danes. (And personally I think Denmark ROCKS.)
 
enduser1 said:
This is the anti religious types advancing their adgenda.

I don't think so. I think it is more a human rights issue. European countries
have outlawed the "circumcision" of girls. The argument then is: Logically, then why should it be allowed on boys?

DATYdude said:
I'm not sure what the state of religious freedom is in Denmark but I think that in Canada a law prohibiting circumcision of males without allowing exceptions for religious practice would violate the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and would be struck down by the courts. The court would balance the harm to the child and the societal interest in protecting children with freedom of religion, and I think given the relative importance and seriousness of both, the court would weigh in favour of religious freedom.

Is genital "circumcision" of girls allowed in Canada?

I fail to see how circumcision has anything to do with religion. If you accept that as
"religious practice", then you also must accept the smoking of weed and carrying a
dagger as "religious practice"
 
Last edited:
I'm glad I had mine done when I could not remember the pain...waiting to age 15 would make it more painful to be done..then it needs to heal for months. The risk of infections goes up too until its done...glad I need not to wash my dick too well when I was a kid.

Its best to get it done the first few weeks of being born...sure I wounder how it would have been if it wasn't done but since I never caught an infection down there or got STD, maybe been circumcision help.
 
A country with animal prostitutes, a national religion and now this.... crazy place my ancestors immigrated from....

OTB
 
If evolution had no reasons for it then you would have been born without a foreskin, removing it is saying evolution was wrong, and it never is

the reasons it is done is to damage nerves so the guy is NEVER 100% sexually satisfied and turns his energy to perusing other goals
 
All i can say on this was that after my circumcision i couldn't walk for at least a year. Speaking was difficult also.





.
 
slaconte1978 said:
If evolution had no reasons for it then you would have been born without a foreskin, removing it is saying evolution was wrong, and it never is

'Evolution' has no reasons, no goals, and no end. 'Evolution' is a blind process of genetic variance that may lead to an improved ability of a species to survive.

jwm
 
danmand said:
I don't think so. I think it is more a human rights issue. European countries
have outlawed the "circumcision" of girls. The argument then is: Logically, then why should it be allowed on boys?



Is genital "circumcision" of girls allowed in Canada?

I fail to see how circumcision has anything to do with religion. If you accept that as
"religious practice", then you also must accept the smoking of weed and carrying a
dagger as "religious practice"

1. Just because the name "circumcision" is applied to both, doesn't mean they are the same in any way. They are different in method and effect. So the logic of your argument is just about the same as "I am allergic to dogs so I must also be allergic to cats."

2. Just because you fail to see how it has anything to do with religion does not mean it has nothing to do with religion, it means YOU FAIL TO SEE IT. Clearly it has a lot to do with 3000 years or more of my religion. That doesn't make it right for you, but I'm not trying to control your life, you're trying to control mine.

3. Smoking weed is a religious practice to some and - less controversially - carrying a dagger is a religious practice to others. Absolutely I accept that. In the case of the latter, so has the Supreme Court of Canada.

I can guarantee you that nobody will ever force you to circumcise your children OR carry a dagger OR have a same-sex wedding. Just don't tell me what to do because you think it's bad, when the level of harm is small relative to the religious or personal significance it has for me. (PS none of this has to do with female 'circumcision", which is more properly called genital mutilation and should be outlawed.)
 
DATYdude said:
1. Just because the name "circumcision" is applied to both, doesn't mean they are the same in any way. They are different in method and effect. So the logic of your argument is just about the same as "I am allergic to dogs so I must also be allergic to cats."

It is not really my argument, and I completely agree with you, that female and male "circumcision" are completely different. that is why I put apostrophies around the word. However, both are mutilations of the body.

DATYdude said:
2. Just because you fail to see how it has anything to do with religion does not mean it has nothing to do with religion, it means YOU FAIL TO SEE IT. Clearly it has a lot to do with 3000 years or more of my religion. That doesn't make it right for you, but I'm not trying to control your life, you're trying to control mine.

I am not trying to control your life, so continue daty'ing.:)

DATYdude said:
3. Smoking weed is a religious practice to some and - less controversially - carrying a dagger is a religious practice to others. Absolutely I accept that. In the case of the latter, so has the Supreme Court of Canada.

You just agreed with me that circumcision has nothing to do with religion.
When any act can be claimed to be religious, then none are.


DATYdude said:
I can guarantee you that nobody will ever force you to circumcise your children OR carry a dagger OR have a same-sex wedding. Just don't tell me what to do because you think it's bad, when the level of harm is small relative to the religious or personal significance it has for me. (PS none of this has to do with female 'circumcision", which is more properly called genital mutilation and should be outlawed.)

Please direct your indignity somewhere else. I was merely trying to explain what the
background for the proposal is, it is not my proposal. I do think, if you are looking for
an argument, that all mutilations, however small they are in your
opinion, should be decided by the body itself, not someone else. In denmark,
the age for that would be 15.
 
slaconte1978 said:
If evolution had no reasons for it then you would have been born without a foreskin, removing it is saying evolution was wrong, and it never is

the reasons it is done is to damage nerves so the guy is NEVER 100% sexually satisfied and turns his energy to perusing other goals

Thats funny. Why do we have an appendix? I guess Evolution wanted us to have a useless organ that would build up toxins over a life time?

I know a lot of people are really uptight over circumcision. It does slow the spread of aids. But it appears bone marrow transplants cure that so.....

Whatever.

EU
 
Normally I prefer if governments do not restrict the freedom of consenting adults. The issue for me is whether the parents have the right to mutilate their child. There is discussion of preventing parents from spanking their children, but spanking has a lot more practical use than circumcision.

And there are degrees of female circumcision, the least severe is basically trimming the outer labia. Which is not that different than removing the foreskin. I consider both unacceptably barbaric.

My solution is that it is allowed, but you have to pay a $1,000 circumcision tax. That way hardcore religious people can get it legally, but the average person is not likely to, so fewer babies get mutilated.
 
I had my son circumcised last year because I thought it was the right thing to do at the time. I was, so it seemed pretty normal to me. I don't feel like I have suffered because of it at all. It was not a religious decision. You will find no one more fiercely atheistic than me. But I truly regret it now and have been wracked with guilt about it. Certainly wouldn't do it again.
 
I don't see the harm it could cause a male. The foreskin is not needed and traps piss in between which can cause infections if not regularly clean. Plus by removing the fore skin the head gets tougher and less likely for the skin to break open when having sex--the main reason its thought to help stop the guy from getting aids. Once the skin breaks open, the grems can get right in to the blood.

It never happen but if all males were circumcision it might just help reduce the spead of STD.

As for "looks" who the heck sees it, very few people. I enjoy sex just fine, also.

The trend today is moving away from circumcision thou...maybe its just the governments and insurance company's to reduce health care costs.

Its much easier to be done when the guy is still a baby, then when he is a teenager. It be so painful to do it --I would rather be spank I believe, ha ha.

As for females, that is wrong to do.
 
The way I look at it is this. I had my sons done very soon after they were born right in the hospital. I did not even wait till I got home to choose another doctor to take them to. I paid the whole more expensive amount to be done after the birth. I feel a baby already is traumatized from the birthing experience and it is a whole new world for them. They a poked in the feet with needle to test glucose amounts etc... in thier blood and just entirely not liking the new world anyway. I say get it all done at once and then move on to a much happier and comforting life in Mothers arms, being nursed and cuddles and wrapped tightly in receivin blankets. Jesh a baby even totally hates having that first bath. Everything is all soon forgotten and days later you see a much more relaxed baby that is more used to the experiences.

If I was a male I would prefer to have it done right after birth myself.

My first husband I recall when he had his done and he wished it was done at birth. Apparently his family just did not have the money at the time and as he got older they did not want to put him through it at a later age. He himself said that he preffered it once it was done and that sex was more enjoyable and he felt it looked much better too.
 
S.C. Joe said:
The trend today is moving away from circumcision thou...maybe its just the governments and insurance company's to reduce health care costs.

.


How do you figure that. I had to pay cash to the hospital. The government never footed that bill. My c section yes and other things needed while I was staying there like my blood patch etc... but they did not cover that.
 
Hygiene? Removing a kid's foreskin to make it easier for him to clean his penis is like cutting his ear off to make it easier for him to get the wax out. The key to good hygiene is good hygiene.

Evolution? I can see that the human appendix might be evolutionarily accidental. But of all things evolutionary, anything to do with the penis is right where evolution is at. The chance of anything to do with the penis being evolutionarily accidental is surely very remote. Don't mess with the kid's penis!

Religion? If a reasonably-mature adult wants to have his foreskin removed, for any reason including religious, by all means let him do that. Just as, if he wants to remove his own ears, let him do that if he wants. (Although we might regard his wanting to cut his ears off as evidence he was not reasonably-mature.) But IMO it is right that we should have laws to prevent his parents from making those decisions for him. Even to the fanatically religious, where's the harm in leaving it until the young man can decide for himself?