Police Videos

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Ever since Rodney King, there has been a string of videos and/or photos of police in action taken by private citizens. Two questions:

1) Isn't it illegal to take a video of somebody, especially a police officer, without their consent?

2) Isn't it illegal making the video public (e.g. YouTube) without the person's consent?
 
I am not a lawyer but...

... I think if someone is in a public place it is not illegal. It would be illegal to secretly videotape them in a private place though.
 
fuji said:
I am not a lawyer but...

... I think if someone is in a public place it is not illegal. It would be illegal to secretly videotape them in a private place though.
True, and some of that even depends on which state or province your in.
In Quebec you cannot take pictures or video of anyone in public (without their consent)
 
What about that video showing a police officer banging a suspect's head against a car roof? Was that in Quebec? If illegal to take a photo of someone in public, what is the penalty? Would video evidence be inadmissible in court because illegal?
 
Rockslinger said:
What about that video showing a police officer banging a suspect's head against a car roof? Was that in Quebec? If illegal to take a photo of someone in public, what is the penalty? Would video evidence be inadmissible in court because illegal?

I think the video was shot in Ottawa.

No the video would not be admissible in court.
 
I believe that vidieo and pictures in public places are fine as long as there is no sound. That is what makes security cameras legal. I believe think that the vids/pics can not be used for profit without consent though.
 
basketcase said:
I believe that vidieo and pictures in public places are fine as long as there is no sound. That is what makes security cameras legal. I believe think that the vids/pics can not be used for profit without consent though.
Maybe true for most of North-america but not for Quebec!
I just recently learned you can be charged in Quebec for simply taking pics of people without their consent. (strange law IMO)
 
1) Isn't it illegal to take a video of somebody, especially a police officer, without their consent?

What difference does it make whether it is a cop or not. No way a cop just because they are a cop should have any more rights then a civilian, esspecialy when it comes to being video taped. They are being paid by the public and the public should have a right to know what they are doing.
 
there is a difference between admissibility in court and whether taking a picture or video of someone in public.

taking a shoe cam picture up a skirt is illegal because it is criminal a charge of mischief without the persons consent.

You don't think they could use the actual video in court because it is illegal is ludicrous !

picture taking or taking videos in public has not been outlawed so much for family albums or vacation videos. It is what you want to do with those pics or vids, needs someones consent to profit from it or display them.
 
XTORONTO said:
1) Isn't it illegal to take a video of somebody, especially a police officer, without their consent?


What difference does it make whether it is a cop or not. No way a cop just because they are a cop should have any more rights then a civilian, esspecialy when it comes to being video taped. They are being paid by the public and the public should have a right to know what they are doing.

Unless it is an 'undercover' cop - if you took a pic of one of those and posted it somewhere then you could be putting a life in danger....
 
Quest4Less said:
Unless it is an 'undercover' cop - if you took a pic of one of those and posted it somewhere then you could be putting a life in danger....

you would get charged for obstruct justice in that case.
 
Esco! said:
Maybe true for most of North-america but not for Quebec!
I just recently learned you can be charged in Quebec for simply taking pics of people without their consent. (strange law IMO)

The criminal law in Canada is the same in Quebec as it is in Ontario as it is everywhere else in Canada. Criminal law is a Federal issue in Canada. Period.

Perhaps under Quebec law you can sue someone if they profit from your image without your consent, but that would be quite different than being charged.
 
Esco! said:
Maybe true for most of North-america but not for Quebec!
I just recently learned you can be charged in Quebec for simply taking pics of people without their consent. (strange law IMO)

Not true - just look at all the videos on Just For Laughs Gags, and they are shot in Montreal.
 
fuji said:
The criminal law in Canada is the same in Quebec as it is in Ontario as it is everywhere else in Canada. Criminal law is a Federal issue in Canada. Period.

Perhaps under Quebec law you can sue someone if they profit from your image without your consent, but that would be quite different than being charged.

Fuji, I am very disappointed in you for injecting facts into this discussion. We all know the best legal advice comes from rumour, speculation, and what gets forwarded around the internet. ;)