Police investigating Chara hit

2canchew

Banned
May 1, 2008
779
0
0
far,far,away
Now this is too much, we are not talking about a Mel Bridgmen assault, like the one on Borji Salming back in the 70s or the Dan Malone attack on Brain Glennie, we are talking about a hit, however, with this happening and one of the most well knowen sponsor ( Air Canada ) warning the NHL to clean up there actor they will pull out, maybe, just maybe Garry Bettmen and the disciplinary committe will lislen.....but then again.
I'm just saying.
 
I wonder if it will have the opposite effect, though... ie., no effect at all on further reckless hits.
 
This is a work place safety issue and I'm not sure if it comes under the police jurisdiction.

The real culprit is the poor design of the rink as there should never have been a trap in a "workplace" where players can get seriously injuries even by innocent mistakes. This tragic incident could have easily occured when two players collided and one lost balance and hit the same spot.

I'm not debating the "intent" issue. We'll never know for sure unless Chara comes clean. The main issue now should be : what can be done to eliminate this "trap" so the tragedy will not be repeated.

It would seem to me that it was a design error. If the partition or pole was properly and adequately protected, this serious injury would not have occurred; and I don't think anyone can dispute that.
 
I'm on board with you there smuddan, there should be some sort of padding for those spots in the rink. Lets hope every NHL, and rinks everywhere for that matter, will learn by this and fix the problem
 
I'm not debating the "intent" issue. We'll never know for sure unless Chara comes clean. The main issue now should be : what can be done to eliminate this "trap" so the tragedy will not be repeated.
.

The "intent" issue??? We will never know what Chara intended. However, lets get serious here guys.. In the heat of battle (an intense hockey, football, or basketball game) sometimes your base instincts take over, and you want to slam that guy as hard as you can. At that one moment in time, some of us must think, "I am going to kill this guy". However, we don't really want our opponent dead or even injured. So intent is a difficult thing when you are playing sports.

Its surprising that the issue of these "traps" has not been corrected a long time ago. Given the speed and intensity of the game, it is also surprising that there have not been more of these types of injuries.
 
I am not completely discounting your theory, however, there are approximately 2,500+ games (including pre-season and post-season) played per year in the NHL and presumably, the padding of the "turnbuckle" is similar across the league's arenas, yet how many serious injuries have been caused (intentionally or not) by someone colliding with it? It would be very minimal.

I work in an office building with an elevator and a staircase. If I tumble down the stairs accidentally, is that poor design of the stairs? Maybe. But what if someone accidentally bumps me at the top of the steps, causing me to fall, can you blame poor design of the staircase? Even moreso, what if I am intentionally pushed down the stairs? The stairs may be poorly designed and may have been a tragedy just waiting to happen, but when you're pushed down them (intentionally or not), any poor design would just be coincidental.

So I do have to respectfully disagree with you: The Hit was the real culprit, not any design flaw.

Bob, when you're walking down the stairs you don't expect to be colliding with another person in a hundred miles per hour speed. And if you do fall, you don't want a piece of metal sticking out from nowhere and piece through your eyeball!

Hitting is part of the game and it can happen anywhere in the rink. Assuming it was a clean hit with no intent to injure, would you be ok with the injury that occurred as a result ?

There will always be players hitting to hurt the guy, and let's not be naive to think otherwise. Unless you want to totally eliminates hitting, this kind of dangerous traps should not have existed in the rink.
 
Now this is too much, we are not talking about a Mel Bridgmen assault, like the one on Borji Salming back in the 70s or the Dan Malone attack on Brain Glennie, we are talking about a hit, however, with this happening and one of the most well knowen sponsor ( Air Canada ) warning the NHL to clean up there actor they will pull out, maybe, just maybe Garry Bettmen and the disciplinary committe will lislen.....but then again.
I'm just saying.

Yeah, OK.
First thing to change is the name of the arena where the Toronto Maple Leafs play. Remove all of the 'Air Canada' ads from said arena immediately !

NHL should call their bluff and order the Leafs to change the name of their home arena.

Hmmm ... "The CTV Centre" has a nice ring.
 
I have to totally agree with you on this. When you play a game your so focused on the main goal and that's to defend the team get the puck and score on the opponents net. You don't always conscientiously think I'm going to hurt this guy or I'm going to kill this guy it just happens. It's sad that someone got seriously hurt but when you play professional sports or even junior league this happens and the only way to eliminate accidents like this is to create more disciplinary actions where checking someone or defending the team comes in. If you understand what i mean by defending the team. I went to a couple junior league games this year and was surprised to see them allow them to fight each other and not stop them. For some reason it would let me post this with the quote but I was responding to Slowandeasy's comment.
 
chara knew where the bench and the glass was, but disregarded the implications of his actions due to a personal quest for vengeance ( they had had issues)..........chara should be out for the season! Max is probably out for the career!
 
Police?
Lame.
Cops got better things to do.
 
Pacioretty is home now according to all reports.
 
One other thing. A presidence has been set.

Next player to injure another in Montreal, regardless of team, in even a marginally questionable way, must they(the law) react in the same way ?
 
I think you mean precedent.
 
Didn't the NHL just hand down a 3game suspension to someone for a elbow.........
a elbow to the HEAD !
I'm just saying

Yes, Pavel Kubina 3 games and 60K fine. Chara's hit was much worse.
 
I don't see this 'hit' as even remotely worthy of even a penalty! He basically gave the guy who was skating beside him a one handed light shove, that's it.
 
What constatiutes a 3, 5, 10 game suspension. There doesn't seem to be a scale.
I know that there are alot of circumstances for suspensions but Kubina's hit look so obvious, elbow up, heading stright for the head, bang, contact ! Only 3 games !
If it's obvious you should get 5 to start.