Police brutality or necessary force

[video]http://video.msn.com/video.aspx?mkt=en-CA&vid=a464ea8f-6420-4c03-8080-77316810ca89[/video]

And in our country.

The officer with the yellow shirt should be fired.
 
sorry, I thought the 2nd video was just another copy of the first...

I agree in the second video those 3 officers should get the maximum penalty allowed by law. There is NO question about this one.........
 
The officer with the yellow shirt should be fired.
For a few assholes, the ability to wield power without checks is the only way to get the respect they couldn't get as a civilian. Are you calmly going to put your hands (and any chance of self defense) behind your back while you are getting kicked ? I think the guy would make a good meter maid but I wouldn't trust his judgment in any normal police work.
 
Usually I give the police a lot of leeway when Vids like this surface because we're just seeing the end result and not the circumstances leading up to the ''police brutality" scenes.

But, the second vid was just horrendous and these officers need to be facing charges.

There's no explanation for that behavior that I can see.
 
Usually I give the police a lot of leeway when Vids like this surface because we're just seeing the end result and not the circumstances leading up to the ''police brutality" scenes.

But, the second vid was just horrendous and these officers need to be facing charges.

There's no explanation for that behavior that I can see.

Yup, agree with you 100% on this, that's what I do too. As you say, it is pretty cut and dried. The ONLY thing I could say might have happened is that the riot cops thought the victim was about to go after the mounted cops so they pounced. I know after many of these games riots break out so they could have been on edge.....but that is why they are trained in self control.
 
There's no explanation for that behavior that I can see.

How about the way the police released a statement containing outright LIES about what happened. If the video didn't exist, we would be led to believe that this guy struck the officers, their horses, and that the horses kicked him causing his injuries.

So even in the event that there was some explanation somebody could pull from the stars to explain the beating, there is no getting around the lies that followed. Lies of that sort should be considered criminal and carry punishment itself.
 
How about the way the police released a statement containing outright LIES about what happened. If the video didn't exist, we would be led to believe that this guy struck the officers, their horses, and that the horses kicked him causing his injuries.

So even in the event that there was some explanation somebody could pull from the stars to explain the beating, there is no getting around the lies that followed. Lies of that sort should be considered criminal and carry punishment itself.

Sorry, but everyone lies to protect themselves. EVERYONE. If you're going to start with this, then anyone who pleads not guilty to a crime and is found guilty should face additional jail time for pleading not guilty.

This is a good example of how having cameras everywhere isn't always a bad thing. I know there is a lot of debate on England and how many cameras they have everywhere (I think they are number 1 or 2 in the world for the amount they have. Supposedly if you leave your house on any given day you'll be caught on 20 cameras throughout the day).

The beauty about this video however is that it shows the WHOLE story, not just the beating part. Anyone remember Rodney King and the shitstorm that created? it was proven in court that the guy who shot the video edited out the part where Rodney was attacking the cops.......
 
Well it's posting against the flow on this thread, but most likely this was necessary force.

You would like too think so but the fact that the police so obviously lied as Gotgutso pointed out tells me different.

Nobody would believe any explanation at this point
 
The editorial take of a Vancouver Island Newspaper

Campbell River Mirror

Excessive force not solely police’s fault


"Another citizen “reporter” has captured police actions on a video camera and once again the actions of officers are under investigation. In Victoria this week, city police busting up an eight-person fight outside a night club were filmed kicking arrestees, re-igniting a furore about what constitutes excessive force in police actions.

The brief video on YouTube shows an officer kicking a man in the process of being detained. Then the same officer diverts his attention to another individual, demanding he get on the ground. When the person does so but apparently not as quickly as the officer would like, he is subjected to a full boot to the ribs. It’s brutal action and will likely result in some sort of punishment for the officer involved.

Now, nobody condones police brutality but the level of frustration exhibited by officers that sparks this kind of action, has to be considered. Weekend after weekend in Victoria, officers are called to downtown bars to quash unruly behaviour. In the process of doing so, they are subjected to all kinds of abuse. It’s a situation that is not unfamiliar to police in smaller places like Campbell River as well. It’s unreasonable to think that young officers are not going to fall victim to frustration with the futility of arrest after arrest of drunken fools charged by a loss of inhibition and rampant emotion. Outnumbered officers have training and equipment available to even the odds but restraining their own emotions is difficult.

The people perpetrating this behaviour after closing times have to shoulder some responsibility. That likely won’t come into play as these officers are scrutinized. Parallels will be drawn with the Robert Dziekanski taser death at Vancouver airport but the two situations are not the same. The night club behaviour by patrons is repetitive and Victoria has a sad history of serious injury occuring to combatants in and just outside drinking establishments."


Also the following should be noted this all occured at 12:30 a.m., and there were witnesses who saw the eight men were kicking another man in the head while he was lying on the ground (said victim has decided he is not going to cooperate)
 
without the full context of the situation it is difficult to assess the actuall situation, that said the officer with the kicking fetish should be charged with assault, the guy was getting down but apparantl;y not fast enough.
 
No amount of "frustration" would even come close to justifying trying to break some guys ribs by kicking him. A slight miscalculation or sudden movement and you have a fractured skull or worse. I'm disgusted with the cop and just as disgusted with the editor of the Campbell River Mirror who just proved why he/she works for some two-bit wortless rag. Charges need to be filed against anyone who kicked anyone in the head cop or not.
 
No amount of "frustration" would even come close to justifying trying to break some guys ribs by kicking him. A slight miscalculation or sudden movement and you have a fractured skull or worse. I'm disgusted with the cop and just as disgusted with the editor of the Campbell River Mirror who just proved why he/she works for some two-bit wortless rag. Charges need to be filed against anyone who kicked anyone in the head cop or not.

so, do the same laws apply to you? any law you break you should be charged with no matter what the circumstances?
 
Sorry, but everyone lies to protect themselves. EVERYONE. If you're going to start with this, then anyone who pleads not guilty to a crime and is found guilty should face additional jail time for pleading not guilty.

In a case like this... where it is blatently obvious that the defense offered is full of falsehoods I would have no problem with someone getting extra penalties for pleading not guilty. If the cops in this video had just come out and said "we overreacted, we are sorry" I would be willing to have some sympathy for them. But in this case the 3 of them conspired to fabricate a fiction that would completely exonerate them from the situation. There is no acceptable explanation for this behaviour.
 
In a case like this... where it is blatently obvious that the defense offered is full of falsehoods I would have no problem with someone getting extra penalties for pleading not guilty. If the cops in this video had just come out and said "we overreacted, we are sorry" I would be willing to have some sympathy for them. But in this case the 3 of them conspired to fabricate a fiction that would completely exonerate them from the situation. There is no acceptable explanation for this behaviour.

ok, are we talking about the first or second video? I'm referring to the second as is the newspaper column......