It's just like you say in your question, it's to keep players guessing. As a rule for myself, if I show anything, I will only show one card and the card I show will depend on what kind of read I have gotten from a player during the hand. You can usually tell when someone is trying to throw their weight around the table and be a bully. It's at that point that if I lay down a hand, I will show my better card. I have actually even gone to the length of telling my opponent in a heads up battle exactly what I have, again just to keep them guessing. I was playing last night and told my buddy flat out that I was holding a 7 / 3 off suit and asked him, how do you play against that? Because of my betting during that hand he ended up folding a pair of nines because he had himself convinced I was really holding better cards. In that particular case I showed him the 3 after he folded. Priceless reaction.