Please read if you do NOT usually vote.

1HandInMyPocket

Unoffical Capital One rep
Mar 2, 2002
1,563
0
36
Mirror Universe
Though this thread is a political topic, I do not believe it should be in the Politics Forum since I wish it to be read my a more general audience that usually would not read threads in the Politics Forum.

I heard about this site before but also noticed that it has already been brought up in the Politics Forum but want to make more people aware of it; VoteCompass on the CBC website http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canadavotes2011/votecompass/

I do get disappointed when I hear about low voter turnouts in Canada and I hope part of the reason is that people may not always know where each Party stands in relation to their own beliefs. The VoteCompass site asks a series of questions then shows which Party has the most in common with your beliefs. You can also see where each Party stand in individual questions.
 
When a million Canadians vote for a party and they don't get a single seat I understand why they wouldn't bother to vote again.

This lack of representation of citizens doesn't bother the major parties, they like the status quo.
 
I think the majority of the younger generation doesn't give a shit. Including me. (Lets say... under 24 years old) Not saying all, but probably the ones that find politics interesting would be the ones to vote.
 
I always make time to vote
NONEOFTHEABOVE-1.jpg
 
I think in general a parliamentary system of government with a "first past the post" system tend to lead to low voter turnout, since the votes of a significant percentage of votes are essentially disregarded. I am curious as to whether other voting systems, such as mixed proportional representation, lead to higher voter participation (perhaps looking at the example of Australia or New Zealand could be instructive).
 
Though this thread is a political topic, I do not believe it should be in the Politics Forum since I wish it to be read my a more general audience that usually would not read threads in the Politics Forum.

I heard about this site before but also noticed that it has already been brought up in the Politics Forum but want to make more people aware of it; VoteCompass on the CBC website http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canadavotes2011/votecompass/

I do get disappointed when I hear about low voter turnouts in Canada and I hope part of the reason is that people may not always know where each Party stands in relation to their own beliefs. The VoteCompass site asks a series of questions then shows which Party has the most in common with your beliefs. You can also see where each Party stand in individual questions.

According to the Sun, one of the architects of that compass worked for Iggy during his last campaign.
 
I read somewhere before that voting is mandatory in Australia -- is the same also the case in New Zealand?

If so, perhaps that is something worth considering in Canada.

We don't need the government setting more obligations on the citizens. People can vote, but they also have the right not to.
 
I read somewhere before that voting is mandatory in Australia -- is the same also the case in New Zealand?

If so, perhaps that is something worth considering in Canada.
When I lived in NZ, voter registration was mandatory but not voting itself.

I have always thought mandatory voting was a crazy idea. Forcing people who may have spent zero time considering the issues to vote, just adds a random element. I think it is great when people who have spent little time studying the issues voluntarily decide not to vote.
 
NZ has always had a history of high voter turnout , even with first past the post system.
 
I've always believed that if you are going to vote, make an informed decision. Learn about the issues and decide who best represents your point of view. If you can't do that, then please don't vote.

I think the danger of mandatory voting is that, as Someone mentioned, you introduce an element of randomness, and/or apathy and ignorance, which could skew the results.

Maybe there should be an aptitude test before allowing a person to vote? I say that partially tongue-in-cheek, since of course voting is a right and not a privilege (as compared, say, to driving a car). Still, if you can't demonstrate a grasp of the issues, should you be voting? Don't you want the decisions which affect you being made by the most informed people? I recall back when George W. Bush was running for President, how many Americans voted for him because he was the candidate people most felt like having a beer with. I'm sorry, but that's not a good enough reason to hand someone the access codes to the big red button, and if that's how you base your decision, then I want you to back away from the polling booth so nobody gets hurt.

Perhaps if voting were mandatory, there would need to be a "Don't Know" option on the ballot. That would allow the uninformed people to complete their civic duty without ruining it for everyone else.

Also, one vote = one voice, and if you choose not to vote, then you don't get to complain afterwards. If you abdicate your right to vote, then you abdicate your right to complain about the results. Please kindly take a seat and STFU until the next time you cast a vote.
 
all of the above options are bad ones, imo and all they do is cause stalemate in the house.
 
all of the above options are bad ones, imo and all they do is cause stalemate in the house. one vote is NOT one voice unless it truly does count.
 
as soon as i find a politician that does what he says he is going to do and doesn't lie just to get what he wants i will vote. till then there is really no point in wasting half of a really good day to go and cast a vote for the lesser of 2 evils only to find out later he lied better than the other guy.
 
Two HUGE problems with what the OP suggests.

First, the CBC's "Vote Compass" incorrectly assigns a single point in a matrix to each Party, when in fact each Party occupies a significant area of the graph. Just because you're "closer" to the point assigned to a Party doesn't mean your opinions are closest to those of that Party (and vice versa). This tool was designed specifically to tell most people that they're Liberal when that is not in fact the case.

Second, despite the media hype, the percentage of the eligible population who vote has NOT been declining. It has held steady for decades. What has been happening is that millions of Canadians have been put on the Voters List who have no intention of voting, resulting in a decline in the percentage of those on the Voters List who actually vote. When you had to take steps to put your name on the voters list, only those with an interest in voting did so and the percentage turnout was high. Now that you only have to mark a box on your tax return, you have more people who enumerated who will not vote and the percentages appear to go down. But it's an illusion, as can be shown by studying the percentage of the population who cast ballots.
 
If you do not vote, then do not complain about the decisions / policies our govt makes
 
Two HUGE problems with what the OP suggests.

First, the CBC's "Vote Compass" incorrectly assigns a single point in a matrix to each Party, when in fact each Party occupies a significant area of the graph. Just because you're "closer" to the point assigned to a Party doesn't mean your opinions are closest to those of that Party (and vice versa). This tool was designed specifically to tell most people that they're Liberal when that is not in fact the case...

Most Party memebers do share a common beliefs in the bigger issues with their Party, ie Long Gun registry. With each question they ask, it is regarding topics that each Party has at one time or another established where they stand.

As for a Liberal bias, I did redo the quiz and was able to make my results show that I should vote Conservative.

A note to others, that afterwards you can evaluate each individual question and see where each Party tends to stand. There are times when Liberals and Conservatives are closer to each other and away from the other Parties, and other times when they are at opposite ends of course.

I think in general a parliamentary system of government with a "first past the post" system tend to lead to low voter turnout, since the votes of a significant percentage of votes are essentially disregarded.

I do believe some sort of proportionate representation is better, however a few years ago there was additional question on the ballots that did ask whether or not you think our first past the post system should be changed, and the results came back as "no". Actually it wasn't even close IIRC. But then again it was a year with another low turnout, so I guess it's another case where the few decide for the many.
 
Most Party memebers do share a common beliefs in the bigger issues with their Party, ie Long Gun registry. With each question they ask, it is regarding topics that each Party has at one time or another established where they stand.

As for a Liberal bias, I did redo the quiz and was able to make my results show that I should vote Conservative.

A note to others, that afterwards you can evaluate each individual question and see where each Party tends to stand. There are times when Liberals and Conservatives are closer to each other and away from the other Parties, and other times when they are at opposite ends of course.



I do believe some sort of proportionate representation is better, however a few years ago there was additional question on the ballots that did ask whether or not you think our first past the post system should be changed, and the results came back as "no". Actually it wasn't even close IIRC. But then again it was a year with another low turnout, so I guess it's another case where the few decide for the many.

The problem with that additional question in the ballot during that year was that there was virtually no public discussion or debate on the merits of first past the post versus alternative voting methods such as mixed-proportional or proportional representation (certainly nothing reported in the media, nor any town-hall meetings), meaning that the vast majority of voters had either no idea what this issue was about, nor any way to decide for themselves what to consider, so people in general simply voted for the status quo.
 
The problem with that additional question in the ballot during that year was that there was virtually no public discussion or debate on the merits of first past the post versus alternative voting methods such as mixed-proportional or proportional representation (certainly nothing reported in the media, nor any town-hall meetings), meaning that the vast majority of voters had either no idea what this issue was about, nor any way to decide for themselves what to consider, so people in general simply voted for the status quo.

Quite the contrary. There were millions of dollars spent advertising the referendum question, and millions more spent by proponents and opponents of that Question. It also got a lot of media coverage.

That you didn't notice speaks more about the nature of advertising and messaging: that people only notice certain things, and advertisers can't unilaterally change that.
 
If you do not vote, then do not complain about the decisions / policies our govt makes

As a citizen, I can both choose not to vote, and still retain my right ti freedom of expression. How about that!