Plastic bag ban

Here's where you're wrong. Nothing, and I mean nothing decomposes in a landfill site as once you bury the crap there's no oxygen and therefore nothing decomposes. …edit…
Perhaps so, but irrelevant to the particular point under discussion, which was bags littering the landscape. If we must have the litter caused by pigs dropping the 'free' bags the rest of us were forced to buy for them, let's have it be made from natural materials than can return to nature.

As to the best tool to take your shopping home in, that'd be a 'permanent' bag or basket that never does see the inside of a landfill. But until such a thing arrives, there may indeed be a place for plastic bags. What there is no place for is the absurd concept of the single use free bag intended to immediately go into our already clogged and costly waste stream and expensive, hard-to-find landfills. Especially when the cost of those 'free' bags is included like a hidden tax in the price of every single purchase, whether you use or want the pesky things at all.

It's a standard conservative thesis that such forced practices drive up shared costs, encourage anti-social behaviour, and degrade the quality of life for all, and they cite the economists' theory of the tragedy of the commons. Usually they're talking about social entitlements from government, like 'free' daycare, healthcare, or welfare but the mechanism and negative consequences are identical. They call it socialistic. and demand to opt out in favour of user pay. User-pay is exactly what Rob tried to eliminate. The over-hasty total ban was the direct consequence of that particular bungle.

Bring back the nickel bag!

Nice to see the repeat appearance of all that stuff about paper bags. Research, even beside the point, is always commendable.
 
The only people who do support a bag ban are false environmentalists who drive their SUV to the grocery store, load up with a week's supply of coffee and granola, and feel they have done their bit for the environment because they brought their own bag.
 
And given how many years of the modern era we managed our supermarket and liquor shopping with paper bags and the occasional box, it's utterly absurd to imagine plastic bags are some sort of necessity.

User pay.
 
Bring back the nickel bag!

Do you actually realize all that changed at this time is the City of Toronto no longer forces a retailer to charge a fee. Very few have changed back. They can tell you its them being environmentally responsible but in reality they charge you 5 cents for something they used to give away.

The city of Toronto passed the by-law but the retailers implemented the fee well beyond the Toronto borders so do you really think they will undo the fee. I don't.

If they want to do this type of thing do it province wide.
 
The only people who do support a bag ban are false environmentalists who drive their SUV to the grocery store, load up with a week's supply of coffee and granola, and feel they have done their bit for the environment because they brought their own bag.

That would be in a hybrid Lincoln Navigator and they would have a case of bottled water.

I'm puzzled how this has become so confused that some people are calling allowing plastic bags right wing and Conservative. One has to assume is that its because these people wants bags banned that everyone that has a different view must be right wing? How simplistic yet distorted is that?
 
Here's where you're wrong. Nothing, and I mean nothing decomposes in a landfill site as once you bury the crap there's no oxygen and therefore nothing decomposes.

The ban was to eliminate the plastic bags retailer's handed out. If they were forced to eliminate these, they would have to find an alternative to satisfy their customer's who at the last minute decided to pop in to purchase something but didn't have a reusable bag with them at the time. You can bet their their choice would be paper, because it doesn't harm the planet like evil plastic.

Two things wrong with this. First, paper is much more harmful to the environment. Secondly, it's typically only used once and takes up significantly more space than plastic in landfill sites. Remember, nothing decomposes in landfill sites as there's no oxygen for decomposition.

The other thing is that they were only going to ban the plastic bags at the check out. The ones you stuff your fruit and veggies into would still be available. I'd imagine if there was a ban, a lot of people would simply put groceries into those bags which never get used more than once, unlike the carry out bags which get reused as garbage bags.

This is why I had to shake my head when the LCBO switched to handing out heavy bottles in plastic bags to paper ones. :confused:



Yeah, paper bags, so much better than plastic!
Excellent post, gameboy
 
Perhaps so, but irrelevant to the particular point under discussion, which was bags littering the landscape
How about we just have the city put our tax dollars to good use and have cleaning crews clean up those places once a week.

Problem solved, genius
 
Do you actually realize all that changed at this time is the City of Toronto no longer forces a retailer to charge a fee. Very few have changed back. They can tell you its them being environmentally responsible but in reality they charge you 5 cents for something they used to give away.

The city of Toronto passed the by-law but the retailers implemented the fee well beyond the Toronto borders so do you really think they will undo the fee. I don't.

If they want to do this type of thing do it province wide.
I don't really know what point you're trying to make. But you did ask:

I do know the previous Council required shops to charge 5¢ a bag, and almost immediately the streets got cleaner and no one seemed to find supplying or buying their own bags too difficult. I'd love it if the nickels saved trees or whales, and the reusable bags helped clean rivers, but that oversight could be fixed and my streets were still improved.

Well over a year later, having accomplished nothing much but repealing the auto tax, and proven he couldn't manage real issues like transit, the Mayor decided everyone who bought groceries should be taxed so he could promise 'free bags for all, and repeal yet another 'tax'.

That he did, but lost his way in the Council meeting and watched helplessly while, his ally Councillor Shiner collected the votes to ban all plastic bags.

The latest act in the clown show is to put the ban—not the 5¢ user fee—on hold for expert study and so citizens have a chance to make submissions. The 5¢ fee didn't really need such formalities, coming or going, because either way anyone could have a bag who wanted one. We call that free choice in a free market. And we all know that does not mean anyone is giving anything away free.

So now, already the bags are beginning to reappear, stuck in fences and bushes, and jamming the catch-basins. And there is no way to choose not to pay for them, 'cause thanks to Ford's 'diktat' everybody pays so someone can think he's getting a free bags. How cheaply some votes are bought.

Thank you Dear Leader Rob.
 
How about we just have the city put our tax dollars to good use and have cleaning crews clean up those places once a week.

Problem solved, genius
Since Ford has yet to balance a budget without a surplus inherited from Miller, that would mean raising taxes even more than he's already admitted he would (no sign he'll ever keep his promise to eliminate the land transfer tax) I'm already bitter about him taxing me for the 'free' bags no one can even be bothered to dispose of properly and now along comes some tax-on-top-of-tax crap to 'solve' the problem of poo-bag entitlements. When did conservatives start throwing away more of taxpayers money to preserve unneeded handouts?

What's wrong with the simple old fashioned principle of user pay? Say how many bags you want and buy 'em.

TANSTAAFL
 
Since Ford has yet to balance a budget without a surplus inherited from Miller, that would mean raising taxes even more than he's already admitted he would
Not really. We could start having prisoners from the Don Jail do some chain gang work and clean up Toronto.

Try thinking outside the box, oj
 
Not really. We could start having prisoners from the Don Jail do some chain gang work and clean up Toronto.

Try thinking outside the box, oj
Gotta pay for the extra guards and the transport as well as negociating the terms with the Province, and pacifying the neighbours. Been tried, more than once—famously under Harris—and hasn't worked here*. Though we all know Alabam' is the envy of the world for its low-cost and high-standard of civic works.

Never mind the box stuff, just try the thinking part. Or was the image of a City fouled by its freeloading citizens and kept clean only by slave labour meant as humour, that I failed somehow to see?

*In modern times. Prisoners did straighten the Don channel from their new Gaol south to the Lake. But men were men in those days, and carried their lunch in pails, and brought baskets to the store or market for their purchases. If they'd seen a paper bag abandoned, they'd have grabbed it as a treasure.
 
I don't really know what point you're trying to make. But you did ask:

I do know the previous Council required shops to charge 5¢ a bag, and almost immediately the streets got cleaner and no one seemed to find supplying or buying their own bags too difficult. I'd love it if the nickels saved trees or whales, and the reusable bags helped clean rivers, but that oversight could be fixed and my streets were still improved.

Well over a year later, having accomplished nothing much but repealing the auto tax, and proven he couldn't manage real issues like transit, the Mayor decided everyone who bought groceries should be taxed so he could promise 'free bags for all, and repeal yet another 'tax'.

That he did, but lost his way in the Council meeting and watched helplessly while, his ally Councillor Shiner collected the votes to ban all plastic bags.

The latest act in the clown show is to put the ban—not the 5¢ user fee—on hold for expert study and so citizens have a chance to make submissions. The 5¢ fee didn't really need such formalities, coming or going, because either way anyone could have a bag who wanted one. We call that free choice in a free market. And we all know that does not mean anyone is giving anything away free.

So now, already the bags are beginning to reappear, stuck in fences and bushes, and jamming the catch-basins. And there is no way to choose not to pay for them, 'cause thanks to Ford's 'diktat' everybody pays so someone can think he's getting a free bags. How cheaply some votes are bought.

Thank you Dear Leader Rob.

I see if the wind was blowing the wrong way it'd be all Ford's fault.
 
Gotta pay for the extra guards and the transport as well as negociating the terms with the Province, and pacifying the neighbours. Been tried, more than once—famously under Harris—and hasn't worked here*. Though we all know Alabam' is the envy of the world for its low-cost and high-standard of civic works
Harris ran on that election campaign platform, he never actually tried it once he was elected IIRC.

And no, it wouldnt cost much at all. Guards are already in place, no need to hire extra. Plus the cost of running a prisoner van wouldn't be much either. And whatever little extra cost you do incur would be offset by having a cleaner environment
 
I see if the wind was blowing the wrong way it'd be all Ford's fault.
It was his idea to fix something that wasn't broken. It was his incompetence at doing that that got us the ban instead of the sensible and functional user pay.
 
Harris ran on that election campaign platform, he never actually tried it once he was elected IIRC.

And no, it wouldnt cost much at all. Guards are already in place, no need to hire extra. Plus the cost of running a prisoner van wouldn't be much either. And whatever little extra cost you do incur would be offset by having a cleaner environment
You really imagine Harris didn't bother to cost out his election platform when he got into power, before he decided it was a bad idea? You must have a lower opinion of his integrity and intelligence than mine. Also goes against my own observations; I'd suspect I saw a pilot project for the Preem, who was smart enough to abandon that simplistic idea when he got the numbers, because the garbage persisted, but the work-party appeared only once.

You and I could uselessly debate finer points of chain-gang management forever, considering stuff like whether leaving an entire range unguarded or under-guarded in order to send a couple of prisoners out was safe or even doable, but to no point. It is however directly on topic just how you imagine having a cleaner environment offsets actual dollar costs as you said. The Free Baggers don't seem to think it's worth even a nickel.

Tell us more.
 
You really imagine Harris didn't bother to cost out his election platform when he got into power, before he decided it was a bad idea? You must have a lower opinion of his integrity and intelligence than mine. Also goes against my own observations; I'd suspect I saw a pilot project for the Preem, who was smart enough to abandon that simplistic idea when he got the numbers, because the garbage persisted, but the work-party appeared only once.

You and I could uselessly debate finer points of chain-gang management forever, considering stuff like whether leaving an entire range unguarded or under-guarded in order to send a couple of prisoners out was safe or even doable, but to no point. It is however directly on topic just how you imagine having a cleaner environment offsets actual dollar costs as you said. The Free Baggers don't seem to think it's worth even a nickel.

Tell us more
Even if the chain-gang idea doesnt work, we pay enough taxes so that the City ought to be able to have crews go around to clean up Toronto from a few bags stuck on some fences. Its not like we're being overrun with plastic bags.

Its funny, because I looked for plastic bags while I was driving around today, and while some areas are worse then others, its not bad enough to warrant a plastic bag ban. Also if the City would be a bit more ambitious they could easily clean up most areas within a few days
 
Even if the chain-gang idea doesnt work, we pay enough taxes so that the City ought to be able to have crews go around to clean up Toronto from a few bags stuck on some fences. Its not like we're being overrun with plastic bags. Yet.

Its funny, because I looked for plastic bags while I was driving around today, and while some areas are worse then others, its not bad enough to warrant a plastic bag ban. Also if the City would be a bit more ambitious they could easily clean up most areas within a few days
As I have said more than once; I'm not a bag-ban supporter. I am a believer in paying for what you want, and not freeloading on everyone else. The Mayor should have realized he had better things to do and left the nickel bags alone.

But at least he realizes that we do not pay enough taxes to start all sorts of new clean-up crews hunting down litter. Because we need to pay more, he's actually raising property taxes, he won't be cancelling the land transfer tax like he promised, and after cutting other services, when couldn't find enough gravy, he's now proposing to cut police and fire services both.

If we truly did pay enough taxes just for what we already need to do, we wouldn't have a crumbling Gardiner to deal with and the streets in my neighbourhood wouldn't look like Damascus. If indeed we're not being overrun with plastic bags, I think you need to recall the pre-nickel bag days when we certainly were, and understand that the total ban was only just repealed. So I fixed your post in the quote above.

You already want me to pay for everyone elses' shopping bags, don't ask me to pay more taxes so City workers will clean up after them too. Just make them buy the bags they want. We call it the free enterprise, capitalist way.