Perhaps so, but irrelevant to the particular point under discussion, which was bags littering the landscape. If we must have the litter caused by pigs dropping the 'free' bags the rest of us were forced to buy for them, let's have it be made from natural materials than can return to nature.Here's where you're wrong. Nothing, and I mean nothing decomposes in a landfill site as once you bury the crap there's no oxygen and therefore nothing decomposes. …edit…
As to the best tool to take your shopping home in, that'd be a 'permanent' bag or basket that never does see the inside of a landfill. But until such a thing arrives, there may indeed be a place for plastic bags. What there is no place for is the absurd concept of the single use free bag intended to immediately go into our already clogged and costly waste stream and expensive, hard-to-find landfills. Especially when the cost of those 'free' bags is included like a hidden tax in the price of every single purchase, whether you use or want the pesky things at all.
It's a standard conservative thesis that such forced practices drive up shared costs, encourage anti-social behaviour, and degrade the quality of life for all, and they cite the economists' theory of the tragedy of the commons. Usually they're talking about social entitlements from government, like 'free' daycare, healthcare, or welfare but the mechanism and negative consequences are identical. They call it socialistic. and demand to opt out in favour of user pay. User-pay is exactly what Rob tried to eliminate. The over-hasty total ban was the direct consequence of that particular bungle.
Bring back the nickel bag!
Nice to see the repeat appearance of all that stuff about paper bags. Research, even beside the point, is always commendable.

