Plastic bag ban

... everything was debated, analyzed, finalized and found to both successful in curbing the use of plastic bags and accepted by the citizens of Toronto until the Rob And Doug side show decided to spew some sounbites on 1010 one Sunday wanting to eliminate the 5 cent bag fee that benefitted our city.

5 cents plus HST is a 'hot-button' issue for Ford Nation.
 
It's actually better than that. They wanted us to put garbage/compost in brand new bags made from virgin material instead of in multi-use grocery bags made from recycled plastics. Yep, sounds like City Council.



Instead of jumping to conclusions simply because you don't like Rob and Doug, you should do a little research. People should have the choice to put items in plastic grocery bags if they want. They are often very handy when purchasing bags of milk, chicken, meat etc. that may leak onto other food items and through reusable bags. They also reduce the spread of bacteria.

Grocery bags are made from recycled plastics and can be reused as garbage bags instead of buying new ones which end up being a single use item. If you end up with too many of them, simply recycle them.

I use reusable bags most of the time but I should have the choice to get a plastic bag if I don't have a reusable one with me. Did you know it takes the equivalent of 300-400 grocery bags to make one reusable bag, which isn't recyclable at the end of its' life. Empty plastic bags make up such a small percentage of landfill that it's almost irrelevant.

The 5 cents went into the retailer's pockets, not to the city.

+1 to all of this. I re-use my disposable bags. For me they cut down on my green garbage use to some degree. I end up with some grocery bags that are surplus to my needs, so I store them, and once a month neatly wrap them in a bundle with food items and drop them in the food bank bin in my supermarket. I used to volunteer at a food bank in Pickering and I know they always need bags.

I view the political impetus to get rid of them as silk stocking elitism. This is the cast of charachters that decided to impose our garbage on a St Thomas landfill instead of finding a way to handle it locally. They skated over the ecological issue of trucks constantly driving back and forth for the rest of eternity to haul the garbage.
 
Can I throw my plastic bags in my Blue Bin?

Grocery and other retail plastic shopping bags can now go into your Blue Bin.

Do I just throw them in?

No. The bags have to be empty; remove any receipts and put all the bags in one bag and then tie closed. Do not use a rubber band or twist tie.

Can all plastic bags go in?

No. At this time only plastic retail and grocery bags can go in.

http://www.toronto.ca/garbage/bags_and_foam_faq.htm#a001
 
... everything was debated, analyzed, finalized and found to both successful in curbing the use of plastic bags and accepted by the citizens of Toronto until the Rob And Doug side show decided to spew some sounbites on 1010 one Sunday wanting to eliminate the 5 cent bag fee that benefitted our city.

Jenn:

I can't understand why you're upset. The plastic bag ban isn't good for the environment. Actually, it's bad for the environment.

I would think this is one decision that everyone would support.
 
why was this even an issue ?
Because the Mayor wanted 'free' bags for all. It's only taken him month's of back and forth and hours of debate in two Council sessions—not that there was any other business to be done—to do away with the user-pay, free market system we had so he could make everyone subsidize those who can't manage to buy garbage an dog-poo bags.

Of course it ain't over yet, further study is needed. Yay Rob! That's doing the City's business.
 
So let me get this straight, they ban plastic store bags which I use as garbage bags that go to the landfill, so then I'll have to buy glad garbage bags, which I will still use as garbage bags, and which will still end up at the same landfill.

Yeah, Lefties are a bright bunch
You got it! What were they thinking!
 
I thought the 5c fee was appropriate but banning the bags is stupid.

There are times I am walking home and make an unexpected stop at the grocery store. If they cannot give me a bag, how the hell would I get my items home?

Carry a bag in my pocket all the time just in case? What if I buy too many items and they don't fit in the bag I have?
 
The whole thing started because councillor Bernedetti (sp? ) wanted to put the 5¢ fee towards the tree canopy project. Ford took it upon himself to re-open an issue that had already been settled and had the backing of retailers and was legally sound.

Plastic bags are bad people.

So yes - the 5¢ fee was -indeed successful. The number of
plastic bags that ended up in landfills was reduced by 58%. Guess who pays for plastic bags going to landfills or ending up in streets or wrapped up in trees? I don't have the dollar figure handy but it's in the millions people....
This is all not to mention the environmental factor of what plastic does.

The 5¢ fee curtailed use of plastic bags and made us more aware of what we were using
Gone are the days of using more bags than necessary - and that's a good thing.

Sometimes I really am saddened by how self-centered people truly are when it comes to the environment. Our kids are going to pay for the stupid decisions of today. No one here should be rejoicing abou saving 5¢ (plus hst lol).

I wasn't thrilled about the ban but we would've coped and we will adjust and cope when a legally-sound ban is brought in in the future.

As I said, city staff is still researching the issue and they're reporting back in June.
 
I thought the 5c fee was appropriate but banning the bags is stupid.

There are times I am walking home and make an unexpected stop at the grocery store. If they cannot give me a bag, how the hell would I get my items home?

Carry a bag in my pocket all the time just in case? What if I buy too many items and they don't fit in the bag I have?

You could buy a bag at the grocery store, either paper, reusable or plastic bags they would have for sale on the shelves. Too many items....buy another bag.

Use your brain.
 
You could buy a bag at the grocery store, either paper, reusable or plastic bags they would have for sale on the shelves. Too many items....buy another bag.

Use your brain.

Oh yeah, lets have retailers supply paper bags like the LCBO. Here's a quick summary on those "environmentally friendly" paper bags.

Where do brown paper bags come from?

Paper comes from trees -- lots and lots of trees. The logging industry, influenced by companies like Weyerhaeuser and Kimberly-Clark, is huge, and the process to get that paper bag to the grocery store is long, sordid and exacts a heavy toll on the planet.

First, the trees are found, marked and felled in a process that all too often involves clear-cutting, resulting in massive habitat destruction and long-term ecological damage. Mega-machinery comes in to remove the logs from what used to be forest, either by logging trucks or even helicopters in more remote areas. This machinery requires fossil fuel to operate and roads to drive on, and, when done unsustainably, logging even a small area has a large impact on the entire ecological chain in surrounding areas.

Once the trees are collected, they must dry at least three years before they can be used. More machinery is used to strip the bark, which is then chipped into one-inch squares and cooked under tremendous heat and pressure. This wood stew is then "digested," with a chemical mixture of limestone and acid, and after several hours of cooking, what was once wood becomes pulp. It takes approximately three tons of wood chips to make one ton of pulp.

The pulp is then washed and bleached; both stages require thousands of gallons of clean water. Coloring is added to more water, and is then combined in a ratio of 1 part pulp to 400 parts water, to make paper. The pulp/water mixture is dumped into a web of bronze wires, and the water showers through, leaving the pulp, which, in turn, is rolled into paper.

Whew! And that's just to make the paper; don't forget about the energy inputs -- chemical, electrical, and fossil fuel-based -- used to transport the raw material, turn the paper into a bag and then transport the finished paper (which weighs more and takes up much more room than plastic) bag all over the world.

Changing from plastic to to paper is a common suggestion from the uninformed. This includes the idiots (McGuinty) who made the decision at the LCBO to switch.
 
No matter what side you are on.....

tis was about eliminating the 5 cent deal.

The left tagged on the TOTAL BAN...STUPID.


So council has finally side with FORD..who had it right all along. 5 CENTS eliminated. BAGS are useable...as the courts would have also decided!

SO FORD was right from the start.....it was the arguing left that kept this going ad nauseum!!!!!
 
Exactly - do some research instead of swallowing everything spouted by David Suzuki and friends.

You got that right!

People should have the option to get a plastic bag if they want one. You can reuse them as compost and garbage bags. If you have too many, place them all in another bag, tie it up and place it in the blue bin to be recycled. What's the problem here?

No matter what side you are on.....

It was about eliminating the 5 cent deal.

The left tagged on the TOTAL BAN...STUPID.


So council has finally side with FORD..who had it right all along. 5 CENTS eliminated. BAGS are useable...as the courts would have also decided!

SO FORD was right from the start.....it was the arguing left that kept this going ad nauseum!!!!!

^^^ So true!


And then there's this...

Government research from the UK that has found plastic bags are 200 times less damaging to the climate than reusable cotton bags. The study – which incorporates the impact of raw material extraction, bag production, transportation and disposal – zeroes in on how many times reusable bags are actually reused. For example, a cotton bag would need to reused every day for a year before it offset the environmental impact of one plastic bag. A canvas tote bag? 171 reuses to break even.
 
No matter what side you are on.....

tis was about eliminating the 5 cent deal.

The left tagged on the TOTAL BAN...STUPID.


So council has finally side with FORD..who had it right all along. 5 CENTS eliminated. BAGS are useable...as the courts would have also decided!

SO FORD was right from the start.....it was the arguing left that kept this going ad nauseum!!!!!

5 cents plus HST is a galvanizing issue for Ford Nation. Never mind that they will still be paying for bags(they just won't realize it....they don't realize much anyway) till council re-visits the 'Ford Nation as many as ya want freebie plastic bags'.

A perfectly sensible and much more enviormentally friendly approach which reduced plastic bag dumpage/usage by 50 odd % was trashed because of the onerous thought of actually having to visibly dig into your Ford Nation pockets for 5 cents plus HST. Heavy, heavy burden. But then, the appearance of 'free', 'you don't have to pay anything for something' always dangles like a tantalizing ripe juicy porker's rump to Ford Nation.

It was Ford Nation stalwart, conservative-leaning councillor David Shiner who brought forth the motion to ban the bags altogether.

The bag ban was put off for further consultation in June I believe, basically for council to get the legal ducks in order(consultation with affected groups).....but rest assured my 'I want free stuff' Ford Nationites, 'so called free bags' for every 'pot-o-gold ' Ford Nation' fairytale believer is not 'free', is enviornmentally unfriendly and likely to be to be figuratively dumped into the trash heap of Ford Nation fairytales as opposed to literally being dumped in real life.
 
You could buy a bag at the grocery store, either paper, reusable or plastic bags they would have for sale on the shelves
So you're against plastic store bags, but glad garbage bags are okay with you??!!


AAArrgh!!!!!!!!!! I cant handle Liberals anymore!!!!


man-pulling-hair-out-21.jpg

(not my actual picture)
 
The bag fee was a badly written law from the get go, it's intent was to get retailers to donate the monies to a charity, but was so badly written it had a huge loophole, which not only allowed retailers to keep the money, but but the blame on the new expense on city council.

The city btw never had the authority to direct where these fees go, to do so it would have had to be a tax, and the city cannot impose new taxes without permission of the province first.

In addition complaint had been filed with the Federal Competition bureau for being a form of price fixing.

Then when COUNCIL decided to remove the fee, and ban plastic bags; as the same time, without any public input or outside consultation of any sort, they are now facing a lawsuit due to that.

If Michelle Berardinetti was the monies to go to a specific fund, she needs to learn how by-laws work, and make a motion for such a fee and have council approve it.