DAMN IT my girl is gone...She was NO way near the worse it chick that is the drama girl ( fighting with simon) was the worse..and that little kid with the glasses has gOT TO GO..the guys talent is VERY weak this year..I agree the big black woman can sing her ass of but she is too big...pickler will not win..like someone said she will run out as the competition heats up..her voice is not all that great...good but not great...the tall basketball woman is very good and so is the last girl of the 1st show..she sings soo easy..the best singer EVER on the show of all 5 seasons was the big black woman Frenchie Davis and she was kicked off...Simon even said after her audition she was going to win this contest! Oh well my girl will be in a magazine soon!!
Pick Pickler!
- Thread starter Spode
- Start date
They're all garbage when compared to Paris and that other black girl.
Pickler should quit the show and become a country singer.
That brunette who looks like a pornstar got kicked off because her and her twin sister were doing donkey shows in Tijuana.
Pickler should quit the show and become a country singer.
That brunette who looks like a pornstar got kicked off because her and her twin sister were doing donkey shows in Tijuana.
I agree, the drama girl should have gone last night.ryick said:
I like what Simon said about the big black woman when she first auditioned. First he said, we gonna need a bigger stage this year. Then Paula said she reminded her of Frenchie, and Simon said, "More like all of France". You have to love this guy.
Paris torches all of these unlucky kids who are unfortunate enough to have to go up against her. The blacks (minus the annoying ****) are so much better than the whites this year, that it's not fair to have them in the same contest.
Like Simon said : Paris, you embarass the rest of the people in the competition. The only way you lose is if racists do the majority of the voting.
Like Simon said : Paris, you embarass the rest of the people in the competition. The only way you lose is if racists do the majority of the voting.
Why do you think racism is a problem here, Rusty? Two Idol winners, Ruben and Fantasia, have been black. And they beat out white counterparts. As I have said before here, I think America is relatively color blind when it comes to sports and entertainment.
Kellie is soooo adorable. She's my favorite because she's the total package. She won't win but she'll go far. She's so much like Carrie Underwood.
I want Paris gone so bad. I just can't stand her. She can sing but I don't like her singing style. I can't stand her squeeky little voice or the fact that she won't stop smiling. I just HATE her.
Alya surprised me. I didn't know she could sing that well.
Becky is hot but I knew she wouldn't last long.
Heather was the second worst singer.
Brenna is a diva bitch who's had her 15 minutes and it was 15 minutes too long. She had the worst performance. With her bad singing and bitch attitude, I'm surprised she got past the 1st round. She'll be gone soon.
Lisa Tucker will go right to the end.
All the ugly girls should go out in to first round. It makes for better TV.
I'm sad to see Stevie go. She is so cute. I thought she sang far better during her fairwell than during the competition.
I want Paris gone so bad. I just can't stand her. She can sing but I don't like her singing style. I can't stand her squeeky little voice or the fact that she won't stop smiling. I just HATE her.
Alya surprised me. I didn't know she could sing that well.
Becky is hot but I knew she wouldn't last long.
Heather was the second worst singer.
Brenna is a diva bitch who's had her 15 minutes and it was 15 minutes too long. She had the worst performance. With her bad singing and bitch attitude, I'm surprised she got past the 1st round. She'll be gone soon.
Lisa Tucker will go right to the end.
I make the rules and the fat girl is too fat to be on TV.homonger said:
All the ugly girls should go out in to first round. It makes for better TV.
I'm sad to see Stevie go. She is so cute. I thought she sang far better during her fairwell than during the competition.
For top six girls, that is, the girls who will be finalists, you have to figure on Katherine McPhee, Lisa Tucker, Paris Bennett, Kellie Pickler, and probably Mandisa, the heavy black girl. I think Heather Cox sucks, and drama girl, Brenna, should get the boot soon too. That leaves Ayla Brown, who could post me up anyday, and Kinnik, the other black woman, to vie for the final spot. I think that spot goes to Ayla.
I always like to watch the ladies perform on AI, but I thought last night's show was a bit of a snoozer. Didn't really like the song selections, and I wasn't wowed by anyone's performance. My less than insightful prediction is that Heather (she sucked again) and Brenna (aka drama girl) or maybe Kinnik (black chick in the cowboy hat) get the boot. Kellie seems to be becoming America's sweetheart, Lisa and Paris appear untouchable at this point, and Katherine, despite not being so great last night, remains a talented, polished performer. The sleeper appears to be Ayla, who seems to be getting better each week.
I really don't care that much about the AI guys, but I feel some equal time is warranted. I thought Chris was the definite best one tonight. He did a great job with that Fuel song. It is interesting to me that no one is using the "rocker" word this year, and I think this guy rocks harder than any of the so-called rockers they've had before. Ace is working his pretty boy charm, kind of a more talented Constantine. He'll get votes. Like the judges have been saying, Taylor is interesting, but I don't know if he is talented enough vocally to go real far.
I think the final six guys will be Taylor, Gedeon, Chris, Ace, Elliott, and then that's where I lose interest. I think the crooner guy has got to go. There have been supposed crooners on the show before, and they never do very well. The bald Hispanic guy has an OK voice, but about as much charisma as a cue ball. The little guy, Kevin, I don't know, he has a certain harmless affability to him, I think he could be in the finals because you know all the pre-teen girls just think he's adorable.
I think the final six guys will be Taylor, Gedeon, Chris, Ace, Elliott, and then that's where I lose interest. I think the crooner guy has got to go. There have been supposed crooners on the show before, and they never do very well. The bald Hispanic guy has an OK voice, but about as much charisma as a cue ball. The little guy, Kevin, I don't know, he has a certain harmless affability to him, I think he could be in the finals because you know all the pre-teen girls just think he's adorable.
homonger said:
Keeping the torch burning while others are asleep at the wheel, thanks Homonger.
I thought the bald guy Sway was a filipino.
As for Kevin, no he is not cute in any way. His voice outdoes his appearance by quite a bit, but thats not saying much. He's a stiff. Chris and Elliot are hands down the best talent on the mens side.
As for the women looking at the previous couple of posts the quality of prognastication is pretty scary. I still think that Kath, Paris and either Mandisa or Lisa are in for the long haul.
Thanks goes to sweetness for reminding me of American Idol and that Pickles is not that hot.
Thanks Spode, I thought I was talking to myself there for awhile (not that that's unusual).Spode said:
Yeah, I think you're right, Sway was Filipino, which is sort of in the Hispanic family, isn't it? It doesn't matter, he's gone.
I don't think you or I are the right judges for Kevin's cuteness. I think he is a funny looking little guy, but the girls (on the show at least) seem to love him. He's not a great singer either. His nearly bad enough to get booted showing in the voting last week suggests he's not that cute.
Are you saying the prognostication is scary because it's been on the money so far? I think this next week will be tough, because I can think of one person who is an obvious choice to go, but not necessarily a second. For the women, Kinnik is the obvious choice to go, but who would be the other? Not Katherine, not Paris, not Lisa. Probably not Kellie or Mandisa. I think the other girl to go would be Melissa. For the guys, the obvious one to go is Kevin, but then who? Not Ace, not Taylor, not Gedeon, not Elliott, not Chris. It would be either Bucky or Will, the kid who looks like Peter Brady. I have not been impressed with Will at all, but Bucky seems like a good guy so I hope he stays.
No surprises on tonight's show, imo. Simon may be getting blunter, but he is probably right, Melissa and Kinnik will be going home. I don't think they are necessarily the two worst singers, but they are probably the two most forgettable.
It is interesting to me how Heart, a group that was kind of undistinguished during its own time, has now become sort of a crucible for vocal performance on this show. Compared to previous Heart efforts--Carrie Underwood's 'Alone' last year, and Mandisa's 'Never' this year--Melissa's attempt at 'What About Love' tonight was horrible in comparison. It makes you really appreciate what a marvelous singer Ann Wilson is. So I think she's gone.
Kinnik, sorry, I like Alicia Keys, but you needed a "wow" performance, and the one you gave tonight was like watching paint dry. Kinnik just doesn't stand out, and I'm sorry, but with three other very strong black women (Paris, Lisa, Mandisa), you are the odd sister out.
Paris and Lisa are coasting now, as I thought they were both just okay, but they are already so popular, they will have no problem advancing. I thought Katherine was really good, and her looks are starting to grow on me. I think she's adorable. Did anyone else catch of glimpse of her mom and dad in the audience? Her mom looks hot, an older version of Katherine. Her dad looks like, well, like he doesn't belong in that picture, and that maybe the mailman is Katherine's real dad.
I liked Ayla's choice of song, and she is one I am starting to like too. She's got personality and has made noticeable strides week to week, so she moves on. And what can you say about Mandisa singing "I'm Every Woman"? Well, I don't know if she's every woman, but she's probably a good 2 or 3 of them. Fat jokes aside, she did a terrific job with the song.
And then there is Kellie, who is just so cute and unassuming, it's hard to imagine her going anywhere. Simon's comment about preferring Kellie to last year's winner was interesting. Carrie was a pretty young girl and could sing, but man, she was as dull as dishwater, personality-wise. I never got the sense Simon was all that crazy about her, even though he had to acknowledge her talent. He probably didn't think she had enough sex appeal or charisma to ever truly stand out and make him a ton of money.
It is interesting to me how Heart, a group that was kind of undistinguished during its own time, has now become sort of a crucible for vocal performance on this show. Compared to previous Heart efforts--Carrie Underwood's 'Alone' last year, and Mandisa's 'Never' this year--Melissa's attempt at 'What About Love' tonight was horrible in comparison. It makes you really appreciate what a marvelous singer Ann Wilson is. So I think she's gone.
Kinnik, sorry, I like Alicia Keys, but you needed a "wow" performance, and the one you gave tonight was like watching paint dry. Kinnik just doesn't stand out, and I'm sorry, but with three other very strong black women (Paris, Lisa, Mandisa), you are the odd sister out.
Paris and Lisa are coasting now, as I thought they were both just okay, but they are already so popular, they will have no problem advancing. I thought Katherine was really good, and her looks are starting to grow on me. I think she's adorable. Did anyone else catch of glimpse of her mom and dad in the audience? Her mom looks hot, an older version of Katherine. Her dad looks like, well, like he doesn't belong in that picture, and that maybe the mailman is Katherine's real dad.
I liked Ayla's choice of song, and she is one I am starting to like too. She's got personality and has made noticeable strides week to week, so she moves on. And what can you say about Mandisa singing "I'm Every Woman"? Well, I don't know if she's every woman, but she's probably a good 2 or 3 of them. Fat jokes aside, she did a terrific job with the song.
And then there is Kellie, who is just so cute and unassuming, it's hard to imagine her going anywhere. Simon's comment about preferring Kellie to last year's winner was interesting. Carrie was a pretty young girl and could sing, but man, she was as dull as dishwater, personality-wise. I never got the sense Simon was all that crazy about her, even though he had to acknowledge her talent. He probably didn't think she had enough sex appeal or charisma to ever truly stand out and make him a ton of money.
Okay, not bad... I was waiting to see what jokes would abound by her song choice. I mean, she did leave herself wide open with that one.homonger said:
I was thinking the same thing about Katherine, but she did improve a bit tonight. She may be the best technical singer and I think she's cute, but she doesn't really do it for me as a performer. I think I finally figured out why - her facial expression doesn't change much. i.e. she could be more expressive, in line with what she is singing.homonger said:
I do hope that's your tongue in your cheek and not some teenage, uh, nevermind.Spode said:
