Philippians Join the LCN

Re: Re: To gryfin and Talerion

happygrump said:
SB, I believe you truly have a point about the training of the Canadian military, and I don't think anyone doubts the courage of Canadian soldiers. But I have to admit that you lost me with the above quote.

Does this also mean that those who support your position - like me - cannot have a valid opinion because we're not in the Forces?


I expect SB is speaking out of frustration as much as anything else. However your point is the same as I pointed out. One does not have to be 'in the job' to have an opinion. Furthermore it is dangerous to take that tact because it leads to the premise that you will find yourself excluded by others who deem that while you are 'close to them' you aren't quite in their club so your opinion doesn't count either.

T.
 
Re: Re: To gryfin and Talerion

nearlynormal said:
The Filipino hostage is a truck driver, trying to make a buck in a very dangerous place. OTB's link takes you to to the Associated Press news release. The information about the hostage being a truck driver appears in the very first sentence of that article. It makes no mention of the hostage being a soldier. He's just a guy for chrissakes!

True but it still sets a terrible precedent. While I know it is easy for us behind our keyboards in our air conditioned homes to dismiss someone's position in Iraq the reality is that for whatever reason he went there, (much like Tom Hamill), he went there of his own accord. One can make arguments that the desperation of his situation at home made him go for economic reasons, again much like Hamill, but in the end it was a voluntary choice and while I do not wish to see anyone executed there is a risk, (which is why it is so economically lucrative), in going there. Part of the risk being that you might be kidnapped by the bad guys.

I realize that there is a serious Islamic and Communist rebel issue in parts of the Phillipines, (talk about the worst of two worlds), and they are very concerned that will be spillover form this theatre to their home. But to start acceding to terrorist demands is such a terrible path to follow. These are not negotiations and should not be treated that way and all the Phillipines will have succeeded in achieving here is giving every terrorist group associated with them the belief that their practices do work.

T.
 
Re: To Speedo

SoldierBoy said:
Speedo

Good point, although you may have possibly taken what I posted out of context.

The meaning of the entire sentence your quote comes from is that I don't care about anyones opinion on the fact that the Canadian Government doesn't care about it's soldiers. To clarify, if you are not in our shoes, you may not know what I'm talking about.

Hope this helps understand my position on that point. Thank you for not slagging as so many do on this site.

SB

Jeez SB, now why couldn't you have posted that to start with!

We could have gotten off to such a better start.


I personally dislike the term LCN because it insults this country's military and their past. I know that the US likes to rewrite history, (did you know that WW2 actually started in late 1941?), but considering that for the two big wars they showed up well after the tide had turned, (not to suggest that they didn't seriously speed things up), and only showed up out of fear of not being there to divide the spoils and not out of some 'defending the free world' premise that they love to espouse, I take issue when I read such phrases as LCN being applied to us.

It is easy to be 'brave' when the tide is turned or when you know that your troops are going to be hundreds of miles away while the only planes in the air or missiles flying are yours. The term LCN being applied to Canada while our troops support Afghanistan making it possible for the US to play in Iraq is political rhertoric at its worst and most self serving.


So now you know where I was coming from.


T.
 
Re: Re: To Speedo

Talerion said:
Jeez SB, now why couldn't you have posted that to start with!

We could have gotten off to such a better start.


I personally dislike the term LCN because it insults this country's military and their past. I know that the US likes to rewrite history, (did you know that WW2 actually started in late 1941?), but considering that for the two big wars they showed up well after the tide had turned, (not to suggest that they didn't seriously speed things up), and only showed up out of fear of not being there to divide the spoils and not out of some 'defending the free world' premise that they love to espouse, I take issue when I read such phrases as LCN being applied to us.

It is easy to be 'brave' when the tide is turned or when you know that your troops are going to be hundreds of miles away while the only planes in the air or missiles flying are yours. The term LCN being applied to Canada while our troops support Afghanistan making it possible for the US to play in Iraq is political rhertoric at its worst and most self serving.


So now you know where I was coming from.


T.

Here we go, the "Americans show up late to every war" part of the Canadian rant.... Goober will be fidgeting under that pink hat any second now.

OTB
 
The Philippines actually provide a wonderful example of the schizophrenia of American foreign policy. The Americans literally built democracy from the ground up after they took over in the aftermath of the 1898 Spanish-American War. In the 1970’s the US was ironically instrumental in demolishing that democracy by nearly unwavering support of the Marcos regime.

That’s why neither the “America is a threat to world peace and supports oppressors as long as they do their bidding” nor the “America is the only defender of democracy in the world” positions are entirely valid. The fact is, both are true, and this may be why so many feel suspicious when they are placed under the control of American “liberators.”

Oh, and OTB, the correct term is “Filipinos.” The “Philippians” were the guys St. Paul wrote all those letters to.

Total burn.
 
Re: Re: Re: To Speedo

onthebottom said:
Here we go, the "Americans show up late to every war" part of the Canadian rant.... Goober will be fidgeting under that pink hat any second now.

OTB

Damn I have got to make a mental note to stop upsetting OTB with all this reality. Messes up his paradigm.


T.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: To gryfin and Talerion

nearlynormal said:
I don't pretend to know the precise long term consequences of the decision by the Philippine gov't to leave a few weeks early. And I'd be willing to bet nobody else really does either. The Filipinos are removing such a small number of troops that it borders on the absurd! How big a capitulation can it be to withdraw a lousy 51 guys who, according to SB, were only doing humanitarian work? I recall the Red Cross and many other humanitarian agencies pulling out of various combat zones over the years because the risks to their workers became too great. And the Americans were awfully quick to withdraw from Somalia at the first sign of trouble. Too bad they didn't do that in Viet Nam but I digress.

So, because the Philippine gov't is withdrawing such a paltry, non combatant force, is that still a significant victory for the terrorists? How can you tell exactly? We're all familiar with the mantra about never giving in to terrorist demands. But exactly how many more Filipinos will die from additional terrorist activities because of this withdrawal and encouragement compared to the number of Filipino contract workers and innocent civilians at home who would have died if they had refused to withdraw and the outrage over the beheading of the truck driver? It could easily be that this decision will save more Filipino lives than the alternative and it allows the Filipino gov't to look like it is sensitive to the Islamic portion of its population. In the long run, the gov't of the Philippines is responsible for the welfare of Filipinos, not Americans or other coalition members.

It really isn't a question of numbers though as much as a demonstration that terrorist threats work. Certainly it will have an effect on the coalition in that it sends a message to the terrorists that their system can prove successful.

For the Phillipines themselves it also sends a local message of the same.

Risky in my opinion.


T.
 
You really want to know what I think

After reading all the replys, I think it would be great to sit with a bunch of you over a beverage or 10. This forum is so filled with all types of people from all walks of life. We would definately have some great conversations / discussions and the initial hostilities would be minimized because we could explain our points of views without having to write a goddamned novel.

Cheers! Here's to us.

SB

Oh ya, when I said we top the LCN list, I never meant all Canadians, just our politicians. Some of the meanest fuckers alive are Canadian (and personal friends of mine).
 
Re: To Speedo

SoldierBoy said:
Speedo

Good point, although you may have possibly taken what I posted out of context.
Guilty as charged. I just did so to make that point. :)


SoldierBoy said:
The meaning of the entire sentence your quote comes from is that I don't care about anyones opinion on the fact that the Canadian Government doesn't care about it's soldiers. To clarify, if you are not in our shoes, you may not know what I'm talking about.

Hope this helps understand my position on that point. Thank you for not slagging as so many do on this site.

SB
Fair enough. And for what it's worth, I wholeheartedly agree on your stance, re: our government's lack of troop support. I did not serve, but I have great respect for those who do. My grandfather, whom I never met, gave his life in the service.
 
Re: You really want to know what I think

SoldierBoy said:
After reading all the replys, I think it would be great to sit with a bunch of you over a beverage or 10. This forum is so filled with all types of people from all walks of life. We would definately have some great conversations / discussions and the initial hostilities would be minimized because we could explain our points of views without having to write a goddamned novel.

Cheers! Here's to us.

<grin> I suspect 99.9% of the testy words on TERB and other boards would never be uttered if the conversations occured in person with folks blowing the froth off a few cold 'uns.

Except for Goob's inane ramblings, of course !! :D
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To gryfin and Talerion

nearlynormal said:
It should be about numbers. When we say "giving in to terrorist demands only encourages more terrorism and more deaths in the long run", we are really saying, for example, that it is better to accept a few dead airline hostages right now than to give in because giving in today will cause a rash of airline hijackings tomorrow and that will result in more overall deaths.

I remember those days of airline hijackings and that is where this whole mantra about never giving in originated. It was always a utilitarian argument based on the old "pay a little now or pay a lot later" premise. So it is that John Stuart Mill calculus made new.

If I was a Filipino voter, I'd expect my gov't to make the call based on what is best for the Philippines. That would involve projected casualties or some other method of weighing one course of action against the other.

I am not certain if the theory developed simultaneously with the Israelis and the West with respect to the 60/70's airline hijackings or even with the response to the Royal Family not to leave London during the blitz, but its principle remains the same. If you start surrendering to an overt attack on one front then you indicate to the attacker that they can expect some success with this approach. Given that the Phillipines is currently experiencing a domestic terrorist issue I would be concerned that this would only increase both local and foreign soil attacks on Flip interests.

You are certainly correct in that the Phillipine's Government has to weigh their options, but in this case given that they already have a fundamentalist Islamic problem at home I am not sure that this cause and effect is a good example.

What most North Americans, especially our friends to the south, fail to realize is that Europe has been making these trade off decisions for years now. Much like WW2 did not begin at Pearl Harbour the Islamic attacks on the Western World did not begin on 9/11. It only just counts now because it happened on US soil. The Europeans have been a lot more pragmatic about the situation and haven't always stood by the 'no negotiation' premise. The Israelis do but of course they add a caveat to the rule, "we will not negotiate with you and if we catch you please note that we do not take prisoners either".

I believe the Spanish example is a bit different because the Government that was elected had campaigned on the position that they were against going into Iraq and would withdraw their troops if elected. The train bombings may have pushed that vote over the top but at least one can argue that a democratically elected Government followed its election promise. In the Flip case despite the argument of 'early withdrawl to avoid a penalty' one can point to existing Government being swayed by terrorist actions.

Like I said, risky, sort of like taking a job in Iraq driving a truck.


T.
 
Re: Re: You really want to know what I think

Speedo said:
<grin> I suspect 99.9% of the testy words on TERB and other boards would never be uttered if the conversations occured in person with folks blowing the froth off a few cold 'uns.

Except for Goob's inane ramblings, of course !! :D

There are times I like to reminisce about the good old days of Usenet and before that the BBS's when people were open to ideas and discussions were a lot more cordial. Then after thinking a bit more about the specifics I remember that really things were not a lot different then than now. Possibly a bit better in that it was a far more select group of people who had the technology in those days, (stand back this 2400 baud modem is about to GO LIVE!), and of course most of the BBS were local so there was a larger proximity risk.

But for the most part the basic problem existed then as it does now, "perceived anonymity". It is too easy to rant and rail when the person on the other end is nothing but ether.


T.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: You really want to know what I think

Winston said:
<sigh>

Oh, I loved Magic Online. And you could not post under a assumed "handle" like you can here. You had to post under your real actual name. You would be surprised at how having to reply to Mary Smith makes you think more about how the message will be received, than if you are replying to HotSlutGyrl.

The first modem that I ran into was an accoustic coupler. The first modem I had for personal use was a 2400 baud, and when I upgraded to a 9600, I thought I was in the super fast lane.

I was pissed when Mosaic, the first graphical browser was released for the PC, and no version for the Mac.

But I digress.

Another jolt to the memory banks. Yes there were some BBS's where you had to use a real validated name and they did tend to keep things more in line. Also I recall some having regular meetings so if you think replying to Mary Smith gave you fodder to consider your words go one step further and put a face and a personal conversation to it.

My first modem was a Hayes or a Motorolla and was something ridiculous like 150 or 300 baud. Then to 1200 Sportster, 2400 Sportster, but then I stopped upgrading until I went big, USR Dual Standard HST 16.8/14.4. I'll give it to USR, that modem was literally cutting edge at the time, ($1000 if you can believe it), but even being so old technology it flash upgraded to 32k and then 56k. It is something like 14 years old and I gave it to an old lady on the street who wanted to get email from her grand-children and even though we finally upgraded her to DSL she still uses it for a fax machine. What a work horse!

I also hated Mosaic, the infamous Internet In A Box package was where I got mine. Then beta testing W95 and also testing Netscape 1.0.

Oddly enough at my work I was about the only person using a dedicated T3 to the internet. No where to go really, but I sure got there fast.


T.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: To Speedo

Talerion said:
Damn I have got to make a mental note to stop upsetting OTB with all this reality. Messes up his paradigm.


T.

LOL, pop quiz, when did WW II start? When did the UK declare war (and thus its dominions like Canada)? Who was late?

OTB
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To Speedo

onthebottom said:
LOL, pop quiz, when did WW II start? When did the UK declare war (and thus its dominions like Canada)? Who was late?

OTB

England declared war a few days after Germany invaded Poland so sometime early in September 1939. Canada had obtained full independence in these types of matters following WW1 lead and declared war on Germany also in early September 1939 but a few days after GB.

The US declared war on Japan the day following the attack on Pearl Harbour December 8, 1941, and then on Germany three days later following Germany's declaration of war on the US and not in unison with their action against Japan as is commonly mistaken.

So to answer your question the war started September 1939 and the US, despite the pleading of England and the rest of Europe, showed up a little two years after the fact.

World War 2 is a bit easier since it was a 'world' scenario rather quickly. WW1 started off locally with the assasination of Archduke Ferdinand by a Serb, (man those guys are always causing problems), resulting in various single declarations of war in a domino effect until German declares war on France which because of a treaty between GB and France, GB declares war on Germany. Canada declared war on Germany hours following GB.

Thus by August 1914 the players are decided.

As in WW2 the US decides to sit back and watch, (well I suppose in fact WW2 was much like WW1 in this matter), and takes a stance of neutrality. April 1917 the US declares war on Germany. November 1918 WW1 end.

I suppose in fairness WW1 was a little more ambiguous in that it isn't quite as easy to point out the obvious evil that was present. Kaiser Wilhelm may not have been a nice guy but he was no Adolph. Also the US made efforts during WW1 to provide war material to the allies via Canada even though such actions would be considered contrary to their stance of neutrality.


So to answer your two questions, (the second being more subtle in the hopes of saying that while not as late as the US entering the war, Canada did so under obligation);

1. The US showed up quite late in WW1, nearly at the end in point of fact, and a full two years late in WW2. In both cases showing up after the war had been acknowledged as turned. Again as I indicated before this is not to suggest that the US involvement did not greatly hurry the end in either case and also in the case of WW2 given the German heavy water experiments it is possible that the first nucleur bomb may have had a swastica stamped on it.

2. While Canada indeed was obliged to follow suit with Britain in WW1, (although there was no question of this happening anyway following their efforts in the Boer War), this obligation ended at the end of WW1 and as such their entrance into WW2 was completely voluntary.


Does that answer your question?


T.
 
onthebottom said:
US troops are already there fighting said "extremism", and I'd hazard a guess that there are more than 51 of them.

OTB
They never actually left after seizing the colony from Spain back in 1898 did they? In spite of the Filipinos' war of independence, the US didn't give the colony its freedom until after WWII, I believe. Just a few more than 51 keeping the place "safe" ever since.
 
This LCN designation is pure BS. If the US was under any serious military threat, we be the first one to help.

"I back you up anytime you're in serious trouble but don't ask me to join your swarming."