Passenger Shot and Killed!!

What kind of farking idiot says he has a bomb in an airport

a mentally ill guy. reportedly the female with him begged them not to shoot because he was bipolar and delusional.
 
Has it been comfimed whether or not he was bi-polar as the his wife and mother-in-law claimed.

No doubt, they took the appropriate action, given what we know, but still it's a loss of life.
 
I still maintain they didn't have to kill him. Perhaps my suggestion to shot him in the legs was not the best idea, but they could have disabled him without having to kill him. The man was apparently deranged, that is no excuse for killing another human being.
It is that trigger happy mentality that the kids today use as a template. Results: gun fights in the street, and Toronto is not exempt, at the rate of one a week.
 
What she SHOULD have done...

feminista said:
a mentally ill guy. reportedly the female with him begged them not to shoot because he was bipolar and delusional.
..was beg him to take his meds.

What she SHOULD have done was beg him to stay home....or at least stay the hell off of airplanes.

I'll say it again - if someone (an adult) says they have a bomb on an airplane, I want them DEAD. I don't care WTF their excuse is.

Are you suggesting that they should have negotiated with the wife and clam her down and get the entire story first? Because there was no chance she was acting as distraction to keep the authorities from acting, right?

Frankly, by asking him to halt first, they did more than I would have...

It is a tragedy, but if he failed to take his meds, he is solely responsible.
 
feminista said:
a mentally ill guy. reportedly the female with him begged them not to shoot because he was bipolar and delusional.


I don't care if he was wearing a chicken suit running up and down the asile. We make it very clear you do not threaten people with a bomb. If you are ordered to stop by an Air Marshal you do and if you say you have a bomb, run, refuse to stop turn around, charge the person with the gun and reach into your pack..........YOU ARE GOING TO BE SHOT DEAD.
 
raydeon said:
I still maintain they didn't have to kill him. Perhaps my suggestion to shot him in the legs was not the best idea, but they could have disabled him without having to kill him. The man was apparently deranged, that is no excuse for killing another human being.
It is that trigger happy mentality that the kids today use as a template. Results: gun fights in the street, and Toronto is not exempt, at the rate of one a week.
When you train as the only cop on the beat, you do not take prisioners at any altitude. You do not risk the lives of hundreds of people, because you someone might say shot him in the legs. You do not risk allowing hundreds of families being devistated because you hesitated. You take out the threat as swiftly as possible. If you can do it by subduing the threat you do so. If not you take it out.
 
raydeon said:
I still maintain they didn't have to kill him. Perhaps my suggestion to shot him in the legs was not the best idea, but they could have disabled him without having to kill him. The man was apparently deranged, that is no excuse for killing another human being.
In retrospect they didn't need to kill him and as A1 pointed out it appears they didn't intend to actually kill him. Allegedly, he appeared to be reaching into his bag and they were under the impression given what he told them that he did have a bomb. It would only take a split second to detonate it, if it were rigged that way.


Maybe there are pieces of the puzzle that will come to light, or that we may never know, but as it stands, weighing the lives of many vs one life and the apparent frenetic situation, as much as it is sad for the family of the man who was gunned down, I don't see any other reasonable course of action that could have been taken.
 
They needed to kill him. If for no other reason than to improve the human gene pool.
 
catchmeonline.com said:
this ol man from newfoundland started tellin me all about his experiences during wwII and sayin that the american army has shit training... comical moment.. i dont meet many old newfies and this one was hilarious..
Well, some 60-70 years ago the US wasn't the military giant it is today. It was good, but not Cold War good. So its not exactly surprising that draftees didn't have the best trainning...
 
raydeon said:
With all the training they have and their marksmanship, why did they have to kill him? They could have easibly disabled him by shooting in the legs. Another example of the cowboy mentality.
If the man has a bomb in a bag in his hands, how exactly will shooting his legs stop him from blowing it up?
Secondly, from what I hear from most law enforcement the whole idea of "percision shooting" is nothing more than movie myth. Not everyone is sniper percise, and trying to be that percise doesn't work well...
 
booboobear said:
None of us were there . What we need to remember is that the marshalls have only a split second to act , we have days to pick apart there decision.
I think they made the right choice . It is unfortunate he was innocent but like I said they didn't have time to check is bag .


The voice of reason.

I would like to see some of those armchair quarterbacks in the same situation. You only have a split second to make a decision.
Imagine the shoe would be on the other foot, and he had a bomb and failed to stop him?

In any case this is a very tragic event. I feel bad for both. the cop who has to live with the thought of killing someone innocent and the poor guy that lost his life.
Sad...really sad.:(
 
what terrorist would be running thru the aisles like a lunatic flailing his arms and yelling while the plane was still on the ground? On top of that the wife is explaining he is nuts and didn't take his meds.

Not only should he not have been killed - he shouldn't have been shot at all.

With this precedent for air marshal behavior - no one with turrets, mental illness, or a propensity to provoke should ever get on a plane becuz authorities can kill you at will.

I'm gonna have to tape my mouth shout the next time I'm on a plane or in an airport - then they'll probably shoot whoever I'm with thinking I'm a hostage or something.
 
feminista said:
what terrorist would be running thru the aisles like a lunatic flailing his arms and yelling while the plane was still on the ground?
No certainly not, terrorists are rational calm people that would never act this way :rolleyes: