Participating in an interesting study tomorrow... Dog bite force...

Who has the strongest bite for a dog?

  • Timberwolf

    Votes: 2 10.5%
  • Rottweiler

    Votes: 5 26.3%
  • German Shepherd

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Belgian Malinois

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • PitBull

    Votes: 6 31.6%
  • Giant Schnauzer

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Argentinian Dogo

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Cane Corso

    Votes: 2 10.5%
  • Neopolitan Mastiff

    Votes: 3 15.8%
  • American Bulldog

    Votes: 1 5.3%

  • Total voters
    19

21pro

Crotch Sniffer
Oct 22, 2003
7,829
1
0
Caledon East
We are waking up early to head over to a park near Guelph University where 20 some dogs are participating in a 'Biting contest' to measure lbs/sq inch, total lbs. pressure, among a few other tests with dogs using a special bite meter... (looks like a tiny version of a weigh scale apparatus that fits in a bite toy.) we've (the selected dog owners- picked from k9 clubs, the police, and a few 'randoms' who replied on Craigslist, etc...) been given a similar toy to play 'tug' with the dog and get them fixed on these toys and develop a good strong bite. From what I know, these are the 'dog breeds' participating tomorrow:

the first is Willie, a 140 lbs. Timber Wolf that's a house pet at Guelph... he's from the forests near Sault Ste. Marie... no bite training. he's too aggressive to approach.
Rottweiler (2m, 1f) 1 of the males is sport trained in protection work.
Giant Schnauzer (1m trained in protection)
American Bulldog (1m trained in protection work)
Boxer (1m)
Great Dane (1m)
Neopolitan Mastiff (1m, 1f- both protection trained)
German Shepherds (6 police k9 unit trained males)
Belgian Malinois (2 protection trained males, 1 protection trained female)
Argentinian Dogo (3 protection trained males, 1 reg pet male, 1 reg pet female)
Cane Corso (1m compound guard dog- and he's one mean sucker...)
Pitbull (3m, 2f)- none have done bite work except for with the sample toy they have had to 'practice with'...


anyone with previous experience with this... any clues to who will win the bite wars??

My German Shepherd tested at our club a few times and usually registers between 300 and 500 lbs. though if the bite is not well developed (ie, uses the k9 teeth instead of the molars) the GSD bites are usually only in the 150-250 range.

My bet is on the Rotty... when I do decoy work (where I wear a sleave and have dogs bite it and take me down) the rotties are definitely the strongest... but, they also bite shallow so I don't really know how it ought to all turn out.

I hope someone shows up with a malamute. They are genetically very close to the wolves of northern Canada. I'm interested to see what the Timberwolf will do. he sounds huge, though they couldn't do any 'practice' with him as he is unapproachable.
 
you sure this is not at the woodbine racetrack? It's like betting on horses , it's a gamble i guess for this stuff haha

If you win I am guessing it will add money to your hobbying-fund?

Best of luck tmr!
 
it's not a betting thing... yet as far as i know. lmao... it's a study put on by the k9 department at Guelph's Small Animal Veterinary school.
 
1) This is silly. Forceful biting comes from strong genetics and/or good training. In a nutshell, it is up to the individual dog. Breed of the dog is not an overwhelming factor.

2) IF you are trying to prove that a particular breed bites harder than the next, your test pool is WAY TOO SMALL. Go to #1.
 
yeah, the pool is small, but the university is using it for other comparisons- nothing to 'write papers and journals over', but my guess is that it is so they can try out their new gear and instruments to maybe plan for a 'real' study some other time... you know universities- it's gotta be funding approved.

and as for us participants- we aren't getting compensated or renumerated for participation... it's rather just dog enthusiasts, hobbyists and k9 cops that volunteered for the study.

there might be more dogs there when I show up... i don't know. i didn't have anything to do with the planning of this. it just striked my interest and i like watching dogs bite things.
 
My money is on the pitt or the rott.
 
About 15 years ago I saw this giant Irish Wolfhound, distroy the biggest black kong they make, in a minute... at the time they were advertised as indistructable so the owner returned it to the company and they repalced it three times before they stopped replaceing them then stopped advertising them as indistructable... so my vote goes for the unlisted Irish Wolfhound... I disagree with a previous poster that claims that breed does not count, that is like saying that a herding breed dosn't have an advantage in herding a flock

b d
 
Sorry but I really don't think Willie the house pet should be in this "study". It sounds as if he is dangerous and shows unwarrented aggression. Why would anyone in their right mind want to encourage this further?

From my understanding bite work is only for dogs with stable temperments. Dogs that have proven themselves to be well rounded and reliable. It sounds as if willie does not even have basic obedience!

On the other hand from the sounds of it the other dogs are well trained and handled. I hope willie does not ruin the fun for them!

My bets are on either the Malinois or the Argentinian Dogo.
 
You left out some of the strongest dogs in the world

- Fila Brasileiro
- Rhodesian Ridgeback
- Akita


But the winner by far is the Tosa Inu, it can weigh up to 220 lbs and can destroy any dog on the planet. Its jaws are massive and I doubt any other dog can match its bite psi

Tosa Inu pictured here
tg9.jpg
 
Sheik said:
If Willie's owner cannot control him then yes he shouldnt be involved. However all owners that I've come across who own wolves know the limitations of their animals. They would not willingly permit a situation to occur where they could lose control of their animal.

Guelph is famous for their veterinary school and would not attempt something that would endanger people.

I am not doubting their competence, rather questioning as to why they would permit a dog who is "too aggressive to approach" in to their study which sounds as if it is a competition on some level. I have no doubt there are safety measures in place, but why would they want to potentially encourage a dog who shows unwarranted aggression to bite?
 
Esco! said:
You left out some of the strongest dogs in the world

- Fila Brasileiro
- Rhodesian Ridgeback
- Akita


But the winner by far is the Tosa Inu, it can weigh up to 220 lbs and can destroy any dog on the planet. Its jaws are massive and I doubt any other dog can match its bite psi

They also forgot one of my favourites:

the Korean Jindo

DSC00408-full;init:.JPG
 
first off i want to point out that this is not to be confused with dog fighting or some kinda unethical aggressive dog development. most of these dogs were police dogs and schutzhund dogs. only 1 was a private security firm's guard dog (personal protection) being the Cane Corso. and Willie is not a pet as you would think of. rather he's an undomesticated wolf that is used for stud purposes and lives at Guelph's vet school.

the clear winner was Willie the Timberwolf. his highest bite score was 635 lbs. to see him up close and hear him snarl had my knees knocking. he spanned about 7 feet in length and weighed 140 lbs.!!

the next class all ranked close together with scores varying from 260-580
these were the strongest biters of domesticated k9s... which has been confirmed in other similar studies.
Rottweiler
Neopolitan Mastiff
German Shepherd
Cane Corso


my german shepherd scored 286-378-366, so right in the middle of the above class. the police k9s were clearly stronger biting german shepherds though (all had scores in upper 500's)... which is interesting because their 'forte' is scent tracking.

this class of dogs did not have a bite register in at over 300 lbs.
Irish Wolfhound - the one above poster inquired about the IWH's bite... there just happened to be one there.
Giant Schnauzer
Great Dane
Belgian Malinois

and the weakest of the bunch: (which is really interesting because these dogs were bred for fighting many attribute a false sense of bite strength to them- but, it's not their bite strength that makes them good at fighting other dogs. I'd suspect that rather it's their small, compact build, low center of gravity, small thick necks that provide protection to vulnerable dog strike areas... but, honestly i've never witnessed any pitfighting so it's all left to the imagination)
none of these registered a score higher than 240 lbs.
Argentinian Dogo
PitBull
American Bulldog
Boxer

38 dogs participated today... alot more than the 20 i thought there were going to be. and more than I could remember to publish here. if I get a weblink uploaded, i'll add it to the thread. there were quite a few video cameras there, so i imagine something will pop up on youtube as well.

generally speaking, the dogs with bite training scored highest relative to dogs that only 'bite balls and toys'... males had stronger bites than females (but breed determined a greater variation) ... the untrained family pet rotty showed a whole 200 lbs. weaker than one that had protection training! (so, as you can see, even within breeds, the bite varies greatly)

the youtube links provided above by another poster shows a NG show where they did a similar study a while ago. the scores were lower in that tv show as what we displayed here, but, they hid a pressure scale in a schutzhund bite sleeve which, I am most certain absorbs some of the pressure and diffuses the overall strength of the bite. Our sleeve was specially built for the purpose of such studies.
 
the Rotty. his highest score was 586.

next was a Neo Mas with 579, a Peel Region Shepherd with 578, and then a Cane Corso with 575... then it was mostly other male police german shepherds...

pretty interesting to note that it only takes 7-12 lbs. of pressure to break a human bone.