parking infraction need advice

doinker

Active member
Oct 26, 2001
310
45
28
west end highpark area
i had to take my wife to the doctor for an emergency she could not walk due to fractures ankle (just one reason why i parked where i did) i saw the sign that had the price for parking and also saw the green pay box at the same place so i parked there payed to park took my wife inside to the doctors office came back out 3 minutes later and there was a $60 parking ticket on my windshield for parking in a no parking zone. i looked at the sign for price for parking and just below it was a small no stopping sign with an arrow pointing in the direction of my car. no problem i did not read the signs completely.I did park in a no parking zone but this happened august 8 2009 and i just got the summons today to appear in court january 14 2011, can i fight this on the time it took to get to court? i know it is only $60 but this city is already taking too much of my money. thanks for your advice
 
Suck it up and pay. You have admitted you were wrong. You want the city to take all of our maney to fight you in court instead of you paying $60.
 
the other point is that the sign was misleading first there is a sigh with the price to pay with the green pay box right where i parked the price sign was a fair size sign then after i noticed that below the price sign there was a small 6"x6" no stopping sign
 
I feel your pain, as a delivery professional from time to time I drive a car for a living too. You have a right to explain your mistake, to the judge, and ask for the fine to be decreased, or extra time to pay the fine if you need it (unemployed, etc.). Asking for the case to be withdrawn due to the length of time it has taken to bring this matter to court is also possible, but less likely. My reccomendation is to arrive early for court, check the docket list outside the courtroom for your name and the parking officers number. Call out the officers number, if he is present, see the prosecutor and tell them you wish to ask for a motion to withdraw the case due to the time it took to get to trial. They will probably tell you why you can't make that motion, if it sounds like the truth, ask to plead guilty with an explaination. Tell your story and admit fault and say your "sorry and won't do it again", ask for the fine to be reduced and good luck. If the officer is not present, which is what will probably happen after a two and half year delay, tell the prosecutor you want to plead not guilty, and wait for your trial to begin and then be withdrawn due to lack of evidence. Photos of the misleading signage will help your case. I have had sixty percent of my tickets cancelled at the parking office. Twenty percent withdrawn at trial, five percent reduced. And the remaining ten percent I have lost and been given extra time to pay. I have had over 100 tickets. Don't worry about it costing more to go to court, it won't, however, not turning up will add court costs to your fine, so don't do nothing about it, pay it now to save the inconveinence of going to court. Good luck.
 
You should go down to the city court and throw a temper tantrum. Be sure to film it and post it on youtube so we can all laugh (with) you.
 
To me "guilty with an explanation" fits the facts here pretty well. You were taking your wife into an emergency room, no doubt you were a little scatter brained as a result of the stress and the rush you were in. In your hurry to get her to the hospital you made an error, which you had come back to rectify only three minutes later.

I usually have no sympathy for people who get parking tickets but if your story is true you deserve a break.

Whether it's worth $60 to you (or part of $60) to go in and spend a day in court is entirely a different question, I sure as hell wouldn't book a day off work for what's likely to be $30 off a $60 ticket.
 
Don't use the argument that it was delayed by 2 1/2 years suggested by BikeMessinger , as that is not correct :)

Also using the emergency excuse as suggested by Fuji... did you go to the ER or Doctor's office ?
 
Did you ignore the ticket and just now get the summons, or did you request a trial back when it happened?
 
I assume this was in Toronto?

You can do one of three things.

Go in, talk to the prosecutor before the trial and explain the situation. You will most likely be given an offer to plead guilty for half the fine.

File a 11(b) motion that the delay denied your right to a speedy trial under the Canadian Charter of Rights. Be prepared to show your rights were infringed. It is simply not enough to point out the amount of time lapsed.

Fight the parking ticket. Remember, parking tickets are absolute liability offenses. In other words, you're guilty until you prove yourself innocent in a court of law.

Good luck!
 
If it took you 2.5 years for your first trial date (and you did nothing to delay it), then as djk said, file a Section 11 (b) motion to have it indefinitely stayed for violating your rights to a prompt trial. This assumes you will do it yourself. If you can't, it won't be worth hiring somebody, so just pay it.

(City Hall has so many excuses to take money from us, and why should we be so obliging to pay).
 
i went to the city building to request a trial 2 days after getting the ticket and i have a court date 17 months later i dont know where 2.5 years came from but is 17 months still too long and if i decide can i still pay the ticket before court?
 
i went to the city building to request a trial 2 days after getting the ticket and i have a court date 17 months later i don't know where 2.5 years came from but is 17 months still too long and if i decide can i still pay the ticket before court?

Whether or not an 11(b) motion will be successful depends on many factors. Time alone is not sufficient in most cases. The fact that it is a parking ticket will both help (ie. it is a simple charge that the Crown should not have needed a great deal of time to prep for) and hurt (ie. it is such a minor charge as to be unlikely to have caused any real prejudice).

The other issue is that it will depend on the jurisdiction you are in. Some jurisdictions will have a greater tolerance for administrative delay than others.

The problem with a parking ticket is that is usually more cost effective to pay the damn thing than to fight it. If you would like to stand on principal, and you have some free time, it may be worthwhile to spend some time in the court you'll be appearing in. See how many (if any) people are trying an 11(b) claim, and how successful they are.
 
My personal take on any sort of ticket is that if i truly did fuck up, I pay the ticket. I learn from the mistake and move on.

You've already admitted you were wrong, just pay, and save all of us the money.
 
Go online and try.
 
Not knowing all of the facts it is difficult to give you any real advice.

My recommendation is review the information here TicketCombat.com and see if this helps any. It is pretty comprehensive and will give you a much better idea of where you stand.

Good luck.