Palm Pre or Blackberry Tour

petitelover said:
Which do you like better and why?

Two different devices.

If you want a iPhone like experience but want multi-tasking, go Pre.

If you're a huge email user, go Blackberry.

I've used both and I'm waiting for my CDMA carrier to make the switch to HSPDA, so I can use an iPhone.
 
I agree, both devices are strong in their areas (although the Pre screen has been very prone to scratching....huge rate of returns since its launch in June, and the multitasking is a massive drain on its battery), but neither stacks up to the iPhone. Add the iPhone's beautiful hardware and elegant OS to its incredible 65,000 selection of apps in the iTunes store, and you have one hell of a pocket computer that can do just about anything you want. I too am waiting for the Telus/Bell switchover to HSPDA at the end of the year, hoping that it will bring more competition to the iPhone, as I want one real bad! I currently have the iPod Touch which pretty much has all of the same capabilities, but I want the on-the-go data and email capability that the iPhone has!
 
You comment on the battery drain of the Pre, but don't mention the iPhones main failing which is it's inadequate battery life...even after they increased it's capacity with the latest gen phones.

It's all fun and nice to have aps, but when your constantly running to charge it...what's the point.

Not even close to the battery life of a Blackberry.
 
Talk time:
Up to 12 hours on 2G
Up to 5 hours on 3G
Standby time: Up to 300 hours

Internet use:
Up to 5 hours on 3G
Up to 9 hours on Wi-Fi
Video playback: Up to 10 hours
Audio playback: Up to 30 hours

How do these stats show a weak battery in the iPhone? I have several friends who have one, and they have never complained about the battery having to be charged multiple times throughout the day. They do plug it in every night, simply because using apps and 3G data is much more of a battery drain than just emailing, talking and texting. All comments I've read on the iPhone's battery point to shutting off 3G when you don't need it, as 3G is a drain on any phone's battery, not just the iPhone.

Sure, a BB will last longer simply because you mainly use it for email/texting/talking. But if you were to use the iPhone in the same way, you'd find that it either lasts just as long as the BB Bold:

Battery & Battery Life
Standby time: 13.5 days (324 hours)
Talk time: 4.5 hours
1500 mAhr removable/rechargeable cryptographic lithium cell

Now if the BB had access to all the apps, then you'd see its battery drain just as fast, if not faster than an iPhone. Besides, all it takes is to plug into your car cigarette lighter while you're driving to pop up your battery. I do that now with just a regular cell phone. It's not like you're having to plug it in everywhere you go! lol
 
masterchief said:
You comment on the battery drain of the Pre, but don't mention the iPhones main failing which is it's inadequate battery life...even after they increased it's capacity with the latest gen phones.

It's all fun and nice to have aps, but when your constantly running to charge it...what's the point.

Not even close to the battery life of a Blackberry.

Depends on which Blackberry. I had a Storm, when I used it heavily, it wouldn't last a day without charging. I also had a touchscreen Windows Mobile device (HTC 6800) and the same issue.

Poor battery life seems to be the trademark of touchscreen devices.

The problem is probably more obvious because the iPhone platform is designed in such a way to encourage heavy use.

Some solutions to consider:

http://store.apple.com/ca/product/MB352LL/B?fnode=MTY1NDA0MQ&mco=MjQzNTIxNw

http://richardsolo.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=264
 
I know about 10 or 15 people with iPhones and they're always complaining about the battery life, even the ones who have a 3GS. A couple of them switched over to BBs becuase of the battery life issue. They've all tried replacing their phones but the have the same issue with the new ones.
 
So they switched from a device that allowed them to be heavy users, having access to 3D games, an awesome iPod, and a multitude of apps (65,000 and counting) that made their iPhone literally into a portable computer, to a device that forced them to be light users, with the main functionality being email (BB certainly excels at this function) and texting? All because the heavy use shortened their battery life?

And they did this without investigating options, such as the one listed in djk's post (there are plenty of other similar battery extending products out there)? Are you serious......this was the reason they switched? :confused:
 
Goomer said:
So they switched from a device that allowed them to be heavy users, having access to 3D games, an awesome iPod, and a multitude of apps (65,000 and counting) that made their iPhone literally into a portable computer, to a device that forced them to be light users, with the main functionality being email (BB certainly excels at this function) and texting? All because the heavy use shortened their battery life?

And they did this without investigating options, such as the one listed in djk's post (there are plenty of other similar battery extending products out there)? Are you serious......this was the reason they switched? :confused:
Absolutely. What's the point of a phone if you can't use it? None of them care about Apps or Games, and you can use a BB as an MP3 player. They don't always have access to a plug and need a phone that can go a full day without needing a charge. Plugging a battery into the bottom of your phone is not a solution a defeats the purpose of a slim sleek phone.

Anyway, they all seem to like the BB and I haven't heard them complain about missing the iTunes store. They all seem to be pretty happy.
 
If they're happy, then that's totally cool. The BB is nothing to sneeze at, as it certainly shines at what it does. But I guess the point I'm trying to make is that if you use the iPhone in the same way that you use the BB (texting, emailing, talking), then the battery lasts just as long as the BB. The battery only gets depleted faster when you start doing things that you can't do on a BB, such as playing 3D games or running graphics intensive apps. If you're mainly using it as a phone and email device, then you'll find the iPhone battery will last as long as anything in the market today.

Like I said, there is absolutely nothing wrong with the BB, and if it wasn't for the iPhone out there, it would be my choice as well.

Cheers :)

Goomer
 
I have both an iPhone 3G and a Blackberry Bold. One is for work, one for personal entertainment. You can already guess which one does what.

What kills the battery is the 3G feature. Turn it off on either one and you amazingly extend the battery life by a mile on both the Bold and iPhone. This is well documented. But why buy a 3G capable phone if you're not going to use it?

The balance has to be right. I need a phone to last 1 full day on a full charge with reasonable use, which the iPhone does, even with my heavy use. I'm not in the jungle, lol, I can charge each night. Plus I can charge it at work, car, if need be etc. If I surf the crap out of the Bold with 3G turned on, the battery life is shit too.

What is important is for the phone to do what you want it to do. For me that's surfing, online gaming, etc. I've gone through a few blackberries and while they are outstanding for email, the best IMO, surfing is not quite the same, slower navigation, everything is slower period (except email). Everything on the iPhone is simple easy to use, no manual required.

I had an iPod and I use iTunes so syncing music was a huge plus for me as well, although this is not important for everyone.

In choosing a smartphone, I'd go with one that has an established platform. Both Blackberry's and iPhone's are platforms are mature and will have development for years to come. What this means is that there will always be apps available, new ones, improvements etc. Personally, I'd never buy those Nokia smartphones, or take a chance on Palm myself. The Pre doesn't have a big enough market yet.

The last 3.0 O/S update for the iPhone added substantial features.
 
Goomer said:
So they switched from a device that allowed them to be heavy users, having access to 3D games, an awesome iPod, and a multitude of apps (65,000 and counting) that made their iPhone literally into a portable computer, to a device that forced them to be light users, with the main functionality being email (BB certainly excels at this function) and texting? All because the heavy use shortened their battery life?

And they did this without investigating options, such as the one listed in djk's post (there are plenty of other similar battery extending products out there)? Are you serious......this was the reason they switched? :confused:

I'd have to agree. Right now, I have a Blackberry and a iPod Touch. Whenever, I'm near accessible wi-fi, the Blackberry stays in my pocket. I can do so much more on an iPod Touch than I ever could on my Blackberry.

When I know I'll be able to use my iPod Touch constantly for a day (eg. at a conference with free wi-fi), I ditch my laptop at home and work off the iPod Touch. The Blackberry is used just for SMS and voice.

I suspect as more people become educated on the versatile nature and power of the iPhone platform, they'll drop their Blackberries and switch.

My reasoning? Goldman Sachs recently did a survey with smartphone power users. And there's a lots of love for Apple.

http://blogs.zdnet.com/BTL/?p=22066
 
djk said:
I've used both and I'm waiting for my CDMA carrier to make the switch to HSPDA, so I can use an iPhone.

I'm a little confused with wireless network standards but I thought that 3G was HSDPA.

I heard that Bell and Telus were upgrading their networks at the end of the year and calling it 4G which is capable of 7 MBPS, which is the same speed as Rogers and Fido's current 3G network.

Bell/Telus still won't use a SIM card on their networks. Their phones will still be locked to their network. The phone may be capable of taking a SIM if you happen to travel.

The iPhone which is a GSM device and requires a SIM card to work won't work on the Bell/Telus network.

This is my understand. Is that correct?
 
Cinema Face said:
I'm a little confused with wireless network standards but I thought that 3G was HSDPA.

I heard that Bell and Telus were upgrading their networks at the end of the year and calling it 4G which is capable of 7 MBPS, which is the same speed as Rogers and Fido's current 3G network.

Bell/Telus still won't use a SIM card on their networks. Their phones will still be locked to their network. The phone may be capable of taking a SIM if you happen to travel.

The iPhone which is a GSM device and requires a SIM card to work won't work on the Bell/Telus network.

This is my understand. Is that correct?

Not exactly. HSDPA is the GSM version of 3G. While EVDO is the CDMA version of it.

What you're referring to is LTE which will be 4G. This technology appears to be the winner as most carriers in the States will be moving to it as well.

The plan is to go to HSDPA then switch to LTE when the technology is ready for mass use.

http://www.informationweek.com/news/mobility/business/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=219300110
http://www.intomobile.com/2008/04/05/att-4g-lte-network-in-2012.html