Palestinian student protest

scouser1 said:
the suicide bombings are a product of the occupation, remove the occupation allow Palestinians to have normal lives where they can grow and foster an economy and then try to convince an 18 year old Palestinian to blow themselves up, they will call you crazy as we do here because we have lives and opportunities in this part of the world, not so in a refugee camp in the Gaza Strip
You know that wonderful quote by Anatole France?: "cet animal est tres mechant; quand on l'attaque, il se defend." ("This animal is very vicious; if you attack it, it defends itself.")

MW
 
scouser1 said:
the suicide bombings are a product of the occupation, remove the occupation allow Palestinians to have normal lives where they can grow and foster an economy and then try to convince an 18 year old Palestinian to blow themselves up, they will call you crazy as we do here because we have lives and opportunities in this part of the world, not so in a refugee camp in the Gaza Strip

As long as Israel exists, whereever it's borders are, there will be Palestinian suicide bombers.
 
maxweber said:
All you said was that both Palestinian extremists and al Qaeeda use suicide bombing as a tactic. Got news: that's a similarity, not a connection. Your other "connection" was this bit of exuberant illogic: "Also there have been many statements by Bin Laden and his #2 feigning empathy and support for the Palestinians as a political ploy to legitimize their illegitimate cause."
Where to start? First, if the support is "feigned," and a mere "ploy," then it's insubstantial; second, "many statements" are not a connection.

Eh? the what?

MW
Still reaching, are we maxwell? Maxy, maxy, maxy c'est tu that proferred the word "connection" in your respone to The Mugger not I. And as par for this discourse and others you have scavenged through, you lose on the facts and thus delve into phonics.
 
Israel needs to disengage from the West Bank like it did with Gaza. It then needs to give East Jerusalem to the Palestinians as a capital. Until this happens there will continue to be bloodshed on both sides.

OTB
 
scouser1 said:
stupid comment hmmm? so why is it even in Israel they are called the occupied territories even amongst those on the right wing of Likud.

As for violence not working for political motivation in the 20th century, oh really, ask the Vietnamese violence did work in establishing their own independent country, the Irish why they got a piece of territory called the Republic of Ireland through violence, and the British still werent able to crush the IRA who will eventually get the rest of the pie in a few years. The ANC used violence in South Africa and well look at that apartheid is all gone, I will never justify suicide bombings as the way to go for a struggle, but its a sad statement on a situation for someone whose life has gotten so pointless and feels so worthless that they have to do such a horrific act.


Well do us all a favour and strap a bomb on yourself - at least at min. you'll be able to bonk 20 virgins.

Non of the examples you mentioned actually came to and end due to violence - ANC, IRA ended their campaign because it became painfully obvious that the citizens would no longer support this violence. Economics in both cases played the major role in settlements.

As for Nam - I seem to recall a rather bloody battle for Saigon, that ended with a dash from the US Embassy that was retreating. Not bloody - boy are just dumb - that bomb idea is looking better - gene pool would benefit.

And lastly - your a complete moron - of course everyone knows about occupied territories, no disputes that - all I said was that Israel was not the first to conquer land and hold - nor will they be the last. The fact remains, Israel won this territory after an all out effort by Arab armies attempted and failed miserably at trying to destroy Israel. Now with that fact, can you not understand why Israel likes a buffer zone between them and their enemies.

Twits, your all twits.
 
onthebottom said:
Israel needs to disengage from the West Bank like it did with Gaza. It then needs to give East Jerusalem to the Palestinians as a capital. Until this happens there will continue to be bloodshed on both sides.

OTB

absolutely the most intelligent thing said on this thread and would be accepted by the majority of Palestinians, nice to see someone post something without calling people twits or morons hmmm :D
 
Good example of the dead end...

So we have two sides each unwilling to listen to the other's point of view, and considerable intransigence, leading to name-calling, and sooner or later we can expect threats of violence...

And I'm talking about this thread!
 
scouser1 said:
absolutely the most intelligent thing said on this thread and would be accepted by the majority of Palestinians, nice to see someone post something without calling people twits or morons hmmm :D

That chick is hot, nice rump on her......

OTB
 
scouser1 said:
OTB if you are interested this is the link http://www.haifawehbe.com/

its Lebanese singer Haifa Wehbe, nice to see a side of the Middle East and the Arab world that doesnt involve bombings and beheadings hmmmm :D

I was thinking boom boom, but a different kind of boom boom - damn that's a fine backside.....

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Israel needs to disengage from the West Bank like it did with Gaza. It then needs to give East Jerusalem to the Palestinians as a capital. Until this happens there will continue to be bloodshed on both sides.

OTB
I think if Israel completely disengages from the West Bank that should be enough. Jerusalem is the holiest city in Judaism............I could never see them giving up any part of it.

Scouser you're too one sided in your beliefs. The conflict is much more complicated than you make it seem. Its sad to see Palestinians suffering but their leadership must hold part of the blame as well. Arafat stole from his people in more ways than one. Its a travesty that he won the Nobel Peace Prize.
 
what about the Muslim and Christian parts of Jerusalem are those all the sudden to be Jewish too, if it were up to the real extremist right wing Jews and their Pat Robertson allies, the Muslim dome of the rock would be torn down in order to build a new temple

The Mideast conflict is simple both sides deserve to live in a prosperous secure state. But the average Palestinian has been the biggest victim of this conflict, screwed by their own leadership, the Israeli occupation and the other Arab countries governments.
 
scouser1 said:
the suicide bombings are a product of the occupation, remove the occupation allow Palestinians to have normal lives where they can grow and foster an economy and then try to convince an 18 year old Palestinian to blow themselves up, they will call you crazy as we do here because we have lives and opportunities in this part of the world, not so in a refugee camp in the Gaza Strip

This was the exact situation from 1948 to 1967. The West Bank and Gaza weren’t under Israeli rule. So why in 1967 did Egypt close the Straits of Tiran and the armies of Egypt, Syria, Jordan and Lebanon amass on the Israeli border?

The answer is of course that the Arabs don't want a "two state" solution. The failure at Oslo is evidence enough. The Arabs will try to kill Jews for the rest of eternity. It’s what they do.
 
ah and of course there are no Jews bent on killing Arabs ever heard of Meir Kahane comparing Palestinians to cockroaches, Baruch Goldstein perhaps or how about the Jewish Defence League and Kach party hmmm
 
scouser1 said:
ah and of course there are no Jews bent on killing Arabs ever heard of Meir Kahane comparing Palestinians to cockroaches, Baruch Goldstein perhaps or how about the Jewish Defence League and Kach party hmmm

And how many Arabs have these "Jews bent on Killing Arabs" actually killed?

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm?
 
scouser1 said:
well take a look at the rates of deaths since the second intifada began the rate of Palestinians killed is 3 times higher than Israelis

http://www.ict.org.il/casualties_project/stats_page.cfm
You don’t get out much do you? This argument has been played out a thousand times before. It is mate in three moves.

Look at the demographics. Over a third of the Israeli casualties are women and children. Less than 7% of the Palestinian casualties are women and children. (Hell they are responsible for 13% of their own casualties.) Twenty percent of the Israeli casualties are combatants, while fifty percent of the Palestinians are combatants.

The reason for these demographics is clear. Israelis don’t target civilians, while Palestinians do. This is the definition of terrorism. The targeting of civilians. If an Israeli is caught targeting civilians he is charged with murder. If a Palestinian kills a civilian, he is knighted. See the difference? It is advanced democratic civilizations versus primitive tribalism.

Now please continue with your apology for these sadistic killers of women and children.
 
arclighter said:
You don’t get out much do you? This argument has been played out a thousand times before. It is mate in three moves.

Look at the demographics. Over a third of the Israeli casualties are women and children. Less than 7% of the Palestinian casualties are women and children. (Hell they are responsible for 13% of their own casualties.) Twenty percent of the Israeli casualties are combatants, while fifty percent of the Palestinians are combatants.

The reason for these demographics is clear. Israelis don’t target civilians, while Palestinians do. This is the definition of terrorism. The targeting of civilians. If an Israeli is caught targeting civilians he is charged with murder. If a Palestinian kills a civilian, he is knighted. See the difference? It is advanced democratic civilizations versus primitive tribalism.

Now please continue with your apology for these sadistic killers of women and children.
Great post arclighter but I must warn you that evidence, facts, truth, reality, sound logic and cognitive reasoning are trumped by falsehoods, myths, disinformation, propoganda, biases, lies, illogic logic and cognitive diseases so amply and pitifully displayed by those who are proud members of the Terrorist Educational Resource Board.
 
rogerstaubach said:
Great post arclighter but I must warn you that evidence, facts, truth, reality, sound logic and cognitive reasoning are trumped by falsehoods, myths, disinformation, propoganda, biases, lies, illogic logic and cognitive diseases so amply and pitifully displayed by those who are proud members of the Terrorist Educational Resource Board.

and when they are completely cornered they put you on ignore....remember the kid on the block that owned the ball, and only let you play by his rules? Then when the rules became fair..he took off taking his ball with him...some here remind me of just that.