Owen Nolan debut as a Maple Leaf

You're right fiasco: However, I totally disagree with you taking the C away from Mats. Must've screwed up whom was in whos camp while cutting and pasting. okay, you're in the YES camp:

Yes: ToronToto, fiasco, widowmaker
No: Kathleen
Undecided: Georgian, sjs (both?)
 
I wouldn't stip him of the C tonight, or closer to the playoffs. It would happen in the spring. Do you mean end of June, after the playoffs are over? Spring is ten days from now and well before the playoffs begin.
 
Talk about the C

Its a good thing none of you work for the Leafs, or even a chance at the cup would never come to Toronto again. All armchair GM's have no idea what it's like in an NHL dressing room, or relations between the players/coaches/management. Look at what the media has created!
 
Actually

BigGuy26 I am privy to a little of what goes on in an NHL room due to personal and bussiness relations including a couple of former Leafs and one current one, but I digress, because you are right , I am no GM and I would not make a good one But these debates are part of what makes sports so much fun.

Kathleen, my post in it's entirety was not directed at you, but all those who always question the captaincy. As for me knowing what he (Roberts) wants you might be suprised. However my point was that he is very well respected and if he or the team felt they would be better served with him as captain instead of Mats then it would be so. Alas I do respect your opinion even though you are wrong LOL. In the end if they win the cup I am positive niether of us will care whose right and I will buy the first cheer at a place of your choosing.
 
Wow

Big deal widowmaker that you know Allan Bester and Peter Ing!
Just kidding - the debates and the conversation are fun, but such a big deal is made out of who is the captain or who should be the captain!

Tony Twist on The Score said this - It doesn't matter who wears the C or the A, the players will find the leader or leader in the dressing room.
 
Agreed

And, with Gilmore and Housley it just mihgt be the year! CHEERS.
 
HeY BigGuy26

FYI. It is Jari Crha and Bob Manno that I hang with. LOL.
 
Kathleen said:


I will agree to that. If that is the case, and we go the distance, you are quite right - our debate will have lost meaning. If you buy the first round, the second is on me. The place... well, I'd like game 6, stanley cup final at the ACC ( while we're up 4-1 over the Wings), but how about Gretzky's?

Thanks
Kathleen

Please stop saying "we". You have absolutely nothing to do with the team. At least try and limit it to one "we" per post.

"We" will be sitting around watching "them" try to reach the cup finals (do any of you really think they can handle whoever comes out of the west?).

The Housley aqquisition was "their" best pick up. He'll help the pp immensly.

Wesley will add stability to the blue line and provide the Leafs with a defensemen (Kaberle is also a good outlet passer) who knows how to break out of the zone.

Nolan will shine against the Flyers, and hopefully be the x factor that was missing when the Leafs meet up with the Devils.

Even if Gilmour falters, he will no doubt lift the spirits of his teammates, thus boosting their play.
 
Funny!

Hey Widowmaker, you sure it wasn't Rick Lanz and Peter Inhacak?

BTW, that's the first time Rusty has posted something serious that I didn't laugh at!
 
BigGuy26

No Lanz is too cool for us mere mortals and Inaceck and his brother are my arch enemies. I have recruited Miroslav Frycer to my ex Leaf posse and now I can brag to the masses. LOL.