Owen Nolan debut as a Maple Leaf

ToronToto

New member
Aug 26, 2002
1,134
0
0
Okay, Oh Canada is now being sung.

How will he perform in his debut as a Maple Leaf?

Of course, there's the after game review.


(Just starting the thread before the fact)
 
Nolan, so it is said, HATED being captain in SJ -just didn't want or enjoy being the centre of attention. Putting him in that situation in the Toronto media environment would destroy the poor guy.

Roberts on the other hand, might be a good choice. Certainly has the respect of team mates and opponents and a great work ethic.

Perhaps Sundin is just in a bit of a ''lull'' right now and will wake up before playoff time.

Georgian
 
Kathleen: - I also like Mats, but he's a captain that supposedly leads by example (on ice), not words. Problem is that he's not "there" for every game. Mats seems to have this way of disappearing during a game, but when he's on it, he's one of the better players in the league.

As for passion, it's probably there, but in a reserved manner (Swedes?). He'll never be the feisty type of captain that Doug Gilmour was, but I doubt that Mats will be losing the "C" any time soon.
 
An oldie...but a goodie!!

It's Game 7 of the Stanley Cup Final, and a man makes his way to his seat right at centre ice.

He sits down, noticing that the seat next to him is empty. He leans over and asks his neighbour if someone will be sitting there.

"No," says the neighbour. "The seat is empty."

"This is incredible", said the man. "Who in their right mind would have a seat like this for the Stanley Cup and not use it?"

The neighbour says "Well, actually, the seat belongs to me. I was supposed to come with my wife, but she passed away. This is the first Stanley Cup we haven't been to together since we got married in 1967."

"Oh ... I'm sorry to hear that. That's terrible. But couldn't you find someone else, a friend or relative, or even a neighbour to take the seat?"

The man shakes his head: "No. They're all at the funeral."
 
broke my heart

Hey Kathleen,
I like hearing your thoughts and usually agree with you 99% of the time regarding your views about the Leafs. However, I totally disagree with you taking the C away from Mats. Let me say I have always been upset with Mats as I think he is easily one of the top 5 players in the world and always proves that when he plays for Sweden. However, I believe it was the 2001 playoffs where Mats totally carried us. Toronto is a fickle city and I voiced my displeasure last year during the playoffs when people were talking about McCauly being a better centre that Mats and he would be our first line centre this year. True Mats is in a slump and has played to his fullest potential (considering he is a much bigger star in sweden than Forsberg) but he is one of the greatest leafs of all time and I think he has what it takes to lead our team. Roberts has been my favorite player ever since he was in Calgary and I think he and Nolan can both be great leaders in the dressing room without taking the c from mats.
 
Fiasco, I am not disputing your claim that Sundin is bigger in Sweden than Forsberg as I simply don't know. However, based on their career accomplishments, why would this be the case? Really, which of the two would you rather have at the respective starts of their careers? Forsberg has consistently been one of the top 3 all around players in the league.
 
Sundin National Hero

Pistol Pete,
In international play Sundin is always the best player on the ice for sweden even with Forsberg and Naslund in the lineup. I used to joke at work that we should change the leafs colours to blue and yellow and then watch Sundin shine. Hopefully he will display the same passion and play for toronto in the playoffs as he does for Sweden in international play.
 
Naslund is the best Swedish player in hockey right now. He's trying to be only the second Swedish player to score 50 goals in the NHL. The only other being Hakan Loob.

As for Naslund being the captain of the Canucks, it was Mark Messier who suggested it after Mark left.

As for trading Tucker, that would be a huge mistake. Who's coming the other way? Janne Niminaa?
 
Strip the

C off Sundin!

His heart will never bleed blue and white. Why would it? After this many seasons as a Leaf and him playing as well as he has, he still is not Toronto's favorite son. This city is the capital of hockey. And Sundin is soft and will never be a bud warrior.

Now for being realistic. Can you imagine the tension that would stir up if he lost his C? He'd be in the same gutter Linden was once in, and it would fuck the Leafs right up.
 
Enough!

How many times am I going to hear the same silly statements of take the C FROM MATS? For those of you who actually watch hockey (not just the leafs) you will remember a team named the Oilers who had a little bit of success with a none vocal none physical captain. I am not comparing Mats with Wayne simply stating that true leadership comes in many forms. The leafs have many leaders on this team some vocal some physical some with talent. Mogilny is not considered by many to be a leader but you are fooling yourself if you think he doesn't lead with his talent. Leadership is not always about fighting or yelling it is about control and consistency and Mats has both. There are many examples of successfull teams that did not have vocal captains. This team is loaded with leaders and if there was a problem with Mats as captain then you can be sure we would have heard rumblings from the players. But no one says boo because they know and respect Mats for every thing he brings to the table, even if we do not. If the players are cool with it then so am I. By the way how many parades done young street did Wendal have or Doug....... exactly! So does this mean they were not good captains, OF COURSE NOT. So cut the guy some slack, remember we could always go back to the days of Brian Bradley as our top center.

P.S. Kathleen if Gary Roberts wanted to be captain he would be, in his whole career he has not been, and he doesn't want it now.
 
Kariya

Kathleen said:


If you think soft player can lead.. then you tell me when Kariya will take the ducks to the promised land.

Kathleen

Hey Kathleen,

Please lay off Kariya. Thanks. ;) Sorry, I just think he's not the same after the Suter hit. But he's still a beaute to watch. It's too bad he plays on the West Coast.

BTW, a big Kariya fan.
 
Well this turned out to be in informal debate about Mats Sudin as captain. Here are the opinions regarding whether he should be captain of Maple Leafs:

Yes: ToronToto, widowmaker
No: Kathleen, fiasco
Undecided: Georgian, sjs (both?)

Kathleen: what do you think would happen to the Leafs in the post season if they ripped the C off Mats after tonite's game and pinned it on Roberts.

Firstly, I think the Toronto fans would be stunned and the guys would be dazed and confused. Maybe your idea would work for next season, but Roberts is too injury prone and is only committing for one more year anyways.
 
Mats is my captain

Hey Torontoto,
Even though I usually wouldnt argue being grouped together with Kathleen for Mats i must take a stand. I'm totally in the camp that Mats is and should be the captain of the leafs. I used to question Mats heart but havent in a few years. He carried us in playoffs 2 years ago playing on a line with Hoglund and Thomas I believe (that should say it all there). Yes he has a tendency to float at times but he'll be ready to go once the playoffs start and for the first time in toronto he gets to play with real wingers. Moreover, I was very impressed when he went down Yonge street after Canada won the gold and talked about how much he would love to win a cup in this city.

Congrats on your 1000th point Mats as I'm sure you're a devoted Terb lurker.