Overdrawn Pc Chequng Account Question For Experts

Razon said:
Yes they can get, R7 status and let me know what the goverment tells you when you cant open a bank account with the 5 major canadian banks. You can be blacklisted from associated banks. Other private banks may pick you up but they can limit your account any way they want, even if collections coems to them and asks them to garnish your account. This is for people who have gone through the whole consolodation process.

The following is from the Bank Act - Access to Basic Banking Regulations


"Refusal to open account

3. (1) Subject to subsection (2), subsection 448.1(1) of the Act does not apply in the following circumstances:

(a) if the member bank has reasonable grounds to believe that the retail deposit account will be used for illegal or fraudulent purposes;

(b) if the individual has a history of illegal or fraudulent activity in relation to providers of financial services and if the most recent instance of such activity occurred less than seven years before the day on which the request to open a retail deposit account is made;

(c) if the member bank has reasonable grounds to believe that the individual, for the purpose of opening the retail deposit account, knowingly made a material misrepresentation in the information provided to the member bank;

(d) if the member bank has reasonable grounds to believe that it is necessary to refuse to open the retail deposit account in order to protect the customers or employees of the member bank from physical harm, harassment or other abuse; or

(e) if the request is made at a branch or point of service of a member bank at which the only retail deposit accounts offered are those that are linked to an account at another financial institution.


Bankruptcy

(2) For greater certainty and for the purpose of paragraph (1)(a), the fact that the individual is or has been a bankrupt does not, by itself without any evidence of fraud or any other illegal activity in relation to the bankruptcy, constitute reasonable grounds for a member bank to believe that an account for the individual will be used for illegal or fraudulent purposes."


If a Bank refuses to open an account they are required to give you a reason why and how to contact the Financial Consumer Agency Of Canada. The banks take this very seriously.
 
To answer benns question, this is for my brother and I have lent him 500 so far.

Which bank is MSMB?

Thanks.

Razon said:
Well you just asnwered your question =) They want him to via bank draft or certified cheque. Tell him to call the PC number on the back of the card, he may have to make one payment with a cheque(if he has another account) if he dosnt have any other bank accounts, he can tell them that and they will re activate his card for deposits only.

Tell him to do this if he wants to save his ass. Because hes probably paying over 11% right? Call up MSMB and sign up for a credit card, right now, they offering 12 months no interest. Throw the whole balance on the card and tell him to make sure he pays the card off atleast 500 a month. It will get his cretid with the bank back up, and then the remaining $5000 he can throw it into a 9-10% Line of credit at the end of the year.
 
Purple:

I say this: why doesn't he just pay them the money he owes them? He knowingly deposited cheques that would be returned (don't even try to tell me he didn't know this because as the law states: ignorance is no excuse), he spent the money, now he has to pay them back. SIMPLE.

Tell him to either start paying them back (and if it is in fact only $2,000.00 that is nothing to pay back) or start selling assets in order to pay them back.

As stated, I bet if he went to the branch (and yes, PC does have branches in many Loblaws stores where you can talk to people directly) and arranged an unsecured loan, deposited the loan amount, and started making payments all is good and well.

And if he does own a car, and has some equity in it, he can use that as collateral for the loan....or other assets he may have.....
 
Razon's right. Back when I had 2 R9s, the Royal Bank refused to open an account based on my poor credit history.

dcbogey said:
A chartered bank in Canada cannot refuse to open an account if your credit is poor. They can refuse to grant you more credit but they cannot refuse to open a savings or chequing account. There are only a few reasons for them to (legally) not open an account for you.
 
Tihs sounds like overdrawn on a chequing account cause PC is silly enough to allow that - so there is no credit charge or monthly payment arranged. If they do accept you as a customer they can put limitations on your account - like any cheques deposited are held until fully cleared (5-10days).

Call PC and make some kind of arrangement to re-pay before it messes up you credit.
 
tboy said:
Purple:

I say this: why doesn't he just pay them the money he owes them? He knowingly deposited cheques that would be returned (don't even try to tell me he didn't know this because as the law states: ignorance is no excuse), he spent the money, now he has to pay them back. SIMPLE.

tboy, I agree with most of what you are saying, but I think the ignorance is no excuse bit needs some clarification. True, ignorance of the law is no defence, but depending on the action in question, there needs to be some intent to commit the action.

If his brother knew that there were insufficient funds to support the cheques, then claiming ignorance that it was illegal to kite cheques will not fly. However, if his brother can legitimately claim that he had no reason to believe that the cheques would bounce, then he does not have the requisite "guilty mind". It's the ignorance of the law itself, not just stupid ignorance in action, that is not a defence.

It can be a subtle point, and I hope I've been clear enough.
 
fuji said:
They cannot garnishee his wages at this point, but at some point they will be able to do that. To get to that stage they have to go to court and get a judgement against him. In the worst case they could force him into bankruptcy.

But...

He is willing to pay $500 per month, which is an acceptable repayment plan. For reference, if it were a line of credit they would demand only 3% per month and he is paying 5% so they should view that as acceptable. While they COULD go get that judgement they will probably CHOOSE to go along with a reasonable repayment plan if he proposes one and sticks to it. It's their choice, but they are in the business of banking, not in the business of filing lawsuits, so they would likely prefer a sensible plan to a lawsuit.

He needs to go and talk to them immediately and get them to AGREE to the repayment plan. They should becaues it is a reasonable one. His objective in this should be to secure a reasonable interest rate. No doubt right now they are charging him something like 22% per year interest. He should be able to negotiate 10% or 12%.

Best post of this entire thread! Contrary to what many of you have stated, banks have NO interest in suing people provided that a suitable repayment arrangement can be worked out! An unauthorized overdraft is just that...unauthorized. If the individual does not contact his FI (financial instituition) to make alternate repayment arrangements, then they WILL go after his income, assets, etc (assuming the amount is more than a couple of hundred dollars).

HOWEVER, if he does the responsible thing and approaches the FI, outlines what happened, and proposes a suitable restructuring of the outstanding amount, such as a personal loan over say 12-24 months, with fixed monthly payments, then the FI is much more likely to accept this solution than resorting to legal action. If he has tangible assets (such as a vehicle) which he can pledge as collateral to the loan, they will be even more receptive to his proposal.

Finally, assuming he does all of the above and makes all of his payments on time and as agreed, this will IMPROVE his credit rating, rather than damage it.

However, none of the above can happen unless and until HE initiates an open discussion with his FI.

* EXPERT OPINION* = 20 years in banking!
 
Updated

Hello everyone, so I talked to my brother this weekend about this and to tell you the truth I am a bit confused...here's what he said.

March 2008 : He called PC and they opened up this account for deposits only, so he deposited in total $2500 (I don't know how many transactions maybe 5x$500) all made in March.

April 2008: He tried to make another deposit only to tell him to call customer service, so he called and they told him the account is closed by the loss management department and the account has been "written-off for cause" <----don't know what WRITE-OFF FOR CAUSE means. They also said he has been sent to collections as of last week.

So really what does this mean? Does he pay? Does he forget about it and if he forgets about it is it only 7 years? I thought write-off is a write-off, why more collections?

I couldn't answer those questions for him, could you guy???
 
PurpleMonkey said:
Hello everyone, so I talked to my brother this weekend about this and to tell you the truth I am a bit confused...here's what he said.

March 2008 : He called PC and they opened up this account for deposits only, so he deposited in total $2500 (I don't know how many transactions maybe 5x$500) all made in March.

April 2008: He tried to make another deposit only to tell him to call customer service, so he called and they told him the account is closed by the loss management department and the account has been "written-off for cause" <----don't know what WRITE-OFF FOR CAUSE means. They also said he has been sent to collections as of last week.

So really what does this mean? Does he pay? Does he forget about it and if he forgets about it is it only 7 years? I thought write-off is a write-off, why more collections?

I couldn't answer those questions for him, could you guy???
Either he isn't tell you the whole story or he is lying. He should call a credit counselor, tell them them the truth/whole story and get advise.
 
hunter001 said:
Either he isn't tell you the whole story or he is lying. He should call a credit counselor, tell them them the truth/whole story and get advise.


I don't think he'll be lying, I know him very well....however I don't know what else in the story he might've left out that I haven't asked him. Those credit counselor guys I wouldn't trust to advise him because I think all they want is $$$$

I told him to just to forget it, nowadays everyone has bad credit and still drives mercedes and buys a house. The only thing that rung my bell was one person here mentioned a judgement or something like that after the "XYZ" inhouse collections transfers the debt over to another collections company....not sure if that would affect his situation since the account has been "written off"
 
PurpleMonkey said:
I don't think he'll be lying, I know him very well....however I don't know what else in the story he might've left out that I haven't asked him. Those credit counselor guys I wouldn't trust to advise him because I think all they want is $$$$

I told him to just to forget it, nowadays everyone has bad credit and still drives mercedes and buys a house. The only thing that rung my bell was one person here mentioned a judgement or something like that after the "XYZ" inhouse collections transfers the debt over to another collections company....not sure if that would affect his situation since the account has been "written off"
If it is a deposit only account what the hell are they collecting on? There has to be way more to the story.

Some credit counseling services are free.
 
PurpleMonkey said:
I don't think he'll be lying, I know him very well....however I don't know what else in the story he might've left out that I haven't asked him.

It sounds like your brother never negotiated anything with the bank, he just tried to make payments, without ever explaining to them what the plan was. That is my guess.

I would have expected a negotiated solution with the bank to take the form of a loan, against which he would have been making regular payments. Instead he had a "deposit only account", which was probably just his original account but locked so that he could only make deposits. He probably called the bank and said "unlock my account so I can pay back the money" without negotiating any kind of repayment plan.

They would then have been expecting full payment, and when they got only partial payment decided they had enough of your brother.

If that's the story honestly he brought this whole mess down on himself. Look at it from their point of view: A guy commits an act which looks a lot like fraud (he's lucky the police aren't involved) then promises to pay back the money but only pays back a fraction of it.

Those credit counselor guys I wouldn't trust to advise him because I think all they want is $$$$

There are some scammers out there for which that's true, that you should beware of. However there are many that are credible and reputable, and your brother sounds like he is in grave need of their services.

He plainly cannot manage money. Period.

I told him to just to forget it, nowadays everyone has bad credit and still drives mercedes and buys a house.

I don't think that's true. If you have bad credit then things like houses and cars become MUCH more expensive for you than they are for other people, because when you go to borrow money you get SCREWED on the rate. You wind up paying twice as much as everybody else does for the same house or car.

The only thing that rung my bell was one person here mentioned a judgement or something like that after the "XYZ" inhouse collections transfers the debt over to another collections company....not sure if that would affect his situation since the account has been "written off"

Certainly the situation has gone from bad to worse, having a debt sent to collection is much worse on your credit record than simply having a late or missed payment.

However don't think it can't get even worse. Having a judgement is worse than collections. Having a bankruptcy is worse than a judgement.

Your brother needs to deal with this ASAP, he has cost himself already by failing to do that, and he will cost himself even more if he doesn't deal with it now.
 
By the way, what "written off" means is that the bank has sold the debt to the collections agency. The bank has been paid some fraction on the dollar of what was owed, and the collector will now come after your brother for the money.

The collector earns a profit if he can get more out of your brother than he paid to the bank.
 
fuji said:
By the way, what "written off" means is that the bank has sold the debt to the collections agency. The bank has been paid some fraction on the dollar of what was owed, and the collector will now come after your brother for the money.

The collector earns a profit if he can get more out of your brother than he paid to the bank.


Thanks for the info. So for example, if the collection agency paid $2000 for the debt and my brother gave them $3000 they would be happy and get off his back?? --- He owed the bank $7000 before it was "written off" In other words, would the collection agency accept something lower than $7000, how can he start negotiating this with the agency (any TIPS to acheive this?), how would this reflect against his credit? Thanks a lot for the knowledge.

Oh yeah, and what point may a judgement be ordered against my brother? Would it be profitable for them to do this? (legal fees, etc) When people talk about garnishing wages, taking the assets how would they even know where you work now and what assets you have? <--this just came up last night when I was talking to him.
 
PurpleMonkey said:
He deposited a couple NSF cheques and took out the funds thinking they were available since the bank does not put a hold on his cheques (those visa cheques got reject because they were overlimit). He said it will take him over a year to pay back the money since he spent the money already.

So these were checks from a credit card and he took out the money before they cleared, and they ended up not clearing. I get it. Interesting. Hmmm. Then get the $$ from the credit card again and deposit it back in the bank.

He should have withdrawn $1 million, rather than a couple of thousand.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
PurpleMonkey said:
So for example, if the collection agency paid $2000 for the debt and my brother gave them $3000 they would be happy and get off his back??

They'll try and collect the full amount, and if they can't collect it, they'll do their level best to fuck up his credit. The bank plays nice. The collections agency is going to play hard ball. They lose 100% on some accounts so they can't be happy if they only break even on the ones they do collect from--to make a profit they have to collect as much as they can from everyone.

Right now his credit is not necessarily that bad. He's got a dispute, which is bad, and a late payment, which is bad, but if he repays the loan it's not THAT bad if he has other regular good payment history.

If he lets the whole thing go into default and the note goes on that it was not satisfactory resolved then his credit is really just one step better than a bankrupt at that point. So he still has a lot to lose by not paying his debt, but yeah, if he wants the credit record of a dead beat, and he's broke, with no viable income, he could probably negotiate a smaller payment.


Oh yeah, and what point may a judgement be ordered against my brother? Would it be profitable for them to do this? (legal fees, etc)

It has to go to a court, the legal fees don't have to be that much for them. They'd make more on the account NOT going to court.

They don't necessarily analyze this on a per-account basis, they make more profit overall by making an example out of a few individuals to scare the rest into complying. OVER ALL, it is profitable for collectors to make a few people's lives a living hell in order to convince a much larger number of people to pay up.


When people talk about garnishing wages, taking the assets how would they even know where you work now and what assets you have?

Several ways. First, a court will order your brother to disclose this information, and if he fails to disclose it, he can be jailed for contempt of court. Second, they'll be able to find anything reported to the credit bureaus, which will include a lot of his bank information. Third, a lot of things are on file--there's public documentation around home ownership, cars, and so on. Finally they may be able to get his employment information from CRA--not sure of the legaility of that. CRA may or may not co-operate.

Note that once they have your bank account information they can see whether you get any direct deposits from employers.

You'd have to ask a collector how they find this information out, but they're in the business of doing this, and they know their job pretty well.
 
Last edited:
Gee guys, thanks for the great feedback, I told my bro about all your insights.
Question: PC said they sent him to a collection agency last Monday april 14th, he isn't usually home during the day to receive phone calls so I don't think they will have any luck trying to reach him by phone so I think they'll send a letter, when do you think the letter should arrive and what would be in the letter - other words, would they give him options for payback, demand payback, or have a tel# for him to call and discuss.

He is really thinking about a repayment plan but wants it stretched out for 3 to 4 years for the $7K, will they let him? How and in what way should he approach them to discuss this (without offending them)? How will that affect his credit?

Thanks a lot guys!
 
PurpleMonkey said:
Gee guys, thanks for the great feedback, I told my bro about all your insights.
Question: PC said they sent him to a collection agency last Monday april 14th, he isn't usually home during the day to receive phone calls so I don't think they will have any luck trying to reach him by phone so I think they'll send a letter, when do you think the letter should arrive and what would be in the letter - other words, would they give him options for payback, demand payback, or have a tel# for him to call and discuss.

He is really thinking about a repayment plan but wants it stretched out for 3 to 4 years for the $7K, will they let him? How and in what way should he approach them to discuss this (without offending them)? How will that affect his credit?

Thanks a lot guys!

Don't worry, collection agents don't just work M-F 8-4, they'll be calling him evenings and weekends too.

As for how to ask, be polite and lay it out that you want to pay it back over several years. Then listen to what terms they will accept to do that for you. I'm sure that if he wants to drag it out for 3-4 years he can expect to pay some interest on it.
 
Seriously his best bet is to engage a credit counsellor. Some of them are free and reputable. I say this for two reasons:

1. They know how to negotiate these plans and what is reasonable

2. He plainly needs help beyond just this one bill, he needs to learn how to budget and plan his spending.

I mean step back a minute--he is in this mess because he originally wrote credit card cheques that bounced. Supposing they had cleared... if he really needs a few years to pay back the money WHAT THE FUCK WAS HE THINKING?

His problem isn't that the cheques bounced, his problem is that he wrote them in the first place, his credit problems are obviously deeper than just this one issue.

In specific answer to your question the collectors will start out with minimal effort and ratchet up if that does not work. They likely will just send a letter at first, and if he doesn't reply they will become more and more aggressive about it.
 
Another reason to get this settled: According to a friend of mine who's in the collection business: That 7 years to clear it off your record doesn't start counting from the time of the incident, it starts from the last time the collection agency deals with your file. Every time they contact you the clock starts over.