Outrageous comments by judge on rape case

stinkynuts

Super
Jan 4, 2005
8,939
3,220
113
http://www.cnn.com/2016/09/12/world/robin-camp-rape-comments-trnd/index.html

This judge must be removed. Immediately.


CNN)A judge in Canada is facing removal from the bench for his conduct when he asked a woman in a rape case why she couldn't "just keep [her] knees together."

Federal Court Judge Robin Camp is in the midst of a week-long judicial council hearing, which will determine whether he ought to be booted from his position.
The case in question took place in 2014 when Camp was a provincial court judge. (He became a Federal Judge last year.)
The 19-year-old woman said she was raped over a bathroom sink during a house party.
According to records of the trial, Camp asked her why she didn't "skew her pelvis" or push her bottom into the sink to avoid penetration. He openly wondered, "Why couldn't you just keep your knees together?"
On the subject of sex in general, and sex with young women in particular, he said, "Young wom[e]n want to have sex, particularly if they're drunk."
In a different part of the trial, he said "Some sex and pain sometimes go together...that's not necessarily a bad thing."
Camp, 64, ultimately acquitted the man charged with the crime, and then told him:
"I want you to tell your friends, your male friends, that they have to be far more gentle with women. They have to be far more patient. And they have to be very careful. To protect themselves, they have to be very careful."
The verdict was overturned on appeal. A new trial is scheduled for November.
'Minimal' knowledge of Canadian law
These and other moments from the trial led the Canadian Judicial Council to open its investigation.
Camp, the council said, "engaged in stereotypical or biased thinking in relation to a sexual assault complainant."
Testifying at the hearing Friday, Camp offered this defense for his comments: "a non-existent" knowledge of Canadian criminal law.
The South African-born judge said he didn't receive training on sex assault cases. In his legal career, he focused mostly on contract and bankruptcy cases, he said.
"My colleagues knew my knowledge of Canadian law was very minimal. It was non-existent," he said at the hearing Friday. "Please remember I wasn't in this country through the 1960s, '70s and '80s."
He also apologized to the woman for his comments, calling them "rude and insulting."
The scrutiny he's already faced
It hasn't taken a full two years for people to notice Camp's off-color comments. According to a Notice of Response from the judicial council, Camp has undergone sensitivity training and has apologized publicly several times.
"[Camp] has undergone counseling and training with [a] Superior Court Justice...with a psychologist... and with an expert on the law of sexual assault...with a view to interrogating his beliefs and improving his understanding of the law, the social context of sexual violence and the psychological impact of sexual assault," the notice reads.
After the hearing Monday, the panel will send its recommendation about Camp's future to the full Canadian Judicial Council.
 
I can see his point. He's a Bay Street lawyer who specialized in business law. He was closeted in a male-dominated, Right Wing, ultra conservative Bay Street environment. He is probably brilliant at bankruptcy distribution cases.

One day, the criminal trial specialist judge calls in sick and the chief judge parachutes Camp into a high profile rape trial. Camp believes he knows it all. He's a judge, after all. And everybody loves him in Bankruptcy Court where he tells all the millionaire creditors how many cents on the dollar each is going to get. So he gifts counsel, the cops and the spectators with 50 years of Bay Street squash club insight into "what women really want" - and believes he's done a marvelous job. Of course, it's a disaster and his career is probably wrecked.
 
Remove him - it's a judge who has the ability to destroy people's lives. If you need sensitivity training - you shouldn't be a judge. The position of judge shouldn't be looked as an ongoing training session. Is any rape victim going to feel comfortable in his courtroom ? Is any accused going to fear a pendulum that will swing hard against him just because the judge has something to prove. ?

I am not even sure why there a debate with his comments on the court record.
 
This guy clearly is not fit to be a judge in any criminal proceedings. Now we know the main reason why judges in the US are elected, not appointed.
 
You nailed it oagre, except one would think that you'd know better, as an educated man. He certainly demonstrated his lack of acumen and a complete lack of real intelligence that should be common sense in this day and age.

His taking sensitivity classes and now "educating" himself on such matters is an even bigger faux pas, as he tries to keep his job. I'm with K Douglas, he should lose his job and be forced to make a real public apology to this woman and pay a "fine" that goes to a woman's shelter.
 
Didn't realize you needed training to know the difference between rape and consensual sex. This judge is an absolute disgrace and should be taken off the bench immediately. What a dick
 
The sensitivity training might work, but it's too late. His judgments will always be tainted by this story so he's a liability and should retire.