Osteopathy and Naturopathy

I think this gets close to the heart of the matter.

What I think is that anything that hasn't been properly tested (using statistically valid methodology) is just unknown...and potentially risky. Most of the time probably more or less harmless, but there could easily be huge problems with some of these alternative remedies and there is no way of ever knowing. And, for the most part most of these alternative treatments are also ineffective...or else they would have been made into a drug treatment long ago.

Have there been mistakes with registering drugs that should never have been approved? Absolutely. Sometimes the testing was not adequate, etc. Doesn't mean that I then need to rely on something with no legitimate scientific evaluation.

If so called "alternative medicine" set up proper scientific testing and peer review of same then they too could verify safety and effectiveness. But as soon as they do this it is no longer "alternative".

Being critical of current drug research and approval processes is one thing. But to say that the alternative is to have no research and approval is the solution is dangerous and not good.

The arguement that some of these remedies are thousands of years old, etc. is also silly. It's still a crap shoot...you can kill rinocerous for their horns to treat impotence...and you can find aspirin in willow leaves...all based on ancient remedies. It takes some sort of science to sort out which is which. And until all of these alternatives have to present peer reviewed scientific evidence I thing they should not be publicly supported in any way.

Actually, the problem is calling any of it "alternative". It's a function of language and the way we think.

It's better to say "therapies studied by science", and those that are not.

The robot brainwashed then bark about the dangers of these therapies "not studied by science" while ignoring those that have been studied, but are killing people anyway...because it's not just about science, but about power, marketing and deep suspicions of "the other".

I have already said I believe in Science, and most "rational" people do, however, I also am intellectually and spiritually curious enough to venture out into "unstudied" therapies and have had shitty, surreal and genuinely healing effects from these things. In my case, mainstream medicine was an utter failure for all of the things that ailed me. I'll say again, though, that mainstream medicine saved me a few times. So it's not a contest between one system or the other.

Also, another thing to shake your certainty about Science: There are many common therapies which mainstream medicine uses, such as skin testing for allergies, and many, many kinds of chemotherapy and radiation (etc) which have miserable science behind them, but we use them anyway. Why? Well, depends on your worldview, but in many cases it's money, others it's inertia, and in a few others, just plain voodoo.

I find myself tiring of educating people on the same false issues over and over. Suffice it to say that if you are happy in a pill-based culture, which is a direct descendent of the mechanized medicine of Rene Descartes and his man-as-machine model, go crazy. I suspect if your father or mother is killed by a prescription drug or many of its horrific side effects, you might wonder if there are alternatives, which there always are. (Whether people will use them is not the issue. In most cases, doctors don't even tell them about them.)

If you're happy getting a liver transplant, and when you die after a year or so because of high incidences of failure or rejection of transplanted organs, you might wonder if there was a better way, say a model of prevention, in which your liver wasn't just functioning or not, but on a continuum between two poles, that diet and herbs and acupuncture could have helped to avoid the transplant in the first place. In the mainstream model, your liver is either dead or alive. No in between. No magical herbs or dietary changes that might make a difference? Google silymarin, which has a little science behind it (not enough) but has enormous anecdotal data for liver regeneration. The Russians have used it for centuries to restore vodka-destroyed livers. Not kidding.

Or when you had terrible psoriasis on your hands, for which doctors routinely and blindly offer powerful steroids with equally powerful side effects, you might wonder if there were some less invasive "alternatives", such as an anti-inflammatory diet and Chinese medicine.

Or when you spend a grand or two getting fitted for a mask for your sleep apnea because your doc tells you that's what you should do (ka-ching), when, if only most people actually knew that losing as little as ten pounds, cutting drinking and smoking can eliminate 50% of cases without any cost involved. Not saying people will do those things, just saying most docs will never tell you that.

Or getting a brace for teeth grinding and wearing the stupid thing every night, when simple supplementation and reducing caffeine can do it simply and naturally.

And so on.

Have there been mistakes with registering drugs that should never have been approved? Absolutely. Sometimes the testing was not adequate, etc. Doesn't mean that I then need to rely on something with no legitimate scientific evaluation.

This is utterly silly. If your Mother died from Vioxx, which as I mentioned killed something like 60,000 people, wouldn't you have liked to know about Zyflamend, or any other "natural" (as in "not isolated to toxic effect") supplement or dietary therapy that don't result in people dying?

What part of that was a "mistake?" The drug companies, in this case and many others, routinely lie and deceive the public about the, ah, adverse effects, while they march to the bank. Most people would be forgiving of "mistakes", a) as long as it didn't involve someone they loved, ha, and b) if there wasn't a continuous rotten history of "mistakes" followed by pay offs, silencing, and character assassination of whistle blowers.

Some might say, well, if we incorporated these "UNPROVEN" therapies, it would be a lot worse. Really? In this day and age, with the power of the internet and 24 hour news cycles? A new therapy which killed people would be removed LIKE THAT (finger snap). But prescription drugs, many forms of chemo and radiation which have miserable science behind them, kill and maim in massive, holocaust-like numbers and it rarely makes the evening news.

A sense of proportion would be nice as a first step. Second step might be to study the real differences between "natural remedies" and drug therapies, and stop thinking that the collective healing wisdom of our vast planet is collected under the tiny umbrella of "scientifically proven therapies". Get real.
 
Actually, the problem is calling any of it "alternative". It's a function of language and the way we think.

It's better to say "therapies studied by science", and those that are not.
Give me the ones that have been studied every single time. They might not always work but your percentages are always, always, always going to be higher than trying something that hasn't been studied. If it hasn't been studied, then, by definition, you are guessing.

A sense of proportion would be nice as a first step. Second step might be to study the real differences between "natural remedies" and drug therapies
The real difference is that studied, tested therapies will be efficacious much more frequently.


and stop thinking that the collective healing wisdom of our vast planet is collected under the tiny umbrella of "scientifically proven therapies". Get real.
And which umbrella is larger than the "tiny" one provided by science? None. Name one discipline that has more knowledge.

And historically, no umbrella has provided more consistent protection.

And those statements are "real" true.