Oscar Pistorius - Guilty or Not Guilty ?

Guity or Not Guilty?

  • Guilty

    Votes: 60 84.5%
  • Not Guilty

    Votes: 6 8.5%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 5 7.0%

  • Total voters
    71
In J'burg, the chances of any intruder is in your home to steel a cup of sugar is near ZERO. They are there to do serious hurt, physically, financially, or emotionally.

Thanks for clarifying the context. Good to know.

Still, it was absolutely stupid to use lethal force knowing that someone else was in the house and NOT positively identifying the supposed bad guy before firing. If not pre-meditated, he was at least negligent.
 
Thanks for clarifying the context. Good to know.

Still, it was absolutely stupid to use lethal force knowing that someone else was in the house and NOT positively identifying the supposed bad guy before firing. If not pre-meditated, he was at least negligent.

There are nearly 50 murders 'a day' in J'burg. Chicago has ~2 murders a day.
 
Break-ins are much more common in South Africa than in Canada, and often these break-ins happen with a great deal of brutality.

Ladies and gentlemen of the terb jury ..... the defense would have you believe that the death of Steenkamp cowering in a locked bathroom is just a tragic result of arming a coward with a gun in a country with a higher incidence of break-ins than Canada. The only relevance that burglary has over the possibility that a space alien was trapped in the bathroom is that burglary is a more believable fabricated lie to explain a cold blooded murder.

As you study the Pistorius lie, the fabricated layers of deceit start to fall aside revealing the naked truth that this was a cold premeditated assassination of a beautiful, terrified and totally helpless girl. The Pistorius lie begins with going to bed at 10 pm in order to set up the premise that it was much later in a darken environment that events unfolded. A Lie ! Stomach contents prove that Steenkamp ate after 1 AM just two hours before her murder. With the normal time line after a meal and retiring to the bedroom - the arguing heard from three independent (and unshakable) witnesses must compel us to listen to the facts and not the unsubstantiated fantasy spun by this coward!

The Pistorius lie continues with the story that he dragged himself around to the entrance of the bathroom and shot directly into the bathroom door in a sheer panic of an unknown killer hiding behind it. But the ballistics evidence shows that he came into the bathroom, moved past the door into an almost adjacent firing position and then fired directly in to an area that a sitting person would occupy. This is not the action of a terrified coward, this is the action of a cold calculating coward who has nothing to fear from moving away from the entrance and positioning himself to carry out the premeditated murder of a girl who he couldn't have.

Burglary, space invasion, in the end none of these fantasies have any relevance in this heartless, savage shooting of a helpless girl.

Yours truly, Hamilton Burger
 
This is what really pisses me off about you guys... :mad:

Except for some isolated reports, no one has heard all the evidence to date; the case is long way from over; Pistorius has not yet given evidence...
Yet we already have very strong opinions and verdicts... :rolleyes:

Geez!

Is that what you would want from others if it were you on trial? Does the presumption of innocence mean anything to you? Does hearing ALL the evidence and arguments mean nothing?
I am not saying he is innocent. I just don't know, and can't begin to form an opinion until all the evidence is in.
Perry
Good grief, calm down! This is just an inter web forum for god's sake, don't take yourself too seriously
OP wanted to know what we all thought after TWO weeks of deliberation, that's all. Of course we haven't heard the whole story. Maybe some of these opinions will change once we hear him out.
Why don't you make a poll yourself, after all sides have testified? We can do a before and after poll. K? Thx. Bye.
 
You're so full of shit!!! That would mean 18,250 murders per year.
In 2011 Johannesburg only had 1,186 murders.

See here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_murder_rate

Are you trying to tell us they suddenly had 17 thousand more murders in 2012 or 2013??

My bad, like you've never made a mistake, that's 18,000 a year in the country. An extra zero was added. Nice to see you occasionally pull your head out of your ass to actually read something.
 
He killed her- this is not the question. A guy with no legs in a place like south africa(that is much rougher than canada) needs to protect himself. Him being legless and trigger happy is no surprise. The fact is we cant know any other truth than the one he tells. She cannot contradict him. What kind of guy knowingly kills his girlfriend in his own bathroom, where he knows he will look guilty? if its premeditated- he is retarded. Otherwise there is some credibility to his story. We will have to see what evidence comes out in the next weeks.
 
He killed her- this is not the question. A guy with no legs in a place like south africa(that is much rougher than canada) needs to protect himself. Him being legless and trigger happy is no surprise. The fact is we cant know any other truth than the one he tells. She cannot contradict him. What kind of guy knowingly kills his girlfriend in his own bathroom, where he knows he will look guilty?
A guy with a quick temper, a gun, and a handicap he can use to claim he felt like his life was being threatened by an intruder. THAT kind of guy.
 
GUILTY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Who would have to be a complete fuckin' moron to believe this scumbag's version of events.
 
I still don't get it. Why kill her?
She was his girlfriend he wasn't like married to her with kids where she was divorcing him and taking him to the cleaners financially.

The guy has fame and money. I'm sure get's pussy.
Why not just break-up with her and go your separate ways and start banging other super hot chicks?
 
I still don't get it. Why kill her?
She was his girlfriend he wasn't like married to her with kids where she was divorcing him and taking him to the cleaners financially.

The guy has fame and money. I'm sure get's pussy.
Why not just break-up with her and go your separate ways and start banging other super hot chicks?

Why not ask O.J. ?

Some people are spoiled with a hot temper and do not accept rejection well.
 
Why not ask O.J. ?

Some people are spoiled with a hot temper and do not accept rejection well.
That is probablty true - this guy is so fucked up, his whole family supports a murderer. To my knowledge they are all behind him. He is guilty and all the facts point to it...a beautiful, intelligent woman had an argument with him, she tried to escape his rage, locked herself in the ensuite, she was trapped, shot multiple times with explosive bullets with thought of where to aim and that is somehow an intruder? What about the cricket bat...? The evidence will come out...just hope justice is served for that poor woman.
 
That is probablty true - this guy is so fucked up, his whole family supports a murderer. To my knowledge they are all behind him. He is guilty and all the facts point to it...a beautiful, intelligent woman had an argument with him, she tried to escape his rage, locked herself in the ensuite, she was trapped, shot multiple times with explosive bullets with thought of where to aim and that is somehow an intruder? What about the cricket bat...? The evidence will come out...just hope justice is served for that poor woman.

Yes, I hope he get punished to the full extent of the law. Shooting at a poor girl, who locked herself into the bathroom to escape from him. He should expect no mercy.