Oracle skewers Google as Android trial opens

onthebottom

Never Been Justly Banned
Jan 10, 2002
40,880
197
63
Hooterville
www.scubadiving.com
This should be popcorn worthy....

Oracle skewers Google as Android trial opens

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Oracle began Monday trying to convince a jury that Google's top executives have long known that they stole a key piece of technology to build the Android software that now powers more than more than 300 million smartphones and tablet computers.

The unflattering portrait of Google Inc. was drawn by Oracle lawyer Michael Jacobs in the opening phase of a complex trial pitting two Silicon Valley powerhouses in a battle delving into the often mind-numbing minutiae of intellectual property and computer coding.

"We will prove to you from beginning to end ... that Google knew it was using someone else's property," Jacobs said near the end of his hour-long opening statement.

Google's lawyers will counter with their opening statements Tuesday.

The showdown in a San Francisco federal court centers on Oracle's allegations that Google's Android software infringes on the patents and copyrights of Java, a programming technology that Sun Microsystems began developing 20 years ago.

Oracle Corp., a business software maker based in Redwood Shores, acquired the rights to Java when it bought Sun Microsystems for $7.3 billion in January 2010.

Google Inc., the Mountain View-based Internet search leader, has steadfastly denied Oracle's allegations since the lawsuit was filed seven months after the Sun deal closed.

The impasse has left it to a 12-member jury to resolve the dispute in a trial scheduled to last as long as 10 weeks. U.S. District Judge William Alsup devoted most of Monday's session to picking the jury, leaving only enough time for Oracle to lay out the framework for its case.

Oracle is seeking hundreds of millions of dollars in damages and an injunction that would force Google to pay future licensing fees or find an alternative to Java to keep its Android system running smoothly.

At one point in the lawsuit, Oracle estimated it might be owed as much as $6.1 billion. But Alsup has whittled the case down in a way that has substantially lowered the size of the potential payout if Google loses.

In a sign of how far apart the two sides are, Google last month said it would be willing to pay $2.8 million plus a tiny percentage of its future revenue if the jury decides Android infringed on two Java patents. Google hasn't publicly estimated what it thinks its liability might be if the jury decides Android violated 37 Java programming copyrights as alleged by Oracle.

The copyright disagreement — the most important point of the case — will be covered in the first phase of the trial followed by the patent dispute. If necessary, a third phase will be devoted to how much money Google owes Oracle.

Much of the evidence presented during the trial will delve into highly technical fare likely only to appeal to programming geeks and patent-law aficionados. However, there may be dramatic interludes that lift a veil on the inner workings of two of the world's most influential technology companies.

The intrigue will include testimony from the two companies' multibillionaire CEOs, Oracle's Larry Ellison and Google's Larry Page. Oracle indicated on Monday that it could call Ellison to the stand as early as Tuesday.

Several other industry luminaries, including former Google CEO Eric Schmidt and former Sun Microsystems CEO Jonathan Schwartz, are also on the list of potential witnesses.

Jacobs focused much of his opening statement on excerpts in internal emails that suggest Google knew it needed to pay licensing fees to use some of the Java technology that went into Android, a project that began in earnest in 2005 when Google bought a startup run by Andy Rubin. The first phone running on Android software didn't go on sale until October 2008, about 15 months before Oracle bought Sun Microsystems and stepped up the attempts to make Google pay up for the Java technology.

Oracle cited an October 2005 email from Rubin to Page as an early sign that Google realized it probably would have to pay Sun for using Java in Android.

"My proposal is that we take a license that specifically grants the right for us to Open Source our product," Rubin wrote.

Jacobs pointed to a May 2006 email from Schmidt to Rubin as an indication that Google knew it might need to seek other solutions for Android if it couldn't work out an agreement with Sun.

"How are we doing on the Sun deal?" Schmidt asked in his message. "Its (sic) it time to develop a non-Java solution to avoid dealing with them?"

By August 2010, Google still hadn't been able to find any satisfactory alternatives to Java, according to an email that Google engineer Tim Lindholm sent to Rubin.

"We have been over a bunch of these, and think they all suck," wrote Lindholm, who worked at Sun Microsystems before joining Google. "We conclude that we need to negotiate a license for Java under the terms we need."

The lack of a licensing agreement ultimately didn't deter Google, Jacobs told the jury, because the company realized it needed a mobile software system to preserve its digital search-and-advertising empire as more sophisticated phones enabled more people to surf the Internet while they were away from their desktop computers. Java provided Google with a springboard into mobile computing because 6 million software programmers were already familiar with the technology and could easily create applications that would run on Android, Jacobs said.

Although Google doesn't charge device makers to use Android, the company makes money from some of the mobile advertising and mobile applications sold on the system. Google has said its mobile advertising revenue now exceeds $2.5 billion, but it hasn't specified how much of that money comes from Android-powered devices.
 
Someone is bound to buy RIM (and make a bad decision)...

Oracle pondered buying RIM, Palm in phone move: CEO

SAN FRANCISCO | Tue Apr 17, 2012 2:13pm EDT
(Reuters) - Oracle Corp Chief Executive Larry Ellison said the software maker had considered building its own smartphone to compete with Apple Inc and Google Inc, but decided it was a "bad idea" after a weeks-long cost and market analysis.

As part of that exhaustive internal analysis, he said, Oracle had pondered at one point buying Blackberry-maker Research in Motion Ltd and Palm -- a smartphone maker scooped up by Hewlett Packard Co.

On the second day of a legal battle between Oracle and Google over Java patents used in Android mobile software, Ellison added that Oracle felt it lacked in-house expertise on smartphones and hence considered acquisitions. But it ultimately decided to abandon the idea.
 
Larry Page Says Android Not Critical to Google

During questioning by attorney David Boies on Wednesday, Google CEO Larry Page claimed that the Android operating system isn’t critical to Google’s future. The comment came during testimony in Oracle’s copyright infringement lawsuit against Google. Oracle, which bought Java-creator Sun Micrososystems in 2009, has accused Google of copying Java APIs in the Android operating system without a license.



Oracle CEO and Larry Page have both testified in the case, with Mr. Page taking the stand starting on Tuesday. That session didn’t last long before Judge William Alsup—who oversaw Apple’s copyright case against would-be Mac cloner Psystar—adjourned court for the day.

On Wednesday, however, Larry Page faced off against David Boies, Oracle’s lead attorney on the case. Another blast from the tech past, David Boies was the lead attorney in the U.S.’s antitrust trial against Microsoft. That case resulted in a court-ordered breakup of Microsoft, a remedy that was subsequently thrown out on appeal, after Mr. Boies was no longer on the case.

According to ZDNet, Mr. Page spent much of his time on the stand not directly answering questions, earning admonishments from Judge Alsup to be more direct in the process. An example of one exchange between the judge, Mr. Page, and Mr. Boies.

Boies: This is a yes or no question. Mr. Page, do you, from your own personal knowledge and experience in the industry, know that Sun wanted to avoid fragmentation of the Java platform?
Page: I think they wanted to patrol the Java platform.
Judge Alsup: You can answer that question “yes” or “no,” please. You can say “yes” or “no,” and give an explanation, or say “I don’t know.”
Page: I’m sorry. Repeat the exact question.
Boies: I’ll try, your honor. Do you know, sir, from your own personal knowledge and experience in the industry that Sun wanted to avoid fragmentation of the Java platform?
Page: Now or previously?
Boies: Let me break it up. Did you know, in 2005, from your own personal knowledge and experience in the industry that Sun wanted to avoid fragmentation of the Java platform?
Page: Um, yes, subject to patrol and other things I mentioned.


According to USA Today, Mr. Page also claimed not to know Google’s policies for copying intellectual property owned by other companies. ZDNet noted that he wasn’t sure whether or not he knew an advisor working for Google named Tim Lindholm, or if he recognized documents being presented by Oracle as internal Google documents.

It was another topic, however, that we found most interesting. CNBC reported that Mr. Page acknowledged that Android was important to Google, but disputed the notion that it was critical to his company’s future.

This, despite the fact that Google purchased Motorola Mobility for US$12.5 billion, a move that was widely seen as an effort to boost intellectual property protection of Android with Moto’s extensive patent portfolio. Android has been positioned from the get-go as Google’s tool for having access to mobile data and user information, information that it uses to sell mobile ads.

“Computing is moving onto mobile,” Mr. Page told The New York Times in an interview at the time of the Moto acquisition. “Even if I have a computer next to me, I’ll still be on my mobile device.”

Mr. Page has technically finished with his testimony, but was placed on recall by Oracle’s attorneys pending their ability to find someone who can independently identify a document Mr. Page said he couldn’t identify.
 
Does all this give ya a Joy Boner???......
08.gif
 
The kleptomaniac on the stand....

Oracle confronts Google's Schmidt about Java

SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Google's former CEO told jurors that he was confident that the Android smartphone platform was developed legally, and that top executives at Sun Microsystems did not object to the project now at the center of a high-stakes court battle.

Eric Schmidt, now Google's executive chairman, took the stand on Tuesday in the trial of Oracle against Google over smartphone technology.

Oracle, which acquired Sun in 2010, sued Google in August 2010, saying Android infringed on its copyrights and patents for the Java programming language. Google countered that it does not violate Oracle's patents and that Oracle cannot copyright certain parts of Java, an open-source, or publicly available, software language.

In court on Tuesday, Oracle attorney David Boies showed Schmidt a 2005 presentation to Google's top managers that said Google "must" take a license from Sun. Schmidt said he could not recall being told that was the case.

Schmidt said at one point that Google derived enough advertising revenue from Android to fund the operating system and a "whole bunch" more.

"The goal was to get as many users as we could on a powerful new platform that could exploit the Web," Schmidt said of Android.

Unlike current Google CEO Larry Page who testified last week, Schmidt appeared much more at ease while parrying questions from Boies about the development of Android.

At one point, Schmidt asked Boies to repeat a question, saying he wanted to be sure he answered it truthfully.

"I want you to answer truthfully," Boies said, prompting Schmidt to laugh.

Schmidt was Oracle's final witness before Oracle rested its copyright case on Tuesday morning - and Google then called him as its first defense witness.

Under questioning from Google attorney Robert Van Nest, Schmidt said Sun wanted roughly $30 million to $50 million in 2006 to jointly develop a mobile platform with Google. Such a deal would have saved Google time in getting Android to market, Schmidt said.

"We would have paid that simply to resolve it," Schmidt said.

However, negotiations between the two companies faltered. Android chief Andy Rubin later testified that while Google wanted to make the software platform open source, Sun wanted to impose restrictions to which Google was opposed.

After Google developed Android on its own and announced it at the end of 2007, Schmidt said he had multiple meetings with Sun Chief Executive Jonathan Schwartz, who never expressed any disapproval about Android.

Google has argued that Oracle launched the lawsuit only after Oracle decided it would be unable to develop a smartphone on its own.

The trial, expected to last at least eight weeks, has been divided into three phases: copyright liability, patent claims, and damages.

Early in the case, estimates of potential damages against Google ran as high as $6.1 billion. But Google successfully narrowed Oracle's patent claims and reduced the possible award. Oracle is seeking roughly $1 billion in copyright damages.

The jury will deliberate on copyright liability before moving on to hear evidence about patent infringement. U.S. District Judge William Alsup may also decide some of the copyright issues.

The case in U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, is Oracle America, Inc v. Google Inc, 10-3561.
 
ok stupid question here, I haven't read the stats.

Why doesn't google just buy 1/2 of oracle and fire all the dumb fucks at oracle.

Oracle does nothing well anymore, so now they are patent trolling?

They don't do anything well anymore? Surely, you jest.

They are one of the best enterprise software companies out there.
 
I don't jest, they are old, severely over priced, have really shitty business ethics and they have no unified solution on anything. Its a database company turned patent troll.

That's a bit silly, how many patent cases has Oracle filed.....

Other than that, you can check their performance, it's a very strong firm....

OTB
 
How many....lol....lets see... Alcatel....SAP...NetApp
and let us not forget this one against Google.

I'm not interested in stock performance, its ethics, and for that their record is poor.

The SAP suite was not a patent suite, SAP had stolen some Oracle's code so they could support Oracle clients.... SAP got nailed to the wall on that one.

I thought the Alcatel was a counter suit that they settled.... but it was a few years ago and I don't really track it.

As for Netapp, they sued Sun I believe.... a storage thing I think....

So I think you're down to two, Google over Java and Alcatel... not much of a patent trolling history...

OTB
 
Since when does history = troll?
It takes once to be a troll.
Oracle is trying a backhanded cash grab and I hope they get slaughtered by Google.

Nice back peddle......

I wouldn't get your hopes up, I'm betting on Google losing this one - not that I think there will be that much cash grabbing.
 
Oracle-Google trial puts ex-Sun execs on opposite sides

Former Sun CEO Jonathan Schwartz sided with Google in its court battle with Oracle, while Sun co-founder Scott McNealy and Java father James Gosling believe that Google infringed on Sun's intellectual property. Who is right?


8 comments
Facebook115
Twitter154
Linked In37
More

Last updated**August 29, 3:30 AM PT,**with a correction on Java inventor James Gosling's view on the suit, and an additional quote from former Sun chief open source officer Simon Phipps.**

In the two weeks that the Oracle v. Google trial has been under way, it's become clear that Sun's top executives weren't unified in their thinking about whether Java could be used without a license from the company.

Oracle, which acquired Sun and the Java brand in January 2010, contends that Google's Android mobile platform infringed on intellectual property related to Java APIs (Application Programming Interfaces) and two patents.

Former Sun CEO Jonathan Schwartz, testifying for the defense on Thursday,**stated that Java APIs**were not considered proprietary or protected by Sun, as long as Google didn't use the Java name for its Android platform.

Schwartz said that Sun wasn't pleased about Google circumventing Sun's Java licensing and maintaining compatibility with its version, and several Sun executives expressed their displeasure with Google.

In a March 8, 2007 email to Schwartz, Sun co-founder and Chairman Scott McNealy wrote: "The Google thing is really a pain. They are immune to copyright laws, good citizenship, they dont share. They dont even call back."

A year later, Vineet Gupta, chief strategy and technology officer of Sun's OEM software systems engineering, mentioned bringing out the "IP hammer" on Google:

So either we find way to work together or they become our biggest competition with Android with our Java ecosystem as part of it- and all points provided for free with Googles ad engine apps and control obviously and we fight thru Suns Java/JavaFX/App Store and loose alliance of OEMs/SPs Then of course there is the IP/Patents hammer..
Despite the complaints from Sun executives, Schwartz maintained in his testimony that as long as Google didn't brand Android as "Java" in any way, there was nothing, from his perspective, that Sun could do to bring Google into the alignment Sun wanted.**

"We saw a handset bypass our brand and licensing restrictions...we decided to grit our teeth and support it so anyone supporting it would see us as part of the value chain," he testified.

McNealy, testifying for Oracle also on Thursday, contradicted Schwartz's testimony. He stated that Java was "extremely valuable" to Sun and that it involved "lots of intellectual property." In response to Oracle lawyer David Boies' question regarding whether it was ever Sun's policy to allow any company to implement an incompatible version of Java so long as they didn't call it Java,**McNealy**told the court, "I don't recall that was ever a strategy that we pursued nor allowed in the marketplace."**

"Open source or open standards doesn't mean 'Let's throw it over the transom,'" McNealy testified. "That's a big difference."

Yet, in the five years that Google was developing Android and talking partnership and licensing with Sun, long after phones based on the platform were in the market and after years of internal discussions at Sun including IP hammers, **Sun didn't file any patent or copyright claims against Google. It**wasn't until Oracle acquired Sun that the lawsuit against Google was launched.

Full coverage: Oracle v. Google

The father of Java, James Gosling, feared that Oracle was going to take Google to court over its use of Java, and he didn't like it. addressed the topic a post on his blog,**Gosling wrote:

The sh*t finally hits the fan.... Thursday August 12, 2010

Oracle finally filed a patent lawsuit against Google. Not a big surprise. During the integration meetings between Sun and Oracle where we were being grilled about the patent situation between Sun and Google, we could see the Oracle lawyer's eyes sparkle. Filing patent suits was never in Sun's genetic code. Alas....

I incorrectly stated his position as opposing Oracle's legal action against Google. He contacted me and pointed to a**recent post to his blog**in which he stated that Google "totally slimed Sun":

Just because Sun didn't have patent suits in our genetic code doesn't mean we didn't feel wronged. While I have differences with Oracle, in this case they are in the right. Google totally slimed Sun. We were all really disturbed, even Jonathan: he just decided to put on a happy face and tried to turn lemons into lemonade.
The Sun culture, similar in many ways to Google's in its engineering esprit de corps, pioneered open source and sharing code. The tension behind the practical business side and the more idealistic engineering is in evidence in the differing views of McNealy and Schwartz. However, Gosling, a legendary software engineer, shares McNealy's view on Oracle's claims against Google, and noted Sun's "genetic" reluctance to filing patent suits. In 2001 Sun**settled a suit against Microsoft**involving Java for $20 million, and in 2004**Sun settled a patent and antitrust suit**against Microsoft that came with a $1.95 billion payment to Sun.

Oracle's view that Java APIs are copyrightable isn't highly popular among staunch open source advocates.**Simon Phipps, the former chief open source officer at Sun, **wrote:

If Oracle wins, the decision could set a legal precedent that legitimizes controlling behaviors by platform vendors -- and introduces a complex and unwelcome legalism into software development. Header files and function prototypes would need copyright statements and corresponding copyright licenses. Open source developers would need to check that the open source license on header files they were using was compatible with the open source license on their software. Corporate developers would receive instructions from their legal departments not to use GPL headers for fear of the license terms becoming applicable to corporate software. Complexity and confusion would return to a world where they have largely been expunged, bringing fear, uncertainty, and doubt back into open source software development.
Whether Google or Oracle **prevails in this copyright infringement phase of the trial is soon up to the judge and jury, which will hear the closing statements from each side early next week.**