olivia chow

Downtown people won't use the DRL. It's for people who work downtown but live in Scarborough. I live downtown, I don't need a subway to get me where I already am.

Faaaaar more Scarborough residents would benefit from a DRL than from the proposed subway to nowhere.

Exactly!!!

Downtown people don't need a DRL.anyone who doesn't get that should be prohibited from voting...

People who live downtown WALK or bike. I never used ttc or drove when I lived at bay and Wellsley and now that i live further west- I still rarely rely on transit or car...

The subway benefits the burbs more than people like me... Yet people think I'm spoiled cuz I live in the city (but rarely use the transit available ...)

People outside of downtown need a DrL.
 
Exactly!!!

Downtown people don't need a DRL.anyone who doesn't get that should be prohibited from voting...

People who live downtown WALK or bike. I never used ttc or drove when I lived at bay and Wellsley and now that i live further west- I still rarely rely on transit or car...

The subway benefits the burbs more than people like me... Yet people think I'm spoiled cuz I live in the city (but rarely use the transit available ...)

People outside of downtown need a DrL.

Agreed. And the cost of it to do it right will probably come in at 50 billion. Which only the feds could come up with. So how do we go about getting the Tories to come up with it? The Liberals haven't despite electing several MP's over the years.

Perhaps the olympics finally? That would bring money in.

Like I said earlier. Watch for 3 more stops on Shepard next, for the municipal election. Then if this city was smart make a DRL a federal election issue. See if the Tories will commit to long term funding. And elect them if they do.

Hell I'd consider putting Junior in if there was a commitment to it.

Would you put Harper Back in if he commited the money to infrastructure in this city?
 
Don't be agnostic... It's a freaking gigantic waste of money.

It's worth caring about...

I wouldn't go quite so far as to say I don't care. :)

I just haven't reached a final position on the matter, which is my right as a procrastinator.

Actually, it would be helpful in this election year to see candidates produce comprehensive transit plans for the city (real plans, not the back-of-the-napkin stuff that Karen Stintz put together). I would like to see the whole plan, rather than judging each expansion on a case-by-case basis.

Similarly, since we are likely also headed into a provincial election this year, it would be nice to see at least one of the parties put forward a meaningful strategy for amalgamating transit throughout the GTA. It's ridiculous that some trips outside of Toronto (eg., from Etobicoke to the outskirts of Mississauga) can take more than an hour when a car ride to the same destination might only take 15 minutes.
 
I wouldn't go quite so far as to say I don't care. :)

I just haven't reached a final position on the matter, which is my right as a procrastinator.

Actually, it would be helpful in this election year to see candidates produce comprehensive transit plans for the city (real plans, not the back-of-the-napkin stuff that Karen Stintz put together). I would like to see the whole plan, rather than judging each expansion on a case-by-case basis.

Similarly, since we are likely also headed into a provincial election this year, it would be nice to see at least one of the parties put forward a meaningful strategy for amalgamating transit throughout the GTA. It's ridiculous that some trips outside of Toronto (eg., from Etobicoke to the outskirts of Mississauga) can take more than an hour when a car ride to the same destination might only take 15 minutes.

Stintz produced several plans all of which included clear costs, timeliness, and funding. They were not back of the napkin. The final plan that was implemented was hers.

Some have said she flip flopped by producing different plans but I think it's more accurate to say she just kept trying until a plan got buyin.

Ford spent three years yapping about subways without ever producing a plan at all. Not even on a napkin.
 
Stintz produced several plans all of which included clear costs, timeliness, and funding. They were not back of the napkin. The final plan that was implemented was hers.

Stintz's plan died a quick death because she hadn't done anything to determine whether it could be funded. Then-transportation minister Bob Chiarelli quickly poured cold water on the plan.

Indeed, all of the politics around the transit debate is one of the reasons I haven't put much effort into determining the actual merits of the subway proposal.

The primary reason that Stintz's plan was praised by some was that it was seen as an embarrassment to Ford. Similarly, it is difficult to get past the idea that some people don't like the Scarborough subway because it is seen as a "win" for Ford. I remember the predictions on TERB that it would be a huge loss for Ford if the subway plan collapsed.

I'm not interested in looking at the Scarborough subway issue through the prism of how it affects Rob Ford. I would like to see the proposal debated on its own merits. In my view, that hasn't happened.

(I should add, by the way, that I don't care for Stintz, but not because of her handling of the transit file. I went sour on Stintz after I saw her appearance on TVO's The Agenda. She seemed kinda flaky to me.)
 
If she was eager or confident she would file as soon as she could
That may be what you would do, but she quite clearly does not share your opinion. Perhaps that arises from having some actual experience contesting and winning elections. As another with real experience, John Tory hasn't declared either, and while his record isn't as long or as successful as Chow's, it's still real experience. He did respectably enough against Miller to be a threat to a Downtown Darling or a drunken, drugged-up, unprincipled, serial liar who accomplished nothing for all his paychheques but disruption and discord.

Our real worry should be the startlingly high percentage of unprincipled idiots happy to boast about wasting their vote—perhaps for the second time—and the City's future on Ford. That's as obvious to me as what Olivia should do is to you.
 
Stintz's plan died a quick death because she hadn't done anything to determine whether it could be funded.

Untrue. Her first plan that was rejected was funded in the exact same way that her final plan that was approved was funded. Namely it cashed for provincial funding to be reallocated, and highlighted the gap that council would need cover from property tax, which has been done.

You are aware that the current, approved, funded plan is a Stintz plan?
 
That may be what you would do, but she quite clearly does not share your opinion. Perhaps that arises from having some actual experience contesting and winning elections. As another with real experience, John Tory hasn't declared either, and while his record isn't as long or as successful as Chow's, it's still real experience, and he did respectably enough against Miller to be a threat to a Downtown Darling or a drunken, drugged-up, unprincipled, serial liar who accomplished nothing for all his paychheques but disruption and discord.

boy you sure get worked up over nothing.


john tory is not going to run, he knows he will lose.

with respect to olivia chow- i think not filing shows she is not confident and has no game plan for the city. You think thats smart politics.
 
Most quotes peg it at $6.2-8.3 Billion. With a 20% overrun that's 10ish billion dollars. 3 or 4 billion from the Feds, 3 or 4 more from the Provence, with the city covering the balance and overruns, would do it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Downtown_Relief_Line[/QUOTE.


It will be higher than this. It would have to go past Bloor to make sense. All the way to Sheppard. On both sides. Having it run just from bloor takes nothing off the load running from the north. That's where the real issue is.

I still think an elevated enclosed "L" down the Don Valley makes sense. All the way from Sheppard to the core.
 
Anbarandy said it was "El Fordo's" plan.
Toronto's greatest mayor ever, has plastered his mug, snout, jawbone and mouth all over the city that it's HIS.
 
Our real worry should be the startlingly high percentage of unprincipled idiots happy to boast about wasting their vote—perhaps for the second time—and the City's future on Ford. That's as obvious to me as what Olivia should do is to you.

Of course, that raises some interesting questions for Anti-Ford Nation.

There is strong opposition to both Ford and Chow. Which means that if a credible third candidate emerges, there will be pressure on supporters in both camps to move to the third candidate.

In fact, the alternatives to Ford become more attractive if voters can feel confident that vote splitting isn't going to lead to a Chow victory. Those who stick with Chow could ultimately be forcing some people to vote for Ford.

I'm one of those people in question. I would prefer someone other than Ford. But I'm already on record as saying, if the race becomes a two-way fight between Chow and Ford, I'm voting for Ford. I'll take the crackhead over the Marxist.

I will vote for someone else but only if I am confident that I won't inadvertently be contributing to a Chow victory.

It's going to be a fun election year.
 
Nope. Stintz is the TTC chair, she wrote it.

According to Marcus Gee at the Globe and Mail, Stintz reportedly told CBC's Metro Morning that she had no idea where the plan came from:

Asked on CBC Radio’s Metro Morning this week who was actually in charge of transit planning, Toronto Transit Commission chair Karen Stintz could only reply that it was a very good question.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...-to-farce/article14175830/#dashboard/follows/
 
That's a different question, and she was no doubt commenting on the turf war between the city and metrolinks.

According to another Globe and Mail story, the plan that was approved was essentially David Miller's plan:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...n-toronto/article13237591/#dashboard/follows/

To go back to my original point on the subway expansion, I don't really care. The debate about subway extensions and a transit plan for the city should focus on the merits of the approved plan and any proposals put forward by other candidates.

I want to focus on the public policy merits of each idea. I don't care who the political "winners" or "losers" are.
 
According to another Globe and Mail story, the plan that was approved was essentially David Miller's plan:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...n-toronto/article13237591/#dashboard/follows/

To go back to my original point on the subway expansion, I don't really care. The debate about subway extensions and a transit plan for the city should focus on the merits of the approved plan and any proposals put forward by other candidates.

I want to focus on the public policy merits of each idea. I don't care who the political "winners" or "losers" are.
And yes, the Miller Transit City plan that was approved by council and the province included a 7 station LRT replacement for the above ground portion of the Scarborough extension of the Bloor/Danforth subway line that would be fully funded by the province until of course, the conductor of THE STUPID TRAIN tore it up as his first STUPID act as pseudo-mayor.

Karen The Khameleon Stintz then brought the whole of the transit plan back to council and the original plan was re-approved by council until course, bye-elections were to held in Scarborough and the provincial liberals decided to try and bribe Scarboro voters with a 2 station subway.

Seizing the opportunity to cast her name as a viable candidate for Mayor Karen The Khameleon flip-flopped in disgrace and put forth the current Scarborough subway extension until of course, El Fordo plastered his mug, his snout, his jawbone and mouth all over that plan and laid claim to it as his own.

Whatever, it is a disgrace all around, from the provincial liberals, to Ford, to Stintz and all those others councilors who sought to curry electoral favor, but mostly for Ford because he is the conductor of THE STUPID TRAIN.
 
And yes, the Miller Transit City plan that was approved by council and the province included a 7 station LRT replacement for the above ground portion of the Scarborough extension of the Bloor/Danforth subway line that would be fully funded by the province until of course, the conductor of THE STUPID TRAIN tore it up as his first STUPID act as pseudo-mayor.

Karen The Khameleon Stintz then brought the whole of the transit plan back to council and the original plan was re-approved by council until course, bye-elections were to held in Scarborough and the provincial liberals decided to try and bribe Scarboro voters with a 2 station subway.

Seizing the opportunity to cast her name as a viable candidate for Mayor Karen The Khameleon flip-flopped in disgrace and put forth the current Scarborough subway extension until of course, El Fordo plastered his mug, his snout, his jawbone and mouth all over that plan and laid claim to it as his own.

Whatever, it is a disgrace all around, from the provincial liberals, to Ford, to Stintz and all those others councilors who sought to curry electoral favor, but mostly for Ford because he is the conductor of THE STUPID TRAIN.


Don't like Stintz either, eh?