No More "Two for One"

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
The law has now been changed to no more 2 or 3 for 1 credit for time served when sentenced to jail time. It was getting ridiculous when someone sentenced to 15 years in prison is out walking the streets in 6 months because of 2 or 3 for 1 credit for time served and 5/6 credit for good behaviour. Maybe now the revolving door will stop. I think the stats are that 15% of the criminals commit 80% of the crime (something like that).
 
Did not hear that but it sounds great to me. Now all the lawyers are going to implement every delay tactic on the planet, then try to have charges dismissed because their client did not get a speedy trial.
 
Now all the lawyers are going to implement every delay tactic on the planet, then try to have charges dismissed because their client did not get a speedy trial.

The "revolving door" is good business for defense lawyers and judges. One defense lawyer said on TV that judges will now give shorter sentences (to keep the revolving door revolving). The criminal defense industry is huge.
 
Longer sentences aren't good for the tax payer. They do little to deter crime, and it costs us a pretty penny to keep someone locked up.

To the average criminal not yet in jail, thinking about doing some crime, the difference between a 10 year and a 15 year sentence is not a factor in their decision making, both are just a "long time". However the 15 year sentence costs us taxpayers 50% more.
 
Longer sentences aren't good for the tax payer. They do little to deter crime, and it costs us a pretty penny to keep someone locked up.

I don't know if there are any studies (there must be, we study everything to death) but I would suggest that it is more expensive to society to have them wrecking havoc on the outside than locked up inside.

I think I saw stats that show 80% of criminals commit only that one crime but 15% of criminals commit 80% of the crimes (the old 20/80 rule). If we lock up that 15% we reduce crime by 80%.
 
i,m just wondering..how can the law be changed, since Parliament is not in session?..........anyone ?
 
I don't mind the 2 for 1 rule for first time offenders - as long as if they are convicted of a later offense that time is added to their sentence.
 
Now thats the kind of clarity I was looking for. After reading this thread and looking deeper into the stories (i'll be honest didnt understand the lingo at first not a law guy) I think the new law is good for us. however, since a point was made earlier, if you think the judges are going to reduce the sentence for the sake of their jobs then shouldn't it be time to implement a system similar to the US where in Judges are voted upon by the people?
 
I don't mind the 2 for 1 rule for first time offenders - as long as if they are convicted of a later offense that time is added to their sentence.

As long as it is added "CONSECUTIVELY". Too often someone gets jail time for like 5 murders and he is sentenced to 15 years CONCURRENTLY then gets time off for time served and good behaviour and 6 months later he is living next door to your daughter.
 
I think I saw stats that show 80% of criminals commit only that one crime but 15% of criminals commit 80% of the crimes (the old 20/80 rule). If we lock up that 15% we reduce crime by 80%.

Wrecking havoc on the outside is probably cheaper than locking them up for most crimes. Not for first degree murder obviously, but for most crimes. It is spectacularly expensive to keep someone in jail and in my opinion most people in jail would be better off being diverted to some sort of supervised program outside of jail.

We don't do nearly enough to make sure that people don't re-offend. When we lock someone up for 5 years and offer them NOTHING to improve their life then basically it amounts to a five year stint in crime university. They come out worse criminals than when they went in.
 
Here we go again. The TERB Law Society chiming in with another bullshit thread, based on reading a headline on page one of that honoured law journal, The Toronto Sun.

The reason that the 2-for1 rule existed was because people doing "dead time" are not eligible for parole calculated on the pre trial time served. Post sentence time served earns parole. That is why criminals who did pre trial time got 2 for 1 credit.

This was changed so that Stephen Harper and his government could get a few headlines and try and bolster their slip-sliding polls rating with a tough "law and order" stance.

But I'm happy you fellows are duly impressed.
 
most people in jail would be better off being diverted to some sort of supervised program outside of jail.

Doesn't Louisana have an outdoor work program where convicts build roads? That way they remain productive members of society when they are serving time and they can work in construction when they are released. (But asking convicts to work probably violates at least 38 of their civil rights.)
 
Doesn't Louisana have an outdoor work program where convicts build roads? That way they remain productive members of society when they are serving time and they can work in construction when they are released. (But asking convicts to work probably violates at least 38 of their civil rights.)

It costs about $50,000/year to keep someone in jail compared to about $5,000/year for a probation order. Half-way houses would be somewhere between. The most appropriate use of prison would be, for most criminals, as a time out when they fail to live up to their probation order. So, throw someone on probation with orders that they engage in actions that will help turn their life away from crime. If they fail to live up to their probation terms, throw them in jail for a week, then give them another shot. Next time for a month. And so on.

Under such a scheme you could hand down quote LONG sentences, say, 15 years on probation, without a large cost to the taxpayer, and a greater chance of getting that person into a life other than one of crime.

Of course if someone is an outright menace to society, like a serial rapist or murderer, or anyone else highly likely to kill or seriously harm someone if left in society, then the $50,000 is money well spent.
 
If I was the presiding Justice in this matter I would remove the 2 for 1 deal and no more 5 / 6 off for good bahavior. Any other time removed will be on a suspended sentence condition. Time not served will be applied if later offences are commited.

I would further reform the prison system where non violent criminals in prison on their first offence will get the option to apply to put themselves into a special facility where they rehabilitate themselves and earn early release by taking courses through a computer ( not connected to the internet ) Upon taking exams after self teaching themselves the courses by computer. Good marks would be applied to early release. Any early release would be on a suspended sentence condition and time not served will be applied to any later offences commited.

This would separate the violent hardend criminals from the first time offenders and give them a chance to improve their skills through learning.




Justice C. Catz

Supreme Cat of Canada
 
Of course if someone is an outright menace to society, like a serial rapist or murderer, or anyone else highly likely to kill or seriously harm someone if left in society, then the $50,000 is money well spent.

If found guilty after due process, would it be cheaper to simply "do away" with Mr. Russell Williams?
 
Longer sentences aren't good for the tax payer. They do little to deter crime, and it costs us a pretty penny to keep someone locked up.

thats as maybe but i bet the victims would not agree
 
If found guilty after due process, would it be cheaper to simply "do away" with Mr. Russell Williams?

Turns out to be more expensive than keeping him in jail for life. Unless you want to do away with the more extreme legal processes that are applied, in which case, raising the chance of killing an innocent man.
 
raising the chance of killing an innocent man.

Maybe LE is better at deducing evidence now than in the past but the number of wrongly convicted is shocking. Donald Marshall, David Milgard, Steven Truscott, Jean Paul Morin, etc. However, in some cases the evidence is beyond doubt (e.g. Paul Bernardo).