No Maine Miracle Cure

onthebottom

Never Been Justly Banned
Jan 10, 2002
40,880
197
63
Hooterville
www.scubadiving.com
This is exactly what many of us who are suspicious of the current health care plans are worried about:

OTB

No Maine Miracle Cure
Another state 'public option' that failed.

Want a preview of ObamaCare in action? Sneak a look at what has happened in Maine. In 2003, the state to great fanfare enacted its own version of universal health care. Democratic Governor John Baldacci signed the plan into law with a bevy of familiar promises. By 2009, it would cover all of Maine's approximately 128,000 uninsured citizens. System-wide controls on hospital and physician costs would hold down insurance premiums. There would be no tax increases. The program was going to provide insurance for everyone and save businesses and patients money at the same time.

After five years, fiscal realities as brutal as the waves that crash along Maine's famous coastline have hit the insurance plan. The system that was supposed to save money has cost taxpayers $155 million and is still rising.

Here's how the program was supposed to work. Two government programs would cover the uninsured. First the legislature greatly expanded MaineCare, the state's Medicaid program. Today Maine families with incomes of up to $44,000 a year are eligible; 22% of the population is now in Medicaid, roughly twice the national average.

Then the state created a "public option" known as DirigoChoice. (Dirigo is the state motto, meaning "I Lead.") This plan would compete with private plans such as Blue Cross. To entice lower income Mainers to enroll, it offered taxpayer-subsidized premiums. The plan's original funding source was $50 million of federal stimulus money the state got in 2003. Over time, the plan was to be "paid for by savings in the health-care system." This is precisely the promise of ObamaCare. Maine saved by squeezing payments to hospitals and physicians.

The program flew off track fast. At its peak in 2006, only about 15,000 people had enrolled in the DirigoChoice program. That number has dropped to below 10,000, according to the state's own reporting. About two-thirds of those who enrolled already had insurance, which they dropped in favor of the public option and its subsidies. Instead of 128,000 uninsured in the program today, the actual number is just 3,400. Despite the giant expansions in Maine's Medicaid program and the new, subsidized public choice option, the number of uninsured in the state today is only slightly lower that in 2004 when the program began.

Why did this happen? Among the biggest reasons is a severe adverse selection problem: The sickest, most expensive patients crowded into DirigoChoice, unbalancing its insurance pool and raising costs. That made it unattractive for healthier and lower-risk enrollees. And as a result, few low-income Mainers have been able to afford the premiums, even at subsidized rates.

This problem was exacerbated because since the early 1990s Maine has required insurers to adhere to community rating and guaranteed issue, which requires that insurers cover anyone who applies, regardless of their health condition and at a uniform premium. These rules—which are in the Obama plan—have relentlessly driven up insurance costs in Maine, especially for healthy people.

The Maine Heritage Policy Center, which has tracked the plan closely, points out that largely because of these insurance rules, a healthy male in Maine who is 30 and single pays a monthly premium of $762 in the individual market; next door in New Hampshire he pays $222 a month. The Granite State doesn't have community rating and guaranteed issue.

One proposal to get people into the DirigoChoice system is to reduce the premiums, presumably to give the uninsured a larger incentive to join. But that would explode the program's costs when it already can't pay its bills. A program that was supposed to save money by reducing health-care waste and inefficiencies has seen a 74% increase in premiums. But even those inflated payments can't keep the program out of the red.

Last year, DirigoCare was so desperate for cash that the legislature broke its original promise of no tax hikes and proposed an infusion of funds through a beer, wine and soda tax, similar to what has been floated to pay for the Obama plan. Maine voters rejected these taxes by two to one. Then this year the legislature passed a 2% tax on paid health insurance claims. Taxing paid insurance claims sounds a tad churlish, but the previous funding formula was so complicated that it was costing the state $1 million a year in lawsuits.

Unlike the federal government, Maine has a balanced budget requirement. So out of fiscal necessity, the state has now capped the enrollment in the program and allowed no new entrants. Now there is a waiting list. DirigoChoice has become yet another expensive, failed experiment in government-run health care, alongside similar fiascoes in Massachusetts and Tennessee.

Not everyone sees it this way. Noting the similarities between the Maine program and the Congressional initiative, Karynlee Harrington, the executive director of the Dirigo Health Agency, boasted recently: "DirigoChoice is consistent with what we think the definition of a public health option is." It certainly is.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204619004574322401816501182.html?mod=djemEditorialPage
 
The disinformation continues......:rolleyes:
 
onthebottom said:
Why did this happen? Among the biggest reasons is a severe adverse selection problem: The sickest, most expensive patients crowded into DirigoChoice, unbalancing its insurance pool and raising costs. That made it unattractive for healthier and lower-risk enrollees. And as a result, few low-income Mainers have been able to afford the premiums, even at subsidized rates.

[/url]

Ok I'm reading this and it states that the biggest problem is that the sickest patients got treated first ?

Am I missing something here ? Wasn't that the point ?

Sounds to me that the biggest problem is the insurance companies that have fucked this up.

Wow this really has OTB worried he's started more threads about than Pekkr did when he was bashing Bush.
 
Let us assume that the OP is correct and that the Maine experiment in public insurance failed. It sounds like the failure ewas because of the mix of public/private plans, but I am not sure.

Now the problem is what to do in the US with a failed system. While health care everywhere is growing in cost, in the US it threatens to dominate the budget. There seem to be a few issues:

- is a 'for profit' approach for insurance companies the proper mechanism for financing health care? will it improve the health care of americans? Sanjay Gupta (on CNN) weighed in on this when he spoke of multi - milionaire Insurace company executives in private jets while policiholders were denied coverage.

Note that the efficient German system is based on Non profit insurance companies(they call them 'sickness' funds).

- should the health care system be tipped to the rich or provide equal care(as much as possible, anyway) to all.


- what, if anything, should the government do to rein in the excessive costs of health care which are behind this debate. For example, should caps on fees be allowed? should we negotiate prices on drugs(rather than pay top dollar, As a side point, note how the threat of cheaper Canadian drugs drove the Bush admin to quell the debate by creating an enormously expenssive Medicare drug plan that only pays TOP dollar to the drug companies. And Obama is keeping this deal to avoid drug company animosity)?

What percent of GDP should be targeted for our medical system.?
 
The problem in Maine is that they allow private insurance operations.

My suspicion is that America's political system is too myopically ideological to ever get this right.
 
train said:
Ok I'm reading this and it states that the biggest problem is that the sickest patients got treated first ?

Am I missing something here ? Wasn't that the point ?

Sounds to me that the biggest problem is the insurance companies that have fucked this up.

Wow this really has OTB worried he's started more threads about than Pekkr did when he was bashing Bush.

Yes, they spent 150 million dollars to insure 3,400 more people, only a government can screw something up that effectively. Perhaps Post Office is the perfect metaphor.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Yes, they spent 150 million dollars to insure 3,400 more people, only a government can screw something up that effectively. Perhaps Post Office is the perfect metaphor.

OTB
Sheer delusional logic......now you channel your dad!.....:D
 
train said:
Wow this really has OTB worried he's started more threads about than Pekkr did when he was bashing Bush.
LOL!
Now we know who pays smug bottie, eh?.....:D
 
train said:
Sounds to me that the biggest problem is the insurance companies that have fucked this up.
For "insurance companies" Train read the State of Maine's Bureau of Insurance since they are the 'insurance company' for Dirigo.
 
fuji said:
The problem in Maine is that they allow private insurance operations.
Fuji, I suspect that you are not particularly familiar with the problems in Maine, given the problems with Dirigo and Medicaid if private insurance was eliminated in all likelyhood the Governor's office would be taken over by force.
 
WoodPeckr said:
Sheer delusional logic......now you channel your dad!.....:D

Read the bold above.....

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Read the bold above.....

OTB
LOL!
Either way, it still sounds like channeling....:D
 
onthebottom said:
Yes, they spent 150 million dollars to insure 3,400 more people, only a government can screw something up that effectively. Perhaps Post Office is the perfect metaphor.

OTB


Your point would seem to be like blowing up the post office just because some yahoos/simple servants there printed $0.50 stamps at a cost of $0.55 each.

Wouldn't the logical answer be to get rid of the simple servants for better ones because you know in the end couriers will cost you more and they won't deliver to everyone ?

The only certain lesson in the Mass. example is that you can't do a half-assed job of something. It does point out the complexities of conversion though.

I am sympathetic to not wanting to have certain political groups gain total control of the bureaucracy - recent examples being the City of Toronto and E Health in Ontario.
 
train said:
Your point would seem to be like blowing up the post office just because some yahoos/simple servants there printed $0.50 stamps at a cost of $0.55 each.

Wouldn't the logical answer be to get rid of the simple servants for better ones because you know in the end couriers will cost you more and they won't deliver to everyone ?

The only certain lesson in the Mass. example is that you can't do a half-assed job of something. It does point out the complexities of conversion though.

I am sympathetic to not wanting to have certain political groups gain total control of the bureaucracy - recent examples being the City of Toronto and E Health in Ontario.

This isn't a simple error that spent 155M to insure 3,400 more people - this is systemic government incompetence. Maine spent over 45k PER PERSON insured - that's crazy.

Even the White House will admit, that after 10 years and a Trillion dollars there will still be large numbers of people uninsured.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
This isn't a simple error that spent 155M to insure 3,400 more people - this is systemic government incompetence. Maine spent over 45k PER PERSON insured - that's crazy.

OTB

While I think that the 3,400 was the ending number, if you truly believe your statement that is bolded then Maine has far worse problems than this.

Seems to me the problem is not universal heslthcare but State incompetence which has the potential to affect every a wide range of matters.
 
train said:
....

Seems to me the problem is not universal heslthcare but State incompetence which has the potential to affect every a wide range of matters.

Change State to government and I think you have a nice synopsis of the point of view.

OTB