No Coalition Petition

danmand said:
It is kind of a sad comment that the discussion seem to gravitate to "who is the
biggest idiot, Harper or Dion?"

In politics it's almost always a choice between idiots.
 
ericlennox said:
Its now 4720 to 29 against the coalition
Too bad what matters in our parliamentary system is the number of elected seats, not the opinions of a few people who signed a petition. If they get anywhere near 15 million Canadian voters to sign, then there might be reason to discuss it.
 
emerging44 said:
Only time will tell!
Personally, I was surprised to hear both the Liberals and NDP so vehemently against the idea of a Coalition during the campaign - especially when it was pretty obvious what the outcome was going to be.
However, if the Coalition succeeds in becoming the Government, I think that will spell the end of Harpers career and the Conservatives will have to spend a few years rebuilding.
I don’t find it hard to understand at all. A coalition with the NDP would have either driven moderate liberals to the conservatives or kept them home on election day. It would also have kept some NDP voters from strategically voting for the liberals if they thought the NDP could be part of the government. I do not see any plus for the liberals in not coming out against such an arrangement during the campaign. From the NDP prospective, once Dion made his speech against it, coming out against it themselves was necessary to save face. Moreover, announcing the possibility of a defacto coalition with the Bloc would really have hurt the liberals with their traditional federalist voters. I don’t even know if Dion bothered to reject that possibility, as I never would have imagined them allying themselves with a party whose whole reason for being is the break up of Canada.
Politics is hard to predict (who would have predicted liberals and separatists as formal allies). However, what ever happens to Harper, I cannot see this hurting the conservatives. Traditional moderate liberal voters now only have two choices. Vote for the conservatives or stay home during the next election. Traditional conservative voters only have the option of either doing the same or forming another breakaway party and after the disaster when that happened the last time, I cannot see that happening again. Moreover, I am sure that there will be some voters from all parties upset at the nondemocratic nature of this. Regardless of the short term out come, I really think that, in the long run, this is a win-win situation for the conservatives. However, I would also like to see a win for democracy in the short run. Not to mention federalism. The only proper way to settle a question this important is with an election where people will now know that the outcome could be such a coalition.