Nipigon River Bridge Failure.....Incompetence?

We have been building large bridges for over 100 years. Back then they didn't have the use of computers. Why engineers want to tinker with something that works is beyond me. I can understand that there are environmental challenges in a lot of places but by know you would think most of them have been dealt with.
 
We have been building large bridges for over 100 years. Back then they didn't have the use of computers. Why engineers want to tinker with something that works is beyond me. I can understand that there are environmental challenges in a lot of places but by know you would think most of them have been dealt with.

Two reasons come to mind: cost, and aesthetics. Who wants to pay $100M for a bridge when you can get the same result for $90M and spend the other $10M on a hospital improvement instead? And if you can get a bridge that enhances the landscape instead of being a blight, well, that has some value to local residents too.
 
The Mackinac bridge was completed almost 60 years ago in a similar climate at a far greater span. The only issues with it are the high winds coming across Lake Michigan. Well worth the $4.50 US toll as long as it's a calm day.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mackinac_Bridge

Driven that a few times. Once did it with a friend who is so shit-scared of heights, and bridges, that he was literally crouched in a fetal position and whimpering.
 
We have been building large bridges for over 100 years. Back then they didn't have the use of computers. Why engineers want to tinker with something that works is beyond me. I can understand that there are environmental challenges in a lot of places but by know you would think most of them have been dealt with.
If only you'd been around to save us from deadly alternating electrical current when organic, naturally-hunted whale oil had been lighting our darkness for more than a mere 100 years.

Look at the evil results of all that engineer tinkering with what works.