Nikon D5100 v D7000

First, if you're just easing your way in I'd start with a more basic body and as your skills grow then you should decide whether or not you need to move on to something else. Who knows? You may decide that you're more of a night-time streetscape artiste and therefore a Leica or Contax might be more up your alley.

Second, have you actually held any of these cameras in your hand. I looked at a couple of Nikons earlier this year and the higher-end model simply would not fit into my hands. It was literally too much camera!

Finally, if you do decide to go for the kit, yes, it is a good idea but you may also see if you can trade in the value for another lens.


Thanks for the responses, everybody. I think I have more questions than answers but I appreciate your input.

I honestly don't know what I plan on shooting. Everything? I suppose it would help if I knew but I don't. I don't really plan on concentrating on one subject. I just want to get into the hobby and see how it goes.

I was originally leaning towards the D5100 and I think that's the way I'm going to go. I wouldn't have to break the bank to buy the D7000 but I'm just not sure if that's the best way to go for me. I think it makes sense to start with the D5100 and see where it grows from there. While not as advanced as the D7000, it's still a camera I can grow into. My interest may fizzle eventually (but probably not) but if it doesn't I can always upgrade my gear down the road, right?

I know it was suggest that I buy just the body and forget about the kit lens. The body is $720 and the kit is $800. The kit lens alone is $180. Doesn't it make sense to get the lens for and extra $80?
 
I guess one more piece of advice is in order (and may well be more justification for my saying just get the basic body/kit) and that is to stop dithering around with reviews. Virtually all DSLRs today will do more than most people will ever do or conceive of doing. Get one, get out there and get shooting.
 
First, if you're just easing your way in I'd start with a more basic body and as your skills grow then you should decide whether or not you need to move on to something else.
You're suggesting I might want an even more basic camera than the D5100 (like the D3100) or the more basic of the two options I presented (D5100)?



Second, have you actually held any of these cameras in your hand. I looked at a couple of Nikons earlier this year and the higher-end model simply would not fit into my hands. It was literally too much camera!
Yes. I was playing around with the D5100 last week. Felt good, camera seemed easy enough to navigate. Didn't seem intimidating.


Finally, if you do decide to go for the kit, yes, it is a good idea but you may also see if you can trade in the value for another lens.
Never thought of that. Thanks for the tip.
 
Whoa! Hold on there. No, I am not suggesting an even more basic camera. You're talking to someone who started out with a no-name Japanese camera from the 1960s that was not even an SLR. What I am suggesting is that you get something that you feel comfortable with and is pretty basic. Work up your skillset over the next couple of years and see what happens. Equipment does not make great photos, it helps but what really matters is the person behind that camera.

Then, after a couple of years, decide whether or not you want to move up to a more advanced camera body. Keep the one you buy today as a spare or sell it/trade in.

Right now, if the D5100 feels good in the hand, then go with that.


You're suggesting I might want an even more basic camera than the D5100 (like the D3100) or the more basic of the two options I presented (D5100)?
 
nikon has two-tier system where some cameras do not have the af motor in the body (like the d5100). they need lenses with af in the lens. i don't really see this as a problem since af in the lens is usually faster anyway, but it does prohibit the use of some old lenses. personally, d7000 with 18-105 would be minimum in the nikon line for me right now.
 
It seems like there are two tiers of conversations going on here..... one is what to get to see if you like photography and will make use of a DSLR (either option will work), the other is if you want to stay with the hobby what will take you the farthest before you upgrade.

You see the discussion about lenses and larry's very insightful observation above about AF because if you stay in the hobby the money/cost/performance isn't as much in the camera as it is in lenses.

OTB