Nikon D5100 v D7000

I'm looking to get into the DSLR game and am currently torn between these two cameras. Henry's has the D5100 with kit lens for $799.99 and the D7000 with kit lens for $1329.99 ($598.90 difference after tax).

I've done a lot of research, know all of the specs and still can't make up my mind (nothing new for me). This will be my first DSLR. I don't really know a heck of a lot about photography but I'm eager to learn and have always really enjoyed taking photos with little knowledge behind the science. Just put it in auto and start shooting.

From what I've read, the D5100 can take photos almost as well as the D7000 (same sensor). The D7000 can take more FPS and has more AF points (best for fast action i.e. sports). One of the biggest knocks I've read about the D5100 (other than the fact that it doesn't have full manual exposure in video mode) is the way it's laid out. Apparently it may be foreign to Nikon users but seeing as I'm a blank canvas, I don't see that as a deal breaker for me. The D7000 has more useful buttons at your finger tips so you don't have to go into a menu to change some of the more common settings. Then again, I'm new to this whole thigh so that may not be a big deal.

I thought I was all set on the D5100 but know I'm not sure. Is it worth it for a learning amature to spend the extra $600? Will I/ can I outgrow the D5100 too fast? Any advice?
 
the d7000 is heads and shoulders better than the entry level d5100. but is it worth $600 more to you? depends on your free cash situation. if i were starting fresh, i would get it over any other aps-c sensor camera. check out viewfinder size:
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/nikond5100/page3.asp

you will need a flash almost right away. better budget another $500

a quick check shows that with the same 18-105 lens, there is only $400 difference. i'm not saying you shouldn't get a dslr, but you do realize that your next lens will be a grand easily? perhaps $2000? if you're not interested in pouring money into this hobby, give it some thought. dslrs are good for low light and difficult shooting circumstances. for daylight, most any camera will be fine. i have 3. a pocketable p&s, a larger sensor compact and a dslr. this is not a hobby for thrifty people.
 
The dual-command dial layout of the higher end Nikon's is awesome. The forward dial does shutter speed, and the rear dial does exposure, and the functions are reversible on some cameras.

Also, the D5100 may not have the mechanism for supporting some of Nikon's older AF lenses. The specifications were not entirely clear. If so, this would be a major drawback.

Pretty sure you are looking at the difference between a low-end professional camera and a consumer camera. In the DSLR world, it is a big jump. The professional cameras have a degree of fit, finish, reliability, and function that is not reflected in the specifications. They are designed to deal with shooting situations the average user rarely encounters, however when the situations are encountered, the results are awesome.

On the other hand, the consumer cameras tend to be really easy to use for everyday shooting needs.
 
the d7000 is heads and shoulders better than the entry level d5100. but is it worth $600 more to you? depends on your free cash situation. if i were starting fresh, i would get it over any other aps-c sensor camera. check out viewfinder size:
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/nikond5100/page3.asp

you will need a flash almost right away. better budget another $500

a quick check shows that with the same 18-105 lens, there is only $400 difference. i'm not saying you shouldn't get a dslr, but you do realize that your next lens will be a grand easily? perhaps $2000? if you're not interested in pouring money into this hobby, give it some thought. dslrs are good for low light and difficult shooting circumstances. for daylight, most any camera will be fine. i have 3. a pocketable p&s, a larger sensor compact and a dslr. this is not a hobby for thrifty people.

While I have a flash I NEVER use it....

I don't know that I'd buy a 2k lens for a DX sensor camera...... 1K is very likely.

OTB
 
While I have a flash I NEVER use it....

I don't know that I'd buy a 2k lens for a DX sensor camera...... 1K is very likely.

OTB
you don't bounce? you never take pictures in a big room? ok.

the nikon 70-200vrII goes for $2400. the sigma EX... goes for $1500. Each to his own, but buying low quality never wins out. If a person can't afford these purchases, they may be better off with a super-zoom or a bridge compact.
 
Well, I'd ask what you are planning on shooting? How much time will you have to devote to this? If you're only going to put it on auto and hold the shutter button down then, spend a couple of hours a month on the hobby and take pics of flowers, then, I'd save the money and get the cheaper option.
 
you don't bounce? you never take pictures in a big room? ok.

I do but I don't need a flash..... very high ISO camera.

the nikon 70-200vrII goes for $2400. the sigma EX... goes for $1500. Each to his own, but buying low quality never wins out. If a person can't afford these purchases, they may be better off with a super-zoom or a bridge compact.

Close:http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/644741-USA/Nikon_2185_AF_S_Nikkor_70_200mm_f_2_8G.html

I have that lens, it's fantastic but it might be a bit of overkill for a DX camera (you're going to lose an f-stop to the sensor).

For less than half the price you can get: http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/124669-GREY/Nikon_1986_AF_Zoom_Nikkor_80_200mm_f_2_8D.html


If he's just getting started I think the way to go is: http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/729950-USA/Nikon_2191_AF_S_NIKKOR_28_300mm_f_3_5_5_6G.html


IMHO

OTB
 
not to go too far off topic. but no VR at all and/or slow and variable aperture are not my ideas of lenses to buy. i have regretted that one already. now i wait till i can afford the right one.

but let it go. the Op is just beginning. who knows the direction he'll go. entry level with pop up and kit lens might do him just fine. i see plenty of people at events using what came from the store. as is. they seem to be enjoying themselves.
 
Well, I'd ask what you are planning on shooting? How much time will you have to devote to this? If you're only going to put it on auto and hold the shutter button down then, spend a couple of hours a month on the hobby and take pics of flowers, then, I'd save the money and get the cheaper option.
is everything bang for the buck? how about just for fun and owning nice things? if you can afford it, why not? the entry level kits have severe limitations. low light mostly. to improve costs money. how much you're willing to spend depends on a lot of things. those who shoot flowers will tell you it can demand a very expensive macro lens with fancy tripod/rails and special flashes. if you take family shots in a house, a bounce flash will work wonders. if you go to a farm, a telephoto zoom is necessary. whatever.
 
"Is everything bang for the buck?"

To a certain extent, yes. Otherwise, it's a waste. Why pay the money for a great body (which will go down in value in three years to almost nil) when you can invest in better lenses and equipment, as per your example of flowers. Note that your example says squat about a great body.

Entry level kits these days will probably cover 70-80% of what your average shooter does now. That's why I am asking what is the OP really planning on doing with the new gear.


is everything bang for the buck? how about just for fun and owning nice things? if you can afford it, why not? the entry level kits have severe limitations. low light mostly. to improve costs money. how much you're willing to spend depends on a lot of things. those who shoot flowers will tell you it can demand a very expensive macro lens with fancy tripod/rails and special flashes. if you take family shots in a house, a bounce flash will work wonders. if you go to a farm, a telephoto zoom is necessary. whatever.
 
Here is the trick with DSLR cameras, just the same as with SLR back in the day:

Buy the cheaper camera body, and buy it without any lens. Hell, buy a used previous generation body off someone else who just has to have the latest and greatest.

Spend the money you saved on the best lens you can afford.

The lens will still be worth almost its full value in a couple of years, meanwhile the camera body will get rapidly cheaper as ones with more memory, faster processors, and better sensors hit the market. Then you can keep on upgrading your camera bodies over the years, buying better ones as they come out, while retaining your investment in the lenses.

Every now and then they screw you by making a big change to the lenses, but anyway they still hold their value for a lot longer than the bodies.
 
Shoot, I've taken some pretty decent photos with $10 disposable cameras in the past, especially on vacation where I don't want to carry a huge camera with a long lense and attract unwanted attention from the locals (like the Iranian secret police). Hee, hee, hee.
 
For my b-day next month I will be buying the D7000 (body) for $1020 from Aden Camera.
http://www.adencamera.com/default.asp?Category=6&Manufacturer=1

I will wait and get the 18-200 VR lens used for about $500.- $550. Craigslist
http://www.adencamera.com/product-overviewer.asp?ProdID=2978&Category=7
depending on your needs, that variable aperture long lens may be ok. may be no good at all. if you're taking pics inside a gym under the lights, you want f/2.8. and night shots the same. if you're tight for disposable cash, well, ok. just put the camera away at night. but, to me,that's the point of a dslr. otherwise, i'd look at the canon s95 or g series.

but this goes on and on. eventually, it's not really about need. it's about status. looking good. things like that. look at the people using the live view on their dslr. they'd be much better off using a quality point and shoot. low weight. image quality very close in daytime.

as for buying old bodies...the high iso capabilities of new bodies is getting better and better. that may make those slow lenses almost usable.
 
Totally agree! The investment should be in your glass and other accoutrements, not in the body.

In fact, I am still considering whether or not to get an old Nikon body such as an FE or FE2 and then get some really nice lenses.


Here is the trick with DSLR cameras, just the same as with SLR back in the day:

Buy the cheaper camera body, and buy it without any lens. Hell, buy a used previous generation body off someone else who just has to have the latest and greatest.

Spend the money you saved on the best lens you can afford.

The lens will still be worth almost its full value in a couple of years, meanwhile the camera body will get rapidly cheaper as ones with more memory, faster processors, and better sensors hit the market. Then you can keep on upgrading your camera bodies over the years, buying better ones as they come out, while retaining your investment in the lenses.

Every now and then they screw you by making a big change to the lenses, but anyway they still hold their value for a lot longer than the bodies.
 
Here is the trick with DSLR cameras, just the same as with SLR back in the day:

Buy the cheaper camera body, and buy it without any lens. Hell, buy a used previous generation body off someone else who just has to have the latest and greatest.

Spend the money you saved on the best lens you can afford.

The lens will still be worth almost its full value in a couple of years, meanwhile the camera body will get rapidly cheaper as ones with more memory, faster processors, and better sensors hit the market. Then you can keep on upgrading your camera bodies over the years, buying better ones as they come out, while retaining your investment in the lenses.

Every now and then they screw you by making a big change to the lenses, but anyway they still hold their value for a lot longer than the bodies.

I agree on the glass holding it's value...

I started digital photography with an entry level DSLR (Nikon 200) many years ago with a kit lens.... used it and took great pictures with it for years. Eventually I upgraded every aspect of my kit.

OTB
 
not to go too far off topic. but no VR at all and/or slow and variable aperture are not my ideas of lenses to buy. i have regretted that one already. now i wait till i can afford the right one.

but let it go. the Op is just beginning. who knows the direction he'll go. entry level with pop up and kit lens might do him just fine. i see plenty of people at events using what came from the store. as is. they seem to be enjoying themselves.

No VR for less than half the price.... depends on budget.

The variable aperture is a great travel lens. Mine:http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/729950-USA/Nikon_2191_AF_S_NIKKOR_28_300mm_f_3_5_5_6G.html

OTB
 
No VR for less than half the price.... depends on budget.

f/2.8 lenses all the way. I don't care if they have VR or not.

I love shooting in low-light without the flash. You need fast lenses for that. Some of the pro-bodies have the counter-balanced shutters, and they make a difference too. Some targets move, and the fast lenses are necessary to take the picture.

The issue is that if the shutter speed drops below 1/125th of a second on a 200 mm f/2.8 lens, you can get motion blur from the subject. I can't imagine shooting the same pictures on a 200mm lens f/5.6 and at 1/30th of a second or slower, even with VR.

The same issue happens even with 50mm lenses. A picture with a 50mm f/1.4 at 1/30 of a second lens is different than a picture taken at 50mm f/4.5 at 1/4th of a second with a VR Zoom. Subjects move in 1/4th of a second!
 
f/2.8 lenses all the way. I don't care if they have VR or not.

I love shooting in low-light without the flash. You need fast lenses for that. Some of the pro-bodies have the counter-balanced shutters, and they make a difference too. Some targets move, and the fast lenses are necessary to take the picture.

The issue is that if the shutter speed drops below 1/125th of a second on a 200 mm f/2.8 lens, you can get motion blur from the subject. I can't imagine shooting the same pictures on a 200mm lens f/5.6 and at 1/30th of a second or slower, even with VR.

The same issue happens even with 50mm lenses. A picture with a 50mm f/1.4 at 1/30 of a second lens is different than a picture taken at 50mm f/4.5 at 1/4th of a second with a VR Zoom. Subjects move in 1/4th of a second!

While I have a bunch of lenses I have 5 main lenses that I use (all Nikkor):

14-24 2.8
24-70 2.8
70-200 2.8 VR
28-300 3.5-5.6 VR (for travel)
50 1.4

Fast glass and a Pro Camera (3Ds) means I almost never need a flash and they can stop motion well (you can read the UPC code on a soccer ball mid-air)

OTB
 
Thanks for the responses, everybody. I think I have more questions than answers but I appreciate your input.

Well, I'd ask what you are planning on shooting? How much time will you have to devote to this? If you're only going to put it on auto and hold the shutter button down then, spend a couple of hours a month on the hobby and take pics of flowers, then, I'd save the money and get the cheaper option.
I honestly don't know what I plan on shooting. Everything? I suppose it would help if I knew but I don't. I don't really plan on concentrating on one subject. I just want to get into the hobby and see how it goes.

I was originally leaning towards the D5100 and I think that's the way I'm going to go. I wouldn't have to break the bank to buy the D7000 but I'm just not sure if that's the best way to go for me. I think it makes sense to start with the D5100 and see where it grows from there. While not as advanced as the D7000, it's still a camera I can grow into. My interest may fizzle eventually (but probably not) but if it doesn't I can always upgrade my gear down the road, right?

I know it was suggest that I buy just the body and forget about the kit lens. The body is $720 and the kit is $800. The kit lens alone is $180. Doesn't it make sense to get the lens for and extra $80?

I was also thinking of getting the Nikon DX Nikkor AF-S 35MM F 1.8. Is this a good start?
http://www.dpreview.com/lensreviews/nikon_35_1p8g_n15/default.asp
http://www.henrys.com/24040-NIKON-DX-NIKKOR-AF-S-35MM-F1-8-LENS.aspx

Kit lens
http://www.henrys.com/24037-NIKON-DX-AF-S-18-55-VR-F3-5-5-6.aspx
http://www.dpreview.com/lensreviews/nikon_18-55_3p5-5p6_vr_n15/