New TFSA contribution 2015

Yes, Barca, it's "hopeful economics" as opposed to your "hopeless economics". Saxon is entirely correct in his argument. How do I know? Well, when I was very young I spent a period (After I arrived back in Canada from England) dead broke, on welfare. I got my first job, in a dumpy factory, saved up enough to go to school and learn a trade, then I used the first trade to finance university and to open my first business. While I'm not exactly super rich, I'm certainly comfortable, and, yes, I added the $4,500 to my TFSA a couple of weeks ago. Trudeau has to pander to the feminist element of the Liberal Party, who will always favour welfare and taxation over productive work and savings. What he really thinks who knows? Perhaps we should ask him to make his banking records public, so we can see if he has maxed out his own TFSA....

Hopeless economics as you call it is the real world, where you eat what you kill and the little guy gets the shaft. Other than your hopeful expectations and political rhetoric do you have any data that supports your thesis?
 
I agree. We can't and shouldn't measure everything we do by "how does this help the poor?" Rising the TSFA limit doesn't hurt the poor (they are no poorer or richer because of it).

Quite to the contrary, by taking tax revenue out of the system and coupling it with the reduction in social programs because of reduced revenues, the poorest feel the immediate impact of these decisions. Or do you think the taxes being reduced were going nowhere?
 
A wholly illogical reply that completely misses the point. First of all, inheritances are tax free. Estates pay the tax on gains and are in no way eligible for TFSA contribution. And besides you could only do $10000 anyways regardless of how big an inheritance you receive! Somehow Trudeau's gold plated pension is relevant to whether Johnny can put away $5k or $10k of that inheritance money this year? Talk about a strawman argument!

I agree with you the an inheritance WHEN RECEIVED is tax free. However the interest earned on that money IS NOT tax free, it is taxable exactly the same as any other interest except that earned in a TFSA, a RRSP or other Registered Pension Plan. Also if Johnny has never contributed to a TSFA previously, he would be eligible to contribute up to $ 36,000 this year. Now you argue that Trudeau's gold plated pension is irrelevant. Well in your Canada if one person can't have something than nobody should have it. Like if Johnny's neighbour down the street can't afford to invest in a TFSA then Johnny shouldn't be allowed either. Also Trudeau's logic. I'm just following the logic of both yourself & Mr. Trudeau, if I & every other Canadian can't get a gold plated pension why should Trudeau get one. I forgot Mr. Trudeau is a Liberal and as one powerful Liberal a few years ago said Liberals are entitled to their entitlements; (like screw the average guy in Canada we're more important).

The only thing that would be TOTALLY fair if we are to follow your logic would be to tax everyone 100 % of their annual income and then give everyone in Canada the exact same monthly welfare payment to live on. Of course the government should confiscate all personal assets before enter the new socialist paradise so nobody has more toys than the person down the street.
 
The argument I made, in case you missed it, isn't that saving is bad. It's that helping people save through a TFSA (and the only ones who could do it in this economy right now are those already in advantageous financial positions on a comparative basis, don't read that as "rich" please) helps much fewer people than other strategies that would reach a much wider element of the population where you'd get the benefit not only of helping people who are already saving, save more (as this TFSA strategy does) but also help those not capable of saving right now (which this TFSA does not help) improve their finances so they too get a chance to save. Since this option takes your position and improves upon it by making it broader in impact and participation, what exactly is the argument against it?

Why aren't you also advocating for an immediate repeal of RRSP's, RRIF's and other registered pension plans as all those allow taxpayers to defer a portion of their income from taxes in the year the deposit is made and all earnings within the plan are tax free until taken out of the registered plan. Surely this discriminates against those who cannot afford to save for their own retirement. We really need to kill all individual incentive within this country so those with no or limited incentive to improve their lives aren't being discriminated against. Makes sense to me. LOL
 
Well, Barca, I'd like to back up my "thesis", if only I knew what it was! How's about: "Taxpayer money belongs to the taxpayer, until government has a very good reason for confiscating it". Or, "people ought to be allowed to keep a bit of their own money - oh, just a little bit, really - to look after themselves, rather than having to depend on government handouts, sorry, I meant to write programs". Or maybe the idea that "social programs mainly benefit the middle class at the expense of the truly poor, who don't know how to push the appropriate government buttons", or hows about, as a general principle, the idea that "people should be responsible for themselves, at least to the extent possible." And the basis of my arguments? Well, I'll go with "We hold these truths to be self-evident..." , at least for now (Let me guess you're an academic, right?)

Great, another one of those "no taxes" posts. Listen, this thread is about the effectiveness of the new TFSA contribution limits within the tax system we have now. It amazes me people can't stay with the topic and it devolves into the fantasy of a "no tax" system where somehow we live in the great country that is Canada but somehow it's all paid without taxes. You can start that fantasy topic if you wish,I'll stay on topic here and discuss the reality of our current tax system and how to maximize its effectiveness for all Canadians, not just a select few.
 
Why aren't you also advocating for an immediate repeal of RRSP's, RRIF's and other registered pension plans as all those allow taxpayers to defer a portion of their income from taxes in the year the deposit is made and all earnings within the plan are tax free until taken out of the registered plan. Surely this discriminates against those who cannot afford to save for their own retirement. We really need to kill all individual incentive within this country so those with no or limited incentive to improve their lives aren't being discriminated against. Makes sense to me. LOL

Canadians require a system that does encourage saving for retirement because the public pension system cannot be the only solution. I am not against these programs in their entirety, (although I thought the introduction of the TFSA was unnecessary since nobody in Canada was asking for it, it was a purely politically expedient move by the government at the time) however, these programs should stay within the context of how reachable it is for the greatest number of Canadians to benefit from it without taking away too much tax revenue that negatively impacts the most vulnerable in Canada.

In addition to that, both the RRSP and RRIF programs are tax-deferred as opposed to completely tax free. Which means, eventually some tax will be paid on it, usually at a reduced level. Society still benefits from that revenue. That is not the case with TFSAs. That is tax revenue that is completely lost.

I am an advocate of a simpler and fairer tax system. A larger tax exemption than the current $11,000 to north of $20,000 (which would benefit almost all Canadians earning income), a fairer marginal tax rate, a simpler private pension system (RRSPs) coupled with a public pension plan. Period.

A system with all these credits and programs just serves to complicate things and make it more difficult for those without access to costly accounting advice to benefit from available programs.
 
both the RRSP and RRIF programs are tax-deferred as opposed to completely tax free. Which means, eventually some tax will be paid on it, usually at a reduced level. Society still benefits from that revenue. That is not the case with TFSAs. That is tax revenue that is completely lost.
Contributions to RRSP's (later convertible to RRIF's) are tax deductible at the front end so it is logical and fair that they should be taxable at the back-end when the savings are withdrawn. Contributions to the TFSA are never tax-deductible.

I assume that the folks who have the money to put into an TFSA are also the highest taxed residents so I have no problem throwing a tiny bone to them in the form of the TFSA.
 
Contributions to RRSP's (later convertible to RRIF's) are tax deductible at the front end so it is logical and fair that they should be taxable at the back-end when the savings are withdrawn. Contributions to the TFSA are never tax-deductible.

I assume that the folks who have the money to put into an TFSA are also the highest taxed residents so I have no problem throwing a tiny bone to them in the form of the TFSA.

Because we need it? I don't recall anyone asking for it. The government surprised everyone with the increase.

What I do recall is large swaths of society (such as our First Nations) living in squalor and needing help. Schools closing. Decaying infrastructure. Soldiers returning from the Middle East needing help. But yeah, someone making $1,000,000 needs that extra $5,000 we just saved him.

I sometimes question our priorities as a society.
 
Because we need it? I don't recall anyone asking for it. The government surprised everyone with the increase.

What I do recall is large swaths of society (such as our First Nations) living in squalor and needing help. Schools closing. Decaying infrastructure. Soldiers returning from the Middle East needing help. But yeah, someone making $1,000,000 needs that extra $5,000 we just saved him.

I sometimes question our priorities as a society.

I don't recall anyone asking for a Charter of Rights, but Trudeau rammed it down our throats anyways.
 
TFSA is great for low income canadians, who can afford to contribute $100-200/month or maybe more? RRSP is totally useless for Canadians who earn under $30000/yr.

TFSA gives low income canadians a chance to save for their retirement, without interfering with OAS (old age security), and other means tested government benefits that they will get when retired or reach age 65 etc.

In my opinion, Trudeau should keep the TFSA yearly limit at $10000 if he wins the October 2015 federal election. Most canadians (from latest poll results), seem happy with the TFSA increase to $10000/yr.

With all the money the gov't wastes anyway,ie (ontario liberals wasting at least a billion dollars of taxpayers money on power plants that weren't even built), I don't really see a big deal that the TFSA maximum contribution has been increased from $5500 to 10000/yr.

Trudeau is not helping his election chances any by threatening to reduce the TFSA back to $5000/yr.

http://www.moneysense.ca/invest/rrsp/rrsp-vs-tfsa-which-is-right-for-you/

I agree and disagree with your post.

There are some reasons why the TFSA can be viewed as a positive tool for lower income Canadians. Those in lower marginal tax rates may not benefit "as much" from RRSP as those in higher marginal tax rates. However, it has been shown that poorer Canadians are a) not saving at all regardless of the program and b) misusing the programs anyways where the benefits to them are minimal to near zero (ie. Using GICs or savings accounts as TFSAs)

For these reasons alone, increasing the contribution limit does absolutely nothing for lower income Canadians and is purely beneficial to higher income earners. This is a fact. There was no reason for Harper to increase the contribution limits (amongst other tax breaks) other than to pad his pork barrel base.

Anyone who is genuinely interested in a fairer and possibly lower tax system wouldn't side with any of the plans I've seen from any of these crooked political parties and would instead look at an overall better tax system that gives everyone tax relief without favouring one group over another, especially when they're the most vulnerable of our society.

The funny thing is a system like that probably would give most users on TERB a more acceptable experience with taxes but instead we buy into the political rhetoric of Harper and his cronies. Such a shame Flaherty died instead of Harper. I respected his fiscal views more than our arrogant PM.
 
Great, another one of those "no taxes" posts. Listen, this thread is about the effectiveness of the new TFSA contribution limits within the tax system we have now. It amazes me people can't stay with the topic and it devolves into the fantasy of a "no tax" system where somehow we live in the great country that is Canada but somehow it's all paid without taxes. You can start that fantasy topic if you wish,I'll stay on topic here and discuss the reality of our current tax system and how to maximize its effectiveness for all Canadians, not just a select few.
You are not on topic.
This thread was about whether or not the new limit is in effect.

Has anyone made the extra contribution for the new TFSA limit of 10000 for those who max out of 5500. Not sure has it been confirm with the banks yet?
 
You are not on topic.
This thread was about whether or not the new limit is in effect.

Yes it's in effect. And here's hoping Trudeau doesn't get elected in the fall as he just wants to fuck up anything that says "tax free".
 
Now THAT is funny! Thanks
Here's another one. To paraphrase the late great Jack Layton: "Those who pay the most taxes should pay even more taxes. It's only fair."

I think it's nice that our government now and then throw a small bone to those taxpayers who are taxed the heaviest.
 
Here's another one. To paraphrase the late great Jack Layton: "Those who pay the most taxes should pay even more taxes. It's only fair."

I think it's nice that our government now and then throw a small bone to those taxpayers who are taxed the heaviest.

First of all, Jack Layton was an idiot and a phony. This lovefest people have with him post-morten is ridiculous.

Second of all, I see nothing nice in giving money to someone who doesn't need it at the expense of programs that benefit those in society that need it most. I'd just rather have a tax system that makes sense instead of making it up as we go along according to political expediency giving no thought to what is the right course of action for everyone to benefit.
 
Here's another one. To paraphrase the late great Jack Layton: "Those who pay the most taxes should pay even more taxes. It's only fair."

I think it's nice that our government now and then throw a small bone to those taxpayers who are taxed the heaviest.

Here is the important one: "pay according to ability, receive according to need"
 
You are uninformed. In this case the person obviously did not contribute to his TFSA in prior years nor did his spouse. So we are not talking $10K here we are talking $40K "headroom" PER person since inception in 2009 for a current max of $80K into the TFSA's. That's not small change nor is it $10K as you stated. Your position on TFSA's overall lacks thoughtfulness. Any hard working person should be able to invest their money however they see fit. The TFSA is not for the rich it is for families who want to save for the future. Why should they suffer in order to appease those you call "less fortunate?" I am sick of the Makers having to give to the "takers."

And besides you could only do $10000 anyways regardless of how big an inheritance you receive! Somehow Trudeau's gold plated pension is relevant to whether Johnny can put away $5k or $10k of that inheritance money this year? Talk about a strawman argument!

I can't stand Trudeau but he's spot on with the TFSA thing. It's bad for the less fortunate in Canada and completely favours the well-off. The ones that are getting ducked are the MANY in Canada that don't have the financial means to take advantage of this strategy and MOST of those who can don't really need the additional tax savings. We should be looking at a solution that benefits everyone, not just a select few. I believe in raising the exemption levels on everyone's income. A much easier and fairer way to reduce taxes. If Harper's treasury is so overflowing with money it's burning a hole in his pocket and he desperately wants to give money back to the Canadian people, this is the best way to do it. Or is it? It certainly wouldn't benefit his base more than those that don't support him, like the poor. So it wouldn't be an advantage for him would it?
 
For clarity you can invest in almost any available equity inside your TFSA. Growth is tax free and as an OP mentioned you can withdraw at anytime however cannot turn around and recontribute funds over the max headroom in any given fiscal year. A small point perhaps but fyi if you incur a capital loss inside any registered fund you cannot claim that loss against other capital gains.
 
Obviously I love TFSA's :) I think the Libs will announce the claw back to $5.5K this year in order to prevent people from funding $10K in early January. What won't happen is any retroactive claw back nonsense as that would be an administrative nightmare. Even Trudeau can't be that asinine can he? They need to complete a plan to Robin Hood as much of our money as they can so I am using similar efforts to figure out how to keep them out of my pocket. So it's me the lowly MBA tax consultant against the part time drama teacher and his gang of merry thieves. And btw why do the "progressives" assume that low income earners are lazy and stupid? Perhaps many of them are maxing their TFSA's and managing them properly to accumulate wealth? If "Joe" needs to spend $200/week on smokes and booze and who knows what else while "Mary" puts that same $200/week into her TFSA why should Mary suffer? And yes I have seen all of the graphs demonstrating who is utilizing and maxing TFSA's.