New TFSA contribution 2015

youwontknow

Banned
Sep 19, 2008
910
3
0
Has anyone made the extra contribution for the new TFSA limit of 10000 for those who max out of 5500. Not sure has it been confirm with the banks yet?
 
RBC says you can. The globe, National post and advisor.ca [whoever the latter is] all say that they CRA spokesmen have cleared it.
I seem to recall reading that both Oliver and the CRA head fromage say it's good to go.
Trudeau said when he is PM he will cancel the increased limit (but maybe not retroactively). He said it is unfair for those people who don't have the money.
 
QUOTE=SkyRider;5230761]Trudeau said when he is PM he will cancel the increased limit (but maybe not retroactively). He said it is unfair for those people who don't have the money.[/QUOTE]

Take the case of little Johnnie who has been raising a family on say $40,000 dollars a year and struggling to keep a roof over his head and food on the table. Now a relative dies and leaves him a small inheritance that he would like to put away for a future rainy day. Justin then comes along with his $200,000 a year salary and his gold plated MP pension plan and says "Fuck Johnny, he is denying the government its right to the $75 a year tax on each $10,000 investment (assuming 3% interest @ a tax rate of 25%) he can make in a TFSA, that tax evasion will bankrupt the federal government".

So Justin's sucking up a quarter of a million dollars per year is completely fair to the people who don't have any spare money but little Johnny's small windfall must be taxed away from him. If Johnny keeps hid funds in the TFSA for 50 years the missed tax won't come close to Justin's annual sucking at the public trough.


What a great leader, what great thinking skills, what great compassion, what a load of BS.
 
Trudeau just hates the thought of anyone keeping even a few cents away from the tax man, no he's not happy unless his Liberals are taxing every last penny you have.
 
RBC says you can. The globe, National post and advisor.ca [whoever the latter is] all say that they CRA spokesmen have cleared it.
I seem to recall reading that both Oliver and the CRA head fromage say it's good to go.

Seems tradition is that the moment it is announced you can act on it in these cases. There are reasons for that but I'll let someone else explain it.
The govt has a majority so it will pass
 
CRA says you are good to go with the higher limit for 2015.

I just added the $4500 extra to my account - no issues.

Get it in now before Trudeau tries to screw everything up!!
 
Trudeau just hates the thought of anyone keeping even a few cents away from the tax man, no he's not happy unless his Liberals are taxing every last penny you have.

Sounds like the ding bat running Ontario into bankruptcy.
 
Trudeau said when he is PM he will cancel the increased limit (but maybe not retroactively). He said it is unfair for those people who don't have the money.

Take the case of little Johnnie who has been raising a family on say $40,000 dollars a year and struggling to keep a roof over his head and food on the table. Now a relative dies and leaves him a small inheritance that he would like to put away for a future rainy day. Justin then comes along with his $200,000 a year salary and his gold plated MP pension plan and says "Fuck Johnny, he is denying the government its right to the $75 a year tax on each $10,000 investment (assuming 3% interest @ a tax rate of 25%) he can make in a TFSA, that tax evasion will bankrupt the federal government".

So Justin's sucking up a quarter of a million dollars per year is completely fair to the people who don't have any spare money but little Johnny's small windfall must be taxed away from him. If Johnny keeps hid funds in the TFSA for 50 years the missed tax won't come close to Justin's annual sucking at the public trough.


What a great leader, what great thinking skills, what great compassion, what a load of BS.

A wholly illogical reply that completely misses the point. First of all, inheritances are tax free. Estates pay the tax on gains and are in no way eligible for TFSA contribution. And besides you could only do $10000 anyways regardless of how big an inheritance you receive! Somehow Trudeau's gold plated pension is relevant to whether Johnny can put away $5k or $10k of that inheritance money this year? Talk about a strawman argument!

I can't stand Trudeau but he's spot on with the TFSA thing. It's bad for the less fortunate in Canada and completely favours the well-off. The ones that are getting ducked are the MANY in Canada that don't have the financial means to take advantage of this strategy and MOST of those who can don't really need the additional tax savings. We should be looking at a solution that benefits everyone, not just a select few. I believe in raising the exemption levels on everyone's income. A much easier and fairer way to reduce taxes. If Harper's treasury is so overflowing with money it's burning a hole in his pocket and he desperately wants to give money back to the Canadian people, this is the best way to do it. Or is it? It certainly wouldn't benefit his base more than those that don't support him, like the poor. So it wouldn't be an advantage for him would it?
 
I believe the argument is that he of all people don't have a leg to stand on when bitching about other people being able to save money. Much like how an earth rapist like Suzuki or Al Gore are not really in a position to lecture people on how they should green up. It doesn't mean they are right or wrong about their positions, it is just that they can't be taken too seriously as spokesmen. Like a fat smoker doctor telling patients to live healthier. He is right but it is a bit rich coming from a dude whose 60 inch gut quivers every time he hacks a lung from his latest smoke.


As for the TFSA. Saving is good for the economy. You should tax bad stuff and avoid taxing good stuff. Anyways, for the ultra rich a 10K per year limit is a drop in the bucket.

Think it through. If by having what Trudeau has, can any politician speak on behalf of the poor? Will it just be first-termers? By that rationale, no politician can do anything for the poor. A ridiculous position.

There is a logical fallacy called an Ad Hominem attack and making the argument about Trudeau's privileged life is a classic example of it. Attacking the person not the point renders the argument moot.

And saving is definitely good, but someone needs to explain to me how giving the poor more room to save when they couldn't even use up the original $5500 will help them in any way? Are we instituting our own version of Reaganomics? Cause the only thing that I know of that flows downhill is shit not money.
 
It isn't an ad hominem attack if you are just attacking the person and not the argument.

It is ad hominem to negate a persons position due to an unrelated personal quality or characteristic. That is exactly what the argument in this thread was doing to Trudeau. So it is 100% a logical fallacy.

There is a huge difference between saying that someone is wrong because they are a two faced shit and simply saying someone is a two faced shit who happens to be wrong because of X Y and Z. It is a subtle difference.

Right. And the argument against Trudeau falls in your first example which is classic ad hominem.

Speaking of ad hominem attacks, are you suggesting that just because something is associated with Reagan it is automatically incorrect because I don't see you putting much argument against it.

No. I'm not sure you even understand my post properly. You're not even clear on what constitutes a logical fallacy.

Increasing the TFSA helps very few poor people [probably me and 5 other guys in weird situations]. However anything that lightens the load on taxation on investment leaves more money for investment. If you can't see how that can be only a good thing, may I suggest going into an empty field with your bare hands and build a car or develop a new drug cure or make a new porn scene and employee people to do the same.

Wow. You just pepper your arguments with illogical reasonings don't you?

The trickle down theory is badly argued but a higher saving rate all else being equal leads to a more prosperous economy down the road. Anyone who disagrees is well... wrong. I really couldn't be bothered to explain the obvious. Having rich people buy more shit doesn't do anything [broken window fallacy] having anyone save more is a different story.

If you can't explain the obvious, what can you explain?

The argument I made, in case you missed it, isn't that saving is bad. It's that helping people save through a TFSA (and the only ones who could do it in this economy right now are those already in advantageous financial positions on a comparative basis, don't read that as "rich" please) helps much fewer people than other strategies that would reach a much wider element of the population where you'd get the benefit not only of helping people who are already saving, save more (as this TFSA strategy does) but also help those not capable of saving right now (which this TFSA does not help) improve their finances so they too get a chance to save. Since this option takes your position and improves upon it by making it broader in impact and participation, what exactly is the argument against it?
 
...

I can't stand Trudeau but he's spot on with the TFSA thing. It's bad for the less fortunate in Canada and completely favours the well-off. The ones that are getting ducked are the MANY in Canada that don't have the financial means to take advantage of this strategy and MOST of those who can don't really need the additional tax savings. We should be looking at a solution that benefits everyone, not just a select few. I believe in raising the exemption levels on everyone's income. A much easier and fairer way to reduce taxes. If Harper's treasury is so overflowing with money it's burning a hole in his pocket and he desperately wants to give money back to the Canadian people, this is the best way to do it. Or is it? It certainly wouldn't benefit his base more than those that don't support him, like the poor. So it wouldn't be an advantage for him would it?
Where to start.

First, it does NOT favour the "well-off". They have a lot more money they're looking to hide from taxes every year: they're maxing out their RRSP contribution, and investing overseas. Can they also take advantage of the TFSA? Sure, but so can anyone. But for the rich, managing an account with only a few thousand dollars in it costs them more than it saves them.

If you normally keep a balance of, say, $500 in your checking account, you can easily put some of that into a TFSA instead - you aren't punished for taking it out as you would be in other investment vehicles, and what interest you earn is tax-free instead of being taxed as it is in your checking account.

The analyses published by the public service indicate that there are a large number of individuals who are far from rich who are able to benefit from the TFSA.
 
Unused TFSA contributions carry forward so someone who can't afford to max out their TFSA today can catch up in later yrs. just because you are low income today doesn't mean you are always are going to be low income. Most people start at the bottom when they enter the workforce but climb the ladder as they get older.
 
Unused TFSA contributions carry forward so someone who can't afford to max out their TFSA today can catch up in later yrs. just because you are low income today doesn't mean you are always are going to be low income. Most people start at the bottom when they enter the workforce but climb the ladder as they get older.

I see. I call that "hopeful economics". Benefits based on events yet to and unknown whether they will happen.

And frankly, as a society I'd hope we'd do the best we can to help them (the poor) today AND in the future rather than just hoping in a better future.

You'd think we'd learn from revolutions past.
 
My $0.02 is that this doesn't help the poor BUT it does help avid savers who we all know are in the minority today... That said I'm not sure why this is a major issue... While I'm not a fan of Harper I look at this and say hey he hasn't taken anything away from us... Just given those who want to save and not rely on the government in the future an enhanced means to do so! I for one say thank you...

I see. I call that "hopeful economics". Benefits based on events yet to and unknown whether they will happen.

And frankly, as a society I'd hope we'd do the best we can to help them (the poor) today AND in the future rather than just hoping in a better future.

You'd think we'd learn from revolutions past.
 
My $0.02 is that this doesn't help the poor BUT it does help avid savers who we all know are in the minority today... That said I'm not sure why this is a major issue... While I'm not a fan of Harper I look at this and say hey he hasn't taken anything away from us... Just given those who want to save and not rely on the government in the future an enhanced means to do so! I for one say thank you...
I agree. We can't and shouldn't measure everything we do by "how does this help the poor?" Rising the TSFA limit doesn't hurt the poor (they are no poorer or richer because of it).