New Ontario "wealth" tax how does it work

It is a marginal tax rate. You pay the increased tax rate only for the portion of income in the tax bracket.
 
It is a marginal tax rate. You pay the increased tax rate only for the portion of income in the tax bracket.
So if your income is $250,000 (250-220k) it will cost another $936 (3.12% of 30k) is this correct?
 
It reads to me that they are adding two more tax brackets.
Old:
0-40120 .0505
40120-80242 .0915
80242-514090 0.1116
514090+ 0.1316

New
0-40120 .0505
40120-80242 0.0915
802420-120000 .1116
120001-220000 .1216
220000-514090 .1316

The article suggests that at 200,000 the additional tax collected is 780.00, and at 400k is 6708.
There will be a new t4127-14f from the CRA when it is implemented.
 
I am down by Bay street today, oddly, no sign off pushing and shoving to get on the next flight out of town among the muckymucks. Looks like they will just pay it.
 
Does anyone actually think is going to work? For starters, who decided that $220k/yr was wealthy? Secondly, it's such a paltry %, it's barely going to make an impact unless people are making vastly more than that. And those that do make vastly more that have so many tax shelters they won't ever pay it.

This is political pandering. Let the masses think politicians are asking the "rich" to pay their fair share while simultaneously not closing ANY of the loopholes their biggest contributors use to hide their money. Of course, the biggest reason we know it's pandering is because the rich already pay more than their share of taxes. This "wealth tax" accomplishes one thing: it asks the upper-middle class to pay more. Which is hilarious because the middle class whines and cries about the shrinking size of the middle class while simultaneously wanting anyone who makes more than them to pay more.

It's a perfect example of why society fails. Business leaders have huge paydays because they're greedy, and everyone who isn't them whines and cries about how unfair it is and how there's no need for them to make that much. But if they happen to live comfortably, God forbid you ask them to kick in more, or ask them to take a cut, or ask them to sacrifice anything. Everyone, at all levels, is greedy. The rich get to buy their support with money, the middle class gets to feel supported because they have numbers to vote, and no one in the group gives a shit about the poor.

I'm well above this "wealth" limit, and I can pretty much guarantee you that I will only end of paying a fraction of what I should because I happen to have a good accountant. I don't consider myself rich, I consider myself upper-middle class. Upper enough to be able to never worry about money, which means I can see the greed both above and below me. I couldn't buy myself a private yacht with a 20-person crew and a helicopter, but I also realize I don't need one. If my taxes go up an extra $2k after I shelter a bunch, fine. I can live with that. But when my neighbours complain that "no one needs" to make $200k/yr, I laugh behind their backs. They're at about $180k/yr. They're capable of being extremely comfortable if they'd stop letting the bank own everything and living on debt, but they're just too greedy. And if they had set this new tax at the $150k/yr limit, they'd be screaming foul.

The hypocrisy of society. Everyone wants, no one wants to give. It's why I've learned to be happy with what I have. When I made $80k/yr, I was happy. Now that I make substantially more, I'm still happy. I do miss living in Alberta however. Flat tax really does seem the most fair to me. Everyone kick in their 13% or whatever it is and call it done. The guy making $1mil can fork over his $130k income tax, the guy making $100k can pay his $13k and the guy making $50k can pay his $6.5k. Even distribution across the board. "Tax the rich" is simply mod rule punishing those who make more money. It's greed going after the greedy and every time it's been tried, it's failed to generate the increased revenue that the masses and the government wanted. I don't really see this being any different.
 
...

The hypocrisy of society. Everyone wants, no one wants to give.....

Pretty much.

I'm "only" in the 120-220 range and have little difficulty if my taxes went up a few hundred. Better the government getting it from me rather than some family making $50,000.

The topic of tax shelters is another hypocrisy. People who could easily afford one less latte a day complaining about taxes when they end up paying less than the average working stiff annoys me (and the government knows that an increase in upper tax rates will likely not have much overall impact because of it).


p.s. BL, being in the top percentile or two of income earners does make us wealthy. Not stupid wealthy but still wealthy.
 
BL, being in the top percentile or two of income earners does make us wealthy. Not stupid wealthy but still wealthy.

Well off, not wealthy. The borderline 1 percent are people with high salaries, not high net worth. The difference between that and being wealthy is that unemployment can make it all go away. To me, wealthy means not having to work unless you want to, and still being able to sip mixed drinks at the country club.
 
They should have added more tax brackets on top of that, or at least plan to do that in the future. While a flat tax may be the "fairest" way to do things, a progressive tax is far better for society.
 
They should have added more tax brackets on top of that, or at least plan to do that in the future. While a flat tax may be the "fairest" way to do things, a progressive tax is far better for society.

Far better how? On paper via math?

Economics isn't a purely mathematical endeavor, and despite the fact that we like to think we invented it, we're still grasping at straws trying to figure it out. Just look at the start differences between Keynesian and Austrian economic theory. Raising taxes has been shown not to necessarily correlate with an increase in tax revenues. You also have to consider that the upper end of the spectrum, the real high end, are capable of moving and hiding money in ways you can't fathom, not to mention a lot of the time, they're "income" isn't in a taxable form. Stock options, for example, have many ways to legally be non-taxable or reduced-tax, as are a variety of other compensation methods. You want the 1% to pay more taxes? They already do, and they probably aren't going to kick in more.

All you have to do is look at the numbers in America to see that this is already happening. The top 10% pay over 70% of all income taxes. This largely isn't being paid by the top 1%, it's being paid by the upper middle class. If you're Mitt Romney, or Bill Gates, or some other bajillionaire, you can probably snake your way into paying ~10-15% federal income tax. That's "the rich". The people that the guy making $50k/yr needs to get to feel his pain and side with him is shouldering the burden upwards of 30-40%. Why should I give a shit about a guy making $50k/yr that thinks paying his 20% tax is rough when he's willing to pile 40% on me?

As long as the middle class continues to remain divided, the wealth distribution and the unfair tax burdens will remain the same. And the only way to fix it is to have politicians close the loopholes... on themselves and their campaign contributors. There's the rich, there's the people not paying their share. If they did, the flat tax rate would work great. Don't get me wrong, when I say flat tax, I recognize there needs to be a cutoff. If you live below the poverty, your part of the tax bill is on me. I'm ok with that. But if you're making $70k/yr and you're saying you think you should pay less than $30k in taxes while simultaneously telling me that my $160k/yr tax bill "isn't doing my share", I'm going to tell you to fuck off, especially if you're rolling around in an SUV and your 7 and 8 year old have cell phones and iPads, with a 50 inch HDTV on your shelf and an Xbox and Playstation in your entertainment center. I drive a hybrid Ford Fusion, I have exactly 1 phone, no TV and no gaming consoles.

People today have more disposable income than they ever did before, they won't give up a dollar to help a homeless guy on the street, they're more wasteful than I would ever imagine, and they want me to subsidize their living?

I'd love to see you explain how progressive tax is better for society and isn't just a con. The biggest reason given for progressive tax is to ensure a fair distribution of wealth. How's that working out for you? The bulk of Canada and USA have been using progressive tax for a long, long time... Is wealth distribution fair? Nope. Is it becoming more fair or less? Less. So that obviously fails.

What's best for society is to tax people based on how they spend. Reward those who save, punish those who like to lavish themselves. If I make $100k/yr and dump $80k into banks, I'm stimulating the economy. That's money that can be used to leverage loans and generate wealth for the good of everyone. If, on the other hand, I only save $20k/yr, I'm obviously being wasteful and choosing to spend my money on myself instead in greedy ways and should pay more. The guy saving is already helping him out, tax him very little. The guy spending a boatload should be taxed on his boatload.

"Progressive Consumption Tax". I'm all in favour. It also means the guy buying a $450mil estate isn't going to be able to shelter his income since he's paying taxes based on his consumption.

But Progressive Income Tax? It fails to achieve it's desired goals and is not fair. I flat out reject the claim that it's better for society based on exactly those reasons. Start closing some loopholes and I might agree with you. But then, if we closed the loopholes, we would have enough income with a lower flat tax anyway.
 
I consider it borderline criminal to take almost 50% of someone's income. Especially since a large portion of our tax dollars are wasted on inefficiencies and fraud.

Money is mobile and people will usually find tax avoidance schemes when rates are too high. Could very well lead in a drop of tax revenues. How government leaders cannot see this is beyond me. Then again most of our politicians are lawyers by trade - the only thing they know about money and economics is how to overbill a client.
 
"I'm well above this "wealth" limit, and I can pretty much guarantee you that I will only end of paying a fraction of what I should because I happen to have a good accountant."

Bluelaser, i don't disagree with your conclusion, but inequality and unfairness in the tax system is based on more than merely its progressive nature. Some people (you, apparently) have an income stream that can be manipulated such that you will pay less that some relatively well paid wage slave, like myself. That rankles.
(But can I get the name of your accountant?)
 
Especially since a large portion of our tax dollars are wasted on inefficiencies and fraud.

Money is mobile and people will usually find tax avoidance schemes when rates are too high.

I agree with that first point. Our focus should be foremost on making better use of existing funds.

As to the second point, people will use tax avoidance schemes regardless of how low or high rates are. Federal rates are significantly lower now than they were for the majority of the 20th century, yet people still look for these loopholes. I have no idea what the history of provincial rates are in Ontario, but I wouldn't be surprised to hear they've followed suit.
 
Another way to view a progressive tax system is as a flat tax with discounted tax rates for lower incomes. Look at it this way - a good chunk of my income is taxed at the highest marginal tax bracket, effectively flat. I get a break on the first chunk of income, but that break isn't nearly as important to me as someone who tops out in the lower brackets.

There is a certain minimum of take-home income that people need to survive, and i don't mind giving those with lower income a break on the rate to keep some money in their pocket for the basics in life.