New definition of shouting

  • Thread starter Thread starter burt-oh-my!
  • Start date Start date
B

burt-oh-my!

Is it just me, or has anyone else noticed that 'shouting' ain't what it used to be?

i have had a few interactions with, it must be said, females exclusively, over the last year or so, where there was an argument, and I was talking in a firm strong voice. Nothing out of the ordinary really, just maybe a bit impassioned, I suppose. But to my astonishment, I was in a few cases accused of shouting!

Now, to me, shouting is hollerring 'Hello!' to a friend down the street. Shouting is what you do when you try and get the attention of someone who is operating a lawnmower. Shouting is what you do when you see a child about to chase a ball out onto a busy street. A shout is a loud vocalization characterized by the need to take in much more air than usual into the lungs, to give real tremendous almost maximum, volume. But speaking in a firm voice? THAT'S shouting? The way I was talking was many, many decibels below a shout.



IMO it's just a way to introduce a completely irrelevant attack into the argument when all other avenues of reasoned debate have deserted you.
 
It sounds like the ladies you are talking to are feeling like you are trying to bully them with strongly voiced opinion, and perhaps not respecting their own position. If you want to get along with said ladies, you might try to tone it down a notch. Its not irrelevant if that's what the ladies are feeling. The fact that several ladies have said the same thing suggests that you need to modify your debating strategy. Whether you call it shouting or raising your voice or speaking with passion is what's irrelevant. It is what it is.
 
You are missing the point entirely - I am not asking you how to get along with these particular people - maybe I don't want to 'get along' with them. Maybe neither they nor I respect each other's opinion. These are not super-important debates about capital punishment or how to lower the deficit - more like everyday things.

The point is since when is talking considered shouting just because you happen to disagree?

rubmeister - acutally, it is the fact that i am completely calm that makes it so irritating!

I think that in essence they are saying, "If you insist on refuting my arguments in a convincing fashion that I am powerless to counter=argue, in anything other than a whisper, you are shouting.
 
These are not women I am having a relationship with - they are not part of my family or anything like that. I have no interest in them whatsoever, other than just normal human interactions.

Also, I have no idea if men do this too, but I haven't had the same problem with a dude.
 
no one is yelled at or punished or talked down to any more in the friendly little society we have where everyone is afraid to hurt anyone's feelings. yelling is when you go down into the bottom of your lungs build up some pressure and say "go fuck yourself" as loud as your voice will take you. the whole world is turned into a pussy, a big sloppy pussy.

oh and i have yelled at guys and they have yelled back and i have never heard or said the words "stop yelling at me".
 
You guys are complaining about the arguments you have with women???? Have you figured out yet that arguing with women does not get you laid? That's why I do all my arguing on terb.
 
You guys are complaining about the arguments you have with women???? Have you figured out yet that arguing with women does not get you laid? That's why I do all my arguing on terb.

Ah that's fucking priceless!

So much of fuji explained in so few words!

AHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!

Fuji, this should be your signature line!
 
You are missing the point entirely - I am not asking you how to get along with these particular people - maybe I don't want to 'get along' with them. Maybe neither they nor I respect each other's opinion. These are not super-important debates about capital punishment or how to lower the deficit - more like everyday things.
OKay, okay, you don't need to shout. Sheesh! :biggrin1:
...Maybe neither they nor I respect each other's opinion...

The point is since when is talking considered shouting just because you happen to disagree?


rubmeister - acutally, it is the fact that i am completely calm that makes it so irritating!

I think that in essence they are saying, "If you insist on refuting my arguments in a convincing fashion that I am powerless to counter=argue, in anything other than a whisper, you are shouting.
I can only go by what you yourself say, since I was not there. If you don't care about respecting them and they do not care about respecting you, then maybe you should kick them to the curb. It doesn't sound like a good situation to me. But maybe you thrive on confrontation and argument. And maybe the ladies don't. But if you are calm as you say when they say this to you, then maybe it is lack of a good response that brings them to that point.
 
Is it just me, or has anyone else noticed that 'shouting' ain't what it used to be?

i have had a few interactions with, it must be said, females exclusively, over the last year or so, where there was an argument, and I was talking in a firm strong voice. Nothing out of the ordinary really, just maybe a bit impassioned, I suppose. But to my astonishment, I was in a few cases accused of shouting!

Now, to me, shouting is hollerring 'Hello!' to a friend down the street. Shouting is what you do when you try and get the attention of someone who is operating a lawnmower. Shouting is what you do when you see a child about to chase a ball out onto a busy street. A shout is a loud vocalization characterized by the need to take in much more air than usual into the lungs, to give real tremendous almost maximum, volume. But speaking in a firm voice? THAT'S shouting? The way I was talking was many, many decibels below a shout.



IMO it's just a way to introduce a completely irrelevant attack into the argument when all other avenues of reasoned debate have deserted you.

I hear you. Wife pulls the same shit every time I get the upper hand in a heated discussion.
When I show her a dictionary or email her a definition of 'shout' she gets ticked. :thumb:
 
I hear you. Wife pulls the same shit every time I get the upper hand in a heated discussion.
When I show her a dictionary or email her a definition of 'shout' she gets ticked. :thumb:

Problem is you need a recording of whatever went on to prove your point. Any sort of stress in the voice can be considered shouting by some (woman usually)...and it is impossible to prove that you were not shouting ...after the fact.
 
There is no preset decible level that defines what a shout is, there is however a difference between shouting out loud, and shouting at someone ,the latter is normally done in anger and directed at someone.

It may have been more accurate for her to say "don't raise your voice at me" ,but shouting has different meanings depending on the context.