New Car Question - Paint Protection

Boyscout352

Member
Jan 20, 2004
173
0
16
When buying a new car, the business rep will usually sell you the following things: Extended Warranty, Rust Proofing, Fabric Protection, and Paint protection/sealant.

Is it worth to pay extra for this (marked-up) paint protection/sealant? Does the car need it? Does it make any difference?

If so, are there places outside the dealer that does paint protection/sealant?

Thanks
 
I'll echo what's said above...

...and also tell you that the paint sealants are a waste of time with today's base coat/clearcoat vehicle finishes. Sealants were OK in the days of acrylic enamel, when bright colours, especially red, would fade drastically in a short period of time, but today's paint finishes are fairly fade resistant...


N2G
 
As new said, the newer finishes do not benefit from paint sealers and with most manufacturers having a no rust through warranty of 10 years, rest proofing is also not necessary.

These items are high profit items that the dealers sell to boost their profits...

If I were you I'd be looking at other value added items for your vehicle that will help with the resale down the road....
 
It's all a huge scam.

Rust proofing has never been proven to work. It actually voids your factory warrantee by the way if you read the moust print. Ask yourself what you would rather have, a factory warrantee, or a joe blow, I'll be out of business in 2 years warrantee.

As far as the paint sealer goes, you can buy the stuff yourself and you will do a better job than the guy at the dealership putting it on, if he even does it.

They're more likely to not even put it on and still charge you for it.
 
Looks like everyone's giving you the thumbs down on all that (Extended Warranty, Rust Proofing, Fabric Protection, and Paint protection/sealant.)

But I got it done (except for the ext warranty)... they all came in a package and it was near-free (yay to promos!)... I have a Saturn so the paint process is slightly different for my dent-resistant panels, therefore the paint protection comes in handy to keep my car vibrant... that's all I really wanted, the fabric and rust stuff was included so it really didn't matter to me.

The only advantage for all that stuff is resale value, by protecting your car now, it;ll be good for the future if you decide to sell it to someone else.
 
Gawd said:
The only advantage for all that stuff is resale value, by protecting your car now, it;ll be good for the future if you decide to sell it to someone else.

Umm don't count on it.....if you look at the value of used vehicles one that has had aftermarket rust proofing doesn't add any value to the vehicle. If you look at the criteria, you won't find it....ie: mileage, condition, options...the only way I can see it adding ANY value is if it does keep the paint vibrant as you say, but the manufacturer's warranty should do that....

Correct me if I'm wrong but aren't those "dent resistant panels" molded in the colour not painted? I know the plastic fiero panels were, not sure about the saturn's......
 
james t kirk said:
It's all a huge scam.

Rust proofing has never been proven to work. It actually voids your factory warrantee by the way if you read the moust print.
Hmmm, rust proofing never proven to work?
Got links to show this?
I just started proofing my car since last year.
Going to do it again, unless you show otherwise.
Where did you hear/read about this?
 
Rustproofing definitely works but it doesn't start to pay off until the car is older. A three year old car with rustproofing will sell in the market for exactly the same price as a three year old car without rustproofing simply because both cars appear the same. If you buy a new car and spend 100 bucks each year to rustproof it and then sell it after three years you will probably not be able to get 300 dollars more for the car but after ten or fifteen years the difference will be quite noticeable and therefore the resell price will be higher.

The question becomes; do you expect to keep the vehicle long enough for it to pay off? The other consideration is that properly applied rustproofing will also protect other components of the vehicle from rust such as shocks/struts, brake lines, the parking brake cable etc. For me personally, the cost of rustproofing is so low compared to the cost of the vehicle I just do it. Maybe I keep the vehicle or keep it in the family and it pays off or maybe not.
 
jjwilson said:
The question becomes; do you expect to keep the vehicle long enough for it to pay off? The other consideration is that properly applied rustproofing will also protect other components of the vehicle from rust such as shocks/struts, brake lines, the parking brake cable etc.

Well, if they are coating the emergency brake cable (which has a plastic covering) then I'd sue their ass because it can cause the cable to jam and not operate.....If they are coating any moving parts at all they are not protecting them, they are preventing them from operating properly.....They shouldn't be coating any: engine components, driveline components, brake components, steering components or suspencion components. In addition, if they clog the drain holes in the body and bottom of the doors then they are just causing more damage than they prevent by not permitting rain water etc from draining properly.....
 
Geeeezus, now you're making me wonder about my rustproofing that I got done last year and the year before :eek:
 
tboy said:
Well, if they are coating the emergency brake cable (which has a plastic covering) then I'd sue their ass because it can cause the cable to jam and not operate.....If they are coating any moving parts at all they are not protecting them, they are preventing them from operating properly.....They shouldn't be coating any: engine components, driveline components, brake components, steering components or suspencion components. In addition, if they clog the drain holes in the body and bottom of the doors then they are just causing more damage than they prevent by not permitting rain water etc from draining properly.....

It all depends what kind of rustproofing you're talking about. I use Krown and here is a clip from their website:

The Krown Process;

Is Compatible with other types of undercoating / rust-proofing
Is non-toxic in nature and contains no solvents or other hazardous or dangerous chemicals
Is safe to spray on electrical connections and wiring.
Has the ability to creep into all cracks and crevices.
Is self-healing.
Displaces moisture.
Is a penetrant / Lubricant / Corrosion Inhibitor.
Is unequaled in the marketplace

And here's a clip from Rustcheck's website:

Rust Check "Rust Proofing"
Protects electrical systems and components.
Penetrates and lubricates all moving parts.
Penetrates existing rust to protect metal.
Bonds to all surfaces for lasting protection.
Completely protects seams and support braces.
Will not clog drain holes.
Creeps into seams and crevices to lock out moisture.

I'm not associated with either product. Both products are based on a light viscosity oil spray which will not cause the problems you are suggesting.
 
Not much use for any of those processes sold by the dealer, and yes, sometimes they won't even bother to do all of the work properly.

No car which was manufactured in the last 10 years has any tendency to surface corrosion, except where the owner chose not to prompotly repair dents & scratches. This is the most dramatic area improvement in mass production cars.

Drilling holes into the doors to fill them with rust inhibitor is a waste, and if not done perfectly it won't work at all. There is no need for this with todays cars. They will rust out eventually, but only at an age when they're worth no more than $3000 in any condition.

Anual underbody spraying is still a good idea and fairly inexpensive insurance for any chasis components which are not sealed - especially if you are not spending the extra money to have everything cleaned and lubed with each oil change.

If you got all of those items done for free, there's no harm in it, although in the long run you'd probably get better value out of the Extended Warranty than any of that other stuff.
 
Paint protection does make a difference. It is like putting a thick coat of wax on your car. It makes the car’s paint shine allot better. I have paint protection on my car and it gives the car a much better look. A friend of mine has the same car which is the same colour as mine and I notice that his car doesn’t have the same kind of shine to it regardless as to how often he washes it. The only time I would say not to get paint protection is if you are into waxing and polishing your car allot. Because that will add the same type of protection. However most people do not know how to properly wax their car. And it can be a hassle.

Rust proofing does work. But you don’t have to get it done at the dealership. There are places out there that do a good job for less. Krown is one of them. I have had all my cars rust proofed since the day I bought them. And believe me it does make a difference. I had a Mustang which I always rust proofed every year and it was always parked outside winter and summer. The car never had a bit of rust on it even after 8 years. Where as my brother never got his car rust proofed, park it beside mine and began to get rust after 5 years. So if you are into keeping your cars for a long time, 5 + years, then I would suggest getting it rust proofed. If you are the type that changes your car every few years, then don’t bother.
 
Talked to my buddy (phenomenal mechanic and knows his shit).
I mentioned all this rust proofing talk and he said, the Krown Rust is fine, because it's vegetable oil based and it's not a sealant but rather a coat.
It pulls/draws moisture away from metal at the same time.
Whereas, other products are sealants, do harden and if sprayed on moving parts will hinder it.
I'll trust my buddy any day of the week. I've seen the under body of his pick-up. Immaculate and it runs fine.
 
tboy said:
Correct me if I'm wrong but aren't those "dent resistant panels" molded in the colour not painted? I know the plastic fiero panels were, not sure about the saturn's......

Nope... painted on like every other car... only difference is the heating and more flex agent to ensure the paint doesn't crack too easily because it's on flexible panels.

I'm not complaining cuz I got absolutely no dings on my Saturn! Compared to my 8 on my last car!

And yes... paint protectant makes the paint look way more vibrant and stands out much more... and in the long run too.