New car price negotiation.

Despo

New member
Jun 22, 2010
263
0
0
I helped a family member purchase a new car last week. I got 2,000 off the 30k asking price, $500 accessory and .99 % financing over 84 months. I kinda felt I left something on the table. For the record I don't much care for bargaining-haggling as I don't feel good destroying the salesman. I could as a salesperson of 30 years trained in the art of nlp and shopping his price .. but still did I do okay or did I make his job too easy..what have you negotiated on a new car purchase
 
Know your price limit BEFORE you start negotiating. Don’t question what you paid after you’ve signed. Too late and it will make you crazy.
 
There was a fee from Unhaggle when I used it in 2014. Most prices came in super tight to one another for a now popular car. I’d use it again for another brand.
 
Depends on what you are buying. Some manufactures wheel and deal, others not at all.

When I bought a vehicle once, I found which one I wanted on the dealer's lot. I offered him 91 percent of the dealer asking price (dealer asking price = window price less discount from the manufacturer). He turned me down flat and I walked away, but left my contact number. 2 weeks later (on the last day of the month), he changed his mind and took my offer. They need to meet monthly sales targets in order to receive factory discounts and bonuses etc. Plus he had the vehicle on his lot.

I never bother with any website, just do it old school.
 
Depends on what you are buying. Some manufactures wheel and deal, others not at all.

When I bought a vehicle once, I found which one I wanted on the dealer's lot. I offered him 91 percent of the dealer asking price (dealer asking price = window price less discount from the manufacturer). He turned me down flat and I walked away, but left my contact number. 2 weeks later (on the last day of the month), he changed his mind and took my offer. They need to meet monthly sales targets in order to receive factory discounts and bonuses etc. Plus he had the vehicle on his lot.

I never bother with any website, just do it old school.

BMW will not, at least not my expereince.
 
From experience, here's how I do it:

a) Figure out what car you want, and the trim level
b) Visit 3 dealerships, in person. Talk to a salesperson, get a business card. I tell them I need their best price. I never tell them the other prices I have gotten. I also tell them I'm buying a car in x days from whoever gives me the best price.
c) After visiting them, I call them again and ask for a better price. One of them will come down a little.
d) Buy from whoever is cheapest, the car is the same from all of them.

I may still leave money on the table, but I find I get good deals or other stuff thrown in (5 oil changes, for example). It's a little time consuming but it saves me money so it's worth it.
 
It shouldn't be easy for salesman to make the sale. Let them work for every buck...Don't try to be difficult and come out as a douche, just tell them the vehicle, model you like and budget...if it's justified, some salesman will give it...Some of these agents crunch in the numbers like selling veggies in the market...remember they will decide the price but you will decide if the purchase will go through or not. Some sellers have a bottom price...I remember back in 09 when I was looking for a new vehicle and my brother's friend was also planning on purhasing one. we walked in as a tandem and when the agent found out this could be a 2 bird in 1 stone...he throw in a lot of extras to get us both...
 
Depends on what you are buying. Some manufactures wheel and deal, others not at all.

When I bought a vehicle once, I found which one I wanted on the dealer's lot. I offered him 91 percent of the dealer asking price (dealer asking price = window price less discount from the manufacturer). He turned me down flat and I walked away, but left my contact number. 2 weeks later (on the last day of the month), he changed his mind and took my offer. They need to meet monthly sales targets in order to receive factory discounts and bonuses etc. Plus he had the vehicle on his lot.

I never bother with any website, just do it old school.

So James, you up for a barter? I will give you a little something if you can do my next car purchase negotiations? LOL

I am so horrible at haggling. I think it is because I hate when it is done to me. Which then I hate that I can't really do it well at all.
 
Just know once you step into a dealership and give them your name along with the vehicle and price you were discussing, any other dealership with the same car brand will have access to that info and what you discussed.
 
I think you did alright. I helped my sis get $6,100 off her $33.5K (all-in) vehicle, but the financing wasn't as good as yours. Note, $2500 of that was manufacturer's discount. My sis made the mistake of originally telling them what her monthly budget was and they took advantage of it until I got involved.

Just be aware of the tricks they pull. For instance, after she told them her monthly budget was $350/mo, they offered her a deal that had her paying $173 biweekly. FYI, $173 biweekly is, on average, $376/mo, not the $346/mo they were trying to trick her into believing. The final deal once I got involved was $334/mo.

You have to be willing to walk away and shop around. And let them know you are considering vehicles at different dealerships. You can work it into the conversation fairly easily. "Well I really like the heated seats the Chevy X has" or "the Dodge Y comes with a tow bar" which serves the duo purpose of trying to get them to throw those items in or give you a discount to compensate, as well as letting them know you're looking elsewhere.
Don't get hung up on a specific car. If you come to the determination that you found the one and only car you want, you've lost bargaining power.
Salespeople may act as your friend, but their primary goal is to sell as many vehicles as possible, and at the highest margin they can get away with. Be friendly with them, but don't trust anything they say.
 
Good topic!

I Google Canadian car forums specific for the brand/make I'm looking for and request pricing information and anything else the dealer threw in from other people in Ontario for the specific model I want. There is a Canadian forum for just about any car and the posters tend to be helpful and mostly honest. From the responses you can get a solid feel for average street pricing, the freebies the dealers may throw in and 1 or 2 dealers will stand-out as lower priced. I then go to the first of the two dealers and offer 2% lower (around $1000-1200) than the calculated street price, negotiate and hopefully buy. I've done this 4 times and usually land within $250 of the calculated street price + a minor dealer giveaways (free detailing or oil changes).

When I was looking at German cars, I was surprised how little variance there was between dealerships within the GTA, especially BMW and Audi. Infiniti pricing between dealers was all over the place, Lexus not as much.

From my readings and conversations:
- Best to buy towards the end of the month and the end of the day and July/August, January and March are slow months for dealerships.
- Dealers make their money off the confidential factory incentives and programs which are hard for us normal people to find out about, Sometimes the forums can provide the info.
- Avoid buying dealership extras (paint protection, interior protection, clear coatings, tinted windows, etc.). Any of those can be bought at a local shop at the same or better quality for 20-50% less money. DO NOT but snow tires from a dealership.
 
I bought in the fall. End of year discounts, they gave me someone else’s employee discount, 750 credit for signing up for a credit card I cancelled, and some other loyalty discount. Then 0% financing 72 months.
Best time to buy new is end of year closings. Started shopping in August, didn’t want to wait till the options I wanted were gone.
 
Depends on what you are buying. Some manufactures wheel and deal, others not at all..

Most do not really deal
They just have a higher starting price to let you think they are making concessions

I've seen places who claim you have a great deal after an hour of haggling then walk into a sticker price only store and see how similar the prices are

Its all smoke & mirrors because people like to think they are good at negotiating
 
All well and good ....... except for the financing. 84 months is way too long, unless you plan on owning the car for more than 84 months. Do the math, and you will find out that you owe more than the car is worth. Not good if you total the car, and the insurance isn't enough to pay the car loan off. Five year financing should be the max.
 
All these big cash discounts must be for American cars/trucks. Japanese companies don't offer huge discounts even for year end models.
Honda basically tells you "here is our best price.If you don't buy the car,someone will be in next week to buy it".
 
I negotiate MSRP every time. If it's a new car but near the end of their corporate year and they are just trying to get rid of last year's models, they won't push back too much. And if they do, I just tell them I'll go to another dealer who will sell the "older" model at MSRP and be done with it. That usually gets them backtracking lol.
 
All well and good ....... except for the financing. 84 months is way too long, unless you plan on owning the car for more than 84 months. Do the math, and you will find out that you owe more than the car is worth. Not good if you total the car, and the insurance isn't enough to pay the car loan off. Five year financing should be the max.

she plans on keeping it until it is junk just wants to start with new so term is good because either way u pay..pay now or pay later depreciation don't care ..cost of financing $1500...200 bucks a year
 
So James, you up for a barter? I will give you a little something if you can do my next car purchase negotiations? LOL

I am so horrible at haggling. I think it is because I hate when it is done to me. Which then I hate that I can't really do it well at all.

Some things I barter for and others I don't.

Cars, I definitely barter for. It's the name of the game.
 
Some things I barter for and others I don't.

Cars, I definitely barter for. It's the name of the game.

I honestly envy those who have the power to do that. There are some that do it in a way that is rude but for others it is a real skill. I know one guy who would negotiate on things I would not even think of and from stores I would not even think of.

My mom was pretty good at it too. Not here in Canada. For the big things she was, but when we traveled, that women could haggle with the best of them. One skill I didn't learn that I wish I had.