Neighbor Issues

SkyRider

Banned
Mar 31, 2009
17,546
2
0
As you may know, I live in the City of Toronto. Here are a couple of questions.

My neighbor has two trees whose branches overhang my property. I asked but he refused to amputate these overhanging branches. Do I have the right to remove them myself? If yes, who is responsible for paying the arborist for cutting these branches?

Does the City allow people to BBQ (grill) in their backyard?
 
Is this the same neighbour you had a fence dispute with, and a dispute about an HE furnace vent? Why so much conflict with your neighbour?
 
Is this the same neighbour you had a fence dispute with, and a dispute about an HE furnace vent? Why so much conflict with your neighbour?
I live in a part of the city where we are all packed in like sardines. The tree neigbor is on the north side of the house. The fence and HE vent issues with the south side neigbor has been resolved.
 
Do the limbs present any type of hazard, or materially diminish property value? Could the limbs fall on your house, or do they drop seeds that stain your driveway, etc. I went through this once and those were the determining factors.
 
best would be to call the appropriate city dept & ask them. bylaws dept maybe?
I don't live in Toronto but I called the city hall where I live and asked the question . I was told that anything that overhangs your property can be trimmed .
 
May seem sort of lame to post directly from the City of Toronto website - but here goes:

Can I prune the branches from my neighbour's tree, that overhang my property?
Three main points to remember when dealing with trees on adjacent private property are that:
You cannot trespass onto your neighbour's property;
You cannot damage your neighbour's property (in this case a tree); and
You have the right to maintain your property in a safe condition
It is therefore best for property owners to come to an agreement between themselves with respect to trees overhanging property lines.
If you are unable to reach an agreement with your neighbour and want to determine your legal rights, you should contact a lawyer.
The act of pruning trees on neighbouring private property affects private property rights and is a civil issue between private property owners.
The City has no jurisdiction with respect to such issues.
Where a tree on private property is protected under the provisions of the Private Tree Bylaw, pruning of the tree is permitted provided the pruning is in accordance with good arboricultural standards. Otherwise, a permit would be required to injure or destroy the tree.
A qualified tree expert should always be retained to carry out tree pruning.

Interesting, i would have thought you can clip back the over hanging branches...

For the OP what is the back story on your question about BBQ's in the back yard?
 
Just call 311 and ask them. If they don't know the answer they will transfer you to the proper department.
 
As you may know, I live in the City of Toronto. Here are a couple of questions.

My neighbor has two trees whose branches overhang my property. I asked but he refused to amputate these overhanging branches. Do I have the right to remove them myself? If yes, who is responsible for paying the arborist for cutting these branches?

Does the City allow people to BBQ (grill) in their backyard?
my brother is a tree guy and got involved in a few disputes like this. i have asked him the very same thing a few times out of curiosity.

anything that hangs on your property is your problem, you will have to pay and there is nothing he can say about you cutting it as long as you only cut the part on your property. he can refuse to allow the tree guy to come on his property to climb the tree to cut the limbs safely but according to the law if it is on your property you can do what you want to it.

last year in a huge windstorm a tree got blown over at my mom's property. it landed on the neighbors house and damaged the roof. my mom called the insurance company and they told her that it wasn't on her property when it landed so it wasn't her problem.
 
oliver's post is the best one yet. If the arborist says cut then cut, otherwise, you could be in a whole lot of trouble and civil court.
 
oliver's post is the best one yet. If the arborist says cut then cut, otherwise, you could be in a whole lot of trouble and civil court.

that is exactly what i said, except i get it right from the source my brother a licensed arborist. been running a tree company for 15 years.
 
For the OP what is the back story on your question about BBQ's in the back yard?
These are just thoughts at the moment. We are thinking of getting a BBQ grill for family cookouts in our backyard on Summer nights and weekends and were wondering if there are any legal restrictions. (I remember there was a thread a while back about BBQ on apartment balconeys.) Then there is also the question whether my neighbor might not like the smoke, smell and noise.
 
If you can't grill in your backyard then everyone I know breaks the law, and I'm the worst offender. Of course you can.
Are your neighbors ok with that or they also grillers? Both my northern and southern neighbors are right next to me (tightly packed in our part of Toronto).
P.S. Do you also live in the City of Toronto?
 
So did you punch your neighbor?
 
These are just thoughts at the moment. We are thinking of getting a BBQ grill for family cookouts in our backyard on Summer nights and weekends and were wondering if there are any legal restrictions. (I remember there was a thread a while back about BBQ on apartment balconeys.) Then there is also the question whether my neighbor might not like the smoke, smell and noise.

Apartments is a fire code thing - storage of propane/combustibles.
 
last year in a huge windstorm a tree got blown over at my mom's property. it landed on the neighbors house and damaged the roof. my mom called the insurance company and they told her that it wasn't on her property when it landed so it wasn't her problem.
Ok, so trees have immunity. What about picnic tables. If your mom had a picnic table in her back yard and the wind picked it up and smashed it into your northern neighbour's garage is your mom responsible?
 
Are your neighbors ok with that or they also grillers? Both my northern and southern neighbors are right next to me (tightly packed in our part of Toronto).
P.S. Do you also live in the City of Toronto?

Unless you're going to be running a smoker 24/7 or an open pit grill, I fail to see any issues with that. Yes, I do live in Toronto.