Good point. A lot of guys don't know they are creepy.
The difference between a guy who women want to be around and one who creeps them out is a guy who is comfortable in his own skin. It doesn't matter if you're rich, handsome (cute, ugh), funny or brilliant. If you are confident in who you are and what you want, you project that (and no, I don't mean confident as in being cocky. I mean, confident as in knowing yourself).
Awkward is creepy. Cocky is annoying.
Maybe, but online dating isn't really dating. And, there's very real danger that he can build himself up to more than he really is and therefor mess up his real life opportunity to meet the girl.