NDA vs patent

jw01

New member
Jul 3, 2005
317
0
0
I am working on a startup with a friend of mine. we are in the beginning stages and looking at ways to fund and create our product. it's related to thr service industry, one I have vast experience in. I would like to ideally target my old company as i have many solid relationships. I am in the midst of obtaining a provisional patent.

my question is... I have a solid relationship with my old Vp, of the company I want to target. now before I go balls deep into this start up., should I meet up with my old vp and make him sign NDA, so he can't talk about it or steal the idea or should I get provisional patent and then discuss? is NDA sufficent for me to discuss with him or can he go and take my idea and replicate it for the company? I want to discuss with him as he would let me know 100% if they would purchase... that's the opportunity cost.

thanks for the help.
 
I am working on a startup with a friend of mine. we are in the beginning stages and looking at ways to fund and create our product. it's related to thr service industry, one I have vast experience in. I would like to ideally target my old company as i have many solid relationships. I am in the midst of obtaining a provisional patent.

my question is... I have a solid relationship with my old Vp, of the company I want to target. now before I go balls deep into this start up., should I meet up with my old vp and make him sign NDA, so he can't talk about it or steal the idea or should I get provisional patent and then discuss? is NDA sufficent for me to discuss with him or can he go and take my idea and replicate it for the company? I want to discuss with him as he would let me know 100% if they would purchase... that's the opportunity cost.

thanks for the help.
A properly witnessed Nondisclosure Agreement is absolutely necessary. The provisional patent is good, but is not as easily enforceable as a proper mutual NDA. To be safe, get both, and make sure that the provisional patent covers the geographic and geopolitical territories that you want to operate in.
 
You definitely need an NDA, and a plan to develop it to a patent. If you discuss sales, you must patent within one year, so scope your conversation accordingly.

A very common mistake is to patent something that everyone in the technical community knows "won't work." This happens because the patent lawyers will tell you to "lawyer up", convinve you that you have the "next great thing", and tell you not to talk to anyone. Be careful with this advice. Often the initial concept has a few well known flaws. The solutions to these flaws are often patented by companies active in the field. If you do not find out about the flaws in your idea, and fix them, before the patent is issued, then you will have to apply for a new patent on the revised idea. This "improved" patent will likely be much harder to get. A commercially successful patent often solves an existing problem in a new way, and is often done by someone highly skilled in the subject area.

An entire business strategy exists around finding bankrupt startups with patents and products, determining if the business conditions have changed, and then relaunching the startup as a going concern. This takes much of the patent risk out of startups.
 
patents can take a long time to get approved and are very expensive to enforce. there are also a number of intricacies if you don't have a knowledge of intellectual property. my suggestion would be to hire lawyers to advise. yes they are expensive but can be worth it. to save $ you can do some of the grunt paperwork instead of a law clerk who charges $250-$300 hr.

as for the NDA, it's an absolute must. that should be drawn up and signed before any discussions occur.
 
hey guys

Thanks for the great tips. question, if I can get NDA from a lawyer (vs downloading), is it OK for me to discuss with my old Vp or can he go ahead and develop the product or file a patent?

primarily I want to layout the concept and product I want to launch to him before heavily spending in the patent route. or is it a must to get a "provisional patent" as I discuss with him with a signed NDA form?

thanks
 
Based on some of the answers here, I don't think peeps know the difference between a NDA and patent, or what a patent is.

Hint: one is a private contract between two parties.

K Douglas has it right.
 
As several have pointed out this is not a "vs" question, it is an "and".

A patent can *never* replace an NDA. No matter what your business is 99% of what you do is not patentable--which markets you plan to go into, who you are working with, how much funding you have, what sorts of customers you are going to go after, how far along you are in getting started up, how big your team is, who is on your team, and whole lot of the way you plan to operate is all information that a competitor could use to damage you, and is not patentable.

A patentable idea can give your company an edge, a differentiating feature to try and steal business away from competitors, but it is almost by definition just a part of the story, and the WHOLE story is sensitive, if you are still in start-up mode.

Even with an inferior technology if your biggest competitor learns that you are starting up a business and hoping to go after customer X, Y, and Z they can move immediately to lock those guys in to some sort of contract, badmouth you to others, and generally go about sabotaging your business in ways that has just nothing to do with patents.

If you think a patent is your business then I question whether you're really ready to start one -- it takes a LOT more than just a better idea.

Meanwhile if you DO have a really good novel idea that is worth patenting, in the long run an NDA won't protect it. If you do have a good patentable idea there are probably others working on the problem who are not far behind you and will independently discover it soon enough. Moreover, just you going into the market and announcing your approach will cause them to start asking the right questions, even if you try and keep the details secret. The NDA will protect you while you are in start-up mode, but before long you will be out flogging your product to customers and in explaining to them why your approach is better you're going to have to give away a few secrets. By then, you need the good secrets protected by a patent--not an NDA--so that you can go promote how much of a better idea you have.
 
I don't think anyone in this thread has done a tech startup.

Neither the NDA or the Patent will protect you unless you have the funds to lawyer up if shit hits the fan. And even then, if you do, have you sold anything, have they sold anything? How would damages or infringement be assessed? The assessment could be close to 0 and did they actually infringe..its a legal minefield.

NDA is a good start. Patent? You better know that your 'solution' is really is novel and not super simple to replicate, there is so much crap patented today by patent trolls you could wind up being in deep do do.
Also don't kid yourself about the value of a patent. Patent's are not required to sell a lot of units: http://inventors.about.com/library/inventors/blpaperclip.htm

Both NDA and Patent will create the "don't copy my idea" image, but if you are a start-up with no money, neither has much teeth.

If you are pitching your idea for funding, there are other agreements for that as well. An IP lawyer can help you.