Napoleon vs Schwarzenberg

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
45,730
11,188
113
Who was Napoleon's nemesis, it wasn't Wellington. Prince Schwartzenberg won the Battle of Nations near Leipzig and arrived in Paris to send Napoleon into exile at Elba.

Then came Waterloo.

 
I starting to hate YouTube The title of your post got me all excited but now I have to watch a bunch of fluff to get into the heat of it. Some actually commentary would be nice. An abstract even.
 
I tried to get to the nitty gritty but Schwarzenberg isn't as well know as the others. Even though he was better than most. His invasion of France was textbook Scipio, for the first time outmaneuvering the French Emperor. Sometimes when you are highlighting the unjustly neglect, you take what's given.

 
Who was Napoleon's nemesis, it wasn't Wellington. Prince Schwartzenberg won the Battle of Nations near Leipzig and arrived in Paris to send Napoleon into exile at Elba.

Then came Waterloo.

Seriously?!

Schwarzy was a fuck-up who got his ass handed at the Battle of Dresden. Blucher won Leipzig for S, while S fucked around and did squat. The Allies also had a 2:1 numerical superiority at Leipzig and Napo fought the battle w teenaged recruits because he lost his army in Russia the year before.

The idea that S was a top tier general is silly.
 
The Prussians had been humiliated at the Battle of Jena in 1806, the terms were harsh. Prussia was reduced to it's East Prussia enclave while Napoleon took Berlin. At Dresden and Leipzig, Blucher was second in command to Schwazie.

Blucher is more famous, he turned the tide at the battle of Waterloo. Wellington's forces were being cut down when Blucher arrived, forcing Napoleon to fight on two fronts. General Ney gambled on breaking Welligton's lines and galloped into a trap. Napoleon deployed his Imperial Guards to stop the Prussian advance but it was too late. Wellington counter-attacked and the French forces were encircled.

Victor Hugo's awesome Les Miserables starts at Waterloo, but that chapter of the book has never been filmed. Jean Valjean's father was a member of the Imperial Guard. After Waterloo, Jean Valjean was fatherless and his family disgraced.
 
The truth is that it was the Americans who beat Napo;leon.
 
The Prussians had been humiliated at the Battle of Jena in 1806, the terms were harsh. Prussia was reduced to it's East Prussia enclave while Napoleon took Berlin. At Dresden and Leipzig, Blucher was second in command to Schwazie.

Blucher is more famous, he turned the tide at the battle of Waterloo. Wellington's forces were being cut down when Blucher arrived, forcing Napoleon to fight on two fronts. General Ney gambled on breaking Welligton's lines and galloped into a trap. Napoleon deployed his Imperial Guards to stop the Prussian advance but it was too late. Wellington counter-attacked and the French forces were encircled.

Victor Hugo's awesome Les Miserables starts at Waterloo, but that chapter of the book has never been filmed. Jean Valjean's father was a member of the Imperial Guard. After Waterloo, Jean Valjean was fatherless and his family disgraced.

True, in the story his father was just a loser...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Insidious Von
True, in the story his father was just a loser...

What an engrossing read Victor Hugo's book is! It massive but a real page turner. Mind you there were passages that could have been left out, the argot translated poorly into English.

I was offered to go see the musical many times but refused. Of the film versions I like the 1935 version the best, Frederic March was great as Valjean but Charles Laughton was sensational as Javert.

Poor Rusty.

 
Poor Rusty.
He was truly miserable. I read once that he had his start in musical theater. Not easy to believe.

The only worse example I can think of is Pierce Brosnan singing in Mama Mia

 
Seriously?!

Schwarzy was a fuck-up who got his ass handed at the Battle of Dresden. Blucher won Leipzig for S, while S fucked around and did squat. The Allies also had a 2:1 numerical superiority at Leipzig and Napo fought the battle w teenaged recruits because he lost his army in Russia the year before.

The idea that S was a top tier general is silly.
How about this one?...
 
The only worse example I can think of is Pierce Brosnan singing in Mama Mia


Yeap, nothing can top our boy Pierce there. The best thing about that movie was watching a young Amanda Seyfried jiggle around in her prime.
 
Indeed, Darts.

Wellington and Napo were head and shoulders above the other generals of the period. Wellington's greatest campaigns were not Waterloo. In 1812, he duelled Marshall Marmont on the plains of Castile for a week. Both men maneuvered their armies in sight of one another waiting for one to make a fatal mistake and lose. In the end, it was Marmont who briefly over extended his lines outside the city of Salamance and this allowed the Duke to concentrate 2 divisions against a single exposed French division, utterly destroying it. The British then worked up the French line from left to right, overwhelming and smashing each French unit as it tried to stop them.

Wellington topped this in 1813 when he force-marched his men for weeks through the mountains of NW Spain and suddenly emerged in the unguarded French rear, forcing the French to fight outnumbered and dispersed at Vitoria. The French were smashed and the Duke then moved to force the passes of the Pyrenees and invade France itself.

Wellington's veteran troops were sent to America to be slaughtered at New Orleans and he fought at Waterloo with an army of recruits and heavily outgunned. He had to hold the line until a Prussian army under Prince Blucher arrived to take the French in the flank.
 
Those Epic History TV episodes on the Napoleonic Wars are fantastic. You watch one battle and then it segues into the next, and before you know it 3 hours have passed.
 
Watched a mini series documentary on Napoleon a couple of years back. A British historian was saying he was probably the most brilliant general of all times or one of them. What I got from it was the fact that during his rule, France was at a constant state of war. The only respite being when they ran out of troops,ordinance and money. Then back at it. The misery and carnage went on for years. For what?
I remember reading a Len Deighton book where he quoted Napoleon's remark that the only thing his soldiers saw when their way to Moscow was the back of the soldier in front of them during the march. As if they declined day trips to Saint Petersburg and Smolensk.
I don't know why he is celebrated. Brought nothing but horror and death to millions.And accomplished what?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Napoleon didn't start the war, it was already in progress when he took command.

The Revolutionary Wars started in 1792 when the Austrian Empire, Prussia and Britain declared war on Revolutionary France. They figured the war would be over in a few months and Louis XVI restored. After all what could filthy peasants do against professional soldiers.

This could be another title: The Duke of Brunswick vs Dumoriez.

 
Watched a mini series documentary on Napoleon a couple of years back. A British historian was saying he was probably the most brilliant general of all times or one of them. What I got from it was the fact that during his rule, France was at a constant state of war. The only respite being when they ran out of troops,ordinance and money. Then back at it. The misery and carnage went on for years. For what?
I remember reading a Len Deighton book where he quoted Napoleon's remark that the only thing his soldiers saw when their way to Moscow was the back of the soldier in front of them during the march. As if they declined day trips to Saint Petersburg and Smolensk.
I don't know why he is celebrated. Brought nothing but horror and death to millions.And accomplished what?
There's a school of historians of the period who agree with you. Napoleon thought he could kick ass of whatever king or emperor tried to take him on and become ruler of Europe, if not the world. But it wrecked his country and eventually, the other kings simply joined forces to get rid of him. They thought he was too dangerous and out of control.

Other historians take IV's PoV and say that Napoleon just countered attacks by the other kings.
 
There's a school of historians of the period who agree with you. Napoleon thought he could kick ass of whatever king or emperor tried to take him on and become ruler of Europe, if not the world. But it wrecked his country and eventually, the other kings simply joined forces to get rid of him. They thought he was too dangerous and out of control.

Other historians take IV's PoV and say that Napoleon just countered attacks by the other kings.


I agree with the mass murder part of Nap.
Pre democracy the world celebrated killing and murder as normal. The Sabine women, is a story of how Romans raped a bunch of women to glorious start their empire. Shows of victory showing murder and rape are common. We stilll see echos of this in action movies where the good guys blow up cities and civilians to get at the bad guys.
Hell Xman has the hero fiends with a mass murder, which indeed of killing keeps alive so me can mas murder non named characters.

There are two parts of Nap celebration, or three.
First, the old fashioned one. From old murderous standards he was great.
2nd, he democratized glory. HIs army was not made of nobles and slaves, but of men fighting for their country. They were conscripted but now they shared in the glory.
3rd, Nap. made France a modern place, with many reforms, and ushered the world into the modern era. Science, law, and basic food stuffs like margarine. There are lots of great soldiers out there, but very few who brings in lasting needed reforms. Compared to the men of his day, nobles who played cards for most of their lives then bought general ships and commanded man shot for not have a clean uniform he was a huge step up.

Plus he did end the blood bath that was the reign of terror. He was a huge thereat to monarchy and they where right, very few monarchies of real power remain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill