My body, my decision...

niceguy

New member
Jul 21, 2002
89
0
0
Ottawa
It appears that "My Body My Decision" is not applicable anymore, in the eyes of federal government with the new prostitution law. It is official now, Nordik model it is. Hope you guys remember this for the next federal election and kick these religious nutcases out of the office:

http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/national/federal+prostitution+coming+soon/9781043/story.html

I am not too optimistic about SC rejecting the law as CH hopes. Why did SC even asked federal government to come up with new law? We already have enough laws to protect those who are forced into prostitution against their wish or for under age girls, there wasn't a need for another one.
 
I'd like to see this study where the findings were that "...more than 90 per cent of prostitutes are “lured” into the sex trade and become victims who are “held captive by beatings” and “have no place to go”. I call complete bullshit. Colour me not surprised though considering the foundations of our federally elected government. Reform they do.
 
Well, there are a lot of people who want to take advantage of escorts. I think it's really important for there to be stiffer penalties for "pimps" and agencies should have to get licenses and be regulated so that any old *sshole can't open up an agency and start taking advantage of the women that work for them.

I got into the business on my own slowly as an MA. I had big dreams of being a stripper and I found that I just didn't have the personality for it. I was too shy so my friend got me a job at with his buddies GF. After that I went out on my own and slowly started escorting. I learned a few things from the woman I worked with originally. I mean I was just guided in the right direction and decided that I liked the money. I was never forced into it, but i have been approached by people who want to be my "agent" and who want me to work for them. They make all these promises that they'll make me all kinds of money, I just have to fork over more than half of my money to them. Or guys that want to be "drivers" but not only want to be paid but also want services. So, if I were to tally what they are getting paid an hour, plus the cost of my services they would technically be making more than me.

Once a month I get approached by someone who wants me to "work for them". This is ridiculous by the way, since I am an independent escort and I keep all of my earnings (I wouldn't be working for them, they would be working for me). I don't need them, but they need me. If I needed them for anything it would be to answer phones and inquiries. I mean if they want to be called an "agent" when they are nothing more than a receptionist all the power to them. But for some reason people have this fantasy where they should get all the money for doing the least amount of work and putting in the least amount of effort.

I have to finish this off soon so I just wanted to share that it is really important that the laws be stricter on people trying to lure women into SW'ing. It's really the first step into stopping it. I had mentioned that I was never lured or forced into escorting, it was my choice. When I was a young teenager about the age of 16 I would get approached all the time by people much older than me who would want to show me what their friend does or make promises that I could make a lot of money by pretending that I wanted to sleep with someone and luring them somewhere to get robbed. That was a pretty common scam people wanted me to be apart of. That could have lead to rape or someone getting seriously hurt. Also, I wasn't sure if the guys would come out and stop it from happening though so i never went through with it. I would walk down the street to my friends place and people would stop and ask if I was "working or walking". Again I should mention, I was only 16. I had a friend with a sister who was 2 years younger than me who was stopped by a car in front of us and asked for BJ. We were out to get ice cream and some sicko asked my friend's 14 year old sister for a bj.

It's stuff like that, that makes me agree that the laws need to be stiffer.




I'd like to see this study where the findings were that "...more than 90 per cent of prostitutes are “lured” into the sex trade and become victims who are “held captive by beatings” and “have no place to go”. I call complete bullshit. Colour me not surprised though considering the foundations of our federally elected government. Reform they do.
 
I had a friend with a sister who was 2 years younger than me who was stopped by a car in front of us and asked for BJ. We were out to get ice cream and some sicko asked my friend's 14 year old sister for a bj.

It's stuff like that, that makes me agree that the laws need to be stiffer.

I know what you mean, but be careful what you wish for. Unfortunately when the Nordic model comes in, the majority of your "gentlemen" clients will retire (out of fear of prosecution), and you will be left with a large proportion of "sickos" with nothing to lose.
 
When I was a young teenager about the age of 16 I would get approached all the time by people much older than me who would want to show me what their friend does or make promises that I could make a lot of money by pretending that I wanted to sleep with someone and luring them somewhere to get robbed. That was a pretty common scam people wanted me to be apart of.
It's stuff like that, that makes me agree that the laws need to be stiffer.

If anything, the scam you were being proposed to become part of, with the new law will become even more widespread. Those clients who are promised by someone who pretends who wants to sleep with them and is robbed would not dare to go to police since he will be charged. Again, current laws are already stiff enough for people who force others into prostitution, we have seen several instances of them. There was no need for any new laws. This new law will have 2 side effects:

1) It will force decent clients out of business (I being one of them). I will not risk getting caught by either a sting operation, or by a group of scams as the ones you refer to
2) It pushes the business underground, making it more dangerous for both the provider (become subject of criminals who don't care about getting caught), and clients (become victim of scam artists and police force)

If anyone, the decent SP's should take this more seriously and object to the new laws, this affects you more than us (we will retire from business entirely).

Just my 2 cents.
 
Apparently (as per another thread) SCC can only reject new laws if they are challenged and make a ruling in about 5 to 10 years and that is IF the new laws can be constitutionally challenged. The reason I say "If it can be constitutionally challenged" is because I asked this question in another thread asking for a constitutional expert to comment (I am not) and one commented that only someone who is charged can challenge new laws. So since under Nordic model sex workers are considered victims (imposed in Sweden first in 1999 by a bunch of ultra feminists who took over than country like Nazis did in Germany in the 1930's) and they will not be charged then likely the new laws if Nordic can never be challenged. Also in my view, there will be no grounds for clients to challenge new laws as they will be engaging in an illegal activity and therefore they will have no grounds to challenge new laws either.

A john has to TOFFT.
 
I agree with Bruckert's assessment. Joy Smith tries to make customers (or johns) look like sociopaths on Criminal Minds. They're not criminals or predators!
 
I think the problem with Smith is that she is trying to make all customers of sex workers as criminals. I guess I take the middle road and say some (likely a minority) are and some aren't. They are some customers (hopefully a tiny minority) who would see sex workers under any circumstances even knowing that they may be underage, forced or trafficked. I have posted the tale of two johns in Ottawa section. Last year there was a case of teenage pimps pimping/forcing other teenagers. Very sad so I followed up on that. Basically they took the 16 year old forcefully using threats and intimidation to a john. The child apparently told the john that she is only 16 and is forced into this. The john allegedly (I say allegedly because it is still in court) did not care and allegedly forced her to give him a BJ and paid her $180. The pimps were not happy with the $180 and wanted more. So they took her to a second customer. The second customer was a hobbyist and took pity on the girl (likely after she told him about it) and apparently didn't touch her but gave her taxi fare to take a taxi to her parent's home and she did. In fact saved her. The first john was charged with sexual assault of a minor (and I hope he rots in jail, if found guilty) and to the best of my knowledge the second was not charged. The existing status quo did well in this case.

Now based on above true story it is clear to even the Cons that what we need are TARGETED LAWS. Laws that target bad johns (like the first john in above case but not the hobbyist) and toughen up existing laws for more severe punishment of those who pimp and those who force especially a throw away the key policy for those who abuse, manipulate or exploit the underage. Also those johns who knowing see (or don't take reasonable precautions) the forced or pimped should be dealt with criminally by new laws but not those hobbyists who participate in consensual sex with adult women and take all necessary precautions to avoid seeing the forced, the pimped and the underage and who care. Criminalizing all as committing violence against adult women who participate willingly is ridiculous.



Unfortunately, the scene for the decent hobbyist is doomed from now on. For most hobbyists, its not worth the gamble to get arrested and your name dragged to court, possibly losing your job and social standing if convicted. Nothing will be safe, in-calls or out-calls, you cannot take a chance in case there is a sting operation. I hear some regional cops have already switched tactics and are now actively going after "johns' and letting SPs off the hook. The new Nordic law will be introduced in a few weeks and its bound for accelerated royal assent in short order. The cops know whats coming down the pipeline and will put all resources to enforce the law. It will take at least 10 plus years to see the law challenged to the SC. I doubt that an SP can have standing in taking this to court because she will not be charged with breaking any law. Touch luck finding a "john" that will openly come out and take this to SC.
 
I agree. Unfortunately most who quit are good hobbyists. Those who have nothing to lose (criminals) would stay. I am no lawyer or constitutional expert but I am not sure even if a willing John be found that he would have any grounds for a challenge. Challenge the new laws on what basis? He has engaged in a would be illegal activity and then challenge the new laws that he has been charged for engaging in an illegal activity? Not any more than a drug dealer can challenge the ban on selling drugs causing the environment unsafe for him.

A professor of criminology at the University of Ottawa thinks though that it can be challenged again and ruled unconstitutional (likely by a sex worker). This is a quote from National Post:

"Bruckert (who is a professor of criminology at the University of Ottawa) said the law would eventually end up back at the Supreme Court and be ruled unconstitutional because it fails to protect prostitutes from danger."

This is the entire article
http://news.nationalpost.com/2014/0...et-pimps-customers-and-sex-trade-traffickers/

It could very well be, but as you yourself said it will take years (or more likely decades). Remember when the original law was considered unconstitutional, both the lower court and SC agreed to allow government to continue using the revoked law until they come up with a new law and it comes into effect. That is while, after the new law passes it will go into effect immediately.
 
I agree with Bruckert's assessment. Joy Smith tries to make customers (or johns) look like sociopaths on Criminal Minds. They're not criminals or predators!

It's an abolitionist model, a progressive one based on a form of feminist theory. The idea is that sex work is inherently a product of an unfair patriarchal society, and that a woman can't really consent because her choice is the product of that society. They don't want to make sex work safer, they want the women out and the johns in jail. Good or bad "hobbyist" is completely irrelevant...you pay for sex, you're in the wrong, period.
 
It's an abolitionist model, a progressive one based on a form of feminist theory. The idea is that sex work is inherently a product of an unfair patriarchal society, and that a woman can't really consent because her choice is the product of that society. They don't want to make sex work safer, they want the women out and the johns in jail. Good or bad "hobbyist" is completely irrelevant...you pay for sex, you're in the wrong, period.

Feminist theory is against sex period, regardless of paid or not. Their slogan is "a woman needs a man as a fish need a bicycle". They are not after equal society where both genders are treated equally.
 
new business model

I was wondering if SP's willing to change their business model to be paid at the end of the session, instead of up front. This would reduce the chances of falling victim to sting operations setup by police (they usually are after quick actions and don't have time to sit around for an hour in order to catch a guy).
 
1) It will force decent clients out of business (I being one of them). I will not risk getting caught by either a sting operation, or by a group of scams as the ones you refer to
2) It pushes the business underground, making it more dangerous for both the provider (become subject of criminals who don't care about getting caught), and clients (become victim of scam artists and police force)

If anyone, the decent SP's should take this more seriously and object to the new laws, this affects you more than us (we will retire from business entirely).
.

I agree that there is so much grey area not being considered in the whole argument or the business model.
I do believe the Nordic Law will make the practice more dangerous, and unfortunately the bad customers would remain. I also agree that the law should be stricter on the punishment of those who victimize women; I am unsure, however, of the effectiveness of criminalizing the 'purchase of sex' as a way of abolishing prostitution all together because is 'wrong'. it should also be considered that not all prostitutes are victims and most independent SPs (it is my understanding) are companions by choice; seems the intent of the law is not to regulate the trade but rather make it inaccessible; it does not make sense to attempt to abolish a trade that has existed since the beginning of time .
 
You guys will always have sites like TERB to share you hobbying experiences anonymously. I am excited about this. I mean, a bit of of fear will probably make the *ssholes who treat me like garbage think twice about it. They won't be threatening me with TERB because they made a mistake or because I wouldn't give them BBFS or give them a discount. I really don't think anything will change. I mean, you guys can go underground. I'm still going to be here doing my thing the same as I always have been but at least now I don't have to worry about getting caught, getting a criminal record and having fewer options. I'm still going to be careful, but I'm sure the way we communicate is going to change and peoples attitudes will change and hobbyists will have to come up with some kind of code instead of us Sp's trying to pick up on small signals from the hobbyist's.

I mean, you guys will figure something out. Same as escorts have figured out how to get around the laws. Some people might retire, others will get caught, but I bet you the majority of hobbyists will have it figured out.
 
I think the problem with Smith is that she is trying to make all customers of sex workers as criminals. I guess I take the middle road and say some (likely a minority) are and some aren't. They are some customers (hopefully a tiny minority) who would see sex workers under any circumstances even knowing that they may be underage, forced or trafficked. I have posted the tale of two johns in Ottawa section. Last year there was a case of teenage pimps pimping/forcing other teenagers. Very sad so I followed up on that. Basically they took the 16 year old forcefully using threats and intimidation to a john. The child apparently told the john that she is only 16 and is forced into this. The john allegedly (I say allegedly because it is still in court) did not care and allegedly forced her to give him a BJ and paid her $180. The pimps were not happy with the $180 and wanted more. So they took her to a second customer. The second customer was a hobbyist and took pity on the girl (likely after she told him about it) and apparently didn't touch her but gave her taxi fare to take a taxi to her parent's home and she did. In fact saved her. The first john was charged with sexual assault of a minor (and I hope he rots in jail, if found guilty) and to the best of my knowledge the second was not charged. The existing status quo did well in this case.

Now based on above true story it is clear to even the Cons that what we need are TARGETED LAWS. Laws that target bad johns (like the first john in above case but not the hobbyist) and toughen up existing laws for more severe punishment of those who pimp and those who force especially a throw away the key policy for those who abuse, manipulate or exploit the underage. Also those johns who knowing see (or don't take reasonable precautions) the forced or pimped should be dealt with criminally by new laws but not those hobbyists who participate in consensual sex with adult women and take all necessary precautions to avoid seeing the forced, the pimped and the underage and who care. Criminalizing all as committing violence against adult women who participate willingly is ridiculous.


Ok. I already know this exists. I should have said that Joy Smith tries to make ALL customers (or johns) look like sociopaths on Criminal Minds.

Don't we already have targeted laws?
 
I agree that there is so much grey area not being considered in the whole argument or the business model.
I do believe the Nordic Law will make the practice more dangerous, and unfortunately the bad customers would remain. I also agree that the law should be stricter on the punishment of those who victimize women; I am unsure, however, of the effectiveness of criminalizing the 'purchase of sex' as a way of abolishing prostitution all together because is 'wrong'. it should also be considered that not all prostitutes are victims and most independent SPs (it is my understanding) are companions by choice; seems the intent of the law is not to regulate the trade but rather make it inaccessible; it does not make sense to attempt to abolish a trade that has existed since the beginning of time .

Very well said Valeria. Please make your voice heard (even discreetly) on online newspaper editorials or write to you the Justice Minister or MPs like Joy Smith.
 
It's an abolitionist model, a progressive one based on a form of feminist theory. The idea is that sex work is inherently a product of an unfair patriarchal society, and that a woman can't really consent because her choice is the product of that society. They don't want to make sex work safer, they want the women out and the johns in jail. Good or bad "hobbyist" is completely irrelevant...you pay for sex, you're in the wrong, period.

They have to be exposed. They don't even care that there are people who can't have a pleasurable sex life (or one at all) and need to go to providers.
 
I agree that there is so much grey area not being considered in the whole argument or the business model.
I do believe the Nordic Law will make the practice more dangerous, and unfortunately the bad customers would remain. I also agree that the law should be stricter on the punishment of those who victimize women; I am unsure, however, of the effectiveness of criminalizing the 'purchase of sex' as a way of abolishing prostitution all together because is 'wrong'. it should also be considered that not all prostitutes are victims and most independent SPs (it is my understanding) are companions by choice; seems the intent of the law is not to regulate the trade but rather make it inaccessible; it does not make sense to attempt to abolish a trade that has existed since the beginning of time .

We are on the same page, thanks for your input. Please note that the only people who can fight the new law are the SP's themselves. Our voice does not and will not count as they consider us the victimizer. You should make your voice heard that you are NOT a victim and you made your own choice.