Most over-rated active soccer player?

matrix2004

Member
Dec 16, 2004
215
1
18
depends how drunk I am
IMHO- the answer's David Beckham-hands down. He's a decent midfielder and a good FREEKICKER, but the way the media portrays him- you'd think he was the second coming of PELE or something. He's not even the best midfielder on his OWN team. On top of that, he doesn't play his best football during the most important big games(when true great players step up and shine). Even his wife is a bit over-rated(after all- the Spice Girls couldn't really sing OR dance and she hasn't done a thing recently to warrant her 'celebrity' status). Any opinions?
 
I second that. But for two people that don't have any talent, they have certainly made alot of cash. His car collection makes all the basketball players and rap stars blush.
 
I agree with all of you above. Beckham is definitely the most overrated player today. Can't believe he made it onto the "FIFA Player of the Year" list this year, when so may other talented players were left out.

Other players who are overrated IMO are:
- Christian Vieri
- Del Piero
- Raul
 
Vieri has a really good scoring record with Inter, I dont think he's over-rated, but he hasnt done much internationally same with Raul. But I think the winner is Del Piero. Oh my he stinks, if anyone saw Milan/Juve last week he was doing his invisible man impression. The knee injury did him in, hasnt been the same player since. Honorable mention goes to Didier Drogba IMO, okay more over-priced then over-rated.
 
agree with you all, but david beckham would be more productive if he played in right wing, the position that made him famous
 
i think he might have been portrayed in the media as a sort of 'great white hype' athlete, so to say... when he was young, his skill level was way beyond any at his age and was touted to become the next great soccer player... kinda like Eric Lindros was portrayed early in his hockey career.
 
Beckham is soft and if you notice he never takes on a player. Yes he is good at free kicks, but so what. In the spanish liga he looks scared. Compare him to Zidane or Figo who attack players.
 
How about the ENTIRE Real Madrid team. Their combined salaries equal the GDP of some small countries and still they couldnt place higher then fifth last year. This year is a bit better but thats still no excuse for poor play.

I'm quietly enjoying it though, Escohort is a Barca fan!!!
 
CORRECTION: In my previous post I said that this year Madrid is playing a bit better. Never mind that, I just checked the standings and they are in 5th place. That is absolutely pathetic!!
 
Madrid needs to overhaul their midfield simply put. Figo is probably gone after this season and Zidane isnt getting any younger. Stick Beckham in Figo's place where he belongs. They should have never let Makelele go, that was a big mistake, no wonder they really wanted Vieira!
 
Mia Hamm..... just joking..

Beckham's a good footballer, but definitely the most over rated. I would also have to go with Vieri.
 
Everyone in this thread agreed that David Beckham is the most over-rated soccer player in the world. He's always breaking down, his production has declined, and he's not the fan favorite he once was with the English team, media and fans. The mofo does have insurance on both of his legs totalling $70 million so thats more than J-Lo's ass and Heidi Klums legs put together.

Alessandro Del Piero plays good on Juve, but usually under performs on the Italian team. Christian Vieri has came back from injury and has been playing well for Inter, and he always represents Italy well.

Ciao,

VT
 
Re: soccer chumps

vivalapanocha said:
What he said : BECKHAM !!!!!

I agree with all of you above. Beckham is definitely the most overrated player today. Can't believe he made it onto the "FIFA What he said


Player of the Year" list this year, when so may other talented players were left out.

Other players who are overrated IMO are:
- Christian Vieri
- Del Piero
- Raul

Raul especially ...he disappears in the World Cup ...

viva
...a little joke first:
Q: What do David Beckham and British rail trains have in common.
A: They both go in and out of Victoria ;)

For Raul to become a great one, he would have to leave Madrid and either go to England or Italy. Look at Ruud van Nistelrooy... this guy has proven himself at ManU. with a stellar performance. He is a true "Great One" and he would make it in any team on this planet. Many players today don't make it beyond their talent and some should take "Bad Boy" lessons from George Best. To bad George is not 27 years old right now... I'll bet he would drawf
Beckhams popularity.
 
DonAngelo said:
...a little joke first:
Q: What do David Beckham and British rail trains have in common.
A: They both go in and out of Victoria
Good one !!! :D

DonAngelo said:
For Raul to become a great one, he would have to leave Madrid and either go to England or Italy.
Yeah, like that's gonna happen. He's a poster boy for Madrid and Spain, so looking at it that way, he will never move. Plus the transfer fee would be enormous .... the only club I can see affording him is Chelsea. Let's not forget that he has it easy at Madrid ... surrounded by great players (some would say over-rated) who do most of the work for him. Just my 2 cents.
 
The_Ladies_Man said:
Let's not forget that he has it easy at Madrid ... surrounded by great players (some would say over-rated) who do most of the work for him. Just my 2 cents.
...that was exactly my point. How can you excel in a situation like this. Actually all the Real players where of peak at Euro'04. Figo improved only later in the tournament. Playing for this stagnant Real team is poisen for all of them, including Ronaldo and Zidane.
 
it seems becks has more in common with brit rail,than some of you lot give him credit for.hes been in more stations than just Victoria.