Moral Question? Ethical Question? What Would You Do? - STDs

RTRD

Registered User
Sep 26, 2003
6,003
3
0
So...I debated whether or not I was going to pose this question, but when I saw the Paris Hilton Herpes thread below, I took it as a sign...

First, let's communicate some facts:

1 out of every 4 women on average has genital herpes (HSV-2). For some segments / demographics the figure is closer to 1 out of 2. For men, the figure is between one out of eight and one out of five, again being higher among certain demographics.

http://www.herpesonline.org/articles/herpes_statistics.html

http://cat.inist.fr/?aModele=afficheN&cpsidt=2621768

http://www.cdc.gov/STD/Trends2000/herpes-close.htm


90% of Herpes HSV-2 carriers do not know they have it, as usually concern does not arise until there is an outbreak, and often outbreaks are mistaken for other maladies or issues, or simply ignored. Only 1/3 of herpes suffers EVER have an outbreak - so if they don't get specific STD testing for herpes, they never know that they are carriers.

http://www.herpesguide.ca/articles/facts_genital_herpes.html

http://www.dph.sf.ca.us/sfcityclinic/stdbasics/herpes.asp

http://www.famvir.com/info/about/wh...ilter_applied=true&NovaId=2229645022397720535


Herpes CAN be spread even if no symptoms are apparent - meaning it can be spread even when there are no signs of an outbreak. Condoms help reduce the chance of transmission, but do so only to a certain degree due to the fact that the do not cover the entire area of potential transmission (area around the base of the penis, the groin, etc.) Essentially, herpes is transmitted by (genital area) skin to (genital area) skin contact...and since there is skin to skin during intercourse EVEN WITH a condom...there is still risk of transmission. Condoms are generally thought to be about 50% effective in reducing herpes transmission risk

http://www.herpes-coldsores.com/asymptomatic_herpes.htm

http://www.herpes.com/Transmission.shtml

http://www.herpesdiagnosis.com/transmit.html


There is no "cure" for herpes, but there are drugs which help to suppress the symptoms, and accordingly are BELIEVED to suppress transmission to some degree. However, the key word is SOME. It is felt that by combining condoms, careful monitoring for outbreaks and anti-viral suppression drugs, chances of HSV-2 transmission can be mitigated by up to 90%

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0CYD/is_/ai_109025345

http://www.natap.org/2004/HIV/092804_08.htm

http://www.herpesdiagnosis.com/treatments.html


Conclusions drawn: If you are a sexually active person with multiple partners (serially or concurrently), you have MUCH more than likely had sex with someone who was infected with HSV-2 / Herpes. If you have sex with persons who have lots of partners (i.e., you "hobby"), it goes without saying that the chances go from much more than likely to almost certain. And if you like to hobby with "ebony" girls, the chances go from almost certain to virtually certain. This of course does not mean that YOU have HSV-2 / herpes...it is more difficult for men to catch the virus than women for the same reason this fact applies to almost all STDs...men pass their bodily fluids INSIDE a woman, while women pass theirs to a man's exterior. It is also true that HSV-2 is not necessarily passed between persons when there is sexual contact...there are countless clinical studies with couples who have intercourse, have had intercourse for years, and have not passed the virus.



Now...the set up....


You have recently come to become acquainted with someone new. This person is attractive, interesting, intelligent, and very sex positive. They are also an HSV-2 carrier (no surprise, given their predilection for sex). They are also ethical - they have TOLD YOU they are a carrier in advance of any sexual activity, leaving you decide how you would like to proceed. They are sexually educated and aware - they know what an outbreak looks like (they diagnosed themselves, and followed it up with a medical diagnosis), and have already told you some activities are off the table (such as cunnilingus) because they are a carrier. However, they are NOT on a suppression regimen, due to costs (apparently it is not covered by OHIP), along with some combination of medical guidance and self- counsel. All these things in concert have led them to conclude that the benefit does not out weigh to cost or side effects at this time.

Any relationship you would have with this person would be strictly casual. Accordingly, they are quite unlikely to make decisions about their care based on your concerns or recommendations. Additionally, your relationship is highly unlikely to be monogamous - on either side of the fence. Indeed, you already have one or more regular sexually partners currently (one of whom is perfectly aware of the non monogamous nature of your relationship...the other who seems to be in more of a "don't ask - don't tell" mindset)...and given her openness regarding her sexuality, there is some chance she does as well.



So...the question....how would you proceed?
 
Last edited:
52kqpvl.jpg
 
If it were me, my conversation with the other party might go along these lines.

"First of all, thank you for being straight with me in regards to your HSV status.

Since neither of us is under any delusion that we'd be committed to one another, I would run the risk of possibly infecting others should I end up contracting HSV from you. I'm not prepared to do that.

I think it's best that we just part as friends and leave it at that."

Short, clear, non-accusatory and direct.
 
If its true only 33% herpes causes outbreaks than whats so "bad" about it/ not trying to be a smart alk but I had chicken poxes when young and that is still inside me but causes me no problems...maybe some worry about herpes too much.

Whats needed is better drugs to help the 33% who have outbreaks.
 
MLAM said:
Conclusions drawn: If you are a sexually active person with multiple partners (serially or concurrently), you have MUCH more than likely had sex with someone who was infected with HSV-2 / Herpes. If you have sex with persons who have lots of partners (i.e., you "hobby"), it goes without saying that the chances go from much more than likely to almost certain. And if you like to hobby with "ebony" girls, the chances go from almost certain to virtually certain.....

While that is an unflattering statistic, wouldn't this statistic ring true for any high volume lady of any race? I understand that it is true that there are more ebony ladies on the face of the planet with STI's - not a matter that I want to delve into because there are many socio-economic/stupid reasons that may be attributed to those ebony ladies that are infected - but be thorough and realistic in your deductions as well. (*Just throwing it out there. ^_^ Don't want to have to battle it out with MLAM...lol.)

IMHO. I doubt that there would be a man that would want to knowingly put his sexual health at risk for the potential of a long term relationship or a good lay. The risks are not pleasurable - I doubt that any one would want ulcers, painful lymph nodes or even potentially becoming a carrier of the disease to pass it onto current/future partners. I would hope that the lady in question would continue to be open and honest about her sexual disease and that the man would be respectful enough (and thank his lucky stars that she was honest) to decline in the appropriate fashion.

What would you do MLAM?
 
MLAM said:
However, they are NOT on a suppression regimen, due to costs (apparently it is not covered by OHIP), along with some combination of medical guidance and self- counsel.

Gotta love the "free" health care all our excessive tax dollars are paying for. Hopefully she'll be able to afford some supplemental coverage to cover it in the future. Funny how we have to pay for so many things under the free health care.
 
MLAM said:
if you like to hobby with "ebony" girls, the chances go from almost certain to virtually certain.

Some activities are off the table (such as cunnilingus) because they are a carrier.

I'm wondering where you got your facts on Ebony "Girls" MLAM. Is this according to some world health organization. While I agree, due to lack of knowledge, particularly when it comes to sex education, economics and the "rape and pilage" mentality of many countries and radical groups in Africa, this might be the case in some third world countries.

I'd think that the ebony ladies here in Canada (especially the ones that were born here) have the same chances of contracting an STI or HSV-2 as ladies of any other ethnicity.....

If cunnilingus is off the table, then the only option would be to thank the lady for her honesty and education myself to the point where I could make a sound decision (outside of a lifetime membership to Dental Dams are Us).
 
While I appreciate the courage it took to disclose the STD, it would have been an immediate turnoff for me. No pussy, no matter how tempting, would mitigate the risk for me.

I'd take a pass.
 
Last edited:
Run away. Its casual anyhow, so why risk anything? Find another casual relationship that won't stay with you forever.