Mexico -- The next failed state

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
I read an interesting article recently that put this theory together:

1. Mexico's government barely controls much of its territory now, in the face of increasingly well armed and well financed drug cartels

2. We are entering a new cold war with Russia, and Russia will be shopping around for ways of creating staggering problems for the USA

3. Mexico city hosts the largest foreign office for Russian intelligence services

4. Russia is pretty good at smuggling arms, training insurgents, and stirring up shit in other countries

5. If Mexico were to become a failed state it would be a staggering problem for the United States, both in terms of border security, in terms of loss of a major trading partner, and in terms of the inflow of drugs creating massive criminal problems inside the USA itself.

Adding it up...

If we do get into a new cold war with Russia they probably won't just sit around waiting for Orange Revolutions to crop up in their near-abroad. They will probably reach out and stir up shit in the USA's near-abroad too.

Mexico would be a good starting point. While the cartels do not need cash, with sophisticated Russian weaponry, advanced military training, and access to Russian intelligence techniques and data, the drug cartels have a good shot at toppling the Mexican government and creating a failed state.

A failed state on the US border would then present the USA with such a huge, expensive, and difficult problem that American administrations, military resources, and intelligence efforts would be tied up dealing with problems nearer home--leaving Russia free to meddle in far away places like Georgia, or wherever, with less to fear.
 
All this is straight out of the 1955 soviet manual on how to cause a rebellion. Absolutly nothing new with this. The only difference right now is the advent of virtuallly instant amd untraceable communications. The communications were always the week side of conspiracies.
 
Talking about failed states, Russia should be near the top of the list.

It will take at least a generation to sort out the problems in that country.

Relations with Russia are a little cool in recent times, but there not even close to going into another cold war.
 
fuji said:
Mexico -- The next failed state

If Mexico were to become a failed state it would be a staggering problem for the United States, both in terms of border security, in terms of loss of a major trading partner, and in terms of the inflow of drugs creating massive criminal problems inside the USA itself.
Does this remind anyone else of the Mexican Campaign of 1916-1917 and the Zimmerman Telegram?
 
Throughout the cold war (and even today), the only hope the Soviet Union/Russia ever had of launching a conventional attack on the U.S. (whether successful or not) would be if it shared a land border with the U.S. - that is, either taking over Canada or Mexico first. They needed a place to mass troops, supply troops from, etc. Russia was too far away to do that without a staging ground nearby. Canada would have been a first choice I think, which is why U.S. took pains to protect Canada from any Russian invasion ideas during the cold war...joint NORAD, mutual defence pacts, etc. No way during the cold war would the U.S. have ever allowed Russia to get a large porous land border with them.
 
the number 3 claim seems a bit out of wack, what is there a huge building in Mexico City with the letters FSB written on it?? highly unlikely.
 
landscaper said:
All this is straight out of the 1955 soviet manual on how to cause a rebellion. Absolutly nothing new with this. The only difference right now is the advent of virtuallly instant amd untraceable communications. The communications were always the week side of conspiracies.

That, and the rise of the drug cartels since then. The Soviets tried to cause a revolution in Mexico in 1968 but it failed--the government of the day was much stronger. These days the govt. of Mexico looks a lot more precarious.

In 1968 they tried to create a pro-Soviet regime, but these days they'd probably achieve their non-ideological goals by simply creating a failed state on the US border.
 
scouser1 said:
the number 3 claim seems a bit out of wack, what is there a huge building in Mexico City with the letters FSB written on it?? highly unlikely.

Most of it's out of wack. With Robert Ludlum dead the fiction becomes sillier and sillier. Number 4 is at least 20 years out of date. Russia is having no less trouble controlling it's former satelite states than the Mexico government is having with the drug cartels.

The one thing that Russia does have now is oil money. It will be interesting if a power struggle develops between Putin and the oil barons in Russia.

If Putin was smart he'd simply buy chunks of the US.
 
The oil barons in russian who did not toe the putin line are in jail on a variety of charges some of them actully true. The russian oil industry is under Putins thumb at the moment. When it comes out from there is anybodies guess. The Russian stock market took a huge hit last week actually worse than wall street. The credit crunch and dropping oil prices killed it, they had to finance huge amounts through the govt in foriegn currency, currency they did not have. Intersting times ahead
 
Perhaps Putin should focus on opening his stock market again before he attemps to destabilize a democracy....

OTB
 
Putin does not want an open stock market he wants a bank account he can use as he sees fit. He is an old school Russian politnik in new cloths. He really needs watching
 
I don't think Putin gives a hoot about his stock market, or about Mexico's democracy. He is a politco/military type who cares about how much power he can project around the world, how far he can push Russia's borders, and so on.

Given the number of similar operations the CIA has carried out lately in Russia's back yard (all the "Orange Revolutions") I don't think Putin is going to see any moral issue with mucking around in Mexico or anywhere else.

Do unto others as you would have them do unto you I guess would be the principle, and I imagine he sees it as his turn to do the doing unto.
 
You are aware that the Russian stock market was closed by the government to trading to stave off a fall are you not?

If Mexico failed (and I seriously doubt it), what would happen:

- Mexicans would come to the US in droves.... like now
- Mexicans would bring crime and drugs with them to the US.... like now

Actually, looking on the bright side, it would give the US the political cover it needs to build a proper barrier on the Southern Boarder.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
- Mexicans would come to the US in droves.... like now
- Mexicans would bring crime and drugs with them to the US.... like now

Much more so, though; and anti-American groups would begin using Mexico as a base to strike the United States. Possibly with Qassam rockets and the like only they'd probably be given some latin American name.
 
fuji said:
Much more so, though; and anti-American groups would begin using Mexico as a base to strike the United States. Possibly with Qassam rockets and the like only they'd probably be given some latin American name.

Any anti american groups that thought they could get away with that would be in for an unpleasant surprise.

The Americans would not hesitate to turn they first 50 miles of Mexican territory into an exlusion zone to stop bombardment of American soil. Any U.S. government that failed to do so would be either out or dead.
 
fuji said:
I read an interesting article recently that put this theory together:

1. Mexico's government barely controls much of its territory now, in the face of increasingly well armed and well financed drug cartels

2. We are entering a new cold war with Russia, and Russia will be shopping around for ways of creating staggering problems for the USA

3. Mexico city hosts the largest foreign office for Russian intelligence services

4. Russia is pretty good at smuggling arms, training insurgents, and stirring up shit in other countries

5. If Mexico were to become a failed state it would be a staggering problem for the United States, both in terms of border security, in terms of loss of a major trading partner, and in terms of the inflow of drugs creating massive criminal problems inside the USA itself.

Adding it up...

If we do get into a new cold war with Russia they probably won't just sit around waiting for Orange Revolutions to crop up in their near-abroad. They will probably reach out and stir up shit in the USA's near-abroad too.

Mexico would be a good starting point. While the cartels do not need cash, with sophisticated Russian weaponry, advanced military training, and access to Russian intelligence techniques and data, the drug cartels have a good shot at toppling the Mexican government and creating a failed state.

A failed state on the US border would then present the USA with such a huge, expensive, and difficult problem that American administrations, military resources, and intelligence efforts would be tied up dealing with problems nearer home--leaving Russia free to meddle in far away places like Georgia, or wherever, with less to fear.

Here is a few words of wisdom...

What goes around comes around!
What is good for the goose is also good for the gander!
You will reap what you saw!

and my favorite one is...

They had it coming!
 
landscaper said:
Any anti american groups that thought they could get away with that would be in for an unpleasant surprise.

The Americans would not hesitate to turn they first 50 miles of Mexican territory into an exlusion zone to stop bombardment of American soil. Any U.S. government that failed to do so would be either out or dead.

I think this is true, not so sure about the 50 mile thing though, might be more dramatic than that.

OTB
 
fuji said:
Much more so, though; and anti-American groups would begin using Mexico as a base to strike the United States. Possibly with Qassam rockets and the like only they'd probably be given some latin American name.

You are 20 years behind the times. Or perhaps 50 years behind back to the Cuban missle crisis.

Did Russia reopen their stock market yet with everything stabilizing a bit ?
 
landscaper said:
Any anti american groups that thought they could get away with that would be in for an unpleasant surprise.

The Americans would not hesitate to turn they first 50 miles of Mexican territory into an exlusion zone to stop bombardment of American soil. Any U.S. government that failed to do so would be either out or dead.

Yeah, exactly, and at that point Putin wins, because at that point he has succeeded in everything he set out to do: America embroiled in a quagmire on its border that consumes loads of cash, occupies the administration, and brings America in for never-ending criticism for running an Israeli style occupation.

At that point Putin's army, rolling into Georgia, rolling into Ukraine, is above American reproach.

I think that's the point.
 
train said:
You are 20 years behind the times. Or perhaps 50 years behind back to the Cuban missle crisis.

The cold war is on again dude, or did you miss the memo?

I would imagine that Russia will make overtures to Cuba again, the strategic situation is the same as it was then, despite the fact that Russia is now a kleptocracy rather than a communist state. A Russian air base in Cuba would still be able to, theoretically, interdict American shipping in and out of the Gulf. Not that they would--it would be viewed as a deterrent to US incursions into Russia's near abroad rather than something anyone would want to do.

In Cuba the tables have turned though--I would imagine that once Fidel is gone there's a reaonable chance of a Cuban/American reconciliation. No doubt the Russians will try overtures to Cuba again anyway but less likely to get traction this time around than in the 60's.

It's the situation in Mexico, with the cartels, that has changed in a way that presents an opportunity for them.